TSTayyab Suratwala

Tayyab Suratwala

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Tayyab Suratwala has a total of 272 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Demonstration of thermal fracture limits of gas-cooled Nd:APG-1 and Tm:YLF slabs

    by Zbynek Hubka, Issa Tamer, František Batysta, Emily Sistrunk, Jason Owens, Andrew Church, Thomas Galvin, Alex Chemali, Drew Willard, Justin Galbraith, et al.

    High-energy short-pulse laser systems demonstrated to date have been limited to low repetition rates due to significant thermal management challenges associated with scaling these systems to high average power, including the need to understand the thermal fracture limits of laser gain media. In this paper, we demonstrate the thermal fracture limits of two high-average-power gain media in a realistic diode-pumped amplifier geometry: a 5 mm thick Nd:APG-1 slab and a 2 mm thick Tm:YLF slab, both cooled by room-temperature helium gas. Finite element analysis revealed maximum tensile stress at fracture of 25 ± 3 MPa for Nd:APG-1 and 30 ± 3 MPa for Tm:YLF. These stress levels correspond to average volumetric heat loads of 13 ± 1 W/cm 3 in Nd:APG-1 and 247 ± 12 W/cm 3 in Tm:YLF. Additional simulations show geometric scaling: thinner slabs tolerate higher heat loads before fracture, while larger pump spots reach the fracture stress at lower heat loads.


  • Subsurface mechanical damage of fused silica glass during grinding by various sub-aperture tools with and without ultrasonics

    by Tayyab Suratwala, William Steele, Gary Tham, James Ross, John Johnson, Oscar Herrera, Mike Cahill, Danelle Bechtold, Michael Bechtold, Rob Bechtold, et al.

    The subsurface mechanical damage (SSD) depth after grinding fused silica glass with a comprehensive set of sub-aperture fixed abrasive grinding tools [cup, wheel, belt, pad, and rotary face mill (with and without ultrasonics)] and process parameters has been statistically measured using the taper wedge technique and evaluated. Consistent with a previously reported grinding model [ J. Non-Cryst. Solids 352 , 5601 –5617 ( 2006 ) 10.1016/j.jnoncrysol.2006.09.012 , Materials Science and Technology of Optical Fabrication (Wiley & Sons, 2018 ) ], based on the sliding indentation fracture by sliding particles or asperities where the normal load per particle determines the depth of the fracture (and ultimately the overall SSD depth), the dominant factor controlling SSD depth was found to be the abrasive size regardless of the tool type and process conditions. Compared to full aperture grinding methods, the overall SSD depth was higher using the sub-aperture tools, likely due to the higher effective pressure and higher load per particle distribution. In addition to abrasive size, a significant reduction in SSD depth was achieved by: (1) reducing the load distribution on the abrasive particles via increase in contact area and/or decrease in mechanical loading; (2) using a more compliant host tool medium; and (3) in what we believe is a more novel way, using ultrasonics. Combining low abrasive size, larger contact area, and a compliant host, the 6 µm diamond in a resin matrix (Trizact) on a foam pad led to very low SSD depth (∼4.6µm), relatively fast grinding rate (186mm 3 /h), and little or no figure degradation. This grinding tool/process is an attractive choice for final grind, resulting in significantly reduced polish out (i.e., “grey out”) times. With the rotary face mill tool, the use of ultrasonics consistently led to a SSD depth reduction (ranging from 17%–34%). A new fracture mechanics-based model, to the best of our knowledge, where the relevant normal load is parallel to the feed direction, has been developed to explain how ultrasonics leads to lower SSD depth. The key factors, supported by finite element stress analysis and load measurements, are (1) the initiation of fractures at higher z heights during the tool’s ultrasonic vertical oscillations, thus propagating less deep into workpiece; (2) reduction in load (and therefore reduction in fracture propagation distance) due to smaller tool-workpiece feed direction contact area (again caused by higher z heights relative to depth of cut); (3) upward movement of the tool during oscillation leads to fracturing toward the surface instead into the depth; and finally (4) at tool’s lowest point of oscillation cycle, there may not be enough time for the fracture to propagate to its full length.


  • Process Methods to Improve Freeform Optic Quality & Fabrication Efficiency

    by T. Suratwala, G. Tham, J. Johnson, R. Steele, O. Herrera

    Progress on process methods to improve freeform optic quality and fabrication efficiency are reviewed (including management of sub-surface damage, rapid greyout polishing, improved figure determinism, and reduction of mid-spatials) especially using novel grinding & polishing tools.

