GPGuido Ignacio Prieto

Guido Ignacio Prieto

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Guido Ignacio Prieto has a total of 6 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Modeling versatility as the hallmark of model organisms

    by Guido I. Prieto, Alejandro Fábregas-Tejeda

    In recent years, discussions on the epistemology of model organism-based research have emerged in the philosophy of science. A key topic of discussion is how the epistemic insights gained from model organisms differ from those gained through other experimental organisms used in laboratory and field research. Here, we argue that model organisms are epistemically special due to their nature as ontogenetically changeable, standardized, and evolved material model carriers . These characteristics afford six important kinds of modeling versatility that biologists marshal in their investigations: (i) synchronic target versatility; (ii) synchronic scope versatility; (iii) diachronic target versatility; (iv) diachronic scope versatility; (v) manipulation versatility; and (vi) discovery versatility. In presenting these dimensions of modeling versatility, we also clarify key notions such as ‘representational target,’ ‘representational scope,’ and ‘representational power’ as these apply to modeling practices that involve model organisms.


  • Open Access

    Representing with model organisms: a refined DEKI account

    by Guido I. Prieto, Alejandro Fábregas-Tejeda

    In this article, we mobilize and refine the DEKI account of scientific representation to contend that model organisms are not models tout court but model ‘carriers,’ only abstracted and selected ‘parts’ of which are included in biological models. These parts correspond to phenomena of interest that are interpreted as mechanisms or other kinds of causal processes within certain theoretical domains. The models can then be used to represent similar target phenomena in other organisms. Our proposal paves the way to reconcile opposing positions apropos the representational status of model organisms and build a more robust epistemology of model organism-based research.


  • Top Cited Papers

    The Riddle of Organismal Agency

    by Alejandro Fábregas-Tejeda, Jan Baedke, Guido I. Prieto, Gregory Radick

    The Riddle of Organismal Agency brings together historians, philosophers, and scientists for an interdisciplinary re-assessment of one of the long-standing problems in the scientific understanding of life. Marshalling insights from diverse sciences including physiology, comparative psychology, developmental biology, and evolutionary biology, the book provides an up-to-date survey of approaches to non-human organisms as agents, capable of performing activities serving their own goals such as surviving or reproducing, and whose doings in the world are thus to be explained teleologically. From an Integrated History and Philosophy of Science perspective, the book contributes to a better conceptual and theoretical understanding of organismal agency, advancing some suggestions on how to study it empirically and how to frame it in relation to wider scientific and philosophical traditions. It also provides new historical entry points for examining the deployment, trajectories, and challenges of agential views of organisms in the history of biology and philosophy. This book will be of interest to philosophers of biology; historians of science; biologists interested in analysing the active roles of organisms in development, ecological interactions, and evolution; philosophers and practitioners of the cognitive sciences; and philosophers and historians of philosophy working on purposiveness and teleology.


  • Organismal Agency

    by Alejandro Fábregas-Tejeda, Jan Baedke, Guido I. Prieto, Gregory Radick

    Organismal agency, together with cognate notions such as goal-directedness, purposiveness, and teleology, has undergone a revival in recent decades and is one of the most intensively debated topics in contemporary philosophy of the life and cognitive sciences. This chapter argues that it constitutes an enormously difficult riddle in biological and philosophical theorisation that shows a curious profile, at once encapsulating central biological phenomena and resisting conceptual clarification and theoretical articulation, whilst displaying a nomadic character, extending across manifold disciplines. A long-standing issue, the problem of organismal agency re-emerges in every generation of biologists and philosophers, taking different forms and being tackled from several standpoints. These peculiar features make organismal agency a challenging subject that demands a better conceptual and theoretical understanding, necessitating an interdisciplinary and Integrated History and Philosophy of Science approach. This orientation can help to clarify the epistemological and ontological underpinnings of this notion, historically contextualise it, explore the continuities and discontinuities of diverse perspectives that have construed it in dissimilar ways, and investigate the consequences of embracing it for the study of development, behaviour, and evolution. This chapter ends by introducing the guiding axes behind the edited collection and outlining the contributions from historians, philosophers, and scientists.


  • Open Access

    ‘Organism’ Versus ‘Biological Individual’: The Missing Demarcation

    by Guido Ignacio Prieto

    The demarcation of organisms from other biological individuals has received relatively little attention. In this paper, I extricate and systematize the different ways in which the organism–biological individual relationship has been construed: (1) coalescence of the two concepts, (2) biological individual eliminativism, (3) organism eliminativism, (4) organism as a ‘paradigmatic’ biological individual, (5) organism as a limit state towards which biological individuals tend in evolution and development, (6) organism as instantiating the whole in a part-whole hierarchy of biological individuals, (7) organism as equivalent to physiological individual, and (8) organism as a special kind of physiological individual. I show that, in most of these stances, the organism concept is too imprecise to be demarcated from other biological individuals, which fosters some form of eliminativism. I also argue that the comparisons between organisms and biological individuals are performed in two different modes: ‘horizontally’ (i.e., between individuals not related hierarchically) or ‘vertically’ (i.e., between individuals belonging to different levels within the same hierarchy). Finally, I explain the challenges that each of these comparison modes face and suggest that the ‘vertical’ mode adumbrates a potential way forward. El problema de la demarcación entre el organismo y otros tipos de individuos biológicos ha recibido relativamente poca atención. En este artículo desgloso y sistematizo las diferentes formas en las que se ha interpretado la relación ‘organismo’-‘individuo biológico’: (1) coalescencia de estos dos términos, (2) eliminativismo del individuo biológico, (3) eliminativismo del organismo, (4) organismo como individuo biológico ