THThomas Howard

Thomas Howard

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Thomas Howard has a total of 17 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Haptic feedback for laparoscopic surgery instruments

    by Thomas Howard

    Retours haptiques pour instruments de chirurgie laparoscopique: La présente thèse traite de l'utilisation de retours haptiques pour fournir des informations aux chirurgiens durant des opérations de chirurgie minimalement invasive dans le but de les aider à améliorer leurs gestes.De meilleurs résultats pour les patients on amené la chirurgie minimalement invasive à devenir le standard pour bon nombre d'interventions. Cependant, la perte de perception de profondeur, la coordination main-oeil compliquée ainsi que les distorsions de sensations haptiques compliquent largement la tâche pour le chirurgien. Nous explorons le potentiel de retours haptiques pour intuitivement assister les chirurgiens durant des gestes de chirurgie minimalement invasive. Les formes de retour évaluées sont principalement haptiques (tactiles et kinesthésiques), avec des comparaisons à des retours visuels et multi-modaux (combinaisons de retours visuels et haptiques).Nos expériences dans le domaine de la navigation d'outils de chirurgie montrent des résultats encourageants quand aux bénéfices obtenus par des retours haptiques en termes d'amélioration de la qualité du geste chirurgical. Les guides par "virtual fixtures" montrent une nette supériorité par rapport aux autres formes de retour étudiées, cependant les retours vibrotactiles permettent aussi des améliorations notables. Des travaux parallèles sur le retour d'informations au sujet des efforts d'intéraction en bout d'outils a mis en évidence des différences importantes en termes des exigences de conception pour le retour tactile. Ceci nous a permis d'effectuer une conception et validation préliminaire de retours tactiles spécifiques à des applications de maitrise d'efforts, en utilisant l'exemple de la suture.

  • Open Access

    Designing 3D Object Rendering Techniques for Ultrasound Mid-Air Haptics using Intersection Strategies

    by Lendy Mulot, Thomas Howard, Sarah Emery, Claudio Pacchierotti, Maud Marchal

    Ultrasound mid-air haptic (UMH) interfaces focus acoustic energy to generate high-pressure focal points in mid-air, creating tactile sensations. When these focal points are modulated over time, they can render tactile patterns with various properties in a 3D workspace. While UMH has been used to render curves and 2D shapes, such as tactile icons, rendering 3D objects in full is nowadays an open problem, as it would require more powerful devices. To overcome this limitation, designers typically only render a representation of the intersection between the user’s hand and the virtual object. However, there is no consensus in the literature on how best to compute this intersection. This paper formalizes a pipeline for computing the intersection between a user’s hand and a 3D virtual object. Together with state-of-the-art sampling strategies, this forms an end-to-end design process for rendering 3D objects with UMH. A user study demonstrates the significant impact of intersection strategy design choices on the perception of 3D object properties, specifically infill density. We illustrate that different strategies can alter the perception of how hollow or filled an object is, which can be challenging to render in mid-air. By providing a standardized way to report and study 3D object rendering with UMH, this work aims to facilitate and motivate further exploration of perceptual effects via UMH technologies.


  • Bimanual Ultrasound Mid-Air Haptics for Virtual Reality Manipulation

    by Lendy Mulot, Thomas Howard, Guillaume Gicquel, Claudio Pacchierotti, Maud Marchal

    The ability to manipulate and physically feel virtual objects without any real object being present and without equipping the user has been a long-standing goal in virtual reality (VR). Emerging ultrasound mid-air haptics (UMH) technology could potentially address this challenge, as it enables remote tactile stimulation of unequipped users. However, to date, UMH has received limited attention in the field of haptic exploration and manipulation in virtual environments. Existing work has primarily focused on interactions requiring a single hand and thus the delivery of unimanual haptic feedback. Despite being fundamental to a large part of haptic interactions with our environments, bimanual tasks have rarely been studied in the field of UMH interaction in VR. In this paper, we propose the use of non-coplanar mid-air haptic devices for providing simultaneous tactile feedback to both hands during bimanual VR manipulation. We discuss coupling schemes and haptic rendering algorithms for providing bimanual haptic feedback in bimanual interactions with virtual environments. We then present two human participant studies, assessing the benefits of bimanual ultrasound haptic feedback in a two-handed grasping and holding task and in a shape exploration task. Results suggest that the use of multiple non-coplanar UMH devices could be an interesting approach for enriching unencumbered haptic manipulation in virtual environments.


