JHJuliet Hounsome

Juliet Hounsome

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Juliet Hounsome has a total of 72 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

    • 19 November 2026
    • Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
      • https://doi.org/10.20944/preprints202611.2061.v1
    Open Access

    Learnings from Healthcare Systems with Large Reductions in Cancer Mortality: A Rapid Evidence Summary

    by Meg Kiseleva, Judit Csontos, Elizabeth Gillen, Juliet Hounsome, Mala Mann, Lasith Dissanayake, Manasi Patil, Deborah Edwards, Adrian Edwards, Alison Cooper, et al.

    In Wales, cancer is responsible for more than one in four deaths. The incidence of cancer is on the rise and it is projected that by 2035, there will be approximately 24,000 new cancer cases each year in Wales compared to approximately 20,000 in 2019. A new 10-year National Cancer Strategy for Wales will be announced in February 2027. This document was produced to gather learnings from other countries that have achieved improved cancer outcomes in recent years, to support the development of the strategy.The aim of this rapid evidence summary was to identify and describe structures and processes implemented at a national or regional level in countries that have significantly improved cancer outcomes in recent years.This rapid evidence summary consists of two parts. The first part summarised published evidence that directly linked cancer outcomes to country-level factors. Systematic searches of multiple academic and grey literature databases as well as supplementary searches were used to identify such evidence. The second part of this document reported learnings from countries with large reductions in mortality. Targeted searches for country-specific evidence were performed. Findings were summarised narratively.This rapid evidence summary identified only two studies linking relevant country-level factors, including healthcare system characteristics and characteristics of countries’ cancer plans and strategies, to cancer outcomes. To support the development of the new 10-year National Cancer Strategy for Wales, learnings from countries that have seen large improvements in cancer mortality over the recent years have been identified and summarised. While it is difficult to directly link improvements in cancer outcomes in a country to national cancer plans, we hope that examples of cancer-related activities in a wide range of countries that have successfully reduced mortality will provide useful learnings. Due to the high variation in the country contexts, considerations about the applicability to Wales need to be made. In the report, we also discuss the policy and practice implications of the findings, and the research implications and evidence gaps.

  • Open Access

    Unified tools for assessing the methodological quality of intervention effects in rapid reviews: a scoping review

    by Deborah Edwards, Emily C. Clark, Judit Csontos, Maureen Dobbins, Elizabeth Gillen, Juliet Hounsome, Sarah E. Neil-Sztramko, Ruth Lewis, Mala Mann, Gillian Prue

    Background: Evaluating the methodological quality of primary studies is a crucial aspect of evidence syntheses, such as rapid reviews. Rapid reviews often include both randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and non-randomised studies (NRSIs) requiring multiple design-specific quality assessment tools. This can complicate workflows and reduce efficiency. Unified tools, designed to assess methodological quality across diverse study designs, may offer a more consistent and streamlined approach. This scoping review aimed to comprehensively identify and describe unified tools for assessing methodological quality across both RCTs and NRSIs. Methods: The review followed JBI scoping review methodology and was reported in line with PRISMA-ScR guidance. Searches were conducted in MEDLINE (Ovid), Embase (Ovid), and CINAHL (EBSCO) from 1998 to 2024, alongside grey literature searches, citation tracking, targeted website searches, and consultation with experts in evidence synthesis. Study selection was performed by two independent reviewers. A tool was defined as any structured instrument developed to support users in assessing methodological quality. Results: A total of 55 publications were included, identifying 29 unique unified tools. These were categorised by structure: scales ( n = 14), checklists with an additional summary judgement ( n = 7), simple checklists ( n = 5), domain-based tools ( n = 2), and other tools ( n = 1). All tools were designed to assess both RCTs and NRSIs, with many also applicable to additional study designs, including descriptive studies ( n = 15), case reports or series ( n = 9), qualitative research ( n = 7), and systematic reviews ( n = 3). Unified tools were developed using a mixture of approaches including literature reviewing ( n = 25), expert consensus ( n = 20), and stakeholder consultations ( n = 17) and pilot testing ( n = 17). Evaluation of psychometric properties was conducted to varying levels across different domains of validity and reliability. Conclusion: This review identified a diverse set of unified tools for assessing methodological quality across both RCTs and NRSIs. However, variation in tool structure, the availability of accompanying guidance, and the limited evaluation of psychometric properties, particularly inter-rater reliability and criterion validity, indicate potential issues for adoption in rapid reviews. Unified tools need further refinement and validation to be embedded in the rapid review process. Systematic review registration: https://osf.io/nyteu/

  • Open Access

    A rapid review of multi-agency working to support transition out of children’s social care

    by Meg Kiseleva, Juliet Hounsome, Mala Mann, Judit Csontos, Elizabeth Gillen, Maria Diamond, Jacob Davies, Rhiannon Tudor Edwards, Melanie McAuley, Adrian Edwards, et al.

