JDJacob Davies

Jacob Davies

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Jacob Davies has a total of 118 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    An economic evaluation alongside a randomised controlled trial of Scanning Eye trAining as a Rehabilitation Choice compared to sham training for Hemianopia after stroke (the SEARCH trial)

    by Fiona J Rowe, Jacob Davies, Kodchawan Doungsong, Ella Brayshaw, Michaela Brown, Kausik Chatterjee, Avril Drummond, Christine Hazelton, Brin Helliwell, Lauren R Hepworth, et al.

    Objective: To explore the cost-effectiveness of visual scanning training for hemianopia compared to sham training. Design: Randomised controlled trial. Setting: Acute stroke unit and outpatient eye clinics. Participants: Adult stroke survivors with homonymous hemianopia. Intervention: Visual scanning training. Comparator: Sham eye pursuit movements. Main measures: Cost-utility and cost-effectiveness analyses were conducted from UK National Health Service (NHS) and wider societal perspectives. The primary analysis was a cost-utility analysis using EQ-5D-5L utility values. Cost-effectiveness analyses using changes in National Eye Institute-Visual Function Questionnaire-25 item composite and Brain Injury-associated Visual Impairment-Impact Questionnaire scores formed the secondary analyses. Results: Both intervention and sham training packages cost £9.58 (printing costs, clinician time to explain self-administration). Mean total health resource use costs at 26-weeks were higher in the intervention (£1406) than in the sham group (£1339). At 26-weeks, the intervention group gained 0.001 (95%CI:-0.018, 0.021) Quality-Adjusted Life Years (QALY) while the sham group evidenced a QALY loss of −0.002 (95%CI:-0.017, 0.012); not statistically significant (p = 0.71). The Incremental Cost-Effectiveness Ratio of visual scanning training compared to sham was £19,790/QALY, below the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) threshold of £20,000–£30,000/QALY. Sensitivity analysis (5000 replications) suggested potential cost-effectiveness of visual scanning training, which had a 67% probability of being cost-effective at £20,000/QALY; this was not significant. Conclusions: This is the first economic evaluation comparing visual scanning training to sham training for treating post-stroke hemianopia. While both interventions had similar costs, the costs were slightly under NICE thresholds. The intervention evidenced marginal but non-significant QALY gain over sham.

  • Open Access

    Nurse-led, community-based interventions for people with or at risk of frailty: A rapid review

    by Eleni Glarou, Clare Davis, David Jarrom, Juliet Hounsome, Elizabeth Gillen, Praveena Pemmasani, Jacob Davies, Rhiannon Tudor Edwards, Deborah Edwards, Adrian Edwards, et al.

    Community-based interventions are designed to address the needs of individuals living in the community, and particularly those with or at risk of frailty. Their primary aim is to support individuals to live independently in their homes. The aim of this rapid review is to identify and assess evidence on the clinical effectiveness of community-based interventions, led by nurses, for individuals with or at risk of frailty. The review includes 23 eligible studies conducted in the UK and Europe, which were published between 1984 and 2023. These studies included 16 distinct nurse-led interventions. The interventions differed considerably in factors including the procedures they used, how they were delivered and how tailored this was to individual needs, and their duration/intensity. 17 studies reported changes in activities of daily living (ADLs). One study suggested that a nurse-led rehabilitation programme for people with frailty was more likely to improve independence in personal ADLs compared to usual care. In eight studies reporting falls incidence, one study found that a nurse-led health consultation programme reduced falls incidence compared to usual care, while seven studies of other interventions found no conclusive evidence for this outcome. 13 studies reported hospital admission rates in people receiving nurse-led interventions. One study found that a nurse-led consultation programme reduced the proportion of participants experiencing hospital admissions compared to usual care, and one study found that a nurse-led surveillance programme for people with frailty was associated with fewer individuals admitted to hospital compared to usual care. We found no conclusive evidence on how any nurse-led interventions affect frailty status or progression, instrumental activities of daily living, mortality, and long-term care needs. Whilst the evidence suggests some specific types of interventions may be beneficial, the evidence is insufficient to conclude that these interventions would offer benefit if deployed. The findings could be used to explore how these interventions fit into the wider context of community care. We found no evidence suggesting that the use of nurse-led community-based interventions was detrimental when compared with usual care. Therefore, such interventions may offer added value by reducing the demand for, and/or the costs associated with, care delivered by other health care professionals. This review only studied interventions led specifically by nurses. It may be helpful to consider our findings alongside new (or existing) research into interventions delivered by wider teams of healthcare professionals.

  • Open Access

    Person-reported outcome measures for goal achievement or functional change in people undergoing rehabilitation with allied health professionals: a rapid evidence map and synthesis

    by Jessica Williams, Charlotte Bowles, Nathan Bromham, Juliet Hounsome, Elizabeth Gillen, Anthony Cope, Jacob Davies, Rhiannon Tudor Edwards, Deborah Edwards, Adrian Edwards, et al.

    Allied Health Professionals (AHPs) play a key role in delivering rehabilitation across Wales, but service-access and evaluation vary. To improve consistency, a national framework is being developed to measure how much care is delivered, its quality, and its impact on quality of life, wellbeing, agency, activity and participation. This review focuses on identifying the best person-reported outcome measures (PROMs) for tracking goal achievement and functional improvement. The review included evidence available up until August 2025. 101 systematic reviews, covering 19 free-of-charge PROMs with evidence of content validity, were included in the rapid evidence map (REM). The REM provides a description of the PROM’s purpose, ease of use, relevance to AHP rehabilitation, and the number of reviews that evaluated the quality and performance of the PROM - and in which populations. It does not summarise the findings. Based on the REM, eight PROMs were selected for detailed analysis. 47 reviews examined the measurement properties of these eight PROMs. The approximate time taken to complete the PROM was five minutes or less for 14 PROMs. Two PROMs had potential administration times of 60 minutes or more. The number of questions included in the PROMs ranged from one to 135. Most systematic reviews included people with general (or mixed) conditions. Many reviews in the REM included populations with neurological and neuromuscular conditions, and musculoskeletal and pain conditions. Few reviews focusing on other specific conditions were identified. Content validity, construct validity and test-retest reliability were the only measurement properties that were investigated in systematic reviews for all 19 PROMs. Face validity was reported for the fewest number of PROMs. Seven PROMs had reviews investigating all measurement properties. The eight PROMs prioritised for detailed analysis were the Goal Attainment Scale (GAS), Lawton-Brody Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (IADL), International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health Measure of Participation and Activities Screener (IMPACT-S), Keele Assessment of Participation (KAP), Patient-Specific Functional Scale (PSFS), Reintegration to Normal Living Index (RLI/RLNI), Utrecht Scale for Evaluation of Rehabilitation – Participation (USER-P) and World Health Organization Disability Assessment Schedule version 2.0 - 12 items (WHODAS 2 -12). Most of the systematic reviews aimed to evaluate the quality and performance of the PROMs in a general population receiving rehabilitation. For each PROM, an overall quality rating was assigned for each measurement property. Four of the PROMs (GAS, IADL, IMPACT-S and RLI/RNLI) were rated as sufficient for three or more measurement properties in the general conditions category, and one PROM (PSFS) was rated as sufficient for two measurement properties in this category. GAS, IADL, IMPACT-S, PSFS, RLI/RNLI and WHODAS 2-12 also had some sufficient measurement properties in the more specific population categories. All the ratings of KAP and USER-P scales were either indeterminate, inconsistent or insufficient. GAS, IADL and RNI/RNLI were the only PROMs identified as having sufficient content validity, considered the most important measurement property as it ensures the outcome measurement instrument accurately and completely captures what it is intended to measure before other types of validity or reliability are assessed. Only GAS and PSFS had evidence of good responsiveness, a crucial property to detect change in function. We also summarise the evidence gaps in this review. While some PROMs (GAS, IADL, IMPACT-S, PSFS, RLI/RNLI and WHODAS 2-12) show promise for the planned shortlist of measures suitable for assessing rehabilitation services across Wales, the choice of PROM will also depend on other things, such as feasibility, population fit and practical considerations.

  • Open Access

    The Impact of Changes in Active Travel Infrastructure on Disabled People: A Rapid Review

    by Deborah Edwards, Judit Csontos, Elizabeth Gillen, Tom Wharf, Catherine Purcell, Beti-Jane Ingram, Jacob Davies, Rhiannon Tudor Edwards, Adrian Edwards, Ruth Lewis

    This review examines international evidence on how changes to active travel infrastructure affect disabled people. It explores the impact of infrastructure changes on accessibility and identifies the barriers and facilitators experienced by disabled people. The review included 11 primary research studies and 8 reviews published between 2015 and July 2025. Populations represented across the studies included: People with visual impairments; People with mobility impairments; Neurodivergent people; People with mobility, hearing, or vision impairments; People with mobility, hearing, vision impairments and neurodivergence; People using mobility assistive devices; and older adults with motor, visual, hearing impairments, or orientation difficulties. Design changes to bus stop infrastructure, were consistently associated with reduced accessibility, subjective feelings of safety, and confidence among disabled people getting on and off buses. Uneven pavements and surface defects reduced perceived safety and confidence for people with visual and mobility impairments, with tactile paving aiding navigation for blind users but creating instability for mobility aid users. The review also describes the impact of kerb level changes, continuous footways, low traffic neighbourhoods, barrier removal, and the development of shared spaces. Raised trapezoidal designs were most effective in providing clear, detectable boundaries and supporting confidence among visually impaired users. Some design features, such as kerb-free layouts, clear tactile paving, and well-marked crossings, acted as facilitators that improved accessibility, perceived safety, and confidence, while other features introduced barriers. Some barriers were consistent across all disability groups, whereas others were impairment-specific. Vehicles parked on pavements created barriers to navigation for neurodivergent people and blocked movement for guide dog users. Tactile paving aided navigation for people with visual impairments but was perceived to create a barrier to wheelchair stability, whereas kerb removal reduced barriers for wheelchair users but created orientation barriers for people with visual impairments. Meeting conflicting accessibility needs of different groups of disabled people can be challenging when planning and implementing change in active travel infrastructure. Inconsistent infrastructure designs across different spaces and regions can create confusion among disabled people and lead to them feeling unsafe or potentially being directed to harm’s way.

  • Open Access

    Broadening sources of finance for health promotion and disease prevention: Smart capacitating investment

    by Maureen Rutten-Van Mölken, Holly Whiteley, Balázs Babarczy, Jacob Davies, Lucas Goossens, Lina Papartyte, Alison Maassen, Balázs Nagy, Stephen Wright, Rhiannon Tudor-Edwards


  • Open Access

    A community-based rehabilitation package following hip fracture: FEMuR III a multi-centre RCT, economic and process evaluation

    by Nefyn H Williams, Monica Busse, Rachael Cooper, Jacob Davies, Susanna Dodd, Shanaz Dorkenoo, Kodchawan Doungsong, Rhiannon Tudor Edwards, Victory Ezeofor, Miriam Golding-Day, et al.

