T. T. Arvind
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
T. T. Arvind has a total of 43 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Joanna Gray
2 shared publicationsLindsay Stirton
York Law School, University of York
2 shared publicationsSarah Wilson
2 shared publicationsAisling McMahon
Maynooth University; National University of Ireland, Maynooth (NUI Maynooth) - Department of Law : Ireland
1 shared publication- Aisling McMahon
Maynooth University
1 shared publication - Alan Thomas
University of York, York, UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 99-121
Epistemic Injustice and the Rule of Law
- 29 September 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 99-118
Thought Styles on Administrative Justice Systems
- 29 September 2024
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 99-118
Thought Styles on Administrative Justice Systems
- Open Access
- 4 March 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Oxford Journal of Legal Studies
- Vol. 44 (2) , 376-404
Partisan Legal Traditions in the Age of Camden and Mansfield
The 18th century is often treated by scholars as a period of juristic consensus. This article argues, in contrast, that the late 18th century saw the emergence of rival ‘Patriot’ and ‘Tory’ legal traditions. Through a detailed study of the jurisprudence of Lords Camden and Mansfield—who were both pillars of the law, as well as political and juristic rivals—we show that they differed systematically in their understanding of the common law, and that those differences had a partisan cast: although they were not crude attempts to instrumentalise law to political ends, their political and jurisprudential commitments influenced each other and emerged from the same intellectual roots. We place these differences in the context of the fragmentation of 18th-century Whig politics, and argue that they have important implications for how we understand and make use of the common law tradition in present-day scholarship.
- 4 March 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Oxford Journal of Legal Studies
- Vol. 44 (2) , 376-404
Open AccessPartisan Legal Traditions in the Age of Camden and Mansfield
The 18th century is often treated by scholars as a period of juristic consensus. This article argues, in contrast, that the late 18th century saw the emergence of rival ‘Patriot’ and ‘Tory’ legal traditions. Through a detailed study of the jurisprudence of Lords Camden and Mansfield—who were both pillars of the law, as well as political and juristic rivals—we show that they differed systematically in their understanding of the common law, and that those differences had a partisan cast: although they were not crude attempts to instrumentalise law to political ends, their political and jurisprudential commitments influenced each other and emerged from the same intellectual roots. We place these differences in the context of the fragmentation of 18th-century Whig politics, and argue that they have important implications for how we understand and make use of the common law tradition in present-day scholarship.
- 16 December 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 2228-2234
Lundstedt, Anders Vilhelm: Philosophy of
- Open Access
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Commodification, Control and the Contractualisation of the Human Body
This chapter puts the philosophical debate on commodification in the context of the legal concept of commodities. In law, commodification is intrinsically connected with contractualisation, through which contract acquires a central role in structuring social relations. This link between contractualisation and commodification has two consequences. Firstly, it gives its objects a legal value, turning them into objects capable of being traded through market transactions and placing the focus on their commodity-value rather than social perceptions of their intrinsic worth. Secondly, in a commodified conception of contracts, the standing of people in their relations with each other is understood in terms of the characteristics of the contractual transactions linking them—their conformity with the parties’ agreement, their fitness for the purposes to which they are applied, etc. This excludes values and evaluative positions other than the contractual values of autonomy and self-ordering. Through an analysis of the impact of patent law on areas ranging from the patenting of isolated genes to access to medicines, we show that commodification affects more domains and has deeper effects than generally assumed. Commodification directs the legal system’s focus towards facilitating the creation of contractual frameworks of self-ordering, and towards insulating law from the broader dimensions of the value of human life, well-being, and different forms of human striving. We argue that the study of commodification must evolve beyond focusing on the limits of markets, and must also focus on the limits of contracts—which are generally modelled on an exchange framework as a way of conceiving relations and on private frameworks of regulation—their aetiology, and on devising ways of ameliorating such limitations.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessCommodification, Control and the Contractualisation of the Human Body
This chapter puts the philosophical debate on commodification in the context of the legal concept of commodities. In law, commodification is intrinsically connected with contractualisation, through which contract acquires a central role in structuring social relations. This link between contractualisation and commodification has two consequences. Firstly, it gives its objects a legal value, turning them into objects capable of being traded through market transactions and placing the focus on their commodity-value rather than social perceptions of their intrinsic worth. Secondly, in a commodified conception of contracts, the standing of people in their relations with each other is understood in terms of the characteristics of the contractual transactions linking them—their conformity with the parties’ agreement, their fitness for the purposes to which they are applied, etc. This excludes values and evaluative positions other than the contractual values of autonomy and self-ordering. Through an analysis of the impact of patent law on areas ranging from the patenting of isolated genes to access to medicines, we show that commodification affects more domains and has deeper effects than generally assumed. Commodification directs the legal system’s focus towards facilitating the creation of contractual frameworks of self-ordering, and towards insulating law from the broader dimensions of the value of human life, well-being, and different forms of human striving. We argue that the study of commodification must evolve beyond focusing on the limits of markets, and must also focus on the limits of contracts—which are generally modelled on an exchange framework as a way of conceiving relations and on private frameworks of regulation—their aetiology, and on devising ways of ameliorating such limitations.