  • Present understanding of ignition and gain using indirect-drive inertial confinement fusion target designs on the U.S. National Ignition Facility

    by O A Hurricane, A Allen, B L Bachmann, K L Baker, S Baxamusa, S D Bhandarkar, J Biener, S R M Bionta, T Braun, T Briggs, et al.

    For many decades, the running joke in fusion research has been that ‘fusion’ is thirty years away and always will be. Yet, these past few years we find ourselves in a position where we can now talk about the milestones of burning plasmas, fusion ignition, and target energy gain greater than unity (scientific breakeven) in the past tense. Fusion is no longer a joke! Yet getting to fusion ignition, the tipping-point of thermonuclear instability resulting in an explosive increase in ion thermal temperature and fusion reaction-rate, and scientific breakeven (target gain, G target = fusion yield/deposited laser energy > 1 , in the laser-driven inertial confinement fusion context) has not been easy. In this publication we discuss our present understanding of the physics and technological challenges surrounding ignition and Gain as well as highlight some outstanding problems that still need resolution.


  • Smoothing tool design and performance during subaperture glass polishing

    by T. Suratwala, G. Tham, R. Steele, L. Wong, J. Menapace, N. Ray, B. Bauman

    During subaperture tool grinding and polishing, overlaps of the tool influence function can result in undesirable mid-spatial frequency (MSF) errors in the form of surface ripples, which are often corrected using a smoothing polishing step. In this study, flat multi-layer smoothing polishing tools are designed and tested to simultaneously (1) reduce or remove MSF errors, (2) minimize surface figure degradation, and (3) maximize the material removal rate. A time-dependent convergence model in which spatial material removal varies with a workpiece-tool height mismatch, combined with a finite element mechanical analysis to determine the interface contact pressure distribution, was developed to evaluate various smoothing tool designs as a function of tool material properties, thicknesses, pad textures, and displacements. An improvement in smoothing tool performance is achieved when the gap pressure constant, h¯ (which describes the inverse rate at which the pressure drops with a workpiece-tool height mismatch), is minimized for smaller spatial scale length surface features (namely, MSF errors) and maximized for large spatial scale length features (i.e., surface figure). Five specific smoothing tool designs were experimentally evaluated. A two-layer smoothing tool using a thin, grooved IC1000 polyurethane pad (with a high elastic modulus, Epad=360MPa), thicker blue foam (with an intermediate modulus, Efoam=5.3MPa) underlayer, and an optimized displacement (d t =1mm) provided the best overall performance (namely, high MSF error convergence, minimal surface figure degradation, and high material removal rate).


  • Understanding the tool influence function during sub-aperture belt-on-wheel glass polishing

    by Tayyab Suratwala, James Ross, R. Steele, Gary Tham, Lana Wong, Franciscus Wolfs, Scott Defisher, Rob Bechtold, Michael Rinkus, Christopher Mah, et al.

    The tool influence function (TIF) during sub-aperture belt-on-wheel polishing has been evaluated as a function of various process conditions (belt use/wear, dwell time, displacement, belt velocity, and wheel modulus and diameter) on fused silica glass workpieces using C e O 2 polishing media. TIF spots are circular or elliptical in shape with a largely flat bottom character. The volumetric removal rate varies significantly with belt use (or wear), stabilizing after ∼ 15 m i n of use. A modified Preston model, where the pressure dependence is adjusted using a different scaling of the wheel modulus ( E w 0.5 ), largely predicts the volumetric removal rate over the range of process conditions evaluated. The relatively high volumetric removal rate of 30 − 60 m m 3 / h using a fixed C e O 2 -in-resin-host belt offers a rapid, and hence, more economical, initial polish of aspheric and freeform optics.


  • Open Access

    Toward the fabrication of a 5-μm-resolution Wolter microscope for the National Ignition Facility (invited)

    by Patrick R. Champey, Jeffery Kolodziejczak, Bernard Kozioziemski, Jacqueline Davis, Charles Griffith, Tom Kester, Kiranmayee Kilaru, Amy Meekham, Joe Menapace, Brian Ramsey, et al.

    Advancements in computer-controlled polishing, metrology, and replication have led to an x-ray mirror fabrication process that is capable of producing high-resolution Wolter microscopes. We present the fabrication and test of a nickel–cobalt replicated full-shell x-ray mirror that was electroformed from a finely figured and polished mandrel. This mandrel was designed for an 8-m source-to-detector-distance microscope, with 10× magnification, and was optimized to reduce shell distortions that occur within 20 mm of the shell ends. This, in combination with an improved replication tooling design and refined bath parameters informed by a detailed COMSOL Multiphysics® model, has led to reductions in replication errors in the mirrors. Mandrel surface fabrication was improved by implementing a computer-controlled polishing process that corrected the low-frequency mandrel figure error and achieved <2.0 nm RMS convergence error. X-ray tests performed on a pair of mirror shells replicated from the mandrel have demonstrated <10 μm full-width at half-maximum (FWHM) spatial resolution. Here, we discuss the development process, highlight results from metrology and x-ray testing, and define a path for achieving a program goal of 5 μm FWHM resolution.


