RHRalf. M. Haefner

Ralf. M. Haefner

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Ralf. M. Haefner has a total of 109 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Reassessing Choice Probability: What 59 Macaque Studies Tell Us About Decision-Related Activity in Visual Cortex

    by Anton Pletenev, Richard T Born, Gregory C DeAngelis, Raymond Doudlah, Ichiro Fujita, Joshua I Gold, Robbe Lt Goris, Alexander C Huk, Kristine Krug, Pooya Laamerad, et al.

    Choice probability (CP) quantifies the trial-by-trial covariation between a sensory neuron’s response and perceptual reports. Despite extensive interest in CP as a window into how perception is linked to the activity of sensory neurons, the usefulness of CP remains debated. On one hand, reported CP magnitudes vary widely across seemingly equivalent studies, questioning its utility as a metric. On the other hand, the absence of clear patterns in CP variability has made it difficult to use it to adjudicate between competing models of visual perception. Here, we performed a meta-analysis of 150 CP estimates from 59 macaque neurophysiology studies to identify factors that systematically influence CP. We confirmed the positive relationship between CP and neuronal sensitivity both across and within individual studies. When controlled for sensitivity, we found remarkable consistency in CP across varying tasks and brain regions with two notable exceptions. First, CPs were higher in tasks involving bistable percepts, reinforcing the link between CP magnitude and subjective perception. Second, CPs were smaller in area V1, supporting prior suggestions about V1’s special role in visual processing. We further found a significant effect of stimulus duration on CP, providing evidence against strictly feedforward models and favoring models with substantial feedback and recurrent processing. Finally, we offer recommendations for future studies to enhance the cross-study comparability and theoretical utility of choice signals as the field transitions to large-scale population recordings. More broadly, our findings demonstrate the benefits of meta-studies that expose patterns across many different tasks and animals – yielding insights that complement large-scale population recordings.

  • Open Access

    Bayesian causal inference unifies perceptual and neuronal processing of center-surround motion in area MT

    by Gabor Lengyel, Sabyasachi Shivkumar, Gregory C DeAngelis, Ralf M Haefner

    Center–surround interactions are a hallmark of visual processing and are especially prominent in area MT, where surround motion can either suppress or facilitate neuronal responses depending on context. However, existing mechanistic descriptions, including divisive normalization, do not explain the full diversity of these effects or their relationship to motion perception. Here, we show that both perceptual and neuronal center–surround phenomena can be understood as consequences of Bayesian causal inference over reference frames. Building on a normative model of motion perception, we derived predictions for the mean responses and variability of single MT neurons across the full fourdimensional space of center and surround directions and speeds. The model generates structured patterns of suppression, facilitation, and coordinate-frame selectivity that qualitatively match the diversity of center–surround effects reported in primate MT. Our results provide a unified computational account linking motion integration and segmentation in perception with contextual response modulation in MT, and yield testable predictions for how the visual system infers and represents reference frames.

  • Open Access

    Reassessing Choice Probability: What 59 Macaque Studies Tell Us About Decision-Related Activity in Visual Cortex

    by Anton Pletenev, Richard T. Born, Gregory C. DeAngelis, Raymond Doudlah, Ichiro Fujita, Joshua I. Gold, Robbe L. T. Goris, Alexander C. Huk, Kristine Krug, Pooya Laamerad, et al.

