Tim Lüttmer
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Tim Lüttmer has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Peter Spichtinger
Institute for Atmospheric Physics, Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz, Mainz, Germany
24 shared publications - Annette Miltenberger
Institute for Atmospheric Physics, Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz, Mainz, Germany
11 shared publications - Axel Seifert
Deutscher Wetterdienst
6 shared publications - Sylwester Arabas
Faculty of Physics and Applied Computer Science, AGH University of Kraków, Kraków, Poland
6 shared publications - Christoph Siewert
Deutscher Wetterdienst, 63067 Offenbach, Germany
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 5 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-27
Comment on egusphere-2026-5375
Warm conveyor belts (WCBs) in extratropical cyclones transport moist boundary-layer air into the upper troposphere and form extensive mixed-phase cloud bands and cirrus cloud shields. The microphysical pathways governing ice formation within these systems remain poorly quantified, particularly with respect to heterogeneous ice nucleation and secondary ice production. We investigate the impact of uncertainty in the ice formation representation on clouds in a WCB using the ICON model with an ice modes two-moment scheme that explicitly tracks ice formed by immersion freezing (IMM), deposition nucleation (DEP), homogeneous droplet freezing (FRZ), homogeneous solution freezing (HOM), and secondary ice (SEC). We test the sensitivity of ice formation pathways to three dust INP activation schemes, perturbations of INP concentration, and three secondary ice mechanisms (rime splintering, collisional breakup, droplet fragmentation). Ice number concentrations in the cirrus regime respond strongly to both INP abundance and activation scheme. Enhanced INP concentrations strengthen heterogeneous modes, particularly DEP, leading to DEP-dominated cirrus and suppression of homogeneous nucleation. Reduced INP concentrations promote compensating increases in HOM and FRZ. Secondary ice from rime splintering and collisional breakup dominates number concentrations in low level mixed-phase clouds but is negligible in cirrus. Importantly, altering the INP activation scheme produces changes comparable in magnitude to variations in INP concentration with scaling coefficients between 0.1 and 15, highlighting substantial uncertainty in heterogeneous ice nucleation assumptions. Overall, the partitioning among ice modes is highly sensitive to microphysical assumptions, but the balance between liquid-origin and in-situ cirrus remains primarily controlled by WCB dynamics and sedimentation.
- 5 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-27
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-5375
Warm conveyor belts (WCBs) in extratropical cyclones transport moist boundary-layer air into the upper troposphere and form extensive mixed-phase cloud bands and cirrus cloud shields. The microphysical pathways governing ice formation within these systems remain poorly quantified, particularly with respect to heterogeneous ice nucleation and secondary ice production. We investigate the impact of uncertainty in the ice formation representation on clouds in a WCB using the ICON model with an ice modes two-moment scheme that explicitly tracks ice formed by immersion freezing (IMM), deposition nucleation (DEP), homogeneous droplet freezing (FRZ), homogeneous solution freezing (HOM), and secondary ice (SEC). We test the sensitivity of ice formation pathways to three dust INP activation schemes, perturbations of INP concentration, and three secondary ice mechanisms (rime splintering, collisional breakup, droplet fragmentation). Ice number concentrations in the cirrus regime respond strongly to both INP abundance and activation scheme. Enhanced INP concentrations strengthen heterogeneous modes, particularly DEP, leading to DEP-dominated cirrus and suppression of homogeneous nucleation. Reduced INP concentrations promote compensating increases in HOM and FRZ. Secondary ice from rime splintering and collisional breakup dominates number concentrations in low level mixed-phase clouds but is negligible in cirrus. Importantly, altering the INP activation scheme produces changes comparable in magnitude to variations in INP concentration with scaling coefficients between 0.1 and 15, highlighting substantial uncertainty in heterogeneous ice nucleation assumptions. Overall, the partitioning among ice modes is highly sensitive to microphysical assumptions, but the balance between liquid-origin and in-situ cirrus remains primarily controlled by WCB dynamics and sedimentation.
