Sana Haroon
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Sana Haroon has a total of 3 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ashraf Iqbal
In charge, Department of Mass Communication, Government College University, Faisalabad, Punjab, Pakistan
1 shared publication - Sameen A. Mohsin Ali
Department of Humanities and Social Sciences, Lahore University of Management Sciences, Lahore, Pakistan
1 shared publication Sumaira Yasmeen
MPhil. Scholar, Department of Mass Communication, Government College University, Faisalabad, Punjab, Pakistan
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 September 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The American Historical Review
- Vol. 129 (3) , 1227-1229
Elisabeth Leake. Afghan Crucible: The Soviet Invasion and the Making of Modern Afghanistan.
Elisabeth Leake’s Afghan Crucible is a history of the ten-year occupation of Afghanistan by the Soviet Union and the civil war that ensued. Eight of the nine chapters of this comprehensive and absorbing account are named for a city that centered an aspect of occupation or responses to it; each of these chapters identifies key actors and provides a thorough account of their organization and imperatives. These chapters come together as a truly international history of the events of 1978 to 1989 that fundamentally changed Afghan politics and society. This is an unparalleled account that will serve scholars and students of the Cold War, Afghanistan, western Asia, international diplomacy, and Islamist politics. Following an introductory chapter about Afghanistan in the 1960s, Leake engages Russian language sources to focus on Kabul and Moscow. Chapter 2 explores the rule of the socialist People’s Democratic Party of Afghanistan (PDPA) after the 1978 coup brought them into power, and chapter 3 reveals that Soviet leaders had to overcome initial reluctance to send armed forces into Afghanistan to reinforce socialist state building and the legitimacy of the government. PDPA carried out its most weeping and radical changes from 1978 to 1979. Babrak Karmal’s rule from 1980 to 1986 was both emboldened by and delegitimized by his reliance on the occupation. Finally, from 1986 to 1992, the government rolled back earlier reforms, never having overcome its uneasy relationship with Islam and traditionalism and its fundamental ineffectiveness. After years of advising and propping up the regime militarily and a final effort to reinforce the PDPA in 1986, the Soviets began to prepare for withdrawal. The Soviet-backed PDPA had failed to create the infrastructures of state that would hold up the regime.
- 1 September 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The American Historical Review
- Vol. 129 (3) , 1227-1229
Elisabeth Leake. Afghan Crucible: The Soviet Invasion and the Making of Modern Afghanistan.
Elisabeth Leake’s Afghan Crucible is a history of the ten-year occupation of Afghanistan by the Soviet Union and the civil war that ensued. Eight of the nine chapters of this comprehensive and absorbing account are named for a city that centered an aspect of occupation or responses to it; each of these chapters identifies key actors and provides a thorough account of their organization and imperatives. These chapters come together as a truly international history of the events of 1978 to 1989 that fundamentally changed Afghan politics and society. This is an unparalleled account that will serve scholars and students of the Cold War, Afghanistan, western Asia, international diplomacy, and Islamist politics. Following an introductory chapter about Afghanistan in the 1960s, Leake engages Russian language sources to focus on Kabul and Moscow. Chapter 2 explores the rule of the socialist People’s Democratic Party of Afghanistan (PDPA) after the 1978 coup brought them into power, and chapter 3 reveals that Soviet leaders had to overcome initial reluctance to send armed forces into Afghanistan to reinforce socialist state building and the legitimacy of the government. PDPA carried out its most weeping and radical changes from 1978 to 1979. Babrak Karmal’s rule from 1980 to 1986 was both emboldened by and delegitimized by his reliance on the occupation. Finally, from 1986 to 1992, the government rolled back earlier reforms, never having overcome its uneasy relationship with Islam and traditionalism and its fundamental ineffectiveness. After years of advising and propping up the regime militarily and a final effort to reinforce the PDPA in 1986, the Soviets began to prepare for withdrawal. The Soviet-backed PDPA had failed to create the infrastructures of state that would hold up the regime.