    Transition from children’s social care is a complex and often challenging process, and coordination between different agencies, such as health, education, and social care, is important to ensure effective communication, engagement, and continuity of care. This review focuses on young people’s experiences with multi-agency approaches to support transition from children’s social care to adults’ social care or support, their perceptions of success of such approaches, and barriers and facilitators of implementing multi-agency approaches to transition and to young people engaging with them. This review included 22 UK studies published between 2014 and 2025. Seven of the studies focused on care leavers, six on young people with learning disabilities (LD) or special educational needs or disabilities (SEND), five on young people in the justice system, and four on other groups of young people. Many of the multi-agency initiatives primarily focused on housing support. For young people in the justice system, the initiatives mainly focused on resettlement in community. There were also studies about broader planning for support needs when the young person transitioned to adulthood.The experiences and perceived success of multi-agency working: Care leavers’ experiences of transitions varied, with some young people experiencing anxiety and distress. Perceptions of the benefits of initiatives often related to the quality of their relationship with their transition worker. Some young people said their confidence, general skills, social relationships, and mental health improved during their involvement in multi-agency initiatives. Little evidence was identified about experiences of young people with LD/SEND. For young people in the justice system, mixed experiences were described. Little information was identified about success of multi-agency work as perceived by young people. Some positive experiences with multi-agency working were also described.Barriers and facilitators of implementing multi-agency work: Barriers included insufficient resources, structural issues and policy and strategy limitations. Shared practices, priorities, and vision as well as information sharing between agencies were important. A significant practitioner-related factor was staff expertise. Barriers and facilitators of young people engaging with multi-agency work: Awareness of the services and flexibility in how young people could engage with them were important factors. More support with engagement for young people could act as a facilitator. Personal factors that might act as barriers to engagement for young people were identified. Good relationships with staff and positive staff attitudes were important facilitators.The review identified evidence gaps and a need for further robust research.

  • Open Access

    Unified tools for assessing the methodological quality of intervention effects in rapid reviews: a scoping review

    by Deborah Edwards, Emily C Clark, Judit Csontos, Maureen Dobbins, Elizabeth Gillen, Juliet Hounsome, Sarah E. Neil-Sztramko, Ruth Lewis, Mala Mann, Gillian Prue

    Background: Evaluating the methodological quality of primary studies is a crucial aspect of evidence syntheses, such as rapid reviews. Rapid reviews often include both randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and non-randomised studies (NRSIs) requiring multiple design-specific methodological quality assessment tools. This can complicate workflows and reduce efficiency. Unified tools, designed to assess methodological quality across diverse study designs, may offer a more consistent and streamlined approach. This scoping review aimed to comprehensively identify and describe unified tools for assessing methodological quality across both RCTs and NRSIs. Methods: The review followed JBI scoping review methodology and was reported in line with PRISMA-ScR guidance. Searches were conducted in MEDLINE (Ovid), Embase (Ovid), and CINAHL (EBSCO) from 1998 to 2024, alongside grey literature searches, citation tracking, targeted website searches, and consultation with experts in evidence synthesis. Study selection was performed by two independent reviewers. A tool was defined as any structured instrument developed to support users in assessing methodological quality. Results: A total of 55 publications were included, identifying 29 unique unified tools. These were categorized by structure: scales (n=14), checklists with judgment (n=7), simple checklists (n=5), domain-based tools (n=2), and other tools (n=1). All tools were designed to assess both RCTs and NRSIs. Of these, 13 focused exclusively on RCTs and NRSIs, while others extended to descriptive studies (n=15), case reports or series (n=9), qualitative research (n=7), and systematic reviews (n=3). Unified tools were developed using a mixture of approaches including literature reviewing (n=25), expert consensus (n=20), and stakeholder consultations (n=17). Reports of pilot testing was identified for 17 unified tools, and evaluation of psychometric properties was conducted to varying levels across different domains of validity and reliability. Conclusion: This review identified a diverse set of unified tools for assessing methodological quality across both RCTs and NRSIs. However, variation in tool structure, the availability of accompanying guidance, and the limited evaluation of psychometric properties, particularly interrater reliability and criterion validity, indicate potential issues for adoption in rapid reviews. Unified tools need further refinement and validation to be embedded in the rapid review process. Systematic review registration: https://osf.io/nyteu/

  • Open Access

    Nurse-led, community-based interventions for people with or at risk of frailty: A rapid review

    by Eleni Glarou, Clare Davis, David Jarrom, Juliet Hounsome, Elizabeth Gillen, Praveena Pemmasani, Jacob Davies, Rhiannon Tudor Edwards, Deborah Edwards, Adrian Edwards, et al.