    Background: Proximal femoral (hip) fracture is common, serious and costly. An enhanced community rehabilitation intervention (Fracture in the Elderly Multidisciplinary Rehabilitation) was codeveloped with patients, carers and therapists. Trial methods have been tested previously in a feasibility study. Objective: To determine the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of the Fracture in the Elderly Multidisciplinary Rehabilitation intervention compared with usual NHS rehabilitation care. To determine the mechanisms and processes that explain the implementation and impacts of the Fracture in the Elderly Multidisciplinary Rehabilitation intervention. Design and methods: Definitive, pragmatic, multisite, parallel-group, two-armed, superiority randomised controlled trial with 1 : 1 allocation ratio. Concurrent economic and process evaluations. Setting: Participant recruitment in 13 hospitals across England and Wales, with the Fracture in the Elderly Multidisciplinary Rehabilitation intervention delivered in the community. Participants: Patients aged over 60 years, with mental capacity, recovering from surgical treatment for proximal femoral fracture, and living in their own home prior to fracture. Interventions: Usual rehabilitation care (control) was compared with usual rehabilitation care plus the Fracture in the Elderly Multidisciplinary Rehabilitation intervention, which comprised a patient-held workbook and goal-setting diary aimed at improving self-efficacy, and six additional therapy sessions delivered in the community (intervention), to increase the practice of exercise and activities of daily living. Primary and secondary outcome measures: Primary effectiveness outcome was the Nottingham Extended Activities of Daily Living scale at 12 months. Secondary outcomes included: Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale, Falls Self-Efficacy – International scale, hip pain intensity, fear of falling, grip strength and Short Physical Performance Battery. Economic outcomes were EuroQol EQ-5D-3L and Client Service Receipt Inventory. Results: In total, 205 participants were randomised ( n = 104 experimental; n = 101 control). Trial processes were adversely affected by the coronavirus disease discovered in 2019 pandemic and the target sample of 446 was not met. By 52 weeks, the intervention group had worse Nottingham Extended Activities of Daily Living scores than the control group (mean difference: −1.9; 95% confidence interval: −3.7 to −0.1), which was not clinically important. Joint modelling analysis testing for difference in longitudinal outcome adjusted for missing values, removed the apparent inferiority of the Fracture in the Elderly Multidisciplinary Rehabilitation intervention with a mean difference of 0.1 (95% confidence interval: −1.1 to 1.3). There was no statistical or clinically significant difference in secondary outcomes between groups. A median of 4.5 extra rehabilitation sessions were delivered to the intervention group, with a median of two sessions delivered in-person. Instrumental variable regression did not find any effect of the amount of rehabilitation on the main outcome. There were 53 unrelated serious adverse events including 11 deaths in the control group: 41 serious adverse events including nine deaths in the intervention group. The mean cost of delivering the Fracture in the Elderly Multidisciplinary Rehabilitation intervention was £444 per participant. The intervention group gained 0.02 (95% confidence interval: −0.036 to 0.076) more quality-adjusted life-years than the control group. This was not clinically or statistically significant. Mean health service use costs were higher in the intervention group. Limitations: The trial was severely impacted by coronavirus disease discovered in 2019. Possible reasons for lack of detected effect included limited intervention fidelity (number and remote mode of delivery), lack of usual levels of support from health professionals and families, and change in recovery beliefs and behaviours during the pandemic. Conclusion: The Fracture in the Elderly Multidisciplinary Rehabilitation intervention was not more effective and had higher costs than usual rehabilitation care. Funding: This synopsis presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme as award number 16/167/09.

  • Open Access

    What is the effectiveness of interventions to support the mental and emotional health and wellbeing of young people who are not in education, employment or training (NEET)? A Rapid Evidence Review

    by Alesha Wale, Salina Khatoon, Claire Morgan, Amy Fox-McNally, Helen Morgan, Kirsty Little, Hannah Shaw, Kelly Davies, Ben Williams, Olivia Gallen, et al.

    Mental health problems among young people have continued to rise over the last decade. Support services are available in higher education and in many workplace environments. However, while approaches to maintain or enhance mental health and wellbeing within these settings are valuable, it is important to understand what alternative community-based supportive measures or interventions are effective for young people who may not be able to access these services. It is estimated that 13.4% of all young people (aged 16-24) are considered not in education, employment or training (NEET) across the UK. Young people who are NEET have also been found to have a higher incidence of mental health problems than young people who are not NEET. The aim of this rapid review is to identify the effectiveness of interventions to support mental and health and wellbeing in young people who are NEET. Included studies were published between 2013 and 2025. Nine primary studies, conducted in a range of countries, were included. Studies investigated psychological interventions (n=3), nature-based interventions (n=2), animal assisted interventions (n=2), social prescribing interventions (n=1), and holistic coaching interventions (n=1). Overall, there is evidence to suggest that interventions delivered in a nonclinical, community- based, or home setting could potentially improve a range of mental health and wellbeing outcomes in young people who are NEET. Participants were generally accepting of the interventions. The psychological interventions were found to improve psychological, social and occupational functioning, reduce difficulties in emotion regulation, reduce psychological distress and led to positive behaviour changes. The nature-based interventions were found to improve social, emotional and behavioural functioning, as well as social connection and mental wellbeing and may be more effective for those who meet the criteria for anxiety or depression. The animal assisted interventions were found to improve social behaviour, and participant abilities however some mixed findings were reported for the impact on self-esteem. The social prescribing intervention improved mental wellbeing and psychological distress. Lastly, the holistic coaching intervention improved participants sense of wellbeing; anxiety; access to peer support resources; knowledge of and access to services; and connection to learning and earning opportunities. Our confidence in the evidence is limited as the majority of outcomes were only evaluated by a single study. However, while the evidence base identified was limited in number and quality, the findings may help to inform the development and delivery of interventions in young people who are NEET. Given the limited evidence base, robust evaluations should be considered when developing and implementing an intervention for young people who are NEET. Further robust studies assessing long term effects are needed to determine how best to support this population.