- 2 January 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Oral History Review
- Vol. 51 (1) , 155-178
Creating an Oral History Archive of Government Work: The Women in Public Service in Pakistan Project
- 2 January 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Oral History Review
- Vol. 51 (1) , 155-178
Creating an Oral History Archive of Government Work: The Women in Public Service in Pakistan Project
- 27 December 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Islamic Studies
- Vol. 35 (3) , 429-430
Law and Muslim Political Thought in Late Colonial North India By Adeel Hussain
Adeel Hussain’s recent book revisits two events of the 1920s and 1930s well known to scholars of Muslim South Asia: the mockery of the Prophet in the Rangila Rasul pamphlet and the Shahidganj mosque dispute in Lahore. Hussain examines Muhammad Ali Jinnah and Muhammad Iqbal’s responses to these events. He additionally examines Jinnah’s belief that legal compromise could achieve very little and Iqbal’s attitude towards the Ahmadi Muslim community. Hussain seeks to bring focus back to Muslim separatism and the ‘more concealed ways’ in which well-known personalities and events of the late colonial era advanced this ideal. In ch. 2 Hussain examines ‘the emergence of the Prophet as a vulnerable figure’ in the Muslim response to the pamphlet Rangila Rasul (1924) that satirized the Prophet’s life. Muhammad Iqbal’s presidential address to the All India Muslim League in 1930 described the Muslims as having suffered an injury that needed healing and khilafat activists and ulema described Muslim feelings of vulnerability. Hussain argues that the Indian Muslim response to Rangila Rasul was formative of, while engagement with the khilafat movement and the notion of the umma in the same period were ‘marginal’ to, the Muslim experience (p. 38). Chapter 3 takes up the story of the Shahidganj mosque that had been occupied by Sikhs since at least the start of the colonial period in the Punjab and was demolished in 1935. Hussain provides a detailed account of the ideas, events, and people that constituted a Muslim response to this mosque demolition. Newspaper reports provide evidence of the positions of the Muslim societies, the Ahrar and the Khaksar, on this matter. Hussain discusses how Muslims ‘began to identify themselves as a minority under threat’ (p. 108), describes electoral politics in this era, and reminds us about the Muslim demonstrations on the street and a host of other contemporaneous political, religious, and legal considerations in Lahore. His reflections on these events are loosely organized by his conclusion, that the Shahidganj dispute ‘stood in for questions of nationality premised on representation, time and territoriality’ (p. 119).
- 27 December 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Islamic Studies
- Vol. 35 (3) , 429-430
Law and Muslim Political Thought in Late Colonial North India By Adeel Hussain
Adeel Hussain’s recent book revisits two events of the 1920s and 1930s well known to scholars of Muslim South Asia: the mockery of the Prophet in the Rangila Rasul pamphlet and the Shahidganj mosque dispute in Lahore. Hussain examines Muhammad Ali Jinnah and Muhammad Iqbal’s responses to these events. He additionally examines Jinnah’s belief that legal compromise could achieve very little and Iqbal’s attitude towards the Ahmadi Muslim community. Hussain seeks to bring focus back to Muslim separatism and the ‘more concealed ways’ in which well-known personalities and events of the late colonial era advanced this ideal. In ch. 2 Hussain examines ‘the emergence of the Prophet as a vulnerable figure’ in the Muslim response to the pamphlet Rangila Rasul (1924) that satirized the Prophet’s life. Muhammad Iqbal’s presidential address to the All India Muslim League in 1930 described the Muslims as having suffered an injury that needed healing and khilafat activists and ulema described Muslim feelings of vulnerability. Hussain argues that the Indian Muslim response to Rangila Rasul was formative of, while engagement with the khilafat movement and the notion of the umma in the same period were ‘marginal’ to, the Muslim experience (p. 38). Chapter 3 takes up the story of the Shahidganj mosque that had been occupied by Sikhs since at least the start of the colonial period in the Punjab and was demolished in 1935. Hussain provides a detailed account of the ideas, events, and people that constituted a Muslim response to this mosque demolition. Newspaper reports provide evidence of the positions of the Muslim societies, the Ahrar and the Khaksar, on this matter. Hussain discusses how Muslims ‘began to identify themselves as a minority under threat’ (p. 108), describes electoral politics in this era, and reminds us about the Muslim demonstrations on the street and a host of other contemporaneous political, religious, and legal considerations in Lahore. His reflections on these events are loosely organized by his conclusion, that the Shahidganj dispute ‘stood in for questions of nationality premised on representation, time and territoriality’ (p. 119).
- 3 April 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Contemporary South Asia
- Vol. 31 (2) , 193-206
Women’s participation in the Central Superior Services of Pakistan 1973–2020
- 3 April 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Contemporary South Asia
- Vol. 31 (2) , 193-206
Women’s participation in the Central Superior Services of Pakistan 1973–2020
- 10 August 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Islamic Studies
- Vol. 34 (1) , 133-134
Boundaries of Belonging: Localities, Citizenship and Rights in India and Pakistan. By Sarah Ansari and William Gould
This coauthored book explores citizenship within the national boundaries of India and Pakistan by identifying and examining the responses of ordinary people to the conceptual frameworks created by the constitution and nationalism. This is urgent work given contemporary debates about rights in India and Pakistan and a valuable contribution to the field of South Asian history in which few models of border crossing studies exist. Each of the thematically organized chapters identifies a body of scholarly work on early postcolonial history and explores events in Sindh and UP connected with constitutional experiments and ideas about citizenship and rights. These themes include: the significance of Gandhi and Jinnah and their deaths (ch. 1), refugees (ch. 2), administrators’ management of public goods (ch. 3), new constitutions (ch. 4), women (ch. 5), and marginalized people (ch. 6). Events such as street demonstrations, demands for accountability of public servants, and demands for rights are...
- 10 August 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Islamic Studies
- Vol. 34 (1) , 133-134
Boundaries of Belonging: Localities, Citizenship and Rights in India and Pakistan. By Sarah Ansari and William Gould
This coauthored book explores citizenship within the national boundaries of India and Pakistan by identifying and examining the responses of ordinary people to the conceptual frameworks created by the constitution and nationalism. This is urgent work given contemporary debates about rights in India and Pakistan and a valuable contribution to the field of South Asian history in which few models of border crossing studies exist. Each of the thematically organized chapters identifies a body of scholarly work on early postcolonial history and explores events in Sindh and UP connected with constitutional experiments and ideas about citizenship and rights. These themes include: the significance of Gandhi and Jinnah and their deaths (ch. 1), refugees (ch. 2), administrators’ management of public goods (ch. 3), new constitutions (ch. 4), women (ch. 5), and marginalized people (ch. 6). Events such as street demonstrations, demands for accountability of public servants, and demands for rights are...
- Open Access
- 30 June 2022
- Published by Humanity Only - HO in Global Regional Review
- Vol. VII (II) , 97-108
A Comparative Analysis of the Editorial Treatment of Arab Israel Relation in US, Pakistan and Iran Press
The principal ulterior motive of this research was to break down the essential content of news editorials considering the details of Arab- Israel relations by a different newspaper. This circumstantial research appraised how much and in which direction diligence was paid to Arab- Israel relations news in the editorial of these newspapers. To delve into the status of Arab- Israel relations in the editorials of elite newspapers, content dissection was conducted. Two theories, the first agenda-setting theory and the second framing theory, were taken as a frame of current research. The determination of detailed results of this study concluded that most of the newspaper contents bounced on the Arab- Israel conflict/crisis and Israel latterly a pperception by Arabs that were highly addressed in the given time period. Conclusion of the quarter editorials summed up the multiple viewpoints. 2/3 of all editorials altercate the nonscientific affirmation. Tehran times had content that was contemptible of scientific affirmation. On the other hand,
- 30 June 2022
- Published by Humanity Only - HO in Global Regional Review
- Vol. VII (II) , 97-108
Open AccessA Comparative Analysis of the Editorial Treatment of Arab Israel Relation in US, Pakistan and Iran Press
The principal ulterior motive of this research was to break down the essential content of news editorials considering the details of Arab- Israel relations by a different newspaper. This circumstantial research appraised how much and in which direction diligence was paid to Arab- Israel relations news in the editorial of these newspapers. To delve into the status of Arab- Israel relations in the editorials of elite newspapers, content dissection was conducted. Two theories, the first agenda-setting theory and the second framing theory, were taken as a frame of current research. The determination of detailed results of this study concluded that most of the newspaper contents bounced on the Arab- Israel conflict/crisis and Israel latterly a pperception by Arabs that were highly addressed in the given time period. Conclusion of the quarter editorials summed up the multiple viewpoints. 2/3 of all editorials altercate the nonscientific affirmation. Tehran times had content that was contemptible of scientific affirmation. On the other hand,
- 1 June 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Social History
- Vol. 56 (4) , 885-886
Hidden Caliphate: Sufi Saints beyond the Oxus and Indus. By Waleed Ziad
This book explores the teachings and activities of the Mujaddidi Sufi Fazl Ahmad and his spiritual and familial descendants to construct a cultural landscape stretching from Peshawar and Dera Ismail Khan in late precolonial India to Bukhara and Khoqand under imperial Russia. Mujaddidis took their identity from their training in the teachings of Shaykh Ahmad Sirhindi (d. 1624). Ziad argues that Mujaddidi sainthood constituted a “hidden caliphate” in the form of a Persianate sacro-cultural sphere; this study of Fazl Ahmad’s lineage maps out a domain of exchange and circulation of Mujaddidi “scholarly, sacred, and diplomatic goods and services.” Chapter 3 and the associated Appendix B track the reproduction of two manuals in print and manuscript form (thirteen of one and nine of the other) presenting a model for understanding the transmission of spiritual knowledge and the extension of the Mujaddidi Sufi order. These manuals served as a Mujaddidi curriculum and,...
- 1 June 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Social History
- Vol. 56 (4) , 885-886
Hidden Caliphate: Sufi Saints beyond the Oxus and Indus. By Waleed Ziad
This book explores the teachings and activities of the Mujaddidi Sufi Fazl Ahmad and his spiritual and familial descendants to construct a cultural landscape stretching from Peshawar and Dera Ismail Khan in late precolonial India to Bukhara and Khoqand under imperial Russia. Mujaddidis took their identity from their training in the teachings of Shaykh Ahmad Sirhindi (d. 1624). Ziad argues that Mujaddidi sainthood constituted a “hidden caliphate” in the form of a Persianate sacro-cultural sphere; this study of Fazl Ahmad’s lineage maps out a domain of exchange and circulation of Mujaddidi “scholarly, sacred, and diplomatic goods and services.” Chapter 3 and the associated Appendix B track the reproduction of two manuals in print and manuscript form (thirteen of one and nine of the other) presenting a model for understanding the transmission of spiritual knowledge and the extension of the Mujaddidi Sufi order. These manuals served as a Mujaddidi curriculum and,...
- 1 January 2022
- Published by OpenEdition in Archives de sciences sociales des religions
- Vol. 199, 45-66
Tribal Elders and Societal Inequities in Pakistan’s Northwestern Borderlands (1947-2018)
Pakistani tribal elders policed and governed their communities in the Pakhtun northwest until they were dismissed in 2018. This paper looks at the role of elders as community leaders and as jurists. The state gave privileges and issued threats to tribal elders, required them to carry out surveillance and community policing for borderland defense in their territories, and to serve on tribal courts called “jirgas” to sentence those accused by the state of crimes. Community members also turned to jirgas to adjudicate intra-tribal accusations of crimes and civil disputes. The principle that the cultural code of Pakhtunwali prevailed in the region provided the rationale for the involvement of elders in border management and adjudication of disputes, but the elements of this so-called tribal code do not emerge in documentation of legal proceedings. These, my paper argues, are better understood as mediations. Judgments in these legal proceedings shaped tribal belonging and status. This paper describes governmental expectations of elders and jirga proceedings as dynamic activities carried out against the backdrop of an armed society and everyday violence, constituting societal inequity. In doing so, it offers a fundamental rethinking of the underpinnings of tribal hierarchy in Pakistan’s northwest.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by OpenEdition in Archives de sciences sociales des religions
- Vol. 199, 45-66
Tribal Elders and Societal Inequities in Pakistan’s Northwestern Borderlands (1947-2018)
Pakistani tribal elders policed and governed their communities in the Pakhtun northwest until they were dismissed in 2018. This paper looks at the role of elders as community leaders and as jurists. The state gave privileges and issued threats to tribal elders, required them to carry out surveillance and community policing for borderland defense in their territories, and to serve on tribal courts called “jirgas” to sentence those accused by the state of crimes. Community members also turned to jirgas to adjudicate intra-tribal accusations of crimes and civil disputes. The principle that the cultural code of Pakhtunwali prevailed in the region provided the rationale for the involvement of elders in border management and adjudication of disputes, but the elements of this so-called tribal code do not emerge in documentation of legal proceedings. These, my paper argues, are better understood as mediations. Judgments in these legal proceedings shaped tribal belonging and status. This paper describes governmental expectations of elders and jirga proceedings as dynamic activities carried out against the backdrop of an armed society and everyday violence, constituting societal inequity. In doing so, it offers a fundamental rethinking of the underpinnings of tribal hierarchy in Pakistan’s northwest.
