NPNatalia S. Pavlova

Natalia S. Pavlova

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Natalia S. Pavlova has a total of 40 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • How Is Constructive Interdisciplinary Discourse Beneficial to Antitrust in the Digital Era? (On Herbert Hovenkamp's "Tech Monopoly")

    by Andrey Shastitko, Natalia Pavlova

    The article presents reflections on the book «Tech Monopoly» by Herbert Hovenkamp, a leading expert in antitrust law, in light of the evolving exchange of ideas between specialists in economic theory (primarily industrial organization) and competition law in the context of the pervasive spread of digital technologies. Comments are provided on the explanation of certain general limits of antitrust (competition) policy in view of a retrospective of interdisciplinary discourse and the approach proposed by Hovenkamp. The article examines variants of anticompetitive conduct by large tech companies, according to Hovenkamp, in the context of such key characteristics of the regulatory object as two-sided markets, digital content, and network effects. The characteristics of the regulatory response to new challenges are revealed, and it is shown why the vision of the subject presented by the author of “Tech Monopoly” can be qualified in terms of a Coasean approach.

  • Open Access

    Regulating Trade in the Era of Marketplaces: The Effects of the 2016 Amendments to the Law on Trade on Suppliers

    by Дарья Максимовна Азарова, Наталья Сергеевна Павлова

    In 2016, Federal Law no. 273-FZ entered into force, introducing a number of significant amendments to the so-called Law on Trade (no. 381-FZ), adopted in 2009 and the central law regulating trade activities in the Russian Federation. This article assesses the impact of the 2016 amendments on the situation of suppliers to retail chains. Its relevance and novelty stem from the significant regulatory asymmetry currently observed between online platforms and traditional retail chains amid the rapid growth of marketplaces. The paper formulates hypotheses regarding the impact of Federal Law no. 273 on suppliers' commercial expenses, based on a detailed review of legislation, analytics, and empirical research. The findings demonstrate the lack of a sustainable long-term effect of the 2016 amendments, the presence of a short-term decline in commercial expenses for food suppliers in 2017, and a widening gap between large and small suppliers. While some of the restrictions are offset by changes in contract structures, they may hinder competition between chains and marketplaces. The conclusions emphasize that the current provisions of the Law on Trade do not guarantee the equalization of bargaining power and require revision, taking into account digitalization and the development of marketplaces. The theoretical significance of this work lies in clarifying the mechanisms by which industry regulation influences the distribution of commercial costs and bargaining power in vertical relations, while its practical significance lies in providing a basis for amending trade legislation and developing more symmetrical competition rules for offline retail chains and marketplaces.

  • Metalanguage for conceptual diversity in economics: Edgeworth box reconsidered

    by A. E. Shastitko, N. S. Pavlova

    The article proposes a concrete example of developing a positive intradisciplinary discourse, based on a new perspective on the Edgeworth box model within the context of a discussion about the prospects of higher economic education in Russia, which unfolded, among other places, on the pages of the journal Voprosy Ekonomiki. By relaxing the explicit and implicit assumptions of zero transaction costs and the availability of structural alternatives for organizing economic exchanges, the paper demonstrates how conceptual diversity within economic science can manifest in relation to a specific model. It further shows how, in this context, critical thinking skills — as understood in the context of economic education — could be engaged both by established researchers and students for the development of a model of positive intradisciplinary discourse. The exposition is built on the idea of a specific form of metalanguage for intradisciplinary discourse, a function performed by neoclassical economic theory as it is presented in university microeconomics courses.

  • The economics of mediation in contractual relationships: From a fat lawsuit to a lean agreement

    by N. S. Pavlova, S. I. Fedorov, A. E. Shastitko

    Effective mechanisms for dispute resolution and the maintenance of contractual relations in voluntary exchanges are an important means of improving the welfare of economic agents under conditions of risk and actual conflicts over limited resources. A mediator is called upon to assist in resolving such conflicts without directly participating in decision-making. The involvement of mediators in the settlement of business disputes has become increasingly common and continues to gain popularity within the framework of alternative dispute resolution (ADR). Building on the conceptual core of transaction cost economics, the paper explains the economic rationale and scope of mediation in business disputes. It clarifies how mediation differs from the involvement of a third party in transactions (a tripartite transaction governance mechanism) and why it is particularly suitable for supporting hybrid institutional arrangements. Applying the conceptual framework of transaction cost theory makes it possible to identify the functions of mediation and the mediator in contractual relations through two key aspects — contract incompleteness and information asymmetry. The differences between a mediator and an arbitrator, consultant, and regulator are highlighted, and the mechanics of information exchange between the parties with the mediator’s participation are described. In addition to applying the analytical tools of transaction cost economics to explain the economic foundations of mediation, the novelty of the study lies in a detailed analysis of mandatory (forced) mediation as one of the alternative methods of conflict resolution. The paper demonstrates both the advantages and limitations of this approach. Finally, it outlines directions for further research in this emerging field within the frameworks of transaction cost economics and the theory of executive behavior management, identifying several issues related to the use of mediation as a tool for resolving conflicts in antitrust enforcement.