  • Open Access

    Preoperative risk prediction tools that predict morbidity risk in adults undergoing surgery: An Evidence Review

    by Alesha Wale, Toby Ayres, Salina Khatoon, Amy Fox-McNally, Claire Morgan, Helen Morgan, Hannah Shaw, Jacob Davies, Rhiannon Tudor Edwards, Claire Dunstan, et al.

    Risk prediction tools play a critical role in preoperative care by estimating the likelihood of adverse outcomes, including mortality, morbidity, and postoperative complications. In low-risk surgical settings such as surgical hubs, accurate risk prediction is particularly valuable. The aim of this review was to identify and map the evidence for 14 validated pre-operative surgical risk prediction tools currently used in Wales within any elective, or non-emergency surgical setting, and to provide a more in-depth look at the findings for a selection of tools deemed to be the most applicable on a population level to the context of surgical hubs. Included studies were published between 1999 and 2024. No evidence was found for two of the risk prediction tools however, a total of 118 studies were identified across 12 risk prediction tools. None of the evidence found was looking at the predictive ability of risk prediction tools for selecting patients suitable for surgical hubs. The tools were used across a range of surgical specialties and measured composite complications, individual complications, and healthcare utilisation and recovery measures. No risk prediction tool adequately predicted complications across all surgical specialties. Among the included studies, there was considerable heterogeneity in which surgical specialties the risk prediction tools were used for, how complications were defined, and which measures were used to determine a tool’s predictive ability. This makes direct comparisons very challenging. Four tools were selected as being potentially the most impactful at a population level for a more in-depth look at the findings: ACS NSQIP, P-POSSUM, RCRI, ASA classification system. A total of 76 studies were identified across these 4 tools. Key findings for the four risk prediction tools of interest are described. Overall, no one tool was identified that adequately predicted complications across all surgical specialties. The predictive ability of the tools varied across different surgical specialties. Further research using consistent methods is needed to better understand the predictive ability of risk prediction tools and allow a robust evaluation. Given no single risk prediction tool adequately predicted complications across all surgical specialties, it may be likely that some tools are better suited for specific surgery types or that a combination of risk prediction tools may be needed to adequately assess an individual’s level of risk. Funding statement The authors and their Institutions were funded for this work by the Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre, itself funded by Health and Care Research Wales on behalf of Welsh Government.

  • Open Access

    What is the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of at-home time-limited reablement service for improving an individual’s independence and health outcomes and reducing the need for long term care: a rapid review

    by Bethany Anthony, Jacob Davies, Kalpa Pisavadia, Sofie Roberts, Greg Flynn, Limssy Varghese, Rachel Louise Granger, Madison Montgomery, Rebecca Rosi, Elizabeth C Gillen, et al.

