Gulay Gurkan
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Gulay Gurkan has a total of 452 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Martin J. Hardcastle
Centre for Astrophysics Research, Department of Physics, Astronomy and Mathematics, University of Hertfordshire
31 shared publications - Isabella Prandoni
INAF – Istituto di Radioastronomia
21 shared publications - Daniel J. B. Smith
University of Hertfordshire
19 shared publications - Wendy L. Williams
SKA Observatory, Jodrell Bank
16 shared publications H. J. A. Röttgering
Leiden Observatory, Leiden University
15 shared publications- Jose Sabater
Astronomy Technology Centre Royal Observatory Edinburgh Blackford Hill EH9 3HJ Edinburgh UK
15 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 6 March 2026
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 707, A198
The LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey
We present the third data release of the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey (LoTSS-DR3). The survey images cover 88% of the northern sky and were created from 12 950 h of data (18.6 PB) accumulated over 10.5 years. Producing the images took 20 million core hours of processing through direction-independent and direction-dependent calibration pipelines that correct for instrumental effects as well as spatially and temporally varying ionospheric distortions. In our 120–168 MHz continuum mosaic images with an angular resolution of 6″ (9″ below declination 10°) we catalogue 13 667 877 sources, formed from 16 943 656 Gaussian components. The scatter in the astrometric precision approximately follows the expected noise-like behaviour but with an additional systematic component of at least 0.24″ that is likely due to calibration imperfections. The random flux density scale error is 6%, while the systematic offset was previously shown to be within 2%. The median sensitivity of our mosaics is 92 μJy beam −1 , improving to 68 μJy beam −1 at high observing elevations, but degrading to 183 μJy beam −1 at the celestial equator due to station area projection effects. Completeness simulations, accounting for realistic source models, time- and bandwidth-smearing effects, and astrometric errors, indicate that we detect more than 95% of compact sources with integrated flux densities exceeding 9 times the local root mean square (RMS) noise. However, the recovered source counts in a particular integrated flux density bin do not match the injected counts until flux densities exceed 45 times the local RMS noise. The Euclidean-normalised differential source counts derived from the survey constrain the radio source population over five orders of magnitude and are in good agreement with previous deep and wide-area surveys. All data products are publicly available, including catalogues, individual-field Stokes I , Q , U , and V images, mosaicked Stokes I images, and uv data with associated direction-dependent calibration solutions.
- 6 March 2026
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 707, A198
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessThe LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey
We present the third data release of the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey (LoTSS-DR3). The survey images cover 88% of the northern sky and were created from 12 950 h of data (18.6 PB) accumulated over 10.5 years. Producing the images took 20 million core hours of processing through direction-independent and direction-dependent calibration pipelines that correct for instrumental effects as well as spatially and temporally varying ionospheric distortions. In our 120–168 MHz continuum mosaic images with an angular resolution of 6″ (9″ below declination 10°) we catalogue 13 667 877 sources, formed from 16 943 656 Gaussian components. The scatter in the astrometric precision approximately follows the expected noise-like behaviour but with an additional systematic component of at least 0.24″ that is likely due to calibration imperfections. The random flux density scale error is 6%, while the systematic offset was previously shown to be within 2%. The median sensitivity of our mosaics is 92 μJy beam −1 , improving to 68 μJy beam −1 at high observing elevations, but degrading to 183 μJy beam −1 at the celestial equator due to station area projection effects. Completeness simulations, accounting for realistic source models, time- and bandwidth-smearing effects, and astrometric errors, indicate that we detect more than 95% of compact sources with integrated flux densities exceeding 9 times the local root mean square (RMS) noise. However, the recovered source counts in a particular integrated flux density bin do not match the injected counts until flux densities exceed 45 times the local RMS noise. The Euclidean-normalised differential source counts derived from the survey constrain the radio source population over five orders of magnitude and are in good agreement with previous deep and wide-area surveys. All data products are publicly available, including catalogues, individual-field Stokes I , Q , U , and V images, mosaicked Stokes I images, and uv data with associated direction-dependent calibration solutions.