    Community-based interventions are designed to address the needs of individuals living in the community, and particularly those with or at risk of frailty. Their primary aim is to support individuals to live independently in their homes. The aim of this rapid review is to identify and assess evidence on the clinical effectiveness of community-based interventions, led by nurses, for individuals with or at risk of frailty. The review includes 23 eligible studies conducted in the UK and Europe, which were published between 1984 and 2023. These studies included 16 distinct nurse-led interventions. The interventions differed considerably in factors including the procedures they used, how they were delivered and how tailored this was to individual needs, and their duration/intensity. 17 studies reported changes in activities of daily living (ADLs). One study suggested that a nurse-led rehabilitation programme for people with frailty was more likely to improve independence in personal ADLs compared to usual care. In eight studies reporting falls incidence, one study found that a nurse-led health consultation programme reduced falls incidence compared to usual care, while seven studies of other interventions found no conclusive evidence for this outcome. 13 studies reported hospital admission rates in people receiving nurse-led interventions. One study found that a nurse-led consultation programme reduced the proportion of participants experiencing hospital admissions compared to usual care, and one study found that a nurse-led surveillance programme for people with frailty was associated with fewer individuals admitted to hospital compared to usual care. We found no conclusive evidence on how any nurse-led interventions affect frailty status or progression, instrumental activities of daily living, mortality, and long-term care needs. Whilst the evidence suggests some specific types of interventions may be beneficial, the evidence is insufficient to conclude that these interventions would offer benefit if deployed. The findings could be used to explore how these interventions fit into the wider context of community care. We found no evidence suggesting that the use of nurse-led community-based interventions was detrimental when compared with usual care. Therefore, such interventions may offer added value by reducing the demand for, and/or the costs associated with, care delivered by other health care professionals. This review only studied interventions led specifically by nurses. It may be helpful to consider our findings alongside new (or existing) research into interventions delivered by wider teams of healthcare professionals.

  • Open Access

    Person-reported outcome measures for goal achievement or functional change in people undergoing rehabilitation with allied health professionals: a rapid evidence map and synthesis

    by Jessica Williams, Charlotte Bowles, Nathan Bromham, Juliet Hounsome, Elizabeth Gillen, Anthony Cope, Jacob Davies, Rhiannon Tudor Edwards, Deborah Edwards, Adrian Edwards, et al.

    Allied Health Professionals (AHPs) play a key role in delivering rehabilitation across Wales, but service-access and evaluation vary. To improve consistency, a national framework is being developed to measure how much care is delivered, its quality, and its impact on quality of life, wellbeing, agency, activity and participation. This review focuses on identifying the best person-reported outcome measures (PROMs) for tracking goal achievement and functional improvement. The review included evidence available up until August 2025. 101 systematic reviews, covering 19 free-of-charge PROMs with evidence of content validity, were included in the rapid evidence map (REM). The REM provides a description of the PROM’s purpose, ease of use, relevance to AHP rehabilitation, and the number of reviews that evaluated the quality and performance of the PROM - and in which populations. It does not summarise the findings. Based on the REM, eight PROMs were selected for detailed analysis. 47 reviews examined the measurement properties of these eight PROMs. The approximate time taken to complete the PROM was five minutes or less for 14 PROMs. Two PROMs had potential administration times of 60 minutes or more. The number of questions included in the PROMs ranged from one to 135. Most systematic reviews included people with general (or mixed) conditions. Many reviews in the REM included populations with neurological and neuromuscular conditions, and musculoskeletal and pain conditions. Few reviews focusing on other specific conditions were identified. Content validity, construct validity and test-retest reliability were the only measurement properties that were investigated in systematic reviews for all 19 PROMs. Face validity was reported for the fewest number of PROMs. Seven PROMs had reviews investigating all measurement properties. The eight PROMs prioritised for detailed analysis were the Goal Attainment Scale (GAS), Lawton-Brody Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (IADL), International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health Measure of Participation and Activities Screener (IMPACT-S), Keele Assessment of Participation (KAP), Patient-Specific Functional Scale (PSFS), Reintegration to Normal Living Index (RLI/RLNI), Utrecht Scale for Evaluation of Rehabilitation – Participation (USER-P) and World Health Organization Disability Assessment Schedule version 2.0 - 12 items (WHODAS 2 -12). Most of the systematic reviews aimed to evaluate the quality and performance of the PROMs in a general population receiving rehabilitation. For each PROM, an overall quality rating was assigned for each measurement property. Four of the PROMs (GAS, IADL, IMPACT-S and RLI/RNLI) were rated as sufficient for three or more measurement properties in the general conditions category, and one PROM (PSFS) was rated as sufficient for two measurement properties in this category. GAS, IADL, IMPACT-S, PSFS, RLI/RNLI and WHODAS 2-12 also had some sufficient measurement properties in the more specific population categories. All the ratings of KAP and USER-P scales were either indeterminate, inconsistent or insufficient. GAS, IADL and RNI/RNLI were the only PROMs identified as having sufficient content validity, considered the most important measurement property as it ensures the outcome measurement instrument accurately and completely captures what it is intended to measure before other types of validity or reliability are assessed. Only GAS and PSFS had evidence of good responsiveness, a crucial property to detect change in function. We also summarise the evidence gaps in this review. While some PROMs (GAS, IADL, IMPACT-S, PSFS, RLI/RNLI and WHODAS 2-12) show promise for the planned shortlist of measures suitable for assessing rehabilitation services across Wales, the choice of PROM will also depend on other things, such as feasibility, population fit and practical considerations.

