Joren Severi
Research Subjects
Joren Severi has a total of 36 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Danilo De Simone
IMEC, Leuven, Belgium
6 shared publications Stefan De Gendt
KU Leuven, Department of Chemistry, Leuven, Belgium
4 shared publications- Gian Francesco Lorusso
IMEC, Leuven, Belgium
3 shared publications Alain Moussa
Imec, Department of Advanced Patterning, Leuven, Belgium
2 shared publications- Chris A. Mack
Fractilia, Austin, Texas, United States
2 shared publications Danilo De Simone
IMEC (Belgium)
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 14 December 2022
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 22 (02) , 021006-10
Unbiased roughness measurements from low signal-to-noise ratio scanning electron microscope images
BackgroundMeasuring and subtracting scanning electron microscope (SEM) noise from a biased measurement of roughness leads to an unbiased roughness measurement. This unbiasing procedure becomes harder as the noise in the image increases. For low image signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) (below about 2), unbiased roughness measurement becomes less reliable.AimIt is important to understand the mechanism for the sensitivity of unbiased roughness accuracy to linescan SNR to look for ways to improve unbiased roughness measurement for very noisy images.ApproachUsing a combination of mathematical analysis, simulations, and experimental data, the role of pixel size and pitch in the SNR sensitivity are explored.ResultsAll evidence points to the correlation of edge detection noise to true edge position as the cause of the errors in unbiased roughness measurement for very noisy images. For small pitch patterns, changes in feature edge position caused by feature roughness will cause changes to the linescan slope, which in turn changes the sensitivity of edge detection to SEM image noise.ConclusionsSmaller pixel sizes and larger feature sizes are less sensitive to the SNR effects described here. For any algorithm used to measure unbiased roughness, the impact of linescan SNR must be carefully assessed.
- 14 December 2022
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 22 (02) , 021006-10
Unbiased roughness measurements from low signal-to-noise ratio scanning electron microscope images
BackgroundMeasuring and subtracting scanning electron microscope (SEM) noise from a biased measurement of roughness leads to an unbiased roughness measurement. This unbiasing procedure becomes harder as the noise in the image increases. For low image signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) (below about 2), unbiased roughness measurement becomes less reliable.AimIt is important to understand the mechanism for the sensitivity of unbiased roughness accuracy to linescan SNR to look for ways to improve unbiased roughness measurement for very noisy images.ApproachUsing a combination of mathematical analysis, simulations, and experimental data, the role of pixel size and pitch in the SNR sensitivity are explored.ResultsAll evidence points to the correlation of edge detection noise to true edge position as the cause of the errors in unbiased roughness measurement for very noisy images. For small pitch patterns, changes in feature edge position caused by feature roughness will cause changes to the linescan slope, which in turn changes the sensitivity of edge detection to SEM image noise.ConclusionsSmaller pixel sizes and larger feature sizes are less sensitive to the SNR effects described here. For any algorithm used to measure unbiased roughness, the impact of linescan SNR must be carefully assessed.
- 10 December 2022
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 22 (02) , 021002-12
Role of landing energy in e-beam metrology of thin photoresist for high-numerical aperture extreme ultraviolet lithography
BackgroundLithography advancements require to resist layer thickness reduction, essential to cope with the low depth of focus (DOF) characteristic of high numerical aperture extreme ultraviolet lithography (HNA EUVL). However, such a requirement poses serious challenges in terms of resist process metrology and characterization, as patterns in thin resist suffer from low contrast, which may affect the performance of the edge detection algorithms used for image analysis, ultimately impacting metrology.AimInvestigate e-beam imaging using low landing energy (LE) settings as a possible way to address the thin resist film metrology issues.ApproachA low-voltage aberration-corrected SEM developed at Carl Zeiss is to image three thin resist thicknesses and two different underlayers, at various LE and number of frames. All images are analyzed using MetroLER software, to extract the parameters of interest [mean critical dimension (CD), line width roughness (LWR), and linescan signal-to-noise ratio (SNR)] in a consistent way.ResultsThe results indicate that mean CD and LWR are affected by the measurement conditions, as expected. Imaging through LE unravels two opposing regimes in the mean CD estimate, the first in which the mean CD increases due to charging and the second in which the mean CD decreases due to shrinkage. Additionally, the trend between LE and linescan SNR varies depending on the stack.ConclusionWe demonstrated the ability of low-voltage aberration-corrected SEM to perform thin-resist metrology with good flexibility and acceptable performance. The LE proved to be an important knob for metrology of thin resist.