- 30 September 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Islamic Studies
- Vol. 33 (1) , 119-121
Modern Sufis and the State: The Politics of Islam in South Asia and Beyond
- 30 September 2021
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Islamic Studies
- Vol. 33 (1) , 119-121
Modern Sufis and the State: The Politics of Islam in South Asia and Beyond
- 4 May 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Contemporary Religion
- Vol. 36 (2) , 243-263
The spatial imaginaries of Mujaddidī Sufis and political integration in the northwestern borderlands of colonial India
This article identifies two comparable teaching and learning lines of the reformist Naqshbandiyya-Mujaddidīyya Sufi order in the Indo-Afghan borderlands in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. It describes the strategies of social engagement of the mobile mullās of the Akhund Ghaffūr-Haddā Mullā line and those of the pīrs of the khānqah (Sufi lodge)-centered line of Khwājāh Usmān Dāmanī. The concurrent establishment of these two Sufi lines in the northwestern borderlands of colonial India was an important historical phenomenon inspired by a ‘reformed’ Mujaddidī practice and the two Sufi lines were comparable because of their roots in Mujaddidī reformism. I argue, however, that the two Sufi lines must also be differentiated because of the loci of their participation in and mediation of the day-to-day affairs of practising communities. Members of the Haddā Mullā’s line dispersed among the Pashtun borderland communities to enforce religious priorities from day to day, while members of Usmān Dāmanī’s line consciously confined their activities to the khānqah. The patterns of activity of the members of the two Mujaddidī lines suggest a new framework for understanding the relationship between Islam and politics in the Indo-Afghan borderlands: it was not the ideological approach to Islam, but the spatial imaginaries employed by the frontier Sufis which produced their respective political agendas and impact.
- 4 May 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Contemporary Religion
- Vol. 36 (2) , 243-263
The spatial imaginaries of Mujaddidī Sufis and political integration in the northwestern borderlands of colonial India
This article identifies two comparable teaching and learning lines of the reformist Naqshbandiyya-Mujaddidīyya Sufi order in the Indo-Afghan borderlands in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. It describes the strategies of social engagement of the mobile mullās of the Akhund Ghaffūr-Haddā Mullā line and those of the pīrs of the khānqah (Sufi lodge)-centered line of Khwājāh Usmān Dāmanī. The concurrent establishment of these two Sufi lines in the northwestern borderlands of colonial India was an important historical phenomenon inspired by a ‘reformed’ Mujaddidī practice and the two Sufi lines were comparable because of their roots in Mujaddidī reformism. I argue, however, that the two Sufi lines must also be differentiated because of the loci of their participation in and mediation of the day-to-day affairs of practising communities. Members of the Haddā Mullā’s line dispersed among the Pashtun borderland communities to enforce religious priorities from day to day, while members of Usmān Dāmanī’s line consciously confined their activities to the khānqah. The patterns of activity of the members of the two Mujaddidī lines suggest a new framework for understanding the relationship between Islam and politics in the Indo-Afghan borderlands: it was not the ideological approach to Islam, but the spatial imaginaries employed by the frontier Sufis which produced their respective political agendas and impact.