- Open Access
- 29 October 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Minds and Machines
- Vol. 32 (4) , 683-715
From Pluralistic Normative Principles to Autonomous-Agent Rules
With recent advancements in systems engineering and artificial intelligence, autonomous agents are increasingly being called upon to execute tasks that have normative relevance. These are tasks that directly—and potentially adversely—affect human well-being and demand of the agent a degree of normative-sensitivity and -compliance. Such norms and normative principles are typically of a social, legal, ethical, empathetic, or cultural (‘SLEEC’) nature. Whereas norms of this type are often framed in the abstract, or as high-level principles, addressing normative concerns in concrete applications of autonomous agents requires the refinement of normative principles into explicitly formulated practical rules. This paper develops a process for deriving specification rules from a set of high-level norms, thereby bridging the gap between normative principles and operational practice. This enables autonomous agents to select and execute the most normatively favourable action in the intended context premised on a range of underlying relevant normative principles. In the translation and reduction of normative principles to SLEEC rules, we present an iterative process that uncovers normative principles, addresses SLEEC concerns, identifies and resolves SLEEC conflicts, and generates both preliminary and complex normatively-relevant rules, thereby guiding the development of autonomous agents and better positioning them as normatively SLEEC-sensitive or SLEEC-compliant.
- 29 October 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Minds and Machines
- Vol. 32 (4) , 683-715
Open AccessFrom Pluralistic Normative Principles to Autonomous-Agent Rules
With recent advancements in systems engineering and artificial intelligence, autonomous agents are increasingly being called upon to execute tasks that have normative relevance. These are tasks that directly—and potentially adversely—affect human well-being and demand of the agent a degree of normative-sensitivity and -compliance. Such norms and normative principles are typically of a social, legal, ethical, empathetic, or cultural (‘SLEEC’) nature. Whereas norms of this type are often framed in the abstract, or as high-level principles, addressing normative concerns in concrete applications of autonomous agents requires the refinement of normative principles into explicitly formulated practical rules. This paper develops a process for deriving specification rules from a set of high-level norms, thereby bridging the gap between normative principles and operational practice. This enables autonomous agents to select and execute the most normatively favourable action in the intended context premised on a range of underlying relevant normative principles. In the translation and reduction of normative principles to SLEEC rules, we present an iterative process that uncovers normative principles, addresses SLEEC concerns, identifies and resolves SLEEC conflicts, and generates both preliminary and complex normatively-relevant rules, thereby guiding the development of autonomous agents and better positioning them as normatively SLEEC-sensitive or SLEEC-compliant.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Bloomsbury Academic
Slaying the Misshapen Monster: The Case for Constitutional Heuristics
ExtractTT Arvind Lindsay Stirton We are grateful to the University of York for funding the translation of non-English source documents used in this chapter, to Firat Cengiz for invaluable assistance with locating Turkish sources, and to Elizabeth Craig, Simon Halliday, Alex Latham-Gambi, Will McCready, Lawrence McNamara, and the volume editors for comments on an earlier draft. On 9 February 1784, Adriaan Kluit, rector magnificus at the University of Leiden, ascended the podium to deliver his valedictory address: ‘On the abuse of constitutional law’. Kluit was speaking at a time of fierce contestation in Dutch politics between the Orangists (with whom Kluit identified) and the anti-Orangist ‘Patriots’. The language of constitutional theory had become a key weapon in their battle, and it was to that language that Kluit’s address was directed. Its contents were sharp and uncompromising. The Patriots, Kluit said, had created ‘a misshapen monster in constitutional law’. The excellent...