- Open Access
- 21 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 546 (3)
What factors shape the radio luminosity of star-forming galaxies? A new calibration from LoTSS-DR2
Radio observations offer a dust-unobscured view of galaxy star formation via the radio continuum–star formation rate (RC–SFR) relation. Emerging evidence of a stellar mass dependence in the RC–SFR relation raises the broader question of how other galaxy properties may influence this relation. In this work, we study the dependence of the global RC–SFR relation on galaxy properties in local ($z\, \le$ 0.3) star-forming galaxies (SFGs) using the second data release of the LOw Frequency ARray (LOFAR) Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS-DR2). Employing a non-parametric decision-tree regression algorithm, we identify the most important galaxy properties for estimating the radio luminosity using a sample of 18 828 emission-line-classified SFGs based on spectroscopic data from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS)-DR8. Along with the spectroscopically obtained SFRs and stellar mass values, we also use SFRs and stellar masses derived using photometric spectral energy distribution-fitting from the GALEX–SDSS–WISE Legacy Catalogue for the same sample. We find that a galaxy’s SFR is most important for predicting the radio luminosity, followed by the stellar mass, at ${\gt} 5\sigma$ significance. Complementing the LoTSS catalogue 150 MHz flux densities with aperture photometry for the rest of the emission-line classified sample (35 099 galaxies in total), we obtain a new calibration of the RC–SFR relation, which does not change significantly whether we use spectroscopic or photometrically derived SFRs and stellar masses, despite the fact that the methods probe star formation on different characteristic time-scales. Our results highlight the utility of decision-tree algorithms for handling censored radio-selected galaxy samples, which will be useful for future spectroscopic surveys of radio sources.- 21 January 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 546 (3)
Open AccessWhat factors shape the radio luminosity of star-forming galaxies? A new calibration from LoTSS-DR2
Radio observations offer a dust-unobscured view of galaxy star formation via the radio continuum–star formation rate (RC–SFR) relation. Emerging evidence of a stellar mass dependence in the RC–SFR relation raises the broader question of how other galaxy properties may influence this relation. In this work, we study the dependence of the global RC–SFR relation on galaxy properties in local ($z\, \le$ 0.3) star-forming galaxies (SFGs) using the second data release of the LOw Frequency ARray (LOFAR) Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS-DR2). Employing a non-parametric decision-tree regression algorithm, we identify the most important galaxy properties for estimating the radio luminosity using a sample of 18 828 emission-line-classified SFGs based on spectroscopic data from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS)-DR8. Along with the spectroscopically obtained SFRs and stellar mass values, we also use SFRs and stellar masses derived using photometric spectral energy distribution-fitting from the GALEX–SDSS–WISE Legacy Catalogue for the same sample. We find that a galaxy’s SFR is most important for predicting the radio luminosity, followed by the stellar mass, at ${\gt} 5\sigma$ significance. Complementing the LoTSS catalogue 150 MHz flux densities with aperture photometry for the rest of the emission-line classified sample (35 099 galaxies in total), we obtain a new calibration of the RC–SFR relation, which does not change significantly whether we use spectroscopic or photometrically derived SFRs and stellar masses, despite the fact that the methods probe star formation on different characteristic time-scales. Our results highlight the utility of decision-tree algorithms for handling censored radio-selected galaxy samples, which will be useful for future spectroscopic surveys of radio sources. - Open Access
- 26 February 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 695, A7
The evolution of extragalactic peaked-spectrum sources down to 54 megahertz
Peaked-spectrum sources, known for their distinct peaked radio spectra, are a type of radio-loud active galactic nuclei. One subtype, megahertz-peaked-spectrum (MPS) sources, which exhibit a spectral peak at a frequency of a hundred megahertz, have emerged as a potential tool for identifying high-redshift candidates. However, the potential evolutionary link between the fraction of these sources and their redshifts remains unclear and requires further investigation. The recent, high-sensitivity Low Frequency Array (LOFAR) surveys enable statistical studies of these objects down to ultra-low frequencies (< 150 MHz). In this study we first used the multi-radio data to investigate the evolution of spectral index with redshift for 1187 quasars from the 16th SDSS quasar catalog. For each quasar, we analyzed available data from the LOFAR Low Band Antenna at 54 MHz, the High Band Antenna at 144 MHz, and the Very Large Array Faint Images of the Radio Sky at Twenty centimeters at 1.4 GHz. We measured the spectral index (α54144 and α1441400) and find no significant change in their median values with redshift. Extended sources have steeper spectral indices than compact sources, which is consistent with previous findings. Based on the spectral index information, we identified MPS sources using the criteria α54144 > = 0.1 and α1441400 < 0, and analyzed their properties. We find that the fraction of MPS sources is constant with the redshift (0.1 − 4.8), bolometric luminosity (1044 − 1048 erg/s), and supermassive black hole mass (107 − 1010.5 M⊙), which suggests that MPS sources have relatively stable physical conditions or formation mechanisms across various evolutionary stages and environments.