  • Open Access

    Learning Disability Liaison services in acute care: a rapid review of effectiveness, barriers, and facilitators

    by Meg Kiseleva, Juliet Hounsome, Mala Mann, Abubakar Sha'ABan, Aadithya Ramesh, Melanie McAuley, Rhiannon Tudor Edwards, Jacob Davies, Adrian Edwards, Ruth Lewis

    People with learning disabilities (LD) have a higher prevalence of health problems than in the general population across many health conditions. At the same time, they often face difficulties in accessing healthcare, experience many health inequalities, and are more likely to die of preventable causes than people in the general population. Learning Disability Liaison (LDL) services were established in the United Kingdom (UK) and the Republic of Ireland (ROI) to support patients with LD in accessing care. The services aim is to improve the quality of care delivery and ensure an equitable and safe service.This review summarises existing evidence from the UK and the ROI regarding the effectiveness of LDL services in improving health-related outcomes for people with LD in secondary care. The review also reports the barriers to and facilitators of implementing LDL services reported in published literature. The included literature was published between 2002 and 2025. 44 academic studies, organisational reports, and other types of literature were identified. Of these, 21 were academic studies from England, Scotland, Wales, and the ROI, and 23 were organisational reports or other types of literature. No studies assessed the effectiveness of LDL services in improving health outcomes for people with LD, but many focused on assessing the impact of LDL services on the care provided. Some evidence suggested that having LDL nurses was a facilitator of identifying patients with LD. Literature reported that LDL nurses facilitated provision of reasonable adjustments and potentially improved patients experiences with hospital care and their ability to access treatments, however, there was some literature that reported mixed or negative experiences. LDL nurses were sometimes described as playing an important role in preparing and sharing accessible information with patients and carers, facilitating communication between patients and carers and hospital staff, and preparing hospital passports for patients with LD. However, some literature reported that other hospital staff did not always consult hospital passports, making them ineffective. There was some evidence that employing an LDL nurse might be associated with reduced length of stay and readmission rates. The review identified barriers to implementation of LDL services, and also barriers to accessing these services.This review provides a broad overview of the functioning of LDL services, with wide-ranging types of outcomes and examples of practice. This can help in designing LDL services and allocating resources. The evidence on the barriers of implementing and accessing LDL services provides a useful resource for service providers seeking to implement or improve LDL services.There is a need for more independent research evaluating the effectiveness of LDL services, particularly in relation to health outcomes.


  • Open Access

    A rapid review of interventions to reduce suicide ideation, attempts, and deaths at public locations

    by Meg Kiseleva, Juliet Hounsome, Mala Mann, Abubakar Sha’aban, Riya Reji, Jacob Rees Davies, Rhiannon Tudor Edwards, Adrian Edwards, Alison Cooper, Ruth Lewis

    Suicide deaths are tragic events and those that occur in public places have an impact not only on the deceased person and their family and friends, but also on members of the public. Having up-to-date information about the effectiveness of interventions allows policymakers and organisations managing locations of concern to choose the most appropriate evidence-based suicide prevention strategies for specific locations. This rapid review was conducted to help inform the development of Welsh national guidance. The review included literature published since 2014. 24 studies were identified, and these were conducted in the UK, Australia, South Korea, Canada, USA, Denmark and Japan. The studies covered railway or underground stations, bridges, cliffs or other natural heights, tall buildings, and other types of locations. Surveillance technologies as a means of increasing opportunity for third-party intervention showed the most promise, although the evidence of their effectiveness was limited. In one study, having more closed-circuit television (CCTV) units was associated with fewer suicides at railway stations. Another study that tested a set of interventions including CCTV, infrared security fences, and a suicidal behaviour recognition and alert system, provided some promising initial descriptive data that showed an increase in the number of prevented suicides. Three other studies showed that there was no change in outcomes following the installation of interventions including surveillance technologies. Based on the assessment of the overall body of the evidence, there is a low level of confidence in the findings related to surveillance technologies because of the quality and designs of the studies. Promotion of suicide helplines as an intervention aimed at increasing opportunities for help seeking was examined in seven studies. Two studies reported that the number of suicides increased after the introduction of the intervention. Three studies, of which two examined a set of interventions including helplines, observed no change. In two studies the effect could not be determined. There is a low level of confidence in the evidence for this outcome. Other interventions evaluated included staff training; deployment of specialist staff; campaigns encouraging bystanders to intervene; a crisis café; blue lights at railway stations; suicide prevention messages, memorials, or notes other than official crisis line signage; spinning rollers at the top of fences that prevent gripping; and others. The effect of these interventions could not be determined with certainty but some of them appeared promising and warrant further research. More robust evaluations are needed before any of the interventions reviewed here can be recommended for implementation. To create a better evidence base, high-quality evaluations should be supported and encouraged. Future research should examine which interventions work for who and in what circumstances.


  • Open Access

    The cost-effectiveness of life after stroke services and the impact of these services on health and social care resource use: a rapid review

    by Kalpa Pisavadia, Bethany Fern Anthony, Jacob Davies, Sofie Roberts, Rachel Granger, Llinos Haf Spencer, Elizabeth C Gillen, Juliet Hounsome, Jayne Noyes, Deborah Fitzsimmons, et al.