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Bloomsbury Academic
Open AccessSlaying the Misshapen Monster: The Case for Constitutional Heuristics
ExtractTT Arvind Lindsay Stirton We are grateful to the University of York for funding the translation of non-English source documents used in this chapter, to Firat Cengiz for invaluable assistance with locating Turkish sources, and to Elizabeth Craig, Simon Halliday, Alex Latham-Gambi, Will McCready, Lawrence McNamara, and the volume editors for comments on an earlier draft. On 9 February 1784, Adriaan Kluit, rector magnificus at the University of Leiden, ascended the podium to deliver his valedictory address: ‘On the abuse of constitutional law’. Kluit was speaking at a time of fierce contestation in Dutch politics between the Orangists (with whom Kluit identified) and the anti-Orangist ‘Patriots’. The language of constitutional theory had become a key weapon in their battle, and it was to that language that Kluit’s address was directed. Its contents were sharp and uncompromising. The Patriots, Kluit said, had created ‘a misshapen monster in constitutional law’. The excellent...
- 17 March 2020
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 28 (3) , 445-477
Responsiveness and the Role of Rights in Medical Law: Lessons from Montgomery†
Over time, medical law has moved away from paternalism in favour of an approach grounded in patients’ rights. Using Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board (2015) as a case study, we offer a deeper analysis of this emerging approach. We argue that patients’ rights should be evaluated in terms of their contribution to making medical law more socially responsive, by developing it to give effect to social needs and aspirations pertaining to health care. Although rights can play an important role in achieving social responsiveness, they also carry the risk of entrenching approaches unrepresentative of patients’ actual needs and empirical realities. This is evident in Montgomery, where the law, despite being derived from General Medical Council (GMC) guidance, has effects that differ significantly from the GMC’s goals. Drawing on socio-legal literature, we outline a new approach for guiding the use of rights in medical law focused on the functional consequences of rights in facilitating patients’ aspirations, and the capacity of rights to respond to social and institutional contexts in which medical interaction occurs. We conclude by showing how this approach, applied to informed consent, would produce a different and arguably a superior duty, providing a sounder basis for responding to patient needs.
- 17 March 2020
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 28 (3) , 445-477
Responsiveness and the Role of Rights in Medical Law: Lessons from Montgomery†
Over time, medical law has moved away from paternalism in favour of an approach grounded in patients’ rights. Using Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board (2015) as a case study, we offer a deeper analysis of this emerging approach. We argue that patients’ rights should be evaluated in terms of their contribution to making medical law more socially responsive, by developing it to give effect to social needs and aspirations pertaining to health care. Although rights can play an important role in achieving social responsiveness, they also carry the risk of entrenching approaches unrepresentative of patients’ actual needs and empirical realities. This is evident in Montgomery, where the law, despite being derived from General Medical Council (GMC) guidance, has effects that differ significantly from the GMC’s goals. Drawing on socio-legal literature, we outline a new approach for guiding the use of rights in medical law focused on the functional consequences of rights in facilitating patients’ aspirations, and the capacity of rights to respond to social and institutional contexts in which medical interaction occurs. We conclude by showing how this approach, applied to informed consent, would produce a different and arguably a superior duty, providing a sounder basis for responding to patient needs.
- Open Access
- 15 March 2019
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of actual problems of jurisprudence
- Vol. 89 (1) , 134-141
Патогенные микроорганизмы как элемент криминалистической характеристики биотерроризма
Статья посвящена криминалистическому анализу обстоятельств поражения материальнойсреды патогенными микроорганизмами при совершении акта терроризма. Тема актуальнатем, что она до настоящего времени не изучена в криминалистической литературе, нерассматривались такие понятия, как «особо опасные инфекции», «биологические агенты»,«бактериологическое оружие», «биологическое оружие», «патогенность», «контагиозныесвойства» и т.д. В криминалистике не систематизированы свойства разработанных к настоящемувремени биологических агентов биологического оружия, механизм и характер следообразованияв той материальной обстановке, где может быть совершен террористический акт с применениемуказанных средств. Не рассматривались вопросы технико-криминалистического обеспеченияпроведения поисковых следственных действий, например, при осмотре места происшествия,если совершен акт терроризма, нет рекомендаций по тактическим особенностям расследованияданной категории преступлений, не известны, в какой процессуальной форме должныпривлекаться специалисты, какие обстоятельства и с помощью каких специалистов должны бытьустановлены для доказывания виновности террориста (-ов), а также не разработаны и другиевопросы, составляющие методику расследования терроризма.Цель исследования, исходя из свойств патогенных микроорганизмов природногопроисхождения и биологических агентов для создания биологического оружия, существующейих классификации по степени патогенности, по способу проникновения и т.д., – выделитьосновные свойства эти микроорганизмов в криминалистическом аспекте, систематизировать ихдля определения тактики проведения следствия на начальном этапе расследования.Методологической основой послужили научные труды микробиологов, вирусологов,биологов, эпидеомиологов, военных эпидеомиологов, посвященные биологическим агентам,биологическому оружию, методам индикации бактериалогического материала, а также трудыкриминалистов, посвященные теории и практике расследования отдельных видов преступлений.Ключевые слова: акт терроризма, патогенные микроорганизмы, биологические агенты, особоопасные инфекции, биологическое оружие, вирус, патогенная бактерия, риккетсия, токсины,тактика, следственные действия.
- 15 March 2019
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of actual problems of jurisprudence
- Vol. 89 (1) , 134-141
Open AccessПатогенные микроорганизмы как элемент криминалистической характеристики биотерроризма
Статья посвящена криминалистическому анализу обстоятельств поражения материальнойсреды патогенными микроорганизмами при совершении акта терроризма. Тема актуальнатем, что она до настоящего времени не изучена в криминалистической литературе, нерассматривались такие понятия, как «особо опасные инфекции», «биологические агенты»,«бактериологическое оружие», «биологическое оружие», «патогенность», «контагиозныесвойства» и т.д. В криминалистике не систематизированы свойства разработанных к настоящемувремени биологических агентов биологического оружия, механизм и характер следообразованияв той материальной обстановке, где может быть совершен террористический акт с применениемуказанных средств. Не рассматривались вопросы технико-криминалистического обеспеченияпроведения поисковых следственных действий, например, при осмотре места происшествия,если совершен акт терроризма, нет рекомендаций по тактическим особенностям расследованияданной категории преступлений, не известны, в какой процессуальной форме должныпривлекаться специалисты, какие обстоятельства и с помощью каких специалистов должны бытьустановлены для доказывания виновности террориста (-ов), а также не разработаны и другиевопросы, составляющие методику расследования терроризма.Цель исследования, исходя из свойств патогенных микроорганизмов природногопроисхождения и биологических агентов для создания биологического оружия, существующейих классификации по степени патогенности, по способу проникновения и т.д., – выделитьосновные свойства эти микроорганизмов в криминалистическом аспекте, систематизировать ихдля определения тактики проведения следствия на начальном этапе расследования.Методологической основой послужили научные труды микробиологов, вирусологов,биологов, эпидеомиологов, военных эпидеомиологов, посвященные биологическим агентам,биологическому оружию, методам индикации бактериалогического материала, а также трудыкриминалистов, посвященные теории и практике расследования отдельных видов преступлений.Ключевые слова: акт терроризма, патогенные микроорганизмы, биологические агенты, особоопасные инфекции, биологическое оружие, вирус, патогенная бактерия, риккетсия, токсины,тактика, следственные действия.
- 20 September 2018
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
Financial Elites, Law, and Regulation
This chapter considers the often-ignored role of legal elites—practitioners, judges, arbitrators, and academics—in shaping and legitimizing modern finance. The financial crisis of 2007 involved legal innovation as much as it involved financial innovation, and this pattern is not new. Legal history shows us a constant trend, going back at least as far as the seventeenth century, of financial elites working through and with legal actors to reshape, extend, and repurpose legal concepts, categories, and understandings in ways that better serve the ends they seek to pursue. This chapter uses a historical analysis to consider who these legal actors are; the role they play within networks of financial elites and the financial system; how they influence understandings of what is and what is not permissible, possible, or legitimate within the framework of law; and how the law might be structured to ameliorate the most deleterious effects of their influence.
- 20 September 2018
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP)
Financial Elites, Law, and Regulation
This chapter considers the often-ignored role of legal elites—practitioners, judges, arbitrators, and academics—in shaping and legitimizing modern finance. The financial crisis of 2007 involved legal innovation as much as it involved financial innovation, and this pattern is not new. Legal history shows us a constant trend, going back at least as far as the seventeenth century, of financial elites working through and with legal actors to reshape, extend, and repurpose legal concepts, categories, and understandings in ways that better serve the ends they seek to pursue. This chapter uses a historical analysis to consider who these legal actors are; the role they play within networks of financial elites and the financial system; how they influence understandings of what is and what is not permissible, possible, or legitimate within the framework of law; and how the law might be structured to ameliorate the most deleterious effects of their influence.