- 10 December 2022
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 22 (02) , 021002-12
Role of landing energy in e-beam metrology of thin photoresist for high-numerical aperture extreme ultraviolet lithography
BackgroundLithography advancements require to resist layer thickness reduction, essential to cope with the low depth of focus (DOF) characteristic of high numerical aperture extreme ultraviolet lithography (HNA EUVL). However, such a requirement poses serious challenges in terms of resist process metrology and characterization, as patterns in thin resist suffer from low contrast, which may affect the performance of the edge detection algorithms used for image analysis, ultimately impacting metrology.AimInvestigate e-beam imaging using low landing energy (LE) settings as a possible way to address the thin resist film metrology issues.ApproachA low-voltage aberration-corrected SEM developed at Carl Zeiss is to image three thin resist thicknesses and two different underlayers, at various LE and number of frames. All images are analyzed using MetroLER software, to extract the parameters of interest [mean critical dimension (CD), line width roughness (LWR), and linescan signal-to-noise ratio (SNR)] in a consistent way.ResultsThe results indicate that mean CD and LWR are affected by the measurement conditions, as expected. Imaging through LE unravels two opposing regimes in the mean CD estimate, the first in which the mean CD increases due to charging and the second in which the mean CD decreases due to shrinkage. Additionally, the trend between LE and linescan SNR varies depending on the stack.ConclusionWe demonstrated the ability of low-voltage aberration-corrected SEM to perform thin-resist metrology with good flexibility and acceptable performance. The LE proved to be an important knob for metrology of thin resist.
- Open Access
- 1 October 2022
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 21 (04) , 044602-12
Resist reflow methodology development to investigate interfacial interactions
BackgroundTo enable printing of smaller feature sizes, lithography has progressed into the extreme ultraviolet lithography (EUVL) regime. Alongside the wavelength scaling, a reduction in resist film thickness (FT) is observed to avoid large aspect ratios that would lead to pattern collapse. The further progression to high numerical aperture (NA) EUVL will require a further reduction in resist FT moving toward an ultra-thin film regime (<30-nm resist FT). This reduction in resist FT will make the interfacial interactions between resist and underlayer more dominant, potentially influencing material behavior and making resist design challenging.AimWe assess a reflow process as a means to investigate interfacial effects and in this way deconvolute the correlation between resist line volume, interfacial effects, and the reflow temperature (TR), defined as the temperature at which the resist line starts broadening, which is indicative of the glass transition temperature (Tg).ApproachWe pattern a model EUV chemically amplified resist at different nominal resist FTs and different critical dimensions (CDs) and half-pitch (HP) combinations to quantify changes in the TR.ResultsThe TR increases with the inverse of the CD, as well as the inverse of the resist FT. Moreover, the TR also scales with the area ratio (the ratio of the area in contact with the ambient to the area in contact with the underlayer).ConclusionsA linear relationship between TR and its volume factor (CD × FT) normalized for the area ratio (area in contact with the ambient to the area in contact with the underlayer) is found, revealing a combined dependency on line volume and interfacial interactions. This opens the potential for the use of the reflow methodology in investigating interfacial interactions.