- Open Access
- 30 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-27
Comment on egusphere-2026-5375
Warm conveyor belts (WCBs) in extratropical cyclones transport moist boundary-layer air into the upper troposphere and form extensive mixed-phase cloud bands and cirrus cloud shields. The microphysical pathways governing ice formation within these systems remain poorly quantified, particularly with respect to heterogeneous ice nucleation and secondary ice production. We investigate the impact of uncertainty in the ice formation representation on clouds in a WCB using the ICON model with an ice modes two-moment scheme that explicitly tracks ice formed by immersion freezing (IMM), deposition nucleation (DEP), homogeneous droplet freezing (FRZ), homogeneous solution freezing (HOM), and secondary ice (SEC). We test the sensitivity of ice formation pathways to three dust INP activation schemes, perturbations of INP concentration, and three secondary ice mechanisms (rime splintering, collisional breakup, droplet fragmentation). Ice number concentrations in the cirrus regime respond strongly to both INP abundance and activation scheme. Enhanced INP concentrations strengthen heterogeneous modes, particularly DEP, leading to DEP-dominated cirrus and suppression of homogeneous nucleation. Reduced INP concentrations promote compensating increases in HOM and FRZ. Secondary ice from rime splintering and collisional breakup dominates number concentrations in low level mixed-phase clouds but is negligible in cirrus. Importantly, altering the INP activation scheme produces changes comparable in magnitude to variations in INP concentration with scaling coefficients between 0.1 and 15, highlighting substantial uncertainty in heterogeneous ice nucleation assumptions. Overall, the partitioning among ice modes is highly sensitive to microphysical assumptions, but the balance between liquid-origin and in-situ cirrus remains primarily controlled by WCB dynamics and sedimentation.
- 30 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-27
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-5375
Warm conveyor belts (WCBs) in extratropical cyclones transport moist boundary-layer air into the upper troposphere and form extensive mixed-phase cloud bands and cirrus cloud shields. The microphysical pathways governing ice formation within these systems remain poorly quantified, particularly with respect to heterogeneous ice nucleation and secondary ice production. We investigate the impact of uncertainty in the ice formation representation on clouds in a WCB using the ICON model with an ice modes two-moment scheme that explicitly tracks ice formed by immersion freezing (IMM), deposition nucleation (DEP), homogeneous droplet freezing (FRZ), homogeneous solution freezing (HOM), and secondary ice (SEC). We test the sensitivity of ice formation pathways to three dust INP activation schemes, perturbations of INP concentration, and three secondary ice mechanisms (rime splintering, collisional breakup, droplet fragmentation). Ice number concentrations in the cirrus regime respond strongly to both INP abundance and activation scheme. Enhanced INP concentrations strengthen heterogeneous modes, particularly DEP, leading to DEP-dominated cirrus and suppression of homogeneous nucleation. Reduced INP concentrations promote compensating increases in HOM and FRZ. Secondary ice from rime splintering and collisional breakup dominates number concentrations in low level mixed-phase clouds but is negligible in cirrus. Importantly, altering the INP activation scheme produces changes comparable in magnitude to variations in INP concentration with scaling coefficients between 0.1 and 15, highlighting substantial uncertainty in heterogeneous ice nucleation assumptions. Overall, the partitioning among ice modes is highly sensitive to microphysical assumptions, but the balance between liquid-origin and in-situ cirrus remains primarily controlled by WCB dynamics and sedimentation.
