Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Jakub Mácha has a total of 9 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Language Without Propositions: Why Large Language Models Hallucinate

    by Jakub Mácha

    This paper defends the thesis that LLM hallucinations are best explained as a truth representation problem: Current models lack an internal representation of propositions as truth-bearers, so truth and falsity cannot constrain generation in the way factual discourse requires. It begins by surveying leading explanations—computational limits on self-verification, deficiencies in training data as truth sources, and architectural factors—and argues that they converge on the same underlying representational deficit. Next, it reconstructs the philosophical background of current LLM design, showing how optimization for fluent continuation aligns with coherence-style evaluation and with broadly structuralist, relational semantics, before turning to David Chalmers’s recent attempt to secure propositional interpretability by drawing on Davidson/Lewis-style radical interpretation and by locating propositional content in “middle-layer” structures; it argues that this approach downplays the ubiquity of hallucination and inherits instability from post-training edits. Finally, the paper offers a positive proposal: Atomic propositions should be represented in the basic vector layer, reviving a logical atomist program as a principled route to reducing hallucination.


  • Open Access

    Language Without Propositions: Why Large Language Models Hallucinate

    by Jakub Mácha

    This paper defends the thesis that LLM hallucinations are best explained as a truth representation problem: Current models lack an internal representation of propositions as truth-bearers, so truth and falsity cannot constrain generation in the way factual discourse requires. It begins by surveying leading explanations—computational limits on self-verification, deficiencies in training data as truth sources, and architectural factors—and argues that they converge on the same underlying representational deficit. Next, it reconstructs the philosophical background of current LLM design, showing how optimization for fluent continuation aligns with coherence-style evaluation and with a broadly structuralist, relational semantics, before turning to David Chalmers’s recent attempt to secure propositional interpretability by drawing on Davidson/Lewis-style radical interpretation and by locating propositional content in “middle-layer” structures; it argues that this approach downplays the ubiquity of hallucination and inherits instability from post-training edits. Finally, the paper offers a positive proposal: Atomic propositions should be represented in the basic vector layer, reviving a logical-atomist program as a principled route to reducing hallucination.


  • Framing metaphysics

    by Jakub Mácha

    This paper examines how Ludwig Wittgenstein and Martin Heidegger conceptualise philosophical grounding through contrasting metaphors – Wittgenstein uses architectural analogies, and Heidegger uses arboreal ones – and how these metaphors frame the metaphysical enterprise. Wittgenstein critiques foundational metaphysical propositions (e.g., “The Nothing noths”) as ornamental gestures devoid of inferential function, akin to decorative frames that highlight the beginning of inquiry without structurally supporting it. Drawing on Adolf Loos’s distinction between style and ornament, he treats such utterances as stylistically contingent rather than logically necessary. Heidegger, by contrast, roots metaphysical grounding in an organic, living system: metaphysics is the root that draws nourishment from Being as soil, with the ground being simultaneously inside and outside the structure it sustains. While both thinkers acknowledge the inarticulability of philosophical ground, Heidegger embraces its ambiguity as essential, whereas Wittgenstein views it as a grammatical confusion. The final sections consider poetic and epigraphic elements as forms of textual ornamentation that gesture towards the ungrounded ground of philosophy; both Wittgenstein and Heidegger locate the grounding limits of reason in lived experience. This reading proposes that ornament is not extrinsic but constitutive of how philosophy frames its beginning – stylistically, conceptually, and metaphysically.

  • Introduction

    by Michaela Fišerová, Jakub Mácha

    This volume reconsiders the notion of ornament, which is often dismissed as superficial embellishment or stylistic surplus, and reveals its aesthetic and metaphysical significance. Against the influential rejections of Kant and Loos, the contributors to this volume argue that ornament is not accidental but operative: it decorates by framing, repeating, and stylising in ways that shape perception, social practice, and truth. The different chapters explore ornament through the lens of diverse traditions – empiricism, voluntarism, Marxism, phenomenology, deconstruction, Deleuzian ontology, genealogy, semiotics, and analytic aesthetics – and across a range of cultural practices, including architecture, craft production, music, propaganda, animal training, and writing. Three aspects structure the inquiry: ornament as repetition (ritual), ornament as delimitation (frame), and ornament as aesthetic stylisation. Each aspect is shown to generate aesthetic and political order, legibility, and identity while also enabling deviation, play, and transformation. Taken together, the chapters collected in this volume advance a positive theory of ornament as a constitutive rather than derivative feature of aesthetic practices of decoration.