- 1 October 2022
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 21 (04) , 044602-12
Open AccessResist reflow methodology development to investigate interfacial interactions
BackgroundTo enable printing of smaller feature sizes, lithography has progressed into the extreme ultraviolet lithography (EUVL) regime. Alongside the wavelength scaling, a reduction in resist film thickness (FT) is observed to avoid large aspect ratios that would lead to pattern collapse. The further progression to high numerical aperture (NA) EUVL will require a further reduction in resist FT moving toward an ultra-thin film regime (<30-nm resist FT). This reduction in resist FT will make the interfacial interactions between resist and underlayer more dominant, potentially influencing material behavior and making resist design challenging.AimWe assess a reflow process as a means to investigate interfacial effects and in this way deconvolute the correlation between resist line volume, interfacial effects, and the reflow temperature (TR), defined as the temperature at which the resist line starts broadening, which is indicative of the glass transition temperature (Tg).ApproachWe pattern a model EUV chemically amplified resist at different nominal resist FTs and different critical dimensions (CDs) and half-pitch (HP) combinations to quantify changes in the TR.ResultsThe TR increases with the inverse of the CD, as well as the inverse of the resist FT. Moreover, the TR also scales with the area ratio (the ratio of the area in contact with the ambient to the area in contact with the underlayer).ConclusionsA linear relationship between TR and its volume factor (CD × FT) normalized for the area ratio (area in contact with the ambient to the area in contact with the underlayer) is found, revealing a combined dependency on line volume and interfacial interactions. This opens the potential for the use of the reflow methodology in investigating interfacial interactions.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2022
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 21 (02) , 021207-13
Chemically amplified resist CDSEM metrology exploration for high NA EUV lithography
Background: The chemically amplified resist (CAR) has been the workhorse of lithography for the past few decades. During the evolution of projection lithography to extreme ultraviolet lithography (EUVL), a continuous reduction in feature size is observed. Also, a reduction in resist film thickness (FT) is required to prevent large aspect ratios that lead to pattern collapse. A further reduction in resist FT, into an ultrathin film regime (<30 nm resist FT), is expected when advancing to high NA EUVL. This brings along associated challenges with (1) resist critical dimension scanning electron microscope (CDSEM) metrology and (2) resist patterning performance. Aim: Assessment of metrology challenges and patterning limits of a CAR working in this ultrathin film regime. Deconvoluting the metrology and patterning effect on the determination of the unbiased line width roughness (uLWR). Approach: Patterning a CAR at different nominal resist FTs on two different underlayers to quantify the changes in CDSEM image quality and resist patterning performance with the resulting uLWR changes. Results: The CDSEM image signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) depends on resist FT and the underlayer. The uLWR increases with a reduction in resist FT but scales differently on the two underlayers. Conclusions: A relationship between CDSEM image SNR and uLWR is found. The SNR and uLWR scaling difference on the two underlayers, as well as the uLWR dependency on SNR was determined to be a metrology effect. The general uLWR increase for a reduced resist FT was determined to be a patterning effect.
- 1 April 2022
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 21 (02) , 021207-13
Open AccessChemically amplified resist CDSEM metrology exploration for high NA EUV lithography
Background: The chemically amplified resist (CAR) has been the workhorse of lithography for the past few decades. During the evolution of projection lithography to extreme ultraviolet lithography (EUVL), a continuous reduction in feature size is observed. Also, a reduction in resist film thickness (FT) is required to prevent large aspect ratios that lead to pattern collapse. A further reduction in resist FT, into an ultrathin film regime (<30 nm resist FT), is expected when advancing to high NA EUVL. This brings along associated challenges with (1) resist critical dimension scanning electron microscope (CDSEM) metrology and (2) resist patterning performance. Aim: Assessment of metrology challenges and patterning limits of a CAR working in this ultrathin film regime. Deconvoluting the metrology and patterning effect on the determination of the unbiased line width roughness (uLWR). Approach: Patterning a CAR at different nominal resist FTs on two different underlayers to quantify the changes in CDSEM image quality and resist patterning performance with the resulting uLWR changes. Results: The CDSEM image signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) depends on resist FT and the underlayer. The uLWR increases with a reduction in resist FT but scales differently on the two underlayers. Conclusions: A relationship between CDSEM image SNR and uLWR is found. The SNR and uLWR scaling difference on the two underlayers, as well as the uLWR dependency on SNR was determined to be a metrology effect. The general uLWR increase for a reduced resist FT was determined to be a patterning effect.
