ANAndrew Ning

Andrew Ning

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Andrew Ning has a total of 96 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Coupled Structural Model for the Gradient-Based Unsteady Optimization of a Wind Turbine Jacket, Tower, and Pile System

    by Weston Pace, Andrew Ning

    Reaching deeper offshore wind resources requires well-designed wind turbine jacket substructures. Prior studies have optimized jacket topology and sizing, but these models often omit the other support-structure subsystems, unsteady effects, or soil-pile compliance from the optimization loop. We optimize the pile, jacket, and tower designs simultaneously, constrained by standard design codes and practices. Using automatic differentiation with SNOPT, we obtain an optimized four-legged jacket substructure supporting the DTU 10~MW turbine at the K13 deep-water site, yielding a total system mass of 1,698~t and satisfying all ultimate, fatigue, modal, and geotechnical limit states. A second study then optimizes the substructure at reduced levels of model fidelity. Designs that ignored fatigue produced damage more than two orders of magnitude above the limit when analyzed under unsteady loading, and rescaling the highest-fidelity design to satisfy damage reached 1.99 times the mass of the unsteady optimum. These findings show that including fatigue and subsystem coupling inside the optimization loop is necessary for mass-efficient deep-water support structures.

  • Open Access

    Efficient derivative computation for unsteady fatigue-constrained nonlinear aero-structural wind turbine blade optimization

    by Adam Cardoza, Andrew Ning

    Gradient-based optimization offers significant efficiency advantages for wind turbine blade design, but its application has often been limited by the cost and accuracy of finite-difference derivative calculations, especially when fatigue constraints are considered. In this work, we systematically compare and evaluate four differentiation techniques, namely algorithmic differentiation, implicit differentiation, sparsity exploitation, and parallelization, to determine their effectiveness in computing accurate gradients through time-domain aero-structural simulations. By integrating these techniques with unsteady nonlinear aerodynamic and structural models, we develop software designed for accurate gradient computation. We show that combining these techniques addresses memory and runtime challenges associated with long simulations required by design load cases. Specifically, the most effective combination reduces derivative computation wall time by over an order of magnitude compared to finite differencing while maintaining superior accuracy. We demonstrate this approach in a proof-of-concept aero-structural optimization of a wind turbine blade that improves the cost of energy by 12.78 %. This comparative study establishes a viable approach for fatigue-aware blade design that balances computational efficiency with modeling accuracy.


  • Open Access

    Aero-Structural-Acoustic Gradient-based Optimization of Electric Ducted Fans

    by Judd Mehr, Tyler Critchfield, Eduardo J. Alvarez, Andrew Ning

    There are many new and exciting technologies employing distributed elec- tric propulsion, including applications for advanced air mobility (AAM). An important consideration for many AAM applications is the trade between aerodynamic performance and noise generation. Electric ducted fans (EDF) have been suggested as potentially able to meet both performance and noise generation constraints. In this work, we utilize gradient-based optimization employing an axisymmetric ducted rotor aerodynamic model, linear cascade surrogate model, geometrically exact beam structural model, and analytically and empirically based acoustics models to explore aero-structural-acoustic trades for EDF preliminary design. We explore rotor count and duct length configurations while optimizing rotor blade and duct geometry for minimum energy expense across a range of tonal sound power level constraints. Our aero-structural-acoustic optimizations of electric ducted fans show that for the low blade counts studied in this work tonal sound power level sources modeled in this work can be reduced by 10 dB for each additional blade with a 0.6-0.7% increase in energy cost for the flight missions explored. Similarly an increase in duct length equal to the rotor tip radius yields a nearly 40 dB reduction in tonal sound power level with an accompanying 4.8% rise in energy expense. For a given configuration, small changes in rotor and duct geometry can provide a 4 dB decrease in tonal sound power level with less than a 1% rise in energy requirements. This work represents a first step in gradient-based, mid-fidelity, aero-structural-acoustic optimization of electric ducted rotors and sets the stage for future development efforts.

  • Open Access

    Efficient derivative computation for unsteady fatigue-constrained nonlinear aero-structural wind turbine blade optimization

    by Adam Cardoza, Andrew Ning

    Gradient-based optimization offers significant efficiency advantages for wind turbine blade design, but its application has often been limited by the cost and accuracy of finite difference derivative calculations, especially when fatigue constraints are considered. In this work, we systematically compare and evaluate four differentiation techniques, namely algorithmic differentiation, implicit differentiation, sparsity exploitation, and parallelization, to determine their effectiveness in computing accurate gradients through time-domain aero-structural simulations. By integrating these techniques with unsteady nonlinear aerodynamic and structural models, we develop software designed for accurate gradient computation. We show that combining these techniques addresses memory and runtime challenges associated with long simulations required by design load cases. Specifically, the most effective combination reduces derivative computation wall time by over an order of magnitude compared to finite differencing while maintaining superior accuracy. We demonstrate this approach in a proof-of-concept aero-structural optimization of a wind turbine blade that improves the cost of energy by 11.4 %. This comparative study establishes a viable approach for fatigue-aware blade design that balances computational efficiency with modeling accuracy.