- 26 February 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 695, A7
Open AccessThe evolution of extragalactic peaked-spectrum sources down to 54 megahertz
Peaked-spectrum sources, known for their distinct peaked radio spectra, are a type of radio-loud active galactic nuclei. One subtype, megahertz-peaked-spectrum (MPS) sources, which exhibit a spectral peak at a frequency of a hundred megahertz, have emerged as a potential tool for identifying high-redshift candidates. However, the potential evolutionary link between the fraction of these sources and their redshifts remains unclear and requires further investigation. The recent, high-sensitivity Low Frequency Array (LOFAR) surveys enable statistical studies of these objects down to ultra-low frequencies (< 150 MHz). In this study we first used the multi-radio data to investigate the evolution of spectral index with redshift for 1187 quasars from the 16th SDSS quasar catalog. For each quasar, we analyzed available data from the LOFAR Low Band Antenna at 54 MHz, the High Band Antenna at 144 MHz, and the Very Large Array Faint Images of the Radio Sky at Twenty centimeters at 1.4 GHz. We measured the spectral index (α54144 and α1441400) and find no significant change in their median values with redshift. Extended sources have steeper spectral indices than compact sources, which is consistent with previous findings. Based on the spectral index information, we identified MPS sources using the criteria α54144 > = 0.1 and α1441400 < 0, and analyzed their properties. We find that the fraction of MPS sources is constant with the redshift (0.1 − 4.8), bolometric luminosity (1044 − 1048 erg/s), and supermassive black hole mass (107 − 1010.5 M⊙), which suggests that MPS sources have relatively stable physical conditions or formation mechanisms across various evolutionary stages and environments.
- 26 May 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 523 (4) , 6082-6102
The LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey: the radio view of the cosmic star formation history
We present a detailed study of the cosmic star formation history over 90 per cent of cosmic time (0 ≲ z ≲ 4), using deep, radio continuum observations that probe star formation activity independent of dust. The Low Frequency Array Two Metre Sky Survey has imaged three well-studied extragalactic fields, Elais-N1, Boötes and the Lockman Hole, reaching |$\sim 20\, \mu \rm {Jy/beam}$| rms sensitivity at |$150\, \rm {MHz}$|. The availability of high-quality ancillary data from ultraviolet to far-infrared wavelengths has enabled accurate photometric redshifts and the robust separation of radio-bright AGN from their star-forming counterparts. We capitalise on this unique combination of deep, wide fields and robustly-selected star-forming galaxies to construct radio luminosity functions and derive the cosmic star formation rate density. We carefully constrain and correct for scatter in the |$L_{150\, \rm {MHz}}-\rm {SFR}$| relation, which we find to be |$\sim 0.3\, \rm {dex}$|. Our derived star formation rate density lies between previous measurements at all redshifts studied. We derive higher star formation rate densities between z ∼ 0 and z ∼ 3 than are typically inferred from short wavelength emission; at earlier times, this discrepancy is reduced. Our measurements are generally in good agreement with far-infrared and radio-based studies, with small offsets resulting from differing star formation rate calibrations.
