Ilan Fischer
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Ilan Fischer has a total of 29 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Shacked Avrashi
School of Psychological Sciences, University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel
5 shared publications - Daniel I. Rubenstein
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology Princeton University Princeton New Jersey USA
3 shared publications Nigel Harvey
3 shared publications- Simon Asher Levin
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, Princeton University
3 shared publications - Lior Givon
Department of Psychology, University of Haifa, Haifa 3103301, Israel
2 shared publications Lior Savranevski
School of Psychological Sciences, University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Integrating Strategic Properties with Social Perspectives: A Bipartite Classification of Two-by-Two Games
Classifying games according to their strategic properties provides meaningful insights into the motivations driving the interacting parties, suggests possible future trajectories, and in some cases also points to potential interventions aiming to influence the interactions’ outcomes. Here, we present a new classification that merges two perspectives: (i) a revised version of Rapoport and Guyer’s taxonomy, which extends beyond the original 78 games they describe by classifying all two-by-two games according to fundamental strategic properties, and (ii) a novel classification grounded in the theory of subjective expected relative similarity, which addresses not only the games’ payoffs but also the players’ strategic perceptions of their opponents. While Rapoport and Guyer’s original taxonomy classifies only strictly-ordinal games, the revised classification addresses all two-by-two games. It comprises eleven categories that are further grouped into five super-categories that focus on the game’s expected outcome and its strategic stability. The second, similarity-based, classification comprises four main categories, specifying whether players’ perceptions of their opponents have the potential to influence strategic decision-making. The merged classification comprises 14 game types, offering a holistic account of the strategic interaction, the players’ underlying motivations, and the expected outcome. It combines the fixed strategic properties with the variable social aspects of the interaction. Moreover, the novel classification points to the potential of social interventions that may influence the game’s outcome by altering strategic similarity perceptions. Therefore, the present work is relevant for both theoretical and experimental research, providing insights into actual choices expected inside and outside of the laboratory.
Open AccessIntegrating Strategic Properties with Social Perspectives: A Bipartite Classification of Two-by-Two Games
Classifying games according to their strategic properties provides meaningful insights into the motivations driving the interacting parties, suggests possible future trajectories, and in some cases also points to potential interventions aiming to influence the interactions’ outcomes. Here, we present a new classification that merges two perspectives: (i) a revised version of Rapoport and Guyer’s taxonomy, which extends beyond the original 78 games they describe by classifying all two-by-two games according to fundamental strategic properties, and (ii) a novel classification grounded in the theory of subjective expected relative similarity, which addresses not only the games’ payoffs but also the players’ strategic perceptions of their opponents. While Rapoport and Guyer’s original taxonomy classifies only strictly-ordinal games, the revised classification addresses all two-by-two games. It comprises eleven categories that are further grouped into five super-categories that focus on the game’s expected outcome and its strategic stability. The second, similarity-based, classification comprises four main categories, specifying whether players’ perceptions of their opponents have the potential to influence strategic decision-making. The merged classification comprises 14 game types, offering a holistic account of the strategic interaction, the players’ underlying motivations, and the expected outcome. It combines the fixed strategic properties with the variable social aspects of the interaction. Moreover, the novel classification points to the potential of social interventions that may influence the game’s outcome by altering strategic similarity perceptions. Therefore, the present work is relevant for both theoretical and experimental research, providing insights into actual choices expected inside and outside of the laboratory.