    Local authorities and health services in Wales are tasked with reablement, to help individuals who are at risk of frailty maintain and improve independence. However, social care resource constraints, mean that the balance of funds and workforce may be focussed on acute health care and long-term care in the community. This review aimed to identify evidence on the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of at-home time-limited reablement services for improving an individuals independence and health outcomes and reducing the need for long term care. Eighteen studies were included in the review: 16 reported on clinical effectiveness and three on cost-effectiveness (one study reported on both). Key clinical-effectiveness findings included person-related and service-level outcomes. Implications for practice: There is international evidence that reablement led by an allied health professional (AHP), such as occupational therapists, or a multi-professional team that includes allied health professionals (AHPs) is effective in improving mobility including activities of daily living (ADL), quality of life and falls outcomes. There is also evidence that demonstrated that reablement led by AHPs can reduce the need for long term care in terms of the use of domiciliary care services and admissions to residential care. Three economic evaluations found reablement services to be cost-effective, although there were some methodological flaws that limited the certainty of findings. There is a need for more studies from a UK perspective - only three UK-based studies were identified, with the rest reflecting an international body of evidence. Report Contributors: Review Team: Bethany Anthony, Jacob Davies, Kalpa Pisavadia, Sofie Roberts, Greg Flynn, Limssy Varghese, Rachel Granger, Madison Montgomery, Rebecca Rosi, Elizabeth Gillen, Juliet Hounsome, Dyfrig Hughes, Jane Noyes, Deborah Fitzsimmons, Rhiannon Tudor Edwards. Methodological Advice: Ruth Lewis Evidence Centre Team: Adrian Edwards, Ruth Lewis, Alison Cooper, Elizabeth Doe and Micaela Gal involved in stakeholder engagement, review of report and editing. Public Partner: Rashmi Kumar Stakeholder(s): Denise Moultrie, Ruth Crowder, Kerrie Phipps, and Rhian Matthews Disclaimer: The views expressed in this publication are those of the authors, not necessarily Health and Care Research Wales. The Health and Care Research Wales Evidence Centre and authors of this work declare that they have no conflict of interest. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: What is a Rapid Review?: Our rapid reviews use a variation of the systematic review approach, abbreviating or omitting some components to generate evidence to inform stakeholders promptly whilst maintaining attention to bias. Who is this Rapid Review for?: The review question was suggested by Health, Social Care and Early Years, Welsh Government. Background / Aim of Rapid Review: Reablement is defined by NICE (2017) as a community-based intervention that aims to increase a service user’s independence by helping them recover lost skills and confidence. Local authorities and health services in Wales are tasked with reablement, to help individuals who are at risk of frailty maintain and improve independence. However, social care resource constraints, mean that the balance of funds and workforce may be focussed on acute health care and long-term care in the community. The review aimed to identify evidence on the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of at -home time-limited reablement services for improving an individual’s independence and health outcomes and reducing the need for long term care. Results of the Rapid Review: The evidence base: The review included evidence available up until December 2024. Eighteen studies were included: 16 reported on clinical effectiveness (11 were controlled trials, 4 uncontrolled before and after studies, and one controlled cohort study); and three on cost-effectiveness (one study reported on both). Ten studies evaluated a step-up reablement model, two studies focused on the step-down reablement, four studies evaluated a reablement both step-up and step-down reablement, whilst the focus was unclear for the remaining two studies. Step-up reablement is defined as early / preventative intervention when an aspect of functioning deteriorates, following injury (e.g. fall) or a period of ill health and mitigating risk of hospital admission. Step-down reablement is the intervention received immediately following discharge with a view to regaining function. Twelve studies evaluated a reablement model led by a multi-professional team, which included allied health professionals (AHPs). 1 Five studies evaluated an AHP-led reablement model. One study evaluated a reablement model led by a nurse case manager coordinator. The reablement intervention was delivered by a range of people including: an occupational therapist (n=1 study); a member of the multiprofessional team or multi-professional workforce (n=10); a multi-professional team consisting of a range of different AHPs only (n=1); or non-health professional such as care manager, homecare personnel, health care assistant, home care aid, or carer (n=6). Key clinical-effectiveness findings: Person-related outcomes: A significant amount of evidence on the effectiveness of reablement interventions on person-related outcomes was identified. Reablement interventions were effective in improving people’s mobility and their ability to undertake activities of daily living (ADL), increasing quality of life, and reducing falls . Reablement interventions may be effective in improving individuals coping, in terms of sense of coherence (how individuals perceive life as comprehensible, manageable & meaningful). Reablement was not found to be effective for improving grip strength or increasing clients’ social support. Service-level outcomes: A significant amount of evidence on the effectiveness of reablement interventions on service-level outcomes was identified. Reablement was effective in reducing the need for long term home care services and residential care admissions . Reablement was also effective in reducing the number of outpatient treatments compared with usual domiciliary care. There were contradictory findings on reablement’s effectiveness in reducing hospital admissions, community care service use, and social care service use. There were inconsistent findings on reablement’s effectiveness in reducing emergency department visits. Type of reablement model: One study conducted in England found that a reablement model that was led and delivered by occupational therapists resulted in greater improvements in activities of daily living, quality of life, and falls, compared to reablement led and delivered by social care workers. Although the sample size was small and findings were not statistically significant, the Occupational Therapy-led model showed promising trends. In terms of community and social care resource use, participants in the Occupational Therapy-led reablement group were less likely to use health services, including GP visits and community support such as meals at home, suggesting potential efficiency benefits compared to the social care worker–led model. Key cost-effectiveness findings: Three economic evaluations found reablement services to be cost-effective , although there were some methodological flaws in the studies, that limited the certainty of findings. Research Implications and Evidence Gaps: There is a need for more studies from a UK perspective - only three UK-based studies were identified, with the rest reflecting an international body of evidence. While the international research is useful when it aligns with how reablement services are delivered in the UK, it is essential to consider the unique context of Wales where reablement services are often hosted within or delivered by local authorities. Noting there is currently significant challenge reported by occupational therapists in local authority in undertaking research activity. The economic evaluations had methodological flaws that limited the certainty of review findings, evidencing a need for future economic evaluations on the topic. Policy and Practice Implications: There is international evidence that reablement led by a multi-professional team that includes allied health professionals (AHPs) 1 , such as occupational therapists, is effective in improving mobility including activities of daily living, quality of life and falls outcomes. There is also evidence that demonstrated that reablement led by AHPs can reduce the need for long term care in terms of the use of domiciliary care services and admissions to residential care. While not all reablement services currently utilise AHPs, the evidence from this review makes a strong case for their inclusion in Wales. AHP-led reablement has been shown to improve person-centred outcomes and reduce the need for long-term care, supporting the case for targeted investment in AHP roles within reablement services. Three economic evaluations identified reablement as a cost-effective alternative to domiciliary care services. Given UK’s ageing population, the evidence from the Science Evidence Advice (SEA) 2023 report of the future prevalence and impact of frailty, and the high costs associated with ongoing care needs for people at risk of frailty, our findings make the case for investing in time-limited reablement interventions in Wales. Economic considerations: Reablement programmes may provide cost savings to commissioners and the health and social care systems through prevention of or reduced length of hospital admission, reductions in hospital readmission and preventing or reducing domiciliary and residential care demand. Frailty has a sizeable impact on healthcare resource use in the UK. Total additional costs of frailty-related healthcare resource use are £8 billion per year when adjusted to 2025 prices.