- 26 May 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 523 (4) , 6082-6102
The LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey: the radio view of the cosmic star formation history
We present a detailed study of the cosmic star formation history over 90 per cent of cosmic time (0 ≲ z ≲ 4), using deep, radio continuum observations that probe star formation activity independent of dust. The Low Frequency Array Two Metre Sky Survey has imaged three well-studied extragalactic fields, Elais-N1, Boötes and the Lockman Hole, reaching |$\sim 20\, \mu \rm {Jy/beam}$| rms sensitivity at |$150\, \rm {MHz}$|. The availability of high-quality ancillary data from ultraviolet to far-infrared wavelengths has enabled accurate photometric redshifts and the robust separation of radio-bright AGN from their star-forming counterparts. We capitalise on this unique combination of deep, wide fields and robustly-selected star-forming galaxies to construct radio luminosity functions and derive the cosmic star formation rate density. We carefully constrain and correct for scatter in the |$L_{150\, \rm {MHz}}-\rm {SFR}$| relation, which we find to be |$\sim 0.3\, \rm {dex}$|. Our derived star formation rate density lies between previous measurements at all redshifts studied. We derive higher star formation rate densities between z ∼ 0 and z ∼ 3 than are typically inferred from short wavelength emission; at earlier times, this discrepancy is reduced. Our measurements are generally in good agreement with far-infrared and radio-based studies, with small offsets resulting from differing star formation rate calibrations.
- Open Access
- 30 August 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 516 (4) , 4716-4738
A machine-learning classifier for LOFAR radio galaxy cross-matching techniques
New-generation radio telescopes like LOFAR are conducting extensive sky surveys, detecting millions of sources. To maximize the scientific value of these surveys, radio source components must be properly associated into physical sources before being cross-matched with their optical/infrared counterparts. In this paper, we use machine learning to identify those radio sources for which either source association is required or statistical cross-matching to optical/infrared catalogues is unreliable. We train a binary classifier using manual annotations from the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey (LoTSS). We find that, compared to a classification model based on just the radio source parameters, the addition of features of the nearest-neighbour radio sources, the potential optical host galaxy, and the radio source composition in terms of Gaussian components, all improve model performance. Our best model, a gradient boosting classifier, achieves an accuracy of 95 per cent on a balanced data set and 96 per cent on the whole (unbalanced) sample after optimizing the classification threshold. Unsurprisingly, the classifier performs best on small, unresolved radio sources, reaching almost 99 per cent accuracy for sources smaller than 15 arcsec, but still achieves 70 per cent accuracy on resolved sources. It flags 68 per cent more sources than required as needing visual inspection, but this is still fewer than the manually developed decision tree used in LoTSS, while also having a lower rate of wrongly accepted sources for statistical analysis. The results have an immediate practical application for cross-matching the next LoTSS data releases and can be generalized to other radio surveys.
- 30 August 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 516 (4) , 4716-4738
Open AccessA machine-learning classifier for LOFAR radio galaxy cross-matching techniques
New-generation radio telescopes like LOFAR are conducting extensive sky surveys, detecting millions of sources. To maximize the scientific value of these surveys, radio source components must be properly associated into physical sources before being cross-matched with their optical/infrared counterparts. In this paper, we use machine learning to identify those radio sources for which either source association is required or statistical cross-matching to optical/infrared catalogues is unreliable. We train a binary classifier using manual annotations from the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey (LoTSS). We find that, compared to a classification model based on just the radio source parameters, the addition of features of the nearest-neighbour radio sources, the potential optical host galaxy, and the radio source composition in terms of Gaussian components, all improve model performance. Our best model, a gradient boosting classifier, achieves an accuracy of 95 per cent on a balanced data set and 96 per cent on the whole (unbalanced) sample after optimizing the classification threshold. Unsurprisingly, the classifier performs best on small, unresolved radio sources, reaching almost 99 per cent accuracy for sources smaller than 15 arcsec, but still achieves 70 per cent accuracy on resolved sources. It flags 68 per cent more sources than required as needing visual inspection, but this is still fewer than the manually developed decision tree used in LoTSS, while also having a lower rate of wrongly accepted sources for statistical analysis. The results have an immediate practical application for cross-matching the next LoTSS data releases and can be generalized to other radio surveys.