- 1 April 2021
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 20 (02) , 1-14
Power spectral density as template for modeling a metal-oxide nanocluster resist to obtain accurate resist roughness profiles
The Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology (JM3) publishes peer-reviewed papers on the core enabling technologies that address the patterning needs of the electronics industry.
- 1 April 2021
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology
- Vol. 20 (02) , 1-14
Power spectral density as template for modeling a metal-oxide nanocluster resist to obtain accurate resist roughness profiles
The Journal of Micro/Nanopatterning, Materials, and Metrology (JM3) publishes peer-reviewed papers on the core enabling technologies that address the patterning needs of the electronics industry.
- Open Access
Dielectric Response Spectroscopy as Means to Investigate Interfacial Effects for Ultra-Thin Film Polymer-Based High NA EUV Lithography
Extreme ultra-violet lithography (EUVL) is the leading-edge technology to produce advanced nanoelectronics. The further development of EUVL is heavily based on implementing the so-called high numerical aperture (NA) EUVL, which will enable even smaller pitches up to 8 nm half pitch (HP). In anticipation of this high NA technology, it is crucial to assess the readiness of the current resist materials for the high NA regime to comply with the demanding requirements of resolution, line-edge roughness, and sensitivity (RLS). The achievable tighter pitches require lower film thicknesses for both resist and underlying transfer layers. A concern that is tied to the thinning down is the potential change in resist properties and behavior due to the interaction with the underlayer. To increase the fundamental understanding of ultra-thin films for high NA EUVL, a method to investigate the interplay of reduced film thickness and different patterning-relevant underlayers is developed by looking at the glass transition temperature (Tg) of polymer-based resists. To minimize the ambiguity of the results due to resist additives (i.e., photoacid generator (PAG) and quencher), it was opted to move forward with polymer-only samples, the main component of the resist, at this stage of the investigation. By using dielectric response spectroscopy, the results obtained show that changing the protection group of the polymer, as well as altering the polymer film thickness impacts the dynamics of the polymer mobility, which can be assessed through the Tg of the system. Unexpectedly, changing the underlayer did not result in a clear change in the polymer mobility at the tested film thicknesses.
Open AccessDielectric Response Spectroscopy as Means to Investigate Interfacial Effects for Ultra-Thin Film Polymer-Based High NA EUV Lithography
Extreme ultra-violet lithography (EUVL) is the leading-edge technology to produce advanced nanoelectronics. The further development of EUVL is heavily based on implementing the so-called high numerical aperture (NA) EUVL, which will enable even smaller pitches up to 8 nm half pitch (HP). In anticipation of this high NA technology, it is crucial to assess the readiness of the current resist materials for the high NA regime to comply with the demanding requirements of resolution, line-edge roughness, and sensitivity (RLS). The achievable tighter pitches require lower film thicknesses for both resist and underlying transfer layers. A concern that is tied to the thinning down is the potential change in resist properties and behavior due to the interaction with the underlayer. To increase the fundamental understanding of ultra-thin films for high NA EUVL, a method to investigate the interplay of reduced film thickness and different patterning-relevant underlayers is developed by looking at the glass transition temperature (Tg) of polymer-based resists. To minimize the ambiguity of the results due to resist additives (i.e., photoacid generator (PAG) and quencher), it was opted to move forward with polymer-only samples, the main component of the resist, at this stage of the investigation. By using dielectric response spectroscopy, the results obtained show that changing the protection group of the polymer, as well as altering the polymer film thickness impacts the dynamics of the polymer mobility, which can be assessed through the Tg of the system. Unexpectedly, changing the underlayer did not result in a clear change in the polymer mobility at the tested film thicknesses.