  • Metaphysics and Aesthetics of Decoration

    by Michaela Fišerová, Jakub Mácha

    This volume offers a fresh and timely contribution to current discussions of ornamentation, repetition, and affect in aesthetics and philosophy. It provides new insights into how ornamentation shapes artistic, philosophical, and social practices, positioning it as a dynamic force in contemporary thought. Through interdisciplinary essays by leading scholars, the volume interrogates ornamentation’s role in structuring metaphysics, aesthetics, and interspecies relations. It challenges the traditional notion that ornament is mere decoration and reframes it as a vital philosophical and cultural concept. Drawing on thinkers like Wittgenstein, Heidegger, Derrida, Deleuze, and Foucault, the contributors explore how ornamentation operates as a parergon, a site of affective repetition, or a marker of epistemological shifts. From critiques of Kantian hierarchies in craft to analyses of Baroque aesthetics and animal territoriality, the chapters reveal ornamentation as both a boundary and a bridge – simultaneously peripheral and essential to meaning-making. This volume offers new and unique perspectives on ornamentation’s universal and culturally specific dimensions. Metaphysics and Aesthetics of Decoration will appeal to scholars and advanced students interested in aesthetics, metaphysics, continental philosophy, and art theory.

  • Open Access

    Inverted Ekphrasis and Hallucinating Stochastic Parrots: Deleuzean Insights into AI and Art in Daily Life

    by Lenka Lee, Jakub Mácha

    This study explores the potential of contemporary large language models (LLMs) to achieve Gilles Deleuze’s goal of integrating art into daily life. Deleuze’s philosophy, with its focus on creative repetition, finds a parallel in LLMs, which replicate and innovate artistic styles by transforming text prompts into various artistic expressions. Although LLMs can very effectively blend and mimic these styles, they remain mere tools – as suggested by the metaphor of a stochastic parrot; the true creative force remains the human artist. Currently, these models are experimental, and their artistic outputs, while impressive, are still viewed as pastiches rather than genuine art. Nonetheless, we can expect advances that may soon enable artists to use LLMs to create genuine artworks.


  • Open Access

    Wittgenstein on the “Alien Will”: A Study of Compatibilism and Divine Influence

    by Jakub Mácha

    In this article, I delve into Wittgenstein’s early manuscripts to examine the idea of an “alien will”, which may have been inspired by Schopenhauer and Weininger. By contrast with other interpretations, I treat this notion not as a metaphor but as the fundamental idea that the world is independent of an individual’s will and appears instead to be influenced by a quasi-divine, alien will. This alien will, distinct from personal will, could either coincide or conflict with an individual subject’s will, affecting their happiness. I argue that this (dis)agreement involves the modal properties of objects rather than being a matter of factual consistency. Ultimately, I position Wittgenstein’s views as a form of pre-emptive compatibilism, according to which divine will shapes human conditions without compromising free will. This contributes a significant perspective to debates in the philosophy of religion.


  • Open Access

    What Should Be? Navigating Moral Exemplarity and Its Categorical Imperative

    by Jakub Mácha

    This essay explores the notion of moral exemplarity, positing that our morality is underpinned by moral exemplars – paradigmatic examples of virtuous individuals or actions. Theoretical precepts of moral exemplarity are explored across historical and contemporary contexts, including the philosophies of Plato, Aristotle, Stoic and Christian ethics, and recent works of Alexandro Ferrara and Linda Zagzebski. This essay debates the necessity of moral exemplars, the intrinsic moral and epistemic exemplarity, and the distinction between categorical and hypothetical exemplarity, as well as referencing the paradoxical Kantian dismissals of moral exemplarity. It critiques current accounts of moral exemplarity and proposes a transcendental explanation, culminating in an examination of the “exemplarist categorical imperative.”