- Open Access
- 27 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 19 (20) , 10185-10202
Stochastic homogeneous freezing of supercooled droplets in mixed-phase clouds in particle-based idealised microphysics framework (exemplified with PySDM v3.0)
Homogeneous freezing of supercooled cloud droplets is an important process governing ice formation during the transition from mixed-phase clouds to pure ice-phase clouds in the upper troposphere. In this study, we implement a stochastic representation of homogeneous freezing in the particle-based aerosol–cloud microphysics model PySDM, treating freezing as a Poisson process dependent on droplet volume, time step, and the nucleation rate. We compare two parameterisations of the nucleation rate: a temperature-dependent formulation and a saturation-dependent formulation. Using an idealised adiabatically ascending air-parcel framework, we investigate the distribution of freezing temperatures and the resulting ice number concentrations across ensembles that vary updraft speed, cloud condensation nuclei number concentration, droplet size distribution, and the number of super-particles. Simulations are performed both with and without vapour deposition on ice, enabling assessment of the role of the Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process. We find that homogeneous freezing occurs over a broad temperature range rather than at a single threshold, with freezing temperatures strongly controlled by cooling rate and droplet size. When vapour deposition on ice is active, early stochastic freezing events dominate the evolution of the frozen droplet fraction and substantially reduce the fraction of droplets that ultimately freeze. The two nucleation-rate formulations produce similar behaviour near water saturation but diverge significantly when supersaturation or subsaturation with respect to water develops, leading to pronounced differences in freezing temperatures and ice number concentrations. Our results highlight the importance of stochastic freezing formulations and nucleation-rate choice for representing cloud glaciation in models.
- 27 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 19 (20) , 10185-10202
Open AccessStochastic homogeneous freezing of supercooled droplets in mixed-phase clouds in particle-based idealised microphysics framework (exemplified with PySDM v3.0)
Homogeneous freezing of supercooled cloud droplets is an important process governing ice formation during the transition from mixed-phase clouds to pure ice-phase clouds in the upper troposphere. In this study, we implement a stochastic representation of homogeneous freezing in the particle-based aerosol–cloud microphysics model PySDM, treating freezing as a Poisson process dependent on droplet volume, time step, and the nucleation rate. We compare two parameterisations of the nucleation rate: a temperature-dependent formulation and a saturation-dependent formulation. Using an idealised adiabatically ascending air-parcel framework, we investigate the distribution of freezing temperatures and the resulting ice number concentrations across ensembles that vary updraft speed, cloud condensation nuclei number concentration, droplet size distribution, and the number of super-particles. Simulations are performed both with and without vapour deposition on ice, enabling assessment of the role of the Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process. We find that homogeneous freezing occurs over a broad temperature range rather than at a single threshold, with freezing temperatures strongly controlled by cooling rate and droplet size. When vapour deposition on ice is active, early stochastic freezing events dominate the evolution of the frozen droplet fraction and substantially reduce the fraction of droplets that ultimately freeze. The two nucleation-rate formulations produce similar behaviour near water saturation but diverge significantly when supersaturation or subsaturation with respect to water develops, leading to pronounced differences in freezing temperatures and ice number concentrations. Our results highlight the importance of stochastic freezing formulations and nucleation-rate choice for representing cloud glaciation in models.
- Open Access
- 20 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-27
Comment on egusphere-2026-5375
Warm conveyor belts (WCBs) in extratropical cyclones transport moist boundary-layer air into the upper troposphere and form extensive mixed-phase cloud bands and cirrus cloud shields. The microphysical pathways governing ice formation within these systems remain poorly quantified, particularly with respect to heterogeneous ice nucleation and secondary ice production. We investigate the impact of uncertainty in the ice formation representation on clouds in a WCB using the ICON model with an ice modes two-moment scheme that explicitly tracks ice formed by immersion freezing (IMM), deposition nucleation (DEP), homogeneous droplet freezing (FRZ), homogeneous solution freezing (HOM), and secondary ice (SEC). We test the sensitivity of ice formation pathways to three dust INP activation schemes, perturbations of INP concentration, and three secondary ice mechanisms (rime splintering, collisional breakup, droplet fragmentation). Ice number concentrations in the cirrus regime respond strongly to both INP abundance and activation scheme. Enhanced INP concentrations strengthen heterogeneous modes, particularly DEP, leading to DEP-dominated cirrus and suppression of homogeneous nucleation. Reduced INP concentrations promote compensating increases in HOM and FRZ. Secondary ice from rime splintering and collisional breakup dominates number concentrations in low level mixed-phase clouds but is negligible in cirrus. Importantly, altering the INP activation scheme produces changes comparable in magnitude to variations in INP concentration with scaling coefficients between 0.1 and 15, highlighting substantial uncertainty in heterogeneous ice nucleation assumptions. Overall, the partitioning among ice modes is highly sensitive to microphysical assumptions, but the balance between liquid-origin and in-situ cirrus remains primarily controlled by WCB dynamics and sedimentation.