  • Open Access

    Improving the Perception of Mid-air Tactile Shapes with Spatio-temporally-modulated Tactile Pointers

    by Lendy Mulot, Thomas Howard, Claudio Pacchierotti, Maud Marchal

    Ultrasound mid-air haptic (UMH) devices can remotely render vibrotactile shapes on the skin of unequipped users, e.g., to draw haptic icons or render virtual object shapes. Spatio-temporal modulation (STM), the state-of-the-art UMH shape-rendering method, provides large freedom in shape design and produces the strongest possible stimuli for this technology. Yet, STM shapes are often reported to be blurry, complicating shape identification. Dynamic tactile pointers (DTP) were recently introduced as a technique to overcome this issue. By tracing a contour with an amplitude-modulated focal point, they significantly improve shape identification accuracy over STM, but at the cost of much lower stimulus intensity. Building upon this, we propose spatio-temporally-modulated Tactile Pointers (STP), a novel method for rendering clearer and sharper UMH shapes while at the same time producing strong vibrotactile sensations. We ran two human participant experiments, which show that STP shapes are perceived as significantly stronger than DTP shapes, while shape identification accuracy is significantly improved over STM and on par with that obtained with DTP. Our work has implications for effective shape rendering with UMH and provides insights that could inform future psychophysical investigation into vibrotactile shape perception in UMH.


  • Does Multi-Actuator Vibrotactile Feedback Within Tangible Objects Enrich VR Manipulation?

    by Pierre-Antoine Cabaret, Thomas Howard, Guillaume Gicquel, Claudio Pacchierotti, Marie Babel, Maud Marchal

    Rich, informative and realistic haptic feedback is key to enhancing Virtual Reality (VR) manipulation. Tangible objects provide convincing grasping and manipulation interactions with haptic feedback of e.g., shape, mass and texture properties. But these properties are static, and cannot respond to interactions in the virtual environment. On the other hand, vibrotactile feedback provides the opportunity for delivering dynamic cues rendering many different contact properties, such as impacts, object vibrations or textures. Handheld objects or controllers in VR are usually restricted to vibrating in a monolithic fashion. In this article, we investigate how spatialiazing vibrotactile cues within handheld tangibles could enable a wider range of sensations and interactions. We conduct a set of perception studies, investigating the extent to which spatialization of vibrotactile feedback within tangible objects is possible as well as the benefits of proposed rendering schemes leveraging multiple actuators in VR. Results show that vibrotactile cues from localized actuators can be discriminated and are beneficial for certain rendering schemes.


  • Ultrasound Mid-Air Haptics for Hand Guidance in Virtual Reality

    by Lendy Mulot, Thomas Howard, Claudio Pacchierotti, Maud Marchal

    This paper presents and evaluates a set of mid-air ultrasound haptic strategies to provide 2-degree-of-freedom position and orientation guidance in Virtual Reality (VR). We devised four strategies for providing position guidance and two for providing orientation guidance. A human subject study evaluated the effectiveness of the proposed techniques in guiding users towards objectives in static and dynamic environments in VR, both in position and orientation. Results show that, compared to visual feedback of the virtual environment alone, the considered strategies significantly improve positioning performance in the static scenario. On the other hand, orientation guidance led to significant improvements only in the dynamic scenario.