  • Open Access

    Introduction to and comparison of deep learning and optimization approaches to analytical wake modeling of a tilted wind turbine

    by James Cutler, Christopher Bay, Andrew Ning

    This paper introduces innovative optimization and deep learning techniques to enhance the prediction of complex wake dynamics in the downstream wind velocity of tilted wind turbines. Traditional methods for calibrating the Bastankhah wake model often lead to increased errors in wind velocity distribution due to overfitting of the local wake characteristics. To address this issue, we propose an additional global optimization step to reduce errors in wind velocity predictions with respect to various wake parameters. Despite this improvement, the Bastankhah model's axisymmetric Gaussian wake shape limits its accuracy for complex wake structures. Therefore, we also propose a deep learning approach, which demonstrates promising results by accurately modeling complex wake shapes across a broader range of tilt angles with minimal computational cost. The deep learning approach achieves near-identical predictions to high-fidelity large-eddy simulations, representing a promising advancement in wake modeling.

  • Mission-Focused Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Tilt-Rotor eVTOL

    by Tyler Critchfield, Andrew Ning

    Tilt-rotor propulsion system design requires a multidisciplinary approach to tackle important challenges and competing tradeoffs between disciplines. This paper models rotor aerodynamics, blade structures, vehicle drag, electric propulsion, and tonal/broadband acoustics for a tilt-rotor, electric vertical takeoff and landing aircraft using low-to-mid fidelity tools. The authors use gradient-based design optimization with automatic differentiation and parameter sensitivity analyses to explore the design space and complex tradeoffs of tilt-rotor distributed electric propulsion systems, exploring effects of variations in payload/empty weight, battery specific energy, and blade tip speed. This framework models multiple operating points with a mission-focused objective to account for the effects of both hover and cruise conditions on the overall system performance. Additionally, we develop a Pareto front between range and noise and observe that, for the same noise output, modeling tonal and broadband noise increases range by 3.1% when compared to using a Mach tip speed surrogate acoustics model.


  • Wind Turbine Rotor Design Using High-Fidelity Aerostructural Optimization

    by Marco Mangano, Sicheng He, Yingqian Liao, Denis-Gabriel Caprace, Andrew Ning, Joaquim R. R. A. Martins

    Large wind turbines yield more energy but demand careful aeroelastic blade design. Coupled multiphysics design strategies can reduce wind energy costs by exploiting fluid–structure interactions. This work presents the first high-fidelity aerostructural optimization study of a large wind turbine rotor. We use blade-resolved fluid dynamics and structural solvers in a monolithic gradient-based optimization framework to explore steady-state torque and blade mass tradeoffs. The coupled-adjoint approach computes gradients efficiently, enabling the optimization of over 100 structural and geometric parameters simultaneously. Our optimization study modifies a DTU 10 MW benchmark with a simplified structure and isotropic material properties. The tightly coupled optimizations increase torque by 14% while reducing rotor mass by 9% or reduce blade mass by 27% while maintaining torque. Blade-resolved models provide greater design freedom, enabling 5% higher mass reductions than conventional parameterizations at equal torque. This framework paves the way for more detailed high-fidelity optimization studies to complement conventional design approaches.


  • Open Access

    Introduction and comparison of novel deep learning and optimization approaches to analytical wake modeling of a tilted wind turbine

    by James Cutler, Christopher Bay, Andrew Ning

    This paper introduces innovative optimization and deep learning techniques to enhance the prediction of complex wake dynamics in the downstream wind velocity of tilted wind turbines. Traditional methods for calibrating the Bastankhah wake model often lead to increased errors in wind velocity distribution due to overfitting local wake characteristics. To address this, we propose an additional global optimization step to reduce errors in wind velocity predictions with respect to various wake parameters. Despite this improvement, the Bastankhah model's axisymmetric Gaussian wake shape limits its accuracy for complex wake structures. Therefore, we also propose a deep learning approach, which demonstrates promising results by accurately modeling complex wake shapes across a broader range of tilt angles with minimal computational cost. The deep learning approach achieves near-identical predictions to high-fidelity large-eddy simulations, representing a promising advancement in wake modeling.

  • Open Access

    Interactional Aerodynamics Analysis of a Multirotor Energy Kite

    by Judd Mehr, Eduardo J. Alvarez, Andrew Ning

    Airborne wind energy (AWE) technology aspires to provide increased options for wind energy harvesting at a lower cost than conventional turbines. As AWE technology is still in its infancy, there is relatively little published information concerning its aerodynamic details. In this study, we apply the FLOWUnsteady suite of aerodynamic analysis tools—including a vortex particle method for wakes and actuator line methods for rotors and wings—to the analysis of a fixed‐wing, on‐board generation, wind harvesting aircraft (or windcraft for short). Specifically, we explore variations in the rotation directions and vertical and horizontal (front to back) spacing of the rotors to understand the complex interactional aerodynamics of a multirotor windcraft design. Our results indicate that for the configurations presented herein, the rotor‐on‐rotor and wing‐on‐rotor interactions induce maximum total variations on cumulative rotor performance of less than 3% relative to baseline, with most configurations varying from baseline by 2% or less. In addition, rotor‐on‐wing interactions cause decreases in wing lift coefficient of up to roughly 7% (for the configurations simulated) relative to the isolated wing. Furthermore, through selecting specific rotor rotation directions, it is possible to prescribe a portion of the shape of the wing lift distribution. Further exploration, perhaps with the assistance of optimization techniques, may yield greater insights into this uncharted space of windcraft interactional aerodynamics.