- 20 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-27
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-5375
Warm conveyor belts (WCBs) in extratropical cyclones transport moist boundary-layer air into the upper troposphere and form extensive mixed-phase cloud bands and cirrus cloud shields. The microphysical pathways governing ice formation within these systems remain poorly quantified, particularly with respect to heterogeneous ice nucleation and secondary ice production. We investigate the impact of uncertainty in the ice formation representation on clouds in a WCB using the ICON model with an ice modes two-moment scheme that explicitly tracks ice formed by immersion freezing (IMM), deposition nucleation (DEP), homogeneous droplet freezing (FRZ), homogeneous solution freezing (HOM), and secondary ice (SEC). We test the sensitivity of ice formation pathways to three dust INP activation schemes, perturbations of INP concentration, and three secondary ice mechanisms (rime splintering, collisional breakup, droplet fragmentation). Ice number concentrations in the cirrus regime respond strongly to both INP abundance and activation scheme. Enhanced INP concentrations strengthen heterogeneous modes, particularly DEP, leading to DEP-dominated cirrus and suppression of homogeneous nucleation. Reduced INP concentrations promote compensating increases in HOM and FRZ. Secondary ice from rime splintering and collisional breakup dominates number concentrations in low level mixed-phase clouds but is negligible in cirrus. Importantly, altering the INP activation scheme produces changes comparable in magnitude to variations in INP concentration with scaling coefficients between 0.1 and 15, highlighting substantial uncertainty in heterogeneous ice nucleation assumptions. Overall, the partitioning among ice modes is highly sensitive to microphysical assumptions, but the balance between liquid-origin and in-situ cirrus remains primarily controlled by WCB dynamics and sedimentation.
- Open Access
- 9 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-27
Role of INP activation schemes and concentrations in controlling ice formation pathways in Warm Conveyor Belts
Warm conveyor belts (WCBs) in extratropical cyclones transport moist boundary-layer air into the upper troposphere and form extensive mixed-phase cloud bands and cirrus cloud shields. The microphysical pathways governing ice formation within these systems remain poorly quantified, particularly with respect to heterogeneous ice nucleation and secondary ice production. We investigate the impact of uncertainty in the ice formation representation on clouds in a WCB using the ICON model with an ice modes two-moment scheme that explicitly tracks ice formed by immersion freezing (IMM), deposition nucleation (DEP), homogeneous droplet freezing (FRZ), homogeneous solution freezing (HOM), and secondary ice (SEC). We test the sensitivity of ice formation pathways to three dust INP activation schemes, perturbations of INP concentration, and three secondary ice mechanisms (rime splintering, collisional breakup, droplet fragmentation). Ice number concentrations in the cirrus regime respond strongly to both INP abundance and activation scheme. Enhanced INP concentrations strengthen heterogeneous modes, particularly DEP, leading to DEP-dominated cirrus and suppression of homogeneous nucleation. Reduced INP concentrations promote compensating increases in HOM and FRZ. Secondary ice from rime splintering and collisional breakup dominates number concentrations in low level mixed-phase clouds but is negligible in cirrus. Importantly, altering the INP activation scheme produces changes comparable in magnitude to variations in INP concentration with scaling coefficients between 0.1 and 15, highlighting substantial uncertainty in heterogeneous ice nucleation assumptions. Overall, the partitioning among ice modes is highly sensitive to microphysical assumptions, but the balance between liquid-origin and in-situ cirrus remains primarily controlled by WCB dynamics and sedimentation.