    The UK is expected to see a 60% increase in first-time strokes over the next 20 years. This translates to about 2.1 million stroke survivors living in the UK by 2035. Life after stroke services aim to support peoples physical and emotional state, are complimentary to rehabilitation and take a non-medical holistic approach to living well after a stroke. This rapid review aimed to identify evidence on the cost-effectiveness of life after stroke services, and the impact of these interventions on health or social care resource use. The review included evidence from 12 studies (7 economic evaluations and 5 randomised controlled trials), published between January 2000 and August 2024. The economic evaluations assessed a number of interventions to support stroke survivors, their families and caregivers. Two of the randomised controlled trials were partial economic evaluations, reporting on cost and resource use data related to training caregivers, and an arts and health-based intervention. The other three trials reported on resource use but not cost data, and assessed family support interventions, and a telehealth intervention to assist stroke survivors and their carers. There was a lack of evidence on the cost-effectiveness of life after stroke as a comprehensive service. However, this review identified evidence on the cost-effectiveness and resource utilisation of specific interventions within these services. Findings include that a community-based Individual Management Program for post-stroke survivors was cost-effective from a societal perspective at 24-month follow-up. A carer training intervention, delivered whilst the stroke patient was in hospital, was associated with a reduction in health and social care resource use when evaluated at a single hospital. However, this intervention was not cost-effective when rolled out and assessed across multiple hospitals. Other findings included that a combination of speech and language therapy with voluntary support services had a lower cost per session compared to NHS speech and language therapy alone. Family support organiser interventions for stroke survivors and carers were associated with reduced healthcare utilisation. To fully understand the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of life after stroke interventions, research is needed to assess potential long-term impacts. A reduction in resource use may be associated with cost savings and reduced burden on the NHS. However, an increase in health care and social care use may also be appropriate due to better signposting or identification of peoples’ needs. While traditional cost-effectiveness analysis provides a valuable framework for evaluating healthcare interventions, it may not fully capture the individual experiences of stroke survivors or the broader impact on their ongoing recovery, wellbeing and the lives of their carers. Future research should seek to quantify the effects of life after stroke support on patients and carers. Evidence is also needed on the cost-effectiveness of supporting stroke survivors in returning to the workforce. Many of the sample sizes in the included studies lacked ethnic diversity. Stroke trials need strategies to achieve equity of access. This review focused on evidence of cost-effectiveness and resource utilisation. Decisions relating to policy and practice should also consider evidence on clinical effectiveness and patient preferences. Funding Statement: The authors were funded for this work by the Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre, itself funded by Health and Care Research Wales on behalf of Welsh Government. Report Contributors: Review Team: Kalpa Pisavadia, Bethany Fern Anthony, Jacob Davies, Sofie Roberts, Rachel Granger, Llinos Haf Spencer, Elizabeth Gillen, Juliet Hounsome, Jayne Noyes, Deborah Fitzsimmons, and Rhiannon Tudor Edwards. Methodological Advice: Ruth Lewis Evidence Centre Team: Ruth Lewis, Adrian Edwards, Alison Cooper, Micaela Gal and Elizabeth Doe involved in Stakeholder engagement, review of report and editing. Public Partner: Robert Hall Stakeholder(s): Angela Contestabile, Heidi James, Lynn Preece, Llinos Wyn Parry, Katie Chappelle, Jonathan Hewitt. Evidence need submitted to the Evidence Centre: 30.10.2023 Initial Stakeholder Consultation Meeting: 29.04.24 Final Report issued: June 2025 The review should be cited as: Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre. A rapid review of cost-effectiveness of life after stroke services and the impact of these services on health and social care resource use_(RR0027). June 2025. Disclaimer: The views expressed in this publication are those of the authors, not necessarily Health and Care Research Wales. The Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre and authors of this work declare that they have no conflict of interest. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: What is a Rapid Review?: Our rapid reviews use a variation of the systematic review approach, abbreviating or omitting some components to generate the evidence to inform stakeholders promptly whilst maintaining attention to bias. Who is this Rapid Review for?: This Rapid Review was conducted as part of the Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre Work Programme. The review question was suggested by representatives of the Stroke Association UK. Background / Aim of Rapid Review: The UK is expected to see a 60% increase in first-time strokes over the next 20 years. This translates to about 2.1 million stroke survivors living in the UK by 2035. Approximately 70,000 stroke survivors are currently living in Wales. Life after stroke services take a non-medical holistic approach to living well after a stroke and are complimentary to rehabilitation. Life after stroke services encompass services that aim to support people’s physical and emotional state. Some of these services are specific to communication and emotional support, providing tools and information, reassurance, coaching and peer support. Life after stroke services have the potential to reduce the cost burden to health and social care. This rapid review aimed to identify evidence on the cost-effectiveness of life after stroke services and the impact of these interventions on health or social care resource use (it did not review the evidence on the clinical effectiveness or peoples lived experience of life after stroke services). Results of the Rapid Review: The evidence base: The review included evidence from studies published between January 2000 and August 2024 (at the time when the searches were conducted). Of the 12 studies included, seven were economic evaluations, and five were randomised controlled trials reporting on cost and or resource use data only. The seven economic evaluations assessed the following interventions: a needs assessment tool for caregivers (Patchwood et al, 2021); training for caregivers (Forster et al, 2013); an exercise and education reintegration programme for stroke survivors and their families (Harrington et al, 2010), a community-based Individual Management Program for post-stroke survivors (Orman et al, 2024); combined speech and language therapy and support services for stroke survivors and their families (van der Gaag and Brooks, 2008); peer-befriending for psychological distress (Flood et al, 2022), and a post-discharge structured assessment (Forster et al, 2015). Two randomised controlled trials were partial economic evaluations which reported on cost and resource use data. These studies specifically related to the following interventions: training caregivers (Kalra et al, 2004); and an arts and health-based intervention (Ellis-Hill et al, 2019). The remaining three randomised controlled trials reported on resource use but not cost data and assessed family support organiser service (Mant et al, 2000; Tilling et al, 2005), and a telehealth support intervention designed to assist stroke survivors and their carers (Bishop et al, 2014). Key findings: This review highlighted a lack of studies evaluating the cost-effectiveness of life after stroke as a comprehensive service as per the national stoke model, particularly when delivered as intended in a holistic multicomponent format. However, this review identified evidence on the cost-effectiveness and resource utilisation of specific interventions within these services, that support both stroke survivors and carers. A community-based Individual Management Program for post-stroke survivors was found to be cost-effective from a societal perspective at 24-month follow-up. A combination