- Open Access
Subjective Game Structures: A Behavioral Game Theoretic Analysis of Hidden Perceptions and Strategic Properties Underlying the Israeli–Palestinian Conflict
Here, we apply a novel framework, termed Subjective Game Structures (SGSs), for uncovering and analyzing hidden motivations in ecological conflicts. SGSs enable the examination of implicit attitudes and motivations within individuals and groups. We elicited SGSs from Israeli and Palestinian participants between March 2019 and February 2020 (approximately three years before 7 October 2023), trying to answer the questions of whether Israelis and Palestinians perceived the conflict in a similar manner, whether they have identical assessments of the associated payoffs, and what can be done to reduce future hostilities and attain peaceful solutions. The results reveal meaningful differences between the parties. Israeli SGSs largely reflected expectations of mutually cooperative outcomes, while Palestinian SGSs exhibited ambivalence and a higher occurrence of confrontational expectations from both parties. Approximately 70% of Israeli SGSs and 40% of Palestinian SGSs were categorized as absolutely stable games, indicating that a meaningful portion of participants implicitly anticipated cooperative and mutually beneficial resolutions. Additionally, Palestinian participants’ perceptions of strategic similarity with Israelis were considerably lower than the perceptions of Israeli participants, pointing to meaningful gaps in the alternatives each side was expecting the other side to choose. The discussion highlights the importance of enhancing subjective perceptions of similarity and shaping parties’ perceived payoff structures as two key pathways to fostering peaceful interactions in diverse social and political conflicts.
Open AccessSubjective Game Structures: A Behavioral Game Theoretic Analysis of Hidden Perceptions and Strategic Properties Underlying the Israeli–Palestinian Conflict
Here, we apply a novel framework, termed Subjective Game Structures (SGSs), for uncovering and analyzing hidden motivations in ecological conflicts. SGSs enable the examination of implicit attitudes and motivations within individuals and groups. We elicited SGSs from Israeli and Palestinian participants between March 2019 and February 2020 (approximately three years before 7 October 2023), trying to answer the questions of whether Israelis and Palestinians perceived the conflict in a similar manner, whether they have identical assessments of the associated payoffs, and what can be done to reduce future hostilities and attain peaceful solutions. The results reveal meaningful differences between the parties. Israeli SGSs largely reflected expectations of mutually cooperative outcomes, while Palestinian SGSs exhibited ambivalence and a higher occurrence of confrontational expectations from both parties. Approximately 70% of Israeli SGSs and 40% of Palestinian SGSs were categorized as absolutely stable games, indicating that a meaningful portion of participants implicitly anticipated cooperative and mutually beneficial resolutions. Additionally, Palestinian participants’ perceptions of strategic similarity with Israelis were considerably lower than the perceptions of Israeli participants, pointing to meaningful gaps in the alternatives each side was expecting the other side to choose. The discussion highlights the importance of enhancing subjective perceptions of similarity and shaping parties’ perceived payoff structures as two key pathways to fostering peaceful interactions in diverse social and political conflicts.
- Open Access
- 17 October 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International Journal of Astrobiology
- Vol. 23, e21
Identifying optimal decision-making strategies and determining effective messaging to maximize the expected outcomes of potential human–extraterrestrial encounters
The question of whether extraterrestrials exist has driven both the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) and some attempts of messaging to extraterrestrial intelligence (METI). Nevertheless, no data-driven or theory-based behavioural policy has been suggested. Here we simulate a comprehensive set of human–extraterrestrial strategic interactions, modelled as two-by-two game-theoretic matrices. We examine a sample of possible outcomes by relying on the theory of subjective expected relative similarity (SERS), which takes into account both the expected payoffs and the extent of strategic similarity – the prospects of the opponent making identical choices. Simulation results suggest: focusing messaging efforts on signalling of complete strategic similarity, monitoring potential alien communications for similarity-indicating signals, and using risk-averse decision rules for policy planning and decision-making. The discussion puts forward three guidelines for METI initiatives and addresses the relevance of the findings to human conflict management.