- 9 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-27
Open AccessRole of INP activation schemes and concentrations in controlling ice formation pathways in Warm Conveyor Belts
Warm conveyor belts (WCBs) in extratropical cyclones transport moist boundary-layer air into the upper troposphere and form extensive mixed-phase cloud bands and cirrus cloud shields. The microphysical pathways governing ice formation within these systems remain poorly quantified, particularly with respect to heterogeneous ice nucleation and secondary ice production. We investigate the impact of uncertainty in the ice formation representation on clouds in a WCB using the ICON model with an ice modes two-moment scheme that explicitly tracks ice formed by immersion freezing (IMM), deposition nucleation (DEP), homogeneous droplet freezing (FRZ), homogeneous solution freezing (HOM), and secondary ice (SEC). We test the sensitivity of ice formation pathways to three dust INP activation schemes, perturbations of INP concentration, and three secondary ice mechanisms (rime splintering, collisional breakup, droplet fragmentation). Ice number concentrations in the cirrus regime respond strongly to both INP abundance and activation scheme. Enhanced INP concentrations strengthen heterogeneous modes, particularly DEP, leading to DEP-dominated cirrus and suppression of homogeneous nucleation. Reduced INP concentrations promote compensating increases in HOM and FRZ. Secondary ice from rime splintering and collisional breakup dominates number concentrations in low level mixed-phase clouds but is negligible in cirrus. Importantly, altering the INP activation scheme produces changes comparable in magnitude to variations in INP concentration with scaling coefficients between 0.1 and 15, highlighting substantial uncertainty in heterogeneous ice nucleation assumptions. Overall, the partitioning among ice modes is highly sensitive to microphysical assumptions, but the balance between liquid-origin and in-situ cirrus remains primarily controlled by WCB dynamics and sedimentation.
- Open Access
- 24 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Reply on RC2
Homogeneous freezing of supercooled cloud droplets is an important process governing ice formation during the transition from mixed-phase clouds to pure ice-phase clouds in the upper troposphere. In this study, we implement a stochastic representation of homogeneous freezing in the particle-based aerosol–cloud microphysics model PySDM, treating freezing as a Poisson process dependent on droplet volume, time step, and the nucleation rate. We compare two parameterisations of the nucleation rate: a temperature-dependent formulation and a saturation-dependent formulation. Using an idealised adiabatically ascending air-parcel framework, we investigate the distribution of freezing temperatures and the resulting ice number concentrations across ensembles that vary updraft speed, cloud condensation nuclei number concentration, droplet size distribution, and the number of super-particles. Simulations are performed both with and without vapour deposition on ice, enabling assessment of the role of the Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process. We find that homogeneous freezing occurs over a broad temperature range rather than at a single threshold, with freezing temperatures strongly controlled by cooling rate and droplet size. When vapour deposition on ice is active, early stochastic freezing events dominate the evolution of the frozen droplet fraction and substantially reduce the fraction of droplets that ultimately freeze. The two nucleation-rate formulations produce similar behaviour near water saturation but diverge significantly when supersaturation or subsaturation with respect to water develops, leading to pronounced differences in freezing temperatures and ice number concentrations. Our results highlight the importance of stochastic freezing formulations and nucleation-rate choice for representing cloud glaciation in models.
- 24 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Open AccessReply on RC2
Homogeneous freezing of supercooled cloud droplets is an important process governing ice formation during the transition from mixed-phase clouds to pure ice-phase clouds in the upper troposphere. In this study, we implement a stochastic representation of homogeneous freezing in the particle-based aerosol–cloud microphysics model PySDM, treating freezing as a Poisson process dependent on droplet volume, time step, and the nucleation rate. We compare two parameterisations of the nucleation rate: a temperature-dependent formulation and a saturation-dependent formulation. Using an idealised adiabatically ascending air-parcel framework, we investigate the distribution of freezing temperatures and the resulting ice number concentrations across ensembles that vary updraft speed, cloud condensation nuclei number concentration, droplet size distribution, and the number of super-particles. Simulations are performed both with and without vapour deposition on ice, enabling assessment of the role of the Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process. We find that homogeneous freezing occurs over a broad temperature range rather than at a single threshold, with freezing temperatures strongly controlled by cooling rate and droplet size. When vapour deposition on ice is active, early stochastic freezing events dominate the evolution of the frozen droplet fraction and substantially reduce the fraction of droplets that ultimately freeze. The two nucleation-rate formulations produce similar behaviour near water saturation but diverge significantly when supersaturation or subsaturation with respect to water develops, leading to pronounced differences in freezing temperatures and ice number concentrations. Our results highlight the importance of stochastic freezing formulations and nucleation-rate choice for representing cloud glaciation in models.