    Choice probability (CP) quantifies the trial-by-trial covariation between a sensory neuron's response and perceptual reports. Despite extensive interest in CP as a window into how perception is linked to the activity of sensory neurons, the usefulness of CP remains debated. On one hand, reported CP magnitudes vary widely across seemingly equivalent studies, questioning its utility as a metric. On the other hand, the absence of clear patterns in CP variability has made it difficult to use it to adjudicate between competing models of visual perception. Here, we performed a meta-analysis of 150 CP estimates from 59 macaque neurophysiology studies to identify factors that systematically influence CP. We confirmed the positive relationship between CP and neuronal sensitivity both across and within individual studies. When controlled for sensitivity, we found remarkable consistency in CP across varying tasks and brain regions with two notable exceptions. First, CPs were higher in tasks involving bistable percepts, reinforcing the link between CP magnitude and subjective perception. Second, CPs were smaller in area V1, supporting prior suggestions about V1's special role in visual processing. We further found a significant effect of stimulus duration on CP, providing evidence against strictly feedforward models and favoring models with substantial feedback and recurrent processing. Finally, we offer recommendations for future studies to enhance the cross-study comparability and theoretical utility of choice signals as the field transitions to large-scale population recordings. More broadly, our findings demonstrate the benefits of meta-studies that expose patterns across many different tasks and animals -- yielding insights that complement large-scale population recordings.


  • Task learning increases information redundancy of neural responses in macaque visual cortex

    by Shizhao Liu, Anton Pletenev, Ralf M. Haefner, Adam C. Snyder

    How does the brain optimize sensory information for decision-making in new tasks? One hypothesis suggests that learning reduces redundancy in neural representations to improve efficiency, whereas another, based on Bayesian inference, predicts that learning increases redundancy by distributing information across neurons. We tested these hypotheses by tracking population responses in macaque cortical area V4 as monkeys learned visual discrimination tasks. We found strong support for the Bayesian predictions: Task learning increased redundancy in neural responses over weeks of training and within single trials. This redundancy did not reduce information but instead increased the information carried by individual neurons. These insights suggest that sensory processing in the brain reflects a generative rather than discriminative inference process.


  • Open Access

    Hierarchical motion perception as causal inference

    by Sabyasachi Shivkumar, Gregory C. DeAngelis, Ralf M. Haefner

    Motion can only be defined relative to a reference frame; yet it remains unclear which reference frame guides perception. A century of psychophysical studies has produced conflicting evidence: retinotopic, egocentric, world-centric, or even object-centric. We introduce a hierarchical Bayesian model mapping retinal velocities to perceived velocities. Our model mirrors the structure in the world, in which visual elements move within causally connected reference frames. Friction renders velocities in these reference frames mostly stationary, formalized by an additional delta component (at zero) in the prior. Inverting this model automatically segments visual inputs into groups, groups into supergroups, progressively inferring structured reference frames and “perceives" motion in the appropriate reference frame. Critical model predictions are supported by two experiments, and fitting our model to the data allows us to infer the subjective set of reference frames used by individual observers. Our model provides a quantitative normative justification for key Gestalt principles providing inspiration for building better models of visual processing in general.


  • Open Access

    How does the brain compute with probabilities?

    by Ralf M. Haefner, Jeff Beck, Cristina Savin, Mehrdad Salmasi, Xaq Pitkow

    This perspective piece is the result of a Generative Adversarial Collaboration (GAC) tackling the question `How does neural activity represent probability distributions?'. We have addressed three major obstacles to progress on answering this question: first, we provide a unified language for defining competing hypotheses. Second, we explain the fundamentals of three prominent proposals for probabilistic computations -- Probabilistic Population Codes (PPCs), Distributed Distributional Codes (DDCs), and Neural Sampling Codes (NSCs) -- and describe similarities and differences in that common language. Third, we review key empirical data previously taken as evidence for at least one of these proposal, and describe how it may or may not be explainable by alternative proposals. Finally, we describe some key challenges in resolving the debate, and propose potential directions to address them through a combination of theory and experiments.


  • Bayesian encoding and decoding as distinct perspectives on neural coding

    by Richard D. Lange, Sabyasachi Shivkumar, Ankani Chattoraj, Ralf M. Haefner

    The Bayesian brain hypothesis is one of the most influential ideas in neuroscience. However, unstated differences in how Bayesian ideas are operationalized make it difficult to draw general conclusions about how Bayesian computations map onto neural circuits. Here, we identify one such unstated difference: some theories ask how neural circuits could recover information about the world from sensory neural activity (Bayesian decoding), whereas others ask how neural circuits could implement inference in an internal model (Bayesian encoding). These two approaches require profoundly different assumptions and lead to different interpretations of empirical data. We contrast them in terms of motivations, empirical support and relationship to neural data. We also use a simple model to argue that encoding and decoding models are complementary rather than competing. Appreciating the distinction between Bayesian encoding and Bayesian decoding will help to organize future work and enable stronger empirical tests about the nature of inference in the brain.