- 17 October 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in International Journal of Astrobiology
- Vol. 23, e21
Open AccessIdentifying optimal decision-making strategies and determining effective messaging to maximize the expected outcomes of potential human–extraterrestrial encounters
The question of whether extraterrestrials exist has driven both the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) and some attempts of messaging to extraterrestrial intelligence (METI). Nevertheless, no data-driven or theory-based behavioural policy has been suggested. Here we simulate a comprehensive set of human–extraterrestrial strategic interactions, modelled as two-by-two game-theoretic matrices. We examine a sample of possible outcomes by relying on the theory of subjective expected relative similarity (SERS), which takes into account both the expected payoffs and the extent of strategic similarity – the prospects of the opponent making identical choices. Simulation results suggest: focusing messaging efforts on signalling of complete strategic similarity, monitoring potential alien communications for similarity-indicating signals, and using risk-averse decision rules for policy planning and decision-making. The discussion puts forward three guidelines for METI initiatives and addresses the relevance of the findings to human conflict management.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Experimental Economics
- Vol. 27 (4) , 922-944
Subjective game structures: eliciting alternatives and payoffs to study the properties of social interactions
The present study transforms subjective conflict perceptions into formally defined games, tests the reliability of the transformation, and explores the properties of several conflict scenarios. To this end we: (i) develop an illustration-based method that transforms implicit perceptions of expected outcomes and experiences into sets of structured numerical values, termed subjective game structures; (ii) develop a reliability index that compares the properties of two subjective games, allowing to test the consistency of repeatedly elicited games; (iii) empirically test game perceptions across eight conflict scenarios; and (iv) interpret the results in terms of two game taxonomies. The results reveal the capacity of the applied methods to transform vague social scenarios into reliable formal games, point to natural solutions, and show the distribution of games that characterizes each conflict scenario. The newly developed model and tools provide a potent instrument for studying a diverse array of social interactions, ranging from interpersonal relations to trade, political conflicts, and war. They represent invaluable resources for conducting polls, examining implicit attitudes, and assisting in the formulation of political, commercial, and social policies.
- 1 September 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Experimental Economics
- Vol. 27 (4) , 922-944
Open AccessSubjective game structures: eliciting alternatives and payoffs to study the properties of social interactions
The present study transforms subjective conflict perceptions into formally defined games, tests the reliability of the transformation, and explores the properties of several conflict scenarios. To this end we: (i) develop an illustration-based method that transforms implicit perceptions of expected outcomes and experiences into sets of structured numerical values, termed subjective game structures; (ii) develop a reliability index that compares the properties of two subjective games, allowing to test the consistency of repeatedly elicited games; (iii) empirically test game perceptions across eight conflict scenarios; and (iv) interpret the results in terms of two game taxonomies. The results reveal the capacity of the applied methods to transform vague social scenarios into reliable formal games, point to natural solutions, and show the distribution of games that characterizes each conflict scenario. The newly developed model and tools provide a potent instrument for studying a diverse array of social interactions, ranging from interpersonal relations to trade, political conflicts, and war. They represent invaluable resources for conducting polls, examining implicit attitudes, and assisting in the formulation of political, commercial, and social policies.
- 15 January 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Behavioral and Brain Sciences
- Vol. 47, e7
The evolution of peace (and war) is driven by an elementary social interaction mechanism
Here we revise Glowacki's model by proposing a simple and empirically tested mechanism that is applicable to a comprehensive set of social interactions. This parsimonious mechanism accounts for the choice of both cooperative and peaceful alternatives and explains when each choice benefits the interacting parties. It is proposed that this mechanism is key to the evolution of both peace and conflict.
- 15 January 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Behavioral and Brain Sciences
- Vol. 47, e7
The evolution of peace (and war) is driven by an elementary social interaction mechanism
Here we revise Glowacki's model by proposing a simple and empirically tested mechanism that is applicable to a comprehensive set of social interactions. This parsimonious mechanism accounts for the choice of both cooperative and peaceful alternatives and explains when each choice benefits the interacting parties. It is proposed that this mechanism is key to the evolution of both peace and conflict.
- Open Access
- 13 November 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Reports
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-10
The effect of similarity perceptions on human cooperation and confrontation
By assuring aversive actions are followed by similarly aversive reactions, legislators of antiquity aimed to reduce belligerence and aggression. In the present study we show how similarity perceptions drive cooperation and confrontation across several strategic decision types. Examining the choices made in three one-shot symmetric conflict games: the prisoner’s dilemma, the chicken, and the battle of the sexes, we show how a short encounter with a stranger accounts for the formation of subjective similarity perceptions, which together with the expected payoffs of the game determine the choice of the preferred alternative. We describe the role of similarity perceptions for all two-by-two games, specifically for a subset of fifty-seven games that are sensitive to similarity perceptions with the opponent. We then suggest that this mechanism, by which individuals maximize expected payoffs, is key to the understanding of the evolution of cooperation and confrontation.