of speech and language therapy with voluntary support services had a lower cost per session than reported costs for equivalent NHS services However, cost-effectiveness was not assessed in this study A telehealth support intervention was associated with a reduction in healthcare utilisation. A caregiver training programme, delivered whilst the stroke patient was still in hospital, was associated with a reduction in health and social care resource use when evaluated at a single hospital. However, this intervention was not found to be cost-effective when rolled out and assessed across multiple hospitals. A community-based arts and health group intervention led to a reduction in outpatient contacts and home care worker contacts compared to usual care. A Family Support Organiser service was associated with a reduction in physiotherapy contact, but the use of other services were comparable with usual care. The addition of a new post-discharge system to an existing community-based Stroke Care Coordinators service was not cost-effective from either a health or societal perspective when compared to the Stroke Care Coordinator usual practice. Peer-befriending was found to be more costly and less effective than usual care alone. The use of a Carer Support Needs Assessment Tool (CSNAT) was not cost-effective compared to usual care. The cost per patient of a community-based combined exercise and education reintegration programme was greater than that of the control group. Policy and Practice Implications: There is some evidence that interventions such as Individual Management Programme; telehealth support, community-based arts and health group, Family Support Organiser, and caregiver training can be cost-effective or lead to a reduction in service utilisation. While the gold standard model of traditional cost-effectiveness analysis proves a robust and valuable framework for assessing the cost-effectiveness of healthcare interventions, it does not capture the individual impact on the recovery of a stroke survivor and the ongoing health and wellbeing of them or their family. This review focused on evidence of cost-effectiveness and resource utilisation, which are helpful in the context of resource allocation for future roll-out of services, however, decisions relating to policy and practice must also consider the wider evidence base on clinical effectiveness and patient preferences going forward. Although a reduction in resource use may be associated with cost savings and reduced burden on the NHS, importantly, an increase in health care and social care use may also be appropriate due to better signposting or identification of peoples’ needs. Research Implications and Evidence Gaps: Further research is needed on cost-effectiveness of life after stroke as a comprehensive service as per the national stoke model To fully understand the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of life after stroke interventions, research is needed to assess potential long-term impacts. Evidence is needed on the cost-effectiveness of supporting stroke survivors in returning to the workforce. The timing of life after stroke interventions appeared to be important in terms of how they are received by stroke survivors, their carers and their families. Many of the samples in the included studies lacked ethnic diversity. Stroke trials need strategies to achieve equity of access, given that a large portion of UK stroke admissions are from Black, Asian and minority ethnic communities (Office for National Statistics, 2021). Economic considerations: The average cost to society per stroke survivor in the first year post-stroke in the UK is £45,409. The key drivers of this cost are informal care and lost productivity costs (Stroke Association, 2020). Appropriate and timely post-stroke support for stroke survivors, their families and or caregivers could help alleviate some of this economic impact. Stroke costs NHS Wales £220 million per year. When considering a wider societal economic cost, this figure rises to £1.6 billion per year. If current trends persist with no action taken, this figure is forecast to increase to £2.8 billion per annum by 2035 (Welsh Government, 2024b). Glossary: Economic evaluation: an assessment of the costs and effects of alternate healthcare interventions. The aim of an economic evaluation is to help decision makers maximise the level of health benefits relative to the finite resources available. Health and Social Care resource use or utilisation: refers to the use of healthcare resources by end users (patients) and intervention deliverers. This can take the form of contacts with health professionals across health and social care, medicines or healthcare consumables used. In economic evaluations, resource use is collected, and costs are assigned to them to identify the costs an intervention places on the healthcare system. Cost-effectiveness analysis: costs are compared with a treatment’s common therapeutic goal, expressed in terms of one main outcome measured in natural units (e.g., improvement in blood pressure or cholesterol level). These outcomes are typically condition-specific, meaning comparison within conditions is possible, but difficulty arises in comparing between conditions. Cost-utility analysis: a method of evaluation that measures health benefits in preference-based, non-monetary units such as Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) or Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALYs). These units are helpful for economic evaluation as they are generic and can be applied across conditions, allowing for comparison between conditions. Full economic evaluation: is an economic evaluation that compares both the costs and effects of alternate healthcare interventions. The examples of cost-effectiveness and cost-utility above reflect full economic evaluations as they analyse both costs and outcomes of interventions. Partial economic evaluation: is an economic evaluation that does not compare both the costs and effects of alternate healthcare interventions. A common partial economic evaluation is a cost-analysis that presents the costs of interventions only, with no consideration of effects. Partial economic evaluations are sometimes conducted within or alongside randomised controlled trials. However, the conduct of partial economic evaluations are not limited to randomised controlled trial study designs, with alternatives including economic evaluations alongside natural experiments or economic modelling studies which often utilise sources of data from previous literature in addition to or instead of collecting primary data. Randomised controlled trial: a study in which a number of similar people are randomly assigned to 2 (or more) groups to test a specific drug, treatment or other intervention. One group (the intervention group) has the intervention being tested, the other (the comparison or control group) has an alternative intervention, a dummy intervention (placebo) or no intervention at all. The groups are followed up at set time periods to see how effective the experimental intervention was. Outcomes are measured at specific times and any difference in response between the groups is assessed statistically. Randomised controlled trials are the highest standard of research trials as their design helps to reduce biases that may impact the findings. Randomised controlled trials with partial economic evaluations: are a study type that follows the randomised controlled trial methodology. Randomised controlled trials with cost comparisons collect information on the costs associated with the interventions studied to allow for comparison across alternate interventions not just based on clinical effect but also costs. Within-trial economic evaluation: is a full economic evaluation of the costs and effects of healthcare interventions that are being studied as part of a clinical trial. The primary aim of clinical trials is typically a measurement of clinical effect of administering an intervention (e.g., change in blood pressure). These clinical effects of the intervention are then assessed together with the costs of the intervention in the economic evaluation. Cost-consequence analysis: Is a form of partial economic evaluation that presents the disaggregated costs and outcomes of an intervention. Statistical significance: a statistically significant result is one that is deemed to be down to a true effect rather than random chance. It is a way to determine if a relationship between variables is caused by something other than chance.