  • Modeling the hydrodynamic impact on the tool influence function during hemispherical subaperture optical polishing

    by Nathan J. Ray, Tayyab Suratwala, Joseph Menapace, Lana Wong, William Steele, Gary Tham, Brian Bauman

    To fabricate high-precision and accurate optics relative to the optical design surface, a high level of deterministic control of material removal (i.e., the tool influence function, TIF) during subaperture tool polishing is required. In this study, a detailed analysis of the pressure distribution, which is a key component of the TIF, has been performed using finite element analysis to couple together solid mechanics and fluid dynamics. Modeling experimental parameters of recently published work reveals that, when considering tool deformation, which in turn influences the fluid film thickness between the tool and workpiece, the effective pressure profile has a flat-top distribution. This flat-top pressure profile differs from the parabolic pressure distributions predicted by Hertzian mechanics. Moreover, the shear contribution is shown here to be a key contributor to material removal, inducing the removal at the periphery of the contact edge and even outside the generally accepted contact area. Finally, the simulated fluid velocities provide evidence of mixed-mode contact polishing, supporting recent experimental findings that also suggest that onset of hydroplaning contributions lead to material removal drop-off.


  • Understanding and reducing mid-spatial frequency ripples during hemispherical sub-aperture tool glass polishing

    by T. Suratwala, J. Menapace, G. Tham, R. Steele, L. Wong, N. Ray, B. Bauman

    During sub-aperture tool polishing of glass optics, mid-spatial surface ripples are generated because of material removal non-uniformities during tool linear translation (resulting in feed ripples) and tool pathway step overlaps (resulting in pitch ripples). A variety of tool influence function (TIF) spots, trenches, and patches were created to understand and minimize such ripples on fused silica workpieces after polishing with cerium oxide slurry using a rotating hemispherical pad-foam tool. The feed ripple amplitude can be decreased by reducing the non-uniformities in the pad texture and/or by minimizing a derived feed ripple metric ( r f = V m a x 0.5 V f / R t ) via adjustments in processing parameters. Pitch ripples can be minimized by reducing relative step distance to spot radius ratio ( x s / a t ) and by achieving a flat bottom trench shape cross section or by reducing the material removal per pass. Using the combined methods, an overall ripple error of ∼ 1.2 n m rms has been achieved.


  • Effect of workpiece curvature on the tool influence function during hemispherical sub-aperture tool glass polishing

    by T. Suratwala, J. Menapace, G. Tham, R. Steele, L. Wong, N. Ray, B. Bauman, M. Gregory, T. Hordin

    The influence of workpiece curvature on the tool influence function spot during polishing of fused silica glass with cerium oxide slurry, while using a rotating hemispherical pad-foam tool for a wide variety of process conditions (tool displacement, inclination angle, and rotation rate), has been investigated. (Workpiece curvature ranged from 500 mm radius concave to 43 mm radius convex.) The TIF spot decreases in diameter and increases in the peak removal rate on more convex workpieces. In contrast, the TIF spot increases both in diameter and peak removal rate on more concave workpieces. For the range of workpiece curvatures investigated, both the spot size and the peak removal rate changed significantly, as much as 2 times. An elastic sphere–sphere contact mechanics model, which utilizes both a modified displacement (that leads to a change in the applied load) as well as a mismatch factor (that influences the pressure distribution shape), has been developed. The model was validated using both offline load-displacement measurements and finite-element analysis simulations. The model quantitatively describes the measured change in the relative contact diameter and relative pressure distribution, as well as semiquantitively describes the change in the relative volumetric removal rate on a large variety of TIF spots. The change in the volumetric removal rate for convex workpieces is a result of the balance between a decreasing spot size (reducing removal) and an increasing peak pressure (increasing removal), which usually results in relatively small changes in volumetric removal. In the case of concave workpieces, the volumetric removal rate change is also governed by a similar balance, but the spot size increase contribution dominates, resulting in a significant increase in volumetric removal rate. Understanding these trends can enable methods to add greater determinism during the fabrication of freeform optics by adjusting polishing parameters (such as dwell time) while the tool translates along a workpiece surface with different local curvatures.