  • Open Access

    Hierarchical motion perception as causal inference

    by Sabyasachi Shivkumar, Gregory C. DeAngelis, Ralf M. Haefner

    Since motion can only be defined relative to a reference frame, which reference frame guides perception? A century of psychophysical studies has produced conflicting evidence: retinotopic, egocentric, world-centric, or even object-centric. We introduce a hierarchical Bayesian model mapping retinal velocities to perceived velocities. Our model mirrors the structure in the world, in which visual elements move within causally connected reference frames. Friction renders velocities in these reference frames mostly stationary, formalized by an additional delta component (at zero) in the prior. Inverting this model automatically segments visual inputs into groups, groups into supergroups, etc. and “perceives” motion in the appropriate reference frame. Critical model predictions are supported by two new experiments, and fitting our model to the data allows us to infer the subjective set of reference frames used by individual observers. Our model provides a quantitative normative justification for key Gestalt principles providing inspiration for building better models of visual processing in general.


  • Open Access

    Weak evidence for neural correlates of task-switching in macaque V1

    by Richard D. Lange, Camille Gómez-Laberge, Vladimir K. Berezovskii, Anton Pletenev, Ariana Sherdil, Till Hartmann, Ralf M. Haefner, Richard T. Born

    Converging evidence suggests that decision processes affect sensory neural activity, and this has informed numerous theories of neural processing. We set out to replicate and extend previous results on decision-related information and noise correlations in V1 of macaque monkeys. However, in our data, we find little evidence for a number of expected effects. Our null results therefore call attention to differences in task training, stimulus design, recording, and analysis techniques between our and prior studies.


  • Open Access

    Pattern completion and disruption characterize contextual modulation in the visual cortex

    by Jiakun Fu, Suhas Shrinivasan, Luca Baroni, Zhuokun Ding, Paul G. Fahey, Paweł Pierzchlewicz, Kayla Ponder, Rachel Froebe, Lydia Ntanavara, Taliah Muhammad, et al.

    A key role of sensory processing is integrating information across space. Neuronal responses in the visual system are influenced by both local features in the receptive field center and contextual information from the surround. While center-surround interactions have been extensively studied using simple stimuli like gratings, investigating these interactions with more complex, ecologically-relevant stimuli is challenging due to the high dimensionality of the stimulus space. We used large-scale neuronal recordings in mouse primary visual cortex to train convolutional neural network (CNN) models that accurately predicted center-surround interactions for natural stimuli. These models enabled us to synthesize surround stimuli that strongly suppressed or enhanced neuronal responses to the optimal center stimulus, as confirmed by in vivo experiments. In contrast to the common notion that congruent center and surround stimuli are suppressive, we found that excitatory surrounds appeared to complete spatial patterns in the center, while inhibitory surrounds disrupted them. We quantified this effect by demonstrating that CNN-optimized excitatory surround images have strong similarity in neuronal response space with surround images generated by extrapolating the statistical properties of the center, and with patches of natural scenes, which are known to exhibit high spatial correlations. Our findings cannot be explained by theories like redundancy reduction or predictive coding previously linked to contextual modulation in visual cortex. Instead, we demonstrated that a hierarchical probabilistic model incorporating Bayesian inference, and modulating neuronal responses based on prior knowledge of natural scene statistics, can explain our empirical results. We replicated these center-surround effects in the multi-area functional connectomics MICrONS dataset using natural movies as visual stimuli, which opens the way towards understanding circuit level mechanism, such as the contributions of lateral and feedback recurrent connections. Our data-driven modeling approach provides a new understanding of the role of contextual interactions in sensory processing and can be adapted across brain areas, sensory modalities, and species.