- 20 September 2020
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 11517, 115170K
Characterizing Variation in EUV Contact Hole Lithography
Local critical dimension uniformity (LCDU) for contact holes may be correlated with stochastic defects (missing or merged holes), but metrology noise will bias the LCDU measured by a CD-SEM. In this work, large contact hole data sets will be collected with varying SEM measurement recipes, such as different numbers of frames of averaging. Additionally, multiple measurements of the same after-etch features will be used to quantify the impact of metrology noise on the biasing of measured LCDU. Finally, a recommendation will be made as to an approach that minimizes, or eliminates, bias in LCDU measurements.
- 20 September 2020
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 11517, 115170K
Characterizing Variation in EUV Contact Hole Lithography
Local critical dimension uniformity (LCDU) for contact holes may be correlated with stochastic defects (missing or merged holes), but metrology noise will bias the LCDU measured by a CD-SEM. In this work, large contact hole data sets will be collected with varying SEM measurement recipes, such as different numbers of frames of averaging. Additionally, multiple measurements of the same after-etch features will be used to quantify the impact of metrology noise on the biasing of measured LCDU. Finally, a recommendation will be made as to an approach that minimizes, or eliminates, bias in LCDU measurements.
- 14 April 2020
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 11323, 113231A
One metric to rule them all: new k4 definition for photoresist characterization
As feature sizes continue to shrink, low-k1 lithographic processes are required to advance chip technologies. In this context, both advances in optical systems and imaging capabilities as well as improvements in EUV photoresist have led to practical gains in resolution. This work focusses on our latest attempt to characterize photoresist performance by a metric that can effectively exclude all other contributors (e.g. scanner) and quantify the true photoresist capabilities. By a cautious analysis of the previous k4 metric for several use cases and resist platforms (chemically amplified vs. metal-oxide resist), we propose an improved formula that incorporates key resist attributes.
- 14 April 2020
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 11323, 113231A
One metric to rule them all: new k4 definition for photoresist characterization
As feature sizes continue to shrink, low-k1 lithographic processes are required to advance chip technologies. In this context, both advances in optical systems and imaging capabilities as well as improvements in EUV photoresist have led to practical gains in resolution. This work focusses on our latest attempt to characterize photoresist performance by a metric that can effectively exclude all other contributors (e.g. scanner) and quantify the true photoresist capabilities. By a cautious analysis of the previous k4 metric for several use cases and resist platforms (chemically amplified vs. metal-oxide resist), we propose an improved formula that incorporates key resist attributes.
- 23 March 2020
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 11323, 113230G-12
Calibration of a MOx-specific EUV photoresist lithography model
MOx resists have matured into promising alternatives to conventional CAR resists for advanced-node EUV lithography where these materials offer potential improvements to patterning fidelity and high etch resistance based on metallic components. This is a particular boon for processes with limited exposure latitudes such as High-NA EUV lithography. Creating and employing first-principle models of MOx lithographic processes should speed adoption and development of these materials and represents an important aspect of platform maturation. Stochastic photochemical models of metalcontaining resist systems have previously been developed, but without extension to computational lithography. Likewise, stochastic models derived from CAR systems have been fit to MOx lithographic data using computational lithography software, facilitating limited stochastic lithography studies without capturing fundamental MOx imaging processes. Recently, a rigorous stochastic model built from the ground up using MOx-specific resist principles has been developed. In this contribution, the performance of this MOx-specific model was assessed by comparing simulated and experimental lithography data for a series of MOx resists under a range of exposure and process conditions. Chemical and physical properties of the resists derived independently from X-ray diffraction, EUV absorbance, FTIR spectroscopy, and ellipsometry measurements were parameterized in the context of the simulation, and calibration routines were used to fit simulated data to experimental CD-SEM exposure data produced using an NXE-3300B EUV scanner. Insights from these models may be used to guide MOx resist development and EUV lithography process optimization. Ultimately, these studies will help to identify process windows, processing points, and possibly improvements to the MOx resists.