- 13 November 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Scientific Reports
- Vol. 13 (1) , 1-10
Open AccessThe effect of similarity perceptions on human cooperation and confrontation
By assuring aversive actions are followed by similarly aversive reactions, legislators of antiquity aimed to reduce belligerence and aggression. In the present study we show how similarity perceptions drive cooperation and confrontation across several strategic decision types. Examining the choices made in three one-shot symmetric conflict games: the prisoner’s dilemma, the chicken, and the battle of the sexes, we show how a short encounter with a stranger accounts for the formation of subjective similarity perceptions, which together with the expected payoffs of the game determine the choice of the preferred alternative. We describe the role of similarity perceptions for all two-by-two games, specifically for a subset of fifty-seven games that are sensitive to similarity perceptions with the opponent. We then suggest that this mechanism, by which individuals maximize expected payoffs, is key to the understanding of the evolution of cooperation and confrontation.
- 7 July 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Behavioral and Brain Sciences
- Vol. 45, 27-28
Interacting with others while reacting to the environment
Here, we revise Pietraszewski's model of groups by assigning participant pairs with two triplets, denoting: (1) the type of game that models the interaction, (2) its critical switching point between alternatives (i.e., the game's similarity threshold), and (3) the perception of strategic similarity with the opponent. These triplets provide a set of primitives that accounts for individuals' strategic motivations and observed behaviors.
- 7 July 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Behavioral and Brain Sciences
- Vol. 45, 27-28
Interacting with others while reacting to the environment
Here, we revise Pietraszewski's model of groups by assigning participant pairs with two triplets, denoting: (1) the type of game that models the interaction, (2) its critical switching point between alternatives (i.e., the game's similarity threshold), and (3) the perception of strategic similarity with the opponent. These triplets provide a set of primitives that accounts for individuals' strategic motivations and observed behaviors.
- Open Access
- 15 June 2022
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 9 (6) , 211515
Vaccination-hesitancy and global warming: distinct social challenges with similar behavioural solutions
Although the COVID-19 vaccine has dramatically changed the fight against the pandemic, many exhibit vaccination-hesitancy. At the same time, continued human-induced emissions of greenhouse gases pose an alarming threat to humanity. Based on the theory of Subjective Expected Relative Similarity (SERS) and a recent international study that drastically modified COVID-19 health-related attitudes, we explain why a similar approach and a corresponding public policy are expected to help resolve both behavioural issues: reduce vaccination hesitancy and motivate climate actions.
- 15 June 2022
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 9 (6) , 211515
Open AccessVaccination-hesitancy and global warming: distinct social challenges with similar behavioural solutions
Although the COVID-19 vaccine has dramatically changed the fight against the pandemic, many exhibit vaccination-hesitancy. At the same time, continued human-induced emissions of greenhouse gases pose an alarming threat to humanity. Based on the theory of Subjective Expected Relative Similarity (SERS) and a recent international study that drastically modified COVID-19 health-related attitudes, we explain why a similar approach and a corresponding public policy are expected to help resolve both behavioural issues: reduce vaccination hesitancy and motivate climate actions.
- Open Access
- 26 August 2020
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 7 (8)
The behavioural challenge of the COVID-19 pandemic: indirect measurements and personalized attitude changing treatments (IMPACT)
Following the outbreak of COVID-19 pandemic, governments around the globe coerced their citizens to adhere to preventive health behaviours, aiming to reduce theeffectivereproduction numbers of the virus. Driven by game theoretic considerations and inspired by the work of US National Research Council's Committee on Food Habits (1943) during WWII, and the post-WWII Yale Communication Research Program, the present research shows how to achieve enhanced adherence to health regulations without coercion. To this aim, we combine three elements: (i) indirect measurements, (ii) personalized interventions, and (iii) attitude changing treatments (IMPACT). We find that a cluster of short interventions, such as elaboration on possible consequences, induction of cognitive dissonance, addressing next of kin and similar others and receiving advice following severity judgements, improves individuals' health-preserving attitudes. We propose extending the use of IMPACT under closure periods and during the resumption of social and economic activities under COVID-19 pandemic, since efficient and lasting adherence should rely on personal attitudes rather than on coercion alone. Finally, we point to the opportunity of international cooperation generated by the pandemic.