  • Open Access

    The clinical and cost-effectiveness of interventions for preventing continence issues resulting from birth trauma: a rapid review

    by Bethany Fern Anthony, Jacob Davies, Kalpa Pisavadia, Sofie Roberts, Llinos Haf Spencer, Elizabeth Gillen, Juliet Hounsome, Jayne Noyes, Dyfrig Hughes, Deborah Fitzsimmons, et al.

    Urinary and faecal incontinence, which are often linked to the stresses and strains of childbirth, particularly perineal trauma, are debilitating conditions that can significantly impact womens quality of life. Approximately 85% of vaginal births in the United Kingdom (UK) are affected by childbirth related perineal trauma, either spontaneously or due to episiotomy. Incontinence also places a significant financial burden on the healthcare system. Previous estimates have shown that stress urinary incontinence alone costs the National Health Service (NHS) 177 million UK pounds per year. The aim of this rapid review was to identify evidence on the clinical effectiveness and cost- effectiveness of interventions for preventing continence issues resulting from birth trauma. Twenty-three studies, published between 2023 and 2024, were included in this review: 20 systematic reviews of clinical effectiveness and three economic evaluations. A number of key findings, research implications and evidence gaps were identified. The findings support the use of exercise-based interventions including pelvic floor muscle training for prenatal and postnatal women to prevent urinary incontinence. However, there is limited evidence supporting their long-term effectiveness. Incontinence is a potential long- term burden as pregnancy and childbirth can weaken the pelvic floor, making women more susceptible to incontinence in later life. Menopause often exacerbates these issues due to hormonal changes and by further weakening the pelvic floor muscles. Non exercise-based interventions, such as prenatal perineal massage and vaginal devices were less represented in the available evidence base, especially for faecal incontinence outcomes. There was a paucity of economic evaluations assessing the cost-effectiveness of interventions for incontinence, however, the substantial economic burden of incontinence on the NHS necessitates investment in clinically effective, preventative options. Our findings present the case for investing in exercise-based interventions. Further research is needed to evaluate the maintenance and long-term effects of exercise-based therapy. More research is also needed that focus on alternative type interventions and the prevention of faecal incontinence. Future reviews need to consider qualitative findings of womens experiences and the acceptability and feasibility of rolling out interventions for the prevention of incontinence. Funding statement The authors and their Institutions were funded for this work by the Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre, itself funded by Health and Care Research Wales on behalf of Welsh Government What is a Rapid Review?Our rapid reviews use a variation of the systematic review approach, abbreviating or omitting some components to generate the evidence to inform stakeholders promptly whilst maintaining attention to bias. Who is this Rapid Review for?This Rapid Review was conducted as part of the Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre Work Programme. The review question was suggested by representatives of the Women’s Health Team of the Welsh Government. The intended audience is Women’s Health and continence service commissioners and policy makers in Wales. Background / Aim of Rapid Review Urinary and faecal incontinence, which are often linked to the stresses and strains of childbirth, particularly perineal trauma, are debilitating conditions that can significantly impact women’s quality of life. Approximately 85% of vaginal births in the United Kingdom (UK) are affected by childbirth related perineal trauma, either spontaneously or due to episiotomy. Incontinence also places a significant financial burden on the healthcare system. Previous estimates have shown that stress urinary incontinence alone costs the National Health Service (NHS) £177 million per year. The prevention of continence issues following childbirth through evidence-based interventions is essential for the health of women both short-term and later in life. The economic cost of incontinence on both individuals and the healthcare system is substantial and the implementation of effective interventions to prevent incontinence following birth trauma can prevent avoidable and costly care in future. The aim of this rapid review was to identify evidence on the clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of interventions for preventing continence issues resulting from birth trauma. The evidence base The review included evidence available up until June 2024 (when the searches were conducted). The included studies identified in this rapid review were published between 2003 and 2024. Twenty-three studies were included in this rapid review: 20 systematic reviews of clinical effectiveness and three economic evaluations. Key findings Twelve systematic reviews of prenatal and/or postnatal pelvic floor muscle training (PFMT) and mixed exercise modes (with a PFMT element) were identified. Of the eleven systematic