  • Open Access

    A rapid review of interventions to reduce suicide ideation, attempts, and deaths at public locations

    by Meg Kiseleva, Juliet Hounsome, Mala Mann, Abubakar Sha’aban, Riya Reji, Jacob Rees Davies, Rhiannon Tudor Edwards, Adrian Edwards, Alison Cooper, Ruth Lewis

    Suicide deaths are tragic events and those that occur in public places have an impact not only on the deceased person and their family and friends, but also on members of the public. Having up-to-date information about the effectiveness of interventions allows policymakers and organisations managing locations of concern to choose the most appropriate evidence-based suicide prevention strategies for specific locations. This rapid review was conducted to help inform the development of Welsh national guidance. The review included literature published since 2014. 24 studies were identified, and these were conducted in the UK, Australia, South Korea, Canada, USA, Denmark and Japan. The studies covered railway or underground stations, bridges, cliffs or other natural heights, tall buildings, and other types of locations. Surveillance technologies as a means of increasing opportunity for third-party intervention showed the most promise, although the evidence of their effectiveness was limited. In one study, having more closed-circuit television (CCTV) units was associated with fewer suicides at railway stations. Another study that tested a set of interventions including CCTV, infrared security fences, and a suicidal behaviour recognition and alert system, provided some promising initial descriptive data that showed an increase in the number of prevented suicides. Three other studies showed that there was no change in outcomes following the installation of interventions including surveillance technologies. Based on the assessment of the overall body of the evidence, there is a low level of confidence in the findings related to surveillance technologies because of the quality and designs of the studies. Promotion of suicide helplines as an intervention aimed at increasing opportunities for help seeking was examined in seven studies. Two studies reported that the number of suicides increased after the introduction of the intervention. Three studies, of which two examined a set of interventions including helplines, observed no change. In two studies the effect could not be determined. There is a low level of confidence in the evidence for this outcome. Other interventions evaluated included staff training; deployment of specialist staff; campaigns encouraging bystanders to intervene; a crisis café; blue lights at railway stations; suicide prevention messages, memorials, or notes other than official crisis line signage; spinning rollers at the top of fences that prevent gripping; and others. The effect of these interventions could not be determined with certainty but some of them appeared promising and warrant further research. More robust evaluations are needed before any of the interventions reviewed here can be recommended for implementation. To create a better evidence base, high-quality evaluations should be supported and encouraged. Future research should examine which interventions work for who and in what circumstances.