- 8 August 2022
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 664, A83
Nearby galaxies in the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey
Context. Cosmic rays and magnetic fields are key ingredients in galaxy evolution, regulating both stellar feedback and star formation. Their properties can be studied with low-frequency radio continuum observations that are free from thermal contamination. Aims. We define a sample of 76 nearby (< 30 Mpc) galaxies with rich ancillary data in the radio continuum and infrared from the CHANG-ES and KINGFISH surveys, which will be observed with the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey (LoTSS) at 144 MHz. Methods. We present maps for 45 of them as part of the LoTSS data release 2 (LoTSS-DR2), where we measure integrated flux densities and study integrated and spatially resolved radio spectral indices. We investigate the radio–star formation rate (SFR) relation using SFRs derived from total infrared and Hα + 24-μm emission. Results. The radio–SFR relation at 144 MHz is clearly super-linear with L144 MHz ∝ SFR1.4−1.5. The mean integrated radio spectral index between 144 and ≈1400 MHz is ⟨α⟩= − 0.56 ± 0.14, in agreement with the injection spectral index for cosmic ray electrons (CREs). However, the radio spectral index maps show variation of spectral indices with flatter spectra associated with star-forming regions and steeper spectra in galaxy outskirts and, in particular, in extra-planar regions. We found that galaxies with high SFRs have steeper radio spectra; we find similar correlations with galaxy size, mass, and rotation speed. Conclusions. Galaxies that are larger and more massive are better electron calorimeters, meaning that the CRE lose a higher fraction of their energy within the galaxies. This explains the super-linear radio–SFR relation, with more massive, star-forming galaxies being radio bright. We propose a semi-calorimetric radio–SFR relation that employs the galaxy mass as a proxy for the calorimetric efficiency.
- 8 August 2022
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 664, A83
Nearby galaxies in the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey
Context. Cosmic rays and magnetic fields are key ingredients in galaxy evolution, regulating both stellar feedback and star formation. Their properties can be studied with low-frequency radio continuum observations that are free from thermal contamination. Aims. We define a sample of 76 nearby (< 30 Mpc) galaxies with rich ancillary data in the radio continuum and infrared from the CHANG-ES and KINGFISH surveys, which will be observed with the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey (LoTSS) at 144 MHz. Methods. We present maps for 45 of them as part of the LoTSS data release 2 (LoTSS-DR2), where we measure integrated flux densities and study integrated and spatially resolved radio spectral indices. We investigate the radio–star formation rate (SFR) relation using SFRs derived from total infrared and Hα + 24-μm emission. Results. The radio–SFR relation at 144 MHz is clearly super-linear with L144 MHz ∝ SFR1.4−1.5. The mean integrated radio spectral index between 144 and ≈1400 MHz is ⟨α⟩= − 0.56 ± 0.14, in agreement with the injection spectral index for cosmic ray electrons (CREs). However, the radio spectral index maps show variation of spectral indices with flatter spectra associated with star-forming regions and steeper spectra in galaxy outskirts and, in particular, in extra-planar regions. We found that galaxies with high SFRs have steeper radio spectra; we find similar correlations with galaxy size, mass, and rotation speed. Conclusions. Galaxies that are larger and more massive are better electron calorimeters, meaning that the CRE lose a higher fraction of their energy within the galaxies. This explains the super-linear radio–SFR relation, with more massive, star-forming galaxies being radio bright. We propose a semi-calorimetric radio–SFR relation that employs the galaxy mass as a proxy for the calorimetric efficiency.