reviews (five of which included meta-analyses) assessing prenatal PFMT and mixed exercise, eight reported findings to support PFMT and exercise for the prevention of urinary incontinence in the postnatal period (up to 6 months postpartum). Evidence from two meta-analyses of longer-term outcomes did not support the effectiveness of prenatal PFMT to prevent urinary incontinence in the late postpartum period (defined as greater than 6-12 months) or after 5 years following childbirth. However, data on longer-term outcomes were combined from a diverse set of studies with varied prescription of the PFMT regimens and the reviews did not explicitly examine the impact of continuing PFMT postnatally. Of the two systematic reviews that assessed postnatal PFMT one focused on existing incontinence and found no evidence on prevention, and the other found conflicting evidence on the prevention of urinary incontinence. Five systematic reviews (of which, three included meta-analyses) explored the effectiveness of prenatal perineal massage. None of the meta-analyses found any significant differences in incidence of urinary incontinence (evidence from three meta-analyses) or faecal incontinence (evidence from two meta-analyses) following prenatal perineal massage. For the other two systematic reviews, one reported a reduction in faecal and gas incontinence but not urinary incontinence, while the other found no effect on any type of incontinence. Two systematic reviews reported on the effectiveness of vaginal devices for existing incontinence but did not report on the prevention of incontinence. In a systematic review of pushing technique, results demonstrated a significant difference in urinary incontinence scores from baseline to postpartum in the spontaneous pushing group compared with the directed pushing group. A cost-utility analysis (conducted to inform NICE guideline 210) utilising a decision analytic Markov model of supervised prenatal pelvic floor muscle training in a population of pregnant women found the intervention to be cost-effective for preventing urinary incontinence when compared to no intervention. The intervention was likely to be cost-effective for all willingness to pay thresholds over £11,000 per QALY gained. A cost-effectiveness analysis found that group-based pelvic floor muscle training was more cost-effective than individually supervised training for the prevention of urinary incontinence, at a cost of $14.53 per case of urinary incontinence prevented or cured if eight women attended a training session. A RCT and cost-consequence analysis reported no significant difference in urinary or faecal incontinence between groups of nulliparous women adopting an upright or lying down birthing position; but the intervention was not specifically designed to prevent incontinence. Policy and Practice Implications This rapid review complements existing NICE guidance on the prevention and non-surgical management of pelvic floor dysfunction (NG210, 2021), and the management of faecal incontinence (CG49, 2007). The NICE 2021 guidance recommends pelvic floor muscle training for prenatal and postnatal women, and our rapid review also identified a large evidence base regarding exercise-based interventions to prevent urinary incontinence. However, the NICE guidance indicates limited evidence supporting the long-term effectiveness of PFMT, which also aligns with the findings of our review. We identified two meta-analyses that failed to demonstrate the effectiveness of PFMT in preventing incontinence in the long term, but the included studies varied in prescription of PFMT regimens and did not examine the impact of continuing PFMT postnatally. Incontinence is a potential long-term burden as pregnancy and childbirth can weaken the pelvic floor, making women more susceptible to incontinence in later life. Menopause often exacerbates these issues due to hormonal changes and by further weakening the pelvic floor muscles. Although our review considered a broader range of interventions than the NICE 2021 guidance, other interventions, such as prenatal perineal massage and vaginal devices were less represented in the available evidence base, especially for faecal incontinence outcomes. Despite a paucity of economic evaluations assessing the cost-effectiveness of interventions for incontinence, the substantial economic burden of incontinence on the NHS necessitates investment in clinically effective, preventative options. Our findings present the case for investing in exercise-based interventions. Future recommendations for policy and practice should also consider qualitative findings of women’s experiences and the acceptability and feasibility of rolling out interventions for the prevention of incontinence. Research Implications and Evidence Gaps A significant evidence gap exists regarding the cost-effectiveness of interventions aimed at preventing incontinence resulting from birth trauma. Further research is needed for non-exercise interventions and maintenance interventions. Future studies adopting longer time horizons are also needed to assess any potential long-term outcomes such as incidence of incontinence during the menopause. Future evidence reviews need to consider qualitative research of the acceptability and feasibility of interventions to prevent continence issues.