- Open Access
- 24 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Reply on RC1
Homogeneous freezing of supercooled cloud droplets is an important process governing ice formation during the transition from mixed-phase clouds to pure ice-phase clouds in the upper troposphere. In this study, we implement a stochastic representation of homogeneous freezing in the particle-based aerosol–cloud microphysics model PySDM, treating freezing as a Poisson process dependent on droplet volume, time step, and the nucleation rate. We compare two parameterisations of the nucleation rate: a temperature-dependent formulation and a saturation-dependent formulation. Using an idealised adiabatically ascending air-parcel framework, we investigate the distribution of freezing temperatures and the resulting ice number concentrations across ensembles that vary updraft speed, cloud condensation nuclei number concentration, droplet size distribution, and the number of super-particles. Simulations are performed both with and without vapour deposition on ice, enabling assessment of the role of the Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process. We find that homogeneous freezing occurs over a broad temperature range rather than at a single threshold, with freezing temperatures strongly controlled by cooling rate and droplet size. When vapour deposition on ice is active, early stochastic freezing events dominate the evolution of the frozen droplet fraction and substantially reduce the fraction of droplets that ultimately freeze. The two nucleation-rate formulations produce similar behaviour near water saturation but diverge significantly when supersaturation or subsaturation with respect to water develops, leading to pronounced differences in freezing temperatures and ice number concentrations. Our results highlight the importance of stochastic freezing formulations and nucleation-rate choice for representing cloud glaciation in models.
- 24 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Open AccessReply on RC1
Homogeneous freezing of supercooled cloud droplets is an important process governing ice formation during the transition from mixed-phase clouds to pure ice-phase clouds in the upper troposphere. In this study, we implement a stochastic representation of homogeneous freezing in the particle-based aerosol–cloud microphysics model PySDM, treating freezing as a Poisson process dependent on droplet volume, time step, and the nucleation rate. We compare two parameterisations of the nucleation rate: a temperature-dependent formulation and a saturation-dependent formulation. Using an idealised adiabatically ascending air-parcel framework, we investigate the distribution of freezing temperatures and the resulting ice number concentrations across ensembles that vary updraft speed, cloud condensation nuclei number concentration, droplet size distribution, and the number of super-particles. Simulations are performed both with and without vapour deposition on ice, enabling assessment of the role of the Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process. We find that homogeneous freezing occurs over a broad temperature range rather than at a single threshold, with freezing temperatures strongly controlled by cooling rate and droplet size. When vapour deposition on ice is active, early stochastic freezing events dominate the evolution of the frozen droplet fraction and substantially reduce the fraction of droplets that ultimately freeze. The two nucleation-rate formulations produce similar behaviour near water saturation but diverge significantly when supersaturation or subsaturation with respect to water develops, leading to pronounced differences in freezing temperatures and ice number concentrations. Our results highlight the importance of stochastic freezing formulations and nucleation-rate choice for representing cloud glaciation in models.
- Open Access
- 27 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Comment on egusphere-2026-2217
Homogeneous freezing of supercooled cloud droplets is an important process governing ice formation during the transition from mixed-phase clouds to pure ice-phase clouds in the upper troposphere. In this study, we implement a stochastic representation of homogeneous freezing in the particle-based aerosol–cloud microphysics model PySDM, treating freezing as a Poisson process dependent on droplet volume, time step, and the nucleation rate. We compare two parameterisations of the nucleation rate: a temperature-dependent formulation and a saturation-dependent formulation. Using an idealised adiabatically ascending air-parcel framework, we investigate the distribution of freezing temperatures and the resulting ice number concentrations across ensembles that vary updraft speed, cloud condensation nuclei number concentration, droplet size distribution, and the number of super-particles. Simulations are performed both with and without vapour deposition on ice, enabling assessment of the role of the Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process. We find that homogeneous freezing occurs over a broad temperature range rather than at a single threshold, with freezing temperatures strongly controlled by cooling rate and droplet size. When vapour deposition on ice is active, early stochastic freezing events dominate the evolution of the frozen droplet fraction and substantially reduce the fraction of droplets that ultimately freeze. The two nucleation-rate formulations produce similar behaviour near water saturation but diverge significantly when supersaturation or subsaturation with respect to water develops, leading to pronounced differences in freezing temperatures and ice number concentrations. Our results highlight the importance of stochastic freezing formulations and nucleation-rate choice for representing cloud glaciation in models.