- Open Access
- 11 April 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 512 (4) , 6104-6121
Deep ASKAP EMU Survey of the GAMA23 field: properties of radio sources
We present the Australian Square Kilometre Array Pathfinder (ASKAP) observations of the Galaxy and Mass Assembly (GAMA)-23h field. The survey was carried out at 887.5 MHz and covers an ∼83 square deg field. We imaged the calibrated visibility data, taken as part of the Evolutionary Mapping of Universe Early Science Programme, using the latest version of the ASKAPSoft pipeline. The final mosaic has an angular resolution of 10 arcsec and a central rms noise of around 38 |$\mu$|Jy beam−1. The derived radio source catalogue has 39 812 entries above a peak flux density threshold of 5σ. We searched for the radio source host galaxy counterparts using the GAMA spectroscopic (with an i-band magnitude limit of 19.2 mag) and multiwavelength catalogues that are available as part of the collaboration. We identified hosts with GAMA spectroscopic redshifts for 5934 radio sources. We describe the data reduction, imaging, and source identification process, and present the source counts. Thanks to the wide area covered by our survey, we obtain very robust counts down to 0.2 mJy. ASKAP’s exceptional survey speed, providing efficient, sensitive, and high-resolution mapping of large regions of the sky in conjunction with the multiwavelength data available for the GAMA23 field, allowed us to discover 63 giant radio galaxies. The data presented here demonstrate the excellent capabilities of ASKAP in the pre-SKA era.
- 11 April 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 512 (4) , 6104-6121
Open AccessDeep ASKAP EMU Survey of the GAMA23 field: properties of radio sources
We present the Australian Square Kilometre Array Pathfinder (ASKAP) observations of the Galaxy and Mass Assembly (GAMA)-23h field. The survey was carried out at 887.5 MHz and covers an ∼83 square deg field. We imaged the calibrated visibility data, taken as part of the Evolutionary Mapping of Universe Early Science Programme, using the latest version of the ASKAPSoft pipeline. The final mosaic has an angular resolution of 10 arcsec and a central rms noise of around 38 |$\mu$|Jy beam−1. The derived radio source catalogue has 39 812 entries above a peak flux density threshold of 5σ. We searched for the radio source host galaxy counterparts using the GAMA spectroscopic (with an i-band magnitude limit of 19.2 mag) and multiwavelength catalogues that are available as part of the collaboration. We identified hosts with GAMA spectroscopic redshifts for 5934 radio sources. We describe the data reduction, imaging, and source identification process, and present the source counts. Thanks to the wide area covered by our survey, we obtain very robust counts down to 0.2 mJy. ASKAP’s exceptional survey speed, providing efficient, sensitive, and high-resolution mapping of large regions of the sky in conjunction with the multiwavelength data available for the GAMA23 field, allowed us to discover 63 giant radio galaxies. The data presented here demonstrate the excellent capabilities of ASKAP in the pre-SKA era.
- Open Access
- 16 February 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 511 (3) , 3250-3271
Accretion mode versus radio morphology in the LOFAR Deep Fields
Radio-loud active galaxies have two accretion modes [radiatively inefficient (RI) and radiatively efficient (RE)], with distinct optical and infrared signatures, and two jet dynamical behaviours, which in arcsec- to arcmin-resolution radio surveys manifest primarily as centre- or edge-brightened structures [Fanaroff–Riley (FR) class I and II]. The nature of the relationship between accretion mode and radio morphology (FR class) has been the subject of long debate. We present a comprehensive investigation of this relationship for a sample of 286 well-resolved radio galaxies in the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey Deep Fields (LoTSS-Deep) first data release, for which robust morphological and accretion mode classifications have been made. We find that two-thirds of luminous FRII radio galaxies are RI, and identify no significant differences in the visual appearance or source dynamic range (peak/mean surface brightness) of the RI and RE FRIIs, demonstrating that both RI and RE systems can produce FRII structures. We also find a significant population of low-luminosity FRIIs (predominantly RI), supporting our earlier conclusion that FRII radio structures can be produced at all radio luminosities. We demonstrate that in the luminosity range where both morphologies are present, the probability of producing FRI or FRII radio morphology is directly linked to stellar mass, while across all morphologies and luminosities, RE accretion occurs in systems with high specific star formation rate, presumably because this traces fuel availability. In summary, the relationship between accretion mode and radio morphology is very indirect, with host-galaxy environment controlling these two key parameters in different ways.