  • Mediation through the Lens of Transaction Cost Economics: Subject Field and Policy Implications

    by Andrey Shastitko, Natalia Pavlova

    Based on the application of the conceptual core of the economic theory of transaction costs, an explanation is offered of the grounds and possibilities of using mediation in economic disputes as a way to ensure the stability of contracts and continuity of transactions in value chains. The place of mediation among alternative mechanisms of transaction management in the spectrum between the hierarchical and market mechanisms is explained using the conceptual schemes of O. Williamson and C. Menard. The paper shows how mediation differs from involving a third party in transactions and why mediation is most appropriate and in demand for maintaining hybrid institutional agreements, which in this case can be ensured by bilateral mechanisms of transaction management. The paper also shows why the participation of mediators in dispute resolution is not a special case of a trilateral transaction management mechanism, but can be attributed to bilateral mechanisms, despite the independence of mediators from the parties to the dispute. Approaches to determining the economic effects of mediation and identifying the limits of the mediator's competence are disclosed. The role, functions and competences of mediators are considered in the context of problems caused by the incompleteness of concluded contracts. The role of diffuse (in the understanding of F. Hayek) and tacit knowledge and their combination as sources of the need for mediation is emphasized. A description of structural alternatives to mediation is proposed, including voluntary and compulsory mediation in their various forms. It is shown that one of the main problems of voluntary mediation as an element of a hybrid transaction management mechanism is enforcement of the agreements reached. This problem can be solved in various ways, including by switching to mandatory mediation. The experience of using mandatory mediation in antitrust regulation is considered. Issues for further economic research of the new subject area are presented in the context of the economic theory of transaction costs. The article was written on the basis of the RANEPA state assignment research programme.


  • Open Access

    Risks From Introducing the Anticartel Government IT System

    by A. E. Shastitko, N. S. Pavlova

    The paper provides an ex ante assessment of risks incurred by developing and implementing the Anticartel state information system (GIS), which will conduct automated screening of Russia’s state procurement in order to detect bid rigging (in other words, software analysis of procurement data using algorithms that identify collusion based on certain formal characteristics). The system will also apply artificial intelligence. Determining the risks of implementing this system is difficult because there is no publicly available information on the specific criteria that will be used in this screening process. This forces specialists to make do with partial data. This paper attempts to reconstruct the operating principles of the Anticartel GIS from external sources including public speeches by representatives of the Federal Antimonopoly Service of Russia together with the technical specifications provided to developers entering the competition to build and implement the system. Key questions prompted by examining Anticartel’s reconstructed features are put forward in order to facilitate analysis during an “expedited” regulatory impact assessment based on the assumption that the decision to employ such a digital screening system is irreversible. The questions and analysis will structure discussion of the risks, associated benefits, and costs of different options for implementation. The principal risks result from probable Type I errors in law enforcement and from the extent of their consequences, which will be amplified as the automated screening system rolls out to include the entire body of regulated procurement, as well as by the use of artificial intelligence. The main consequences of this type of error and how it would arise are explained in the article. In addition, certain risks from using digital tools for identifying collusion especially in commodity markets are identified.

  • National system of price indicators: From theory to practice

    by A. E. Shastitko, N. S. Pavlova, A. I. Meleshkina

    Under the conditions of sanctions against the Russian Federation, foreign price indicators, which were previously widely used by both business and regulators, have become difficult to access and generally less relevant due to changes in the direction of commodity flows. There is a need for a national system of price indicators, the design of which is currently being decided, and the concept, despite more than two years of discussion and a high degree of priority, has not yet been adopted. The purpose of the article is to outline the subject field of the problem of constructing a national system of price indicators both from the point of view of the theory of the issue and in terms of its application to the problems of antimonopoly policy. The approaches of the new institutional economic theory and Austrian economic theory serve as the methodological basis of the study, and its methods are comparison of structural alternatives. The information base of the study was made up of data from the Federal Antimonopoly Service on law enforcement practice. The results of the study emphasize that in order to fulfill their functions, national price indicators must be formed in the conditions of the market (not quasi-regulation) and competition. The volume and frequency of data collected to calculate the indicators should be determined taking into account the power of the regulator as a guarantor, the characteristics of companies and transactions as factors in demand for long-term formula-based contracts, the risks of concerted actions and tacit collusion (as a broader category). The findings enable participants in the debate both within and outside the academic community to understand the scope of what is possible in constructing a national price indicator system, both in terms of the alternatives available and the price that would have to be paid for the preferred alternative.