- 27 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-2217
Homogeneous freezing of supercooled cloud droplets is an important process governing ice formation during the transition from mixed-phase clouds to pure ice-phase clouds in the upper troposphere. In this study, we implement a stochastic representation of homogeneous freezing in the particle-based aerosol–cloud microphysics model PySDM, treating freezing as a Poisson process dependent on droplet volume, time step, and the nucleation rate. We compare two parameterisations of the nucleation rate: a temperature-dependent formulation and a saturation-dependent formulation. Using an idealised adiabatically ascending air-parcel framework, we investigate the distribution of freezing temperatures and the resulting ice number concentrations across ensembles that vary updraft speed, cloud condensation nuclei number concentration, droplet size distribution, and the number of super-particles. Simulations are performed both with and without vapour deposition on ice, enabling assessment of the role of the Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process. We find that homogeneous freezing occurs over a broad temperature range rather than at a single threshold, with freezing temperatures strongly controlled by cooling rate and droplet size. When vapour deposition on ice is active, early stochastic freezing events dominate the evolution of the frozen droplet fraction and substantially reduce the fraction of droplets that ultimately freeze. The two nucleation-rate formulations produce similar behaviour near water saturation but diverge significantly when supersaturation or subsaturation with respect to water develops, leading to pronounced differences in freezing temperatures and ice number concentrations. Our results highlight the importance of stochastic freezing formulations and nucleation-rate choice for representing cloud glaciation in models.
- Open Access
- 14 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Comment on egusphere-2026-2217
Homogeneous freezing of supercooled cloud droplets is an important process governing ice formation during the transition from mixed-phase clouds to pure ice-phase clouds in the upper troposphere. In this study, we implement a stochastic representation of homogeneous freezing in the particle-based aerosol–cloud microphysics model PySDM, treating freezing as a Poisson process dependent on droplet volume, time step, and the nucleation rate. We compare two parameterisations of the nucleation rate: a temperature-dependent formulation and a saturation-dependent formulation. Using an idealised adiabatically ascending air-parcel framework, we investigate the distribution of freezing temperatures and the resulting ice number concentrations across ensembles that vary updraft speed, cloud condensation nuclei number concentration, droplet size distribution, and the number of super-particles. Simulations are performed both with and without vapour deposition on ice, enabling assessment of the role of the Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process. We find that homogeneous freezing occurs over a broad temperature range rather than at a single threshold, with freezing temperatures strongly controlled by cooling rate and droplet size. When vapour deposition on ice is active, early stochastic freezing events dominate the evolution of the frozen droplet fraction and substantially reduce the fraction of droplets that ultimately freeze. The two nucleation-rate formulations produce similar behaviour near water saturation but diverge significantly when supersaturation or subsaturation with respect to water develops, leading to pronounced differences in freezing temperatures and ice number concentrations. Our results highlight the importance of stochastic freezing formulations and nucleation-rate choice for representing cloud glaciation in models.