- 16 February 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Vol. 511 (3) , 3250-3271
Open AccessAccretion mode versus radio morphology in the LOFAR Deep Fields
Radio-loud active galaxies have two accretion modes [radiatively inefficient (RI) and radiatively efficient (RE)], with distinct optical and infrared signatures, and two jet dynamical behaviours, which in arcsec- to arcmin-resolution radio surveys manifest primarily as centre- or edge-brightened structures [Fanaroff–Riley (FR) class I and II]. The nature of the relationship between accretion mode and radio morphology (FR class) has been the subject of long debate. We present a comprehensive investigation of this relationship for a sample of 286 well-resolved radio galaxies in the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey Deep Fields (LoTSS-Deep) first data release, for which robust morphological and accretion mode classifications have been made. We find that two-thirds of luminous FRII radio galaxies are RI, and identify no significant differences in the visual appearance or source dynamic range (peak/mean surface brightness) of the RI and RE FRIIs, demonstrating that both RI and RE systems can produce FRII structures. We also find a significant population of low-luminosity FRIIs (predominantly RI), supporting our earlier conclusion that FRII radio structures can be produced at all radio luminosities. We demonstrate that in the luminosity range where both morphologies are present, the probability of producing FRI or FRII radio morphology is directly linked to stellar mass, while across all morphologies and luminosities, RE accretion occurs in systems with high specific star formation rate, presumably because this traces fuel availability. In summary, the relationship between accretion mode and radio morphology is very indirect, with host-galaxy environment controlling these two key parameters in different ways.
- Open Access
Finding Rare Quasars: VLA Snapshot Continuum Survey of FRI Quasar Candidates Selected from the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS)
The radiative and jet power in active galactic nuclei is generated by accretion of material on to supermassive galactic-centre black holes. For quasars, where the radiative power is by definition very high, objects with high radio luminosities form 10 per cent of the population, although it is not clear whether this is a stable phase. Traditionally, quasars with high radio luminosities have been thought to present jets with edge-brightened morphology (Fanaroff-Riley II—FR II) due to the limitations of previous radio surveys (i.e., FRIs were not observed as part of the quasar population). The LOw Frequency ARray (LOFAR) Two-metre Sky Survey (LoTSS) with its unprecedented sensitivity and resolution covering wide sky areas has enabled the first systematic selection and investigation of quasars with core-brightened morphology (Fanaroff-Riley I—FR). We carried out a Very Large Array (VLA) snapshot survey to reveal inner structures of jets in selected quasar candidates; 15 (25 per cent) out of 60 sources show clear inner jet structures that are diagnostic of FRI jets and 13 quasars (∼22 per cent) show extended structures similar to those of FRI jets. Black hole masses and Eddington ratios do not show a clear difference between FRI and FRII quasars. FRII quasars tend to have higher jet powers than FRI quasars. Our results show that the occurrence of FRI jets in powerful radiatively efficient systems is not common, probably mainly due to two factors: galaxy environment and jet power.