  • Can we Effectively Combine Tangibles and Ultrasound Mid-Air Haptics? A Study of Acoustically Transparent Tangible Surfaces

    by Thomas Howard, Guillaume Gicquel, Claudio Pacchierotti, Maud Marchal

    We propose to study the combination of acoustically transparent tangible objects (ATTs) and ultrasound mid-air haptic (UMH) feedback to support haptic interactions with digital content. Both these haptic feedback methods have the advantage of leaving users unencumbered, and present uniquely complementary strengths and weaknesses. In this paper, we provide an overview of the design space for haptic interactions covered by this combination, as well as requirements for their technical implementation. Indeed, when imagining the concurrent manipulation of physical objects and delivery of mid-air haptic stimuli, reflection and absorption of sound by the tangibles may impede delivery of the UMH stimuli. To demonstrate the viability of our approach, we study the combination of single ATT surfaces, i.e. the basic building blocks for any tangible object, and UMH stimuli. We investigate attenuation of a focal point focused through various plates of acoustically transparent materials, and run three human subject experiments investigating the impact of acoustically transparent materials on detection thresholds, discrimination of motion, and localization of ultrasound haptic stimuli. Results show that tangible surfaces which do not significantly attenuate ultrasound can be fabricated with relative ease. The perception studies confirm that ATT surfaces do not impede perception of UMH stimulus properties, and thus that both may viably be combined in haptics applications.


  • PalmEx: Adding Palmar Force-Feedback for 3D Manipulation With Haptic Exoskeleton Gloves

    by Elodie Bouzbib, Marc Teyssier, Thomas Howard, Claudio Pacchierotti, Anatole Lécuyer

    Haptic exoskeleton gloves are a widespread solution for providing force-feedback in Virtual Reality (VR), especially for 3D object manipulations. However, they are still lacking an important feature regarding in-hand haptic sensations: the palmar contact. In this paper, we present PalmEx, a novel approach which incorporates palmar force-feedback into exoskeleton gloves to improve the overall grasping sensations and manual haptic interactions in VR. PalmEx’s concept is demonstrated through a self-contained hardware system augmenting a hand exoskeleton with an encountered palmar contact interface – physically encountering the users’ palm. We build upon current taxonomies to elicit PalmEx’s capabilities for both the exploration and manipulation of virtual objects. We first conduct a technical evaluation optimising the delay between the virtual interactions and their physical counterparts. We then empirically evaluate PalmEx’s proposed design space in a user study (n=12) to assess the potential of a palmar contact for augmenting an exoskeleton. Results show that PalmEx offers the best rendering capabilities to perform believable grasps in VR. PalmEx highlights the importance of the palmar stimulation, and provides a low-cost solution to augment existing high-end consumer hand exoskeletons.


  • Open Access

    Gap Detection in Pairs of Ultrasound Mid-air Vibrotactile Stimuli

    by Thomas Howard, Karina Kirk Driller, William Frier, Claudio Pacchierotti, Maud Marchal, Jessica Hartcher-O’bRien

    Ultrasound mid-air haptic (UMH) devices are a novel tool for haptic feedback, capable of providing localized vibrotactile stimuli to users at a distance. UMH applications largely rely on generating tactile shape outlines on the users’ skin. Here we investigate how to achieve sensations of continuity or gaps within such two-dimensional curves by studying the perception of pairs of amplitude-modulated focused ultrasound stimuli. On the one hand, we aim to investigate perceptual effects that may arise from providing simultaneous UMH stimuli. On the other hand, we wish to provide perception-based rendering guidelines for generating continuous or discontinuous sensations of tactile shapes. Finally, we hope to contribute toward a measure of the perceptually achievable resolution of UMH interfaces. We performed a user study to identify how far apart two focal points need to be to elicit a perceptual experience of two distinct stimuli separated by a gap. Mean gap detection thresholds were found at 32.3-mm spacing between focal points, but a high within- and between-subject variability was observed. Pairs spaced below 15 mm were consistently (>95%) perceived as a single stimulus, while pairs spaced 45 mm apart were consistently (84%) perceived as two separate stimuli. To investigate the observed variability, we resort to acoustic simulations of the resulting pressure fields. These show a non-linear evolution of actual peak pressure spacing as a function of nominal focal point spacing. Beyond an initial threshold in spacing (between 15 and 18 mm), which we believe to be related to the perceived size of a focal point, the probability of detecting a gap between focal points appears to linearly increase with spacing. Our work highlights physical interactions and perceptual effects to consider when designing or investigating the perception of UMH shapes.