  • Deglobalization of the Internet: Myth or Reality?

    by Lomonosov Moscow State University, Andrey E. Shastitko, Russian Presidential Academy Of National Economy And Public Administration, Natalia S. Pavlova, Lomonosov Moscow State University; Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration

    The article shows that, along with technical restrictions on access to internet resources around the world, including due to the use of geo-blocking, new deglobalization factors have emerged associated with the spread of digital platforms and the creation of digital ecosystems. The effect of these factors is based on the exploitation of the bounded rationality of platform users and on the difficulties of solving the problem of collective actions of users, which together create new switching costs and impede the development of competition. The approaches of new institutional economic theory and theory of industrial organization are used as the methodological basis for the study. The main strategies of ecosystem leaders to increase the costs of switching for users and to “lock” them into the ecosystem are described: from strategies less dangerous for competition, such as recommendation systems or bonus programs, to more dangerous ones – in particular, strategies to prevent innovations that would make it easier to multihome or to switch between ecosystems. The article demonstrates how traditional theories of harm developed in antitrust can be used to explain the “sharing” of users between ecosystems, and what effects are unexplained and require further theoretical elaboration. In particular, the applicability of the concepts of input foreclosure and aftermarkets to the analysis of ecosystem behavior strategies is analyzed. New approaches from foreign methodological documents in the field of antitrust related to market analysis and merger assessment are considered as ex ante control measures. It is shown that, despite some progress in practice, a number of questions remain unanswered, including at the theoretical level. The article may be of interest to both regulatory authorities and antitrust experts.


  • Big data as a source of market power of digital platforms

    by Pavel A. Levakov, Natalia S. Pavlova

    Big data is widely used by digital platforms in multi-sided markets, which are often considered monopolistic. Big data is analyzed as a potential source of market power of digital platforms, and its characteristics as an economic resource are considered. Arguments for classifying certain categories of big data (for example, historical data) as club goods are specified. The use of big data by digital platforms has already become the object of antitrust proceedings. Based on the analysis of those cases, as well as the review of scientific literature, the relationship between the market power of digital platforms and their use of big data is examined. Firstly, big data can be used by platforms while implementing the strategy of price discrimination. Secondly, the usage of big data creates barriers to entry for new platforms, which are caused by the lack of access to data and increased spending on hardware, software and hiring personnel. Finally, big data can be used by digital platforms to exert market power on adjacent markets and create discriminatory conditions. Based on this research, recommendations for antimonopoly regulation of digital platforms in Russia are provided. Several structural alternatives to antimonopoly regulation of big data are considered: the requirements for anonymized big data disclosure; the creation of a big data market; the partial restrictions on generating and using big data in certain ways (similar to the new regulation in the EU).


  • Microfoundations of dominance of fundamentalism in economic policy: Is there an antidote?

    by N. S. Pavlova, A. E. Shastitko

    The article examines the possible reasons for the dominance of fundamentalism( in the form of Pigouvianism or market fundamentalism) over functionalism (Coasianism) in the practice of decision-making in economic policy. Continuing the study of the relationship between Coasianism, Pigouvianism and market fundamentalism, presented in previous works, the article focuses on finding the basis for the dominance of fundamentalism at the level of individual decisions and actions — in particular, in the field of cognitive bias and behavioral effects. Decision-making using an automatic cognitive system, subject to cognitive bias, as opposed to a reflective system, can lead to the choice of a fundamentalist solution to a problem where it is not the most efficient, and also reduces the efficiency of functionalism, since it prevents the correct identification of the problem itself, of the structural alternatives for its solution, as well as identifying and comparing the effects associatedwith each of the alternatives. The microfoundations of insufficient supply and demand of the Coasian approach are explored. Based on the identified problems of supply and demand for Coasianism, as one of the possible ways to promote it, it is proposed to consider the primary socialization of the individual in the learning process, the formation of substantive critical thinking. It is emphasized that adjustments to the socialization process are a matter of long-term strategy