Jan Kandiyali
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Jan Kandiyali has a total of 1 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Martin O'NEill
University of York
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Open Library of the Humanities in Political Philosophy
- Vol. 2 (1)
"We Cease to be Mere Fragments": Justice, Alienation, Liberalism and Socialism
What is the relationship between liberalism and socialism? Partisans of each political tradition often focus on the shortcomings of the other, with socialists charging liberals with defending merely formal ideas of freedom, which lead them to a naïve defence of the status quo, while liberals often view socialists as excessively utopian, and as blind to the ways in which collective forms of economic organisation can lead to oppression. This article examines the prospects for a more eirenic understanding of the relationship between liberalism and socialism, by means of examining the significance of the main points of contention between canonical representatives of each tradition, Rawls and Marx. By examining questions relating to the limits of liberal rights, the problems of alienation and self-realisation in work, the place of distributive principles in socialist views, and the possibility of a society beyond justice, the article defends a partial reconciliation between these two traditions.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Open Library of the Humanities in Political Philosophy
- Vol. 2 (1)
Top Cited PapersOpen Access"We Cease to be Mere Fragments": Justice, Alienation, Liberalism and Socialism
What is the relationship between liberalism and socialism? Partisans of each political tradition often focus on the shortcomings of the other, with socialists charging liberals with defending merely formal ideas of freedom, which lead them to a naïve defence of the status quo, while liberals often view socialists as excessively utopian, and as blind to the ways in which collective forms of economic organisation can lead to oppression. This article examines the prospects for a more eirenic understanding of the relationship between liberalism and socialism, by means of examining the significance of the main points of contention between canonical representatives of each tradition, Rawls and Marx. By examining questions relating to the limits of liberal rights, the problems of alienation and self-realisation in work, the place of distributive principles in socialist views, and the possibility of a society beyond justice, the article defends a partial reconciliation between these two traditions.
- Open Access
- 25 December 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Politics, Philosophy & Economics
- Vol. 23 (3) , 273-294
What makes communism possible? The self-realisation interpretation
In the Critique of Gotha Programme, Karl Marx famously argues that a communist society will be characterised by the principle, ‘From each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs!’ I take up a question about this principle that was originally posed by G.A. Cohen , namely: what makes communism (so conceived) possible for Marx? In reply to this question, Cohen interprets Marx as saying that communism is possible because of limitless abundance, a view that Cohen takes to be implausible for ecological reasons. I develop a new interpretation of Marx's position. On this interpretation, people in communist society achieve self-realisation through providing others with the goods and services required for their self-realisation. Coupled with a reasonably high (but not immense) development of productive power, self-realisation generates conditions in which people can produce according to their abilities and receive according to their needs. I defend this view as an interpretation of Marx and I argue that it represents a more plausible account of what makes communism possible than Cohen's interpretation in which technological advance and limitless abundance play the predominant role.
- 25 December 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Politics, Philosophy & Economics
- Vol. 23 (3) , 273-294
Open AccessWhat makes communism possible? The self-realisation interpretation
In the Critique of Gotha Programme, Karl Marx famously argues that a communist society will be characterised by the principle, ‘From each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs!’ I take up a question about this principle that was originally posed by G.A. Cohen , namely: what makes communism (so conceived) possible for Marx? In reply to this question, Cohen interprets Marx as saying that communism is possible because of limitless abundance, a view that Cohen takes to be implausible for ecological reasons. I develop a new interpretation of Marx's position. On this interpretation, people in communist society achieve self-realisation through providing others with the goods and services required for their self-realisation. Coupled with a reasonably high (but not immense) development of productive power, self-realisation generates conditions in which people can produce according to their abilities and receive according to their needs. I defend this view as an interpretation of Marx and I argue that it represents a more plausible account of what makes communism possible than Cohen's interpretation in which technological advance and limitless abundance play the predominant role.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 11 May 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy
- Vol. 27 (7) , 1032-1049
Should socialists be republicans?