- 23 March 2020
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng
- Vol. 11323, 113230G-12
Calibration of a MOx-specific EUV photoresist lithography model
MOx resists have matured into promising alternatives to conventional CAR resists for advanced-node EUV lithography where these materials offer potential improvements to patterning fidelity and high etch resistance based on metallic components. This is a particular boon for processes with limited exposure latitudes such as High-NA EUV lithography. Creating and employing first-principle models of MOx lithographic processes should speed adoption and development of these materials and represents an important aspect of platform maturation. Stochastic photochemical models of metalcontaining resist systems have previously been developed, but without extension to computational lithography. Likewise, stochastic models derived from CAR systems have been fit to MOx lithographic data using computational lithography software, facilitating limited stochastic lithography studies without capturing fundamental MOx imaging processes. Recently, a rigorous stochastic model built from the ground up using MOx-specific resist principles has been developed. In this contribution, the performance of this MOx-specific model was assessed by comparing simulated and experimental lithography data for a series of MOx resists under a range of exposure and process conditions. Chemical and physical properties of the resists derived independently from X-ray diffraction, EUV absorbance, FTIR spectroscopy, and ellipsometry measurements were parameterized in the context of the simulation, and calibration routines were used to fit simulated data to experimental CD-SEM exposure data produced using an NXE-3300B EUV scanner. Insights from these models may be used to guide MOx resist development and EUV lithography process optimization. Ultimately, these studies will help to identify process windows, processing points, and possibly improvements to the MOx resists.
- Open Access
Molecular Modeling of EUV Photoresist Revealing the Effect of Chain Conformation on Line-Edge Roughness Formation
Extreme ultraviolet lithography (EUVL) is a leading-edge technology for pattern miniaturization and the production of advanced electronic devices. One of the current critical challenges for further scaling down the technology is reducing the line-edge roughness (LER) of the final patterns while simultaneously maintaining high resolution and sensitivity. As the target sizes of features and LER become closer to the polymer size, polymer chain conformations and their distribution should be considered to understand the primary sources of LER. Here, we proposed a new approach of EUV photoresist modeling with an explicit description of polymer chains using a coarse-grained model. Our new simulation model demonstrated that interface variation represented by width and fluctuation at the edge of the pattern could be caused by characteristic changes of the resist material during the lithography processes. We determined the effect of polymer chain conformation on LER formation and how it finally contributed to LER formation with various resist material parameters (e.g., Flory–Huggins parameter, molecular weight, protected site ratio, and Tg).
Open AccessMolecular Modeling of EUV Photoresist Revealing the Effect of Chain Conformation on Line-Edge Roughness Formation
Extreme ultraviolet lithography (EUVL) is a leading-edge technology for pattern miniaturization and the production of advanced electronic devices. One of the current critical challenges for further scaling down the technology is reducing the line-edge roughness (LER) of the final patterns while simultaneously maintaining high resolution and sensitivity. As the target sizes of features and LER become closer to the polymer size, polymer chain conformations and their distribution should be considered to understand the primary sources of LER. Here, we proposed a new approach of EUV photoresist modeling with an explicit description of polymer chains using a coarse-grained model. Our new simulation model demonstrated that interface variation represented by width and fluctuation at the edge of the pattern could be caused by characteristic changes of the resist material during the lithography processes. We determined the effect of polymer chain conformation on LER formation and how it finally contributed to LER formation with various resist material parameters (e.g., Flory–Huggins parameter, molecular weight, protected site ratio, and Tg).