Open AccessFinding Rare Quasars: VLA Snapshot Continuum Survey of FRI Quasar Candidates Selected from the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS)
The radiative and jet power in active galactic nuclei is generated by accretion of material on to supermassive galactic-centre black holes. For quasars, where the radiative power is by definition very high, objects with high radio luminosities form 10 per cent of the population, although it is not clear whether this is a stable phase. Traditionally, quasars with high radio luminosities have been thought to present jets with edge-brightened morphology (Fanaroff-Riley II—FR II) due to the limitations of previous radio surveys (i.e., FRIs were not observed as part of the quasar population). The LOw Frequency ARray (LOFAR) Two-metre Sky Survey (LoTSS) with its unprecedented sensitivity and resolution covering wide sky areas has enabled the first systematic selection and investigation of quasars with core-brightened morphology (Fanaroff-Riley I—FR). We carried out a Very Large Array (VLA) snapshot survey to reveal inner structures of jets in selected quasar candidates; 15 (25 per cent) out of 60 sources show clear inner jet structures that are diagnostic of FRI jets and 13 quasars (∼22 per cent) show extended structures similar to those of FRI jets. Black hole masses and Eddington ratios do not show a clear difference between FRI and FRII quasars. FRII quasars tend to have higher jet powers than FRI quasars. Our results show that the occurrence of FRI jets in powerful radiatively efficient systems is not common, probably mainly due to two factors: galaxy environment and jet power.
- 12 November 2021
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series
- Vol. 257 (2) , 30
Characterising the Extended Morphologies of BL Lacertae Objects at 144 MHz with LOFAR
We present a morphological and spectral study of a sample of 99 BL Lac objects using the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey Second Data Release (LDR2). Extended emission has been identified at gigahertz frequencies around BL Lac objects, but with LDR2 it is now possible to systematically study their morphologies at 144 MHz, where more diffuse emission is expected. LDR2 reveals the presence of extended radio structures around 66/99 of the BL Lac nuclei, with angular extents ranging up to 115″, corresponding to spatial extents of 410 kpc. The extended emission is likely to be both unbeamed diffuse emission and beamed emission associated with relativistic bulk motion in jets. The spatial extents and luminosities of the extended emission are consistent with the unification scheme for active galactic nuclei, where BL Lac objects correspond to low-excitation radio galaxies with the jet axis aligned along the line of sight. While extended emission is detected around the majority of BL Lac objects, the median 144–1400 MHz spectral index and core dominance at 144 MHz indicate that the core component contributes ∼42% on average to the total low-frequency flux density. A stronger correlation was found between the 144 MHz core flux density and the γ-ray photon flux (r = 0.69) than between the 144 MHz extended flux density and the γ-ray photon flux (r = 0.42). This suggests that the radio-to-γ-ray connection weakens at low radio frequencies because the population of particles that give rise to the γ-ray flux are distinct from the electrons producing the diffuse synchrotron emission associated with spatially extended features.
- 12 November 2021
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series
- Vol. 257 (2) , 30
Characterising the Extended Morphologies of BL Lacertae Objects at 144 MHz with LOFAR
We present a morphological and spectral study of a sample of 99 BL Lac objects using the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey Second Data Release (LDR2). Extended emission has been identified at gigahertz frequencies around BL Lac objects, but with LDR2 it is now possible to systematically study their morphologies at 144 MHz, where more diffuse emission is expected. LDR2 reveals the presence of extended radio structures around 66/99 of the BL Lac nuclei, with angular extents ranging up to 115″, corresponding to spatial extents of 410 kpc. The extended emission is likely to be both unbeamed diffuse emission and beamed emission associated with relativistic bulk motion in jets. The spatial extents and luminosities of the extended emission are consistent with the unification scheme for active galactic nuclei, where BL Lac objects correspond to low-excitation radio galaxies with the jet axis aligned along the line of sight. While extended emission is detected around the majority of BL Lac objects, the median 144–1400 MHz spectral index and core dominance at 144 MHz indicate that the core component contributes ∼42% on average to the total low-frequency flux density. A stronger correlation was found between the 144 MHz core flux density and the γ-ray photon flux (r = 0.69) than between the 144 MHz extended flux density and the γ-ray photon flux (r = 0.42). This suggests that the radio-to-γ-ray connection weakens at low radio frequencies because the population of particles that give rise to the γ-ray flux are distinct from the electrons producing the diffuse synchrotron emission associated with spatially extended features.