This paper presents a critique of left republican writings from a non-republican socialist standpoint. It examines three claims that have been advanced by left republican authors: that workers are dominated 1) by their lack of access to the means of production; 2) by the market; and 3) by their employer. With regard to 1) and 2), it argues that alternative conceptions of freedom can identify the unfreedom in question, and that there are good reasons for pressing these complaints on the basis of these alternative conceptions. With regard to 3), it argues that, while alternative conceptions of freedom may be able to identify the unfreedom in question, republican freedom provides a more suitable basis for pressing this claim. It concludes that while left republicans have shown that socialists have reason to care about republican freedom, they have not shown that socialists should adopt republican freedom at the expense of other conceptions of freedom.
- 11 May 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy
- Vol. 27 (7) , 1032-1049
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessShould socialists be republicans?
This paper presents a critique of left republican writings from a non-republican socialist standpoint. It examines three claims that have been advanced by left republican authors: that workers are dominated 1) by their lack of access to the means of production; 2) by the market; and 3) by their employer. With regard to 1) and 2), it argues that alternative conceptions of freedom can identify the unfreedom in question, and that there are good reasons for pressing these complaints on the basis of these alternative conceptions. With regard to 3), it argues that, while alternative conceptions of freedom may be able to identify the unfreedom in question, republican freedom provides a more suitable basis for pressing this claim. It concludes that while left republicans have shown that socialists have reason to care about republican freedom, they have not shown that socialists should adopt republican freedom at the expense of other conceptions of freedom.
- 10 August 2017
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Philosophy
- Vol. 25 (3) , 833-839
Marx on the compatibility of freedom and necessity: A reply to David James
In a recent paper, David James argues for a new understanding of the compatibility of freedom and necessity in Marx's idea of a communist society. According to James, such compatibility has less to do with anything distinctive about the nature of labour and more to do with how communist producers organize the sphere of material production. In this paper, I argue that James provides a nuanced and plausible account of one part of Marx's story of the compatibility of freedom and necessity in communist society but that his account misses another, and, in my view, more fundamental part of the story. The part I have in mind centres on Marx's claim that communist producers achieve their freedom through the performance of necessary labour—by helping others to satisfy their needs. I argue that Marx is committed to a stronger claim than James wishes to make, namely, that freedom and necessity are not merely compatible but that participation in the realm of necessity is required for human freedom.
- 10 August 2017
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Philosophy
- Vol. 25 (3) , 833-839
Marx on the compatibility of freedom and necessity: A reply to David James
In a recent paper, David James argues for a new understanding of the compatibility of freedom and necessity in Marx's idea of a communist society. According to James, such compatibility has less to do with anything distinctive about the nature of labour and more to do with how communist producers organize the sphere of material production. In this paper, I argue that James provides a nuanced and plausible account of one part of Marx's story of the compatibility of freedom and necessity in communist society but that his account misses another, and, in my view, more fundamental part of the story. The part I have in mind centres on Marx's claim that communist producers achieve their freedom through the performance of necessary labour—by helping others to satisfy their needs. I argue that Marx is committed to a stronger claim than James wishes to make, namely, that freedom and necessity are not merely compatible but that participation in the realm of necessity is required for human freedom.
- 2 January 2014
- Published by Taylor & Francis in British Journal for the History of Philosophy
- Vol. 22 (1) , 104-123
Freedom and Necessity in Marx's Account of Communism
- 2 January 2014
- Published by Taylor & Francis in British Journal for the History of Philosophy
- Vol. 22 (1) , 104-123
Freedom and Necessity in Marx's Account of Communism
- 1 January 2014
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH
- Vol. 11 (1) , 111-115
Paul Blackledge and Kelvin Knight (eds)
"Paul Blackledge and Kelvin Knight (eds)" published on 01 Jan 2014 by Brill.
- 1 January 2014
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH
- Vol. 11 (1) , 111-115
Paul Blackledge and Kelvin Knight (eds)
"Paul Blackledge and Kelvin Knight (eds)" published on 01 Jan 2014 by Brill.
- 8 October 2013
- Published by Springer Nature in Res Publica
- Vol. 19 (4) , 387-391
Marxism and Liberalism: A New Synthesis
- 8 October 2013
- Published by Springer Nature in Res Publica
- Vol. 19 (4) , 387-391
Marxism and Liberalism: A New Synthesis