- 14 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-28
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-2217
Homogeneous freezing of supercooled cloud droplets is an important process governing ice formation during the transition from mixed-phase clouds to pure ice-phase clouds in the upper troposphere. In this study, we implement a stochastic representation of homogeneous freezing in the particle-based aerosol–cloud microphysics model PySDM, treating freezing as a Poisson process dependent on droplet volume, time step, and the nucleation rate. We compare two parameterisations of the nucleation rate: a temperature-dependent formulation and a saturation-dependent formulation. Using an idealised adiabatically ascending air-parcel framework, we investigate the distribution of freezing temperatures and the resulting ice number concentrations across ensembles that vary updraft speed, cloud condensation nuclei number concentration, droplet size distribution, and the number of super-particles. Simulations are performed both with and without vapour deposition on ice, enabling assessment of the role of the Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process. We find that homogeneous freezing occurs over a broad temperature range rather than at a single threshold, with freezing temperatures strongly controlled by cooling rate and droplet size. When vapour deposition on ice is active, early stochastic freezing events dominate the evolution of the frozen droplet fraction and substantially reduce the fraction of droplets that ultimately freeze. The two nucleation-rate formulations produce similar behaviour near water saturation but diverge significantly when supersaturation or subsaturation with respect to water develops, leading to pronounced differences in freezing temperatures and ice number concentrations. Our results highlight the importance of stochastic freezing formulations and nucleation-rate choice for representing cloud glaciation in models.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Stochastic homogeneous freezing of supercooled droplets in particle-based microphysics
Homogeneous freezing of supercooled cloud droplets controls the transition from mixed- to ice-phase regime in the upper troposphere. We discuss a stochastic representation of the process, for use in particle-based aerosol-cloud microphysics models. The embraced Poissonian formulation is governed by droplet volume, model time step, and the homogeneous nucleation rate.Using an implementation of the model in the PySDM particle-based modelling package, we evaluate two nucleation-rate formulations: a temperature-dependent and a water-activity-based parameterisations, the latter applicable also to aqueous solution droplets.Using an air-parcel framework, we investigate freezing-temperature distributions and resulting ice number concentrations across ensembles of simulations with varying updraft speeds, CCN concentrations, droplet size distributions, and number of super-particles. The two nucleation-rate parameterisations diverge under super- or subsaturated conditions with respect to water, yielding differences in freezing temperatures and ice number concentrations.To asses the impact of Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process on ice concentrations, we consider simulations with and without vapour deposition on ice. With deposition enabled, early stochastic freezing events dominate the evolution of the frozen droplet fraction and substantially reduce the number of droplets that ultimately freeze.The developed model allows to validate the common assumption that homogeneous freezing is a threshold phenomenon occurring at ca. 235 K. We find that homogeneous freezing spans a broad temperature range controlled by cooling rate and droplet size, highlight the importance of stochastic freezing formulations and nucleation-rate choice for representing cloud glaciation.
- 13 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessStochastic homogeneous freezing of supercooled droplets in particle-based microphysics
Homogeneous freezing of supercooled cloud droplets controls the transition from mixed- to ice-phase regime in the upper troposphere. We discuss a stochastic representation of the process, for use in particle-based aerosol-cloud microphysics models. The embraced Poissonian formulation is governed by droplet volume, model time step, and the homogeneous nucleation rate.Using an implementation of the model in the PySDM particle-based modelling package, we evaluate two nucleation-rate formulations: a temperature-dependent and a water-activity-based parameterisations, the latter applicable also to aqueous solution droplets.Using an air-parcel framework, we investigate freezing-temperature distributions and resulting ice number concentrations across ensembles of simulations with varying updraft speeds, CCN concentrations, droplet size distributions, and number of super-particles. The two nucleation-rate parameterisations diverge under super- or subsaturated conditions with respect to water, yielding differences in freezing temperatures and ice number concentrations.To asses the impact of Wegener-Bergeron-Findeisen process on ice concentrations, we consider simulations with and without vapour deposition on ice. With deposition enabled, early stochastic freezing events dominate the evolution of the frozen droplet fraction and substantially reduce the number of droplets that ultimately freeze.The developed model allows to validate the common assumption that homogeneous freezing is a threshold phenomenon occurring at ca. 235 K. We find that homogeneous freezing spans a broad temperature range controlled by cooling rate and droplet size, highlight the importance of stochastic freezing formulations and nucleation-rate choice for representing cloud glaciation.