- 26 August 2020
- Published by The Royal Society in Royal Society Open Science
- Vol. 7 (8)
Open AccessThe behavioural challenge of the COVID-19 pandemic: indirect measurements and personalized attitude changing treatments (IMPACT)
Following the outbreak of COVID-19 pandemic, governments around the globe coerced their citizens to adhere to preventive health behaviours, aiming to reduce theeffectivereproduction numbers of the virus. Driven by game theoretic considerations and inspired by the work of US National Research Council's Committee on Food Habits (1943) during WWII, and the post-WWII Yale Communication Research Program, the present research shows how to achieve enhanced adherence to health regulations without coercion. To this aim, we combine three elements: (i) indirect measurements, (ii) personalized interventions, and (iii) attitude changing treatments (IMPACT). We find that a cluster of short interventions, such as elaboration on possible consequences, induction of cognitive dissonance, addressing next of kin and similar others and receiving advice following severity judgements, improves individuals' health-preserving attitudes. We propose extending the use of IMPACT under closure periods and during the resumption of social and economic activities under COVID-19 pandemic, since efficient and lasting adherence should rely on personal attitudes rather than on coercion alone. Finally, we point to the opportunity of international cooperation generated by the pandemic.
- 5 June 2015
- Published by Springer Nature in Memory & Cognition
- Vol. 43 (7) , 1056-1070
Extending the two faces of subjective randomness: From the gambler’s and hot-hand fallacies toward a hierarchy of binary sequence perception
In this study, we examined perceptions of binary sequences under uncertainty in an attempt to depict a holistic and unifying framework. The first experiment applied a projection method that motivated participants to observe binary series and provide descriptions of their possible underlying mechanisms or processes. This procedure revealed four distinct perceptual categories: two previously studied categories of chance mechanisms and human performance, associated with the gambler’s and hot-hand fallacies, and two newly identified categories—periods and processes and traits and preferences. The next three experiments tested the associations between the four categories and the alternation rates of the observed sequences under three categorical decisions structures: screening, discrimination, and classification. The results reveal the relativity of binary sequence perception. They show that the categories of chance mechanisms and periods and processes reflected rather stable perception across all tested conditions, whereas the other two categories were more susceptible to the context in which they were embedded. The findings support previous research on the gambler’s fallacy and show that the hot-hand fallacy is confined to comparisons of human performance and chance mechanisms. A proposed developmental hierarchy suggests that all four categories embody basic cognitive structures that assist in detecting, decoding, and interpreting both inanimate and social aspects of the environment.
- 5 June 2015
- Published by Springer Nature in Memory & Cognition
- Vol. 43 (7) , 1056-1070
Extending the two faces of subjective randomness: From the gambler’s and hot-hand fallacies toward a hierarchy of binary sequence perception
In this study, we examined perceptions of binary sequences under uncertainty in an attempt to depict a holistic and unifying framework. The first experiment applied a projection method that motivated participants to observe binary series and provide descriptions of their possible underlying mechanisms or processes. This procedure revealed four distinct perceptual categories: two previously studied categories of chance mechanisms and human performance, associated with the gambler’s and hot-hand fallacies, and two newly identified categories—periods and processes and traits and preferences. The next three experiments tested the associations between the four categories and the alternation rates of the observed sequences under three categorical decisions structures: screening, discrimination, and classification. The results reveal the relativity of binary sequence perception. They show that the categories of chance mechanisms and periods and processes reflected rather stable perception across all tested conditions, whereas the other two categories were more susceptible to the context in which they were embedded. The findings support previous research on the gambler’s fallacy and show that the hot-hand fallacy is confined to comparisons of human performance and chance mechanisms. A proposed developmental hierarchy suggests that all four categories embody basic cognitive structures that assist in detecting, decoding, and interpreting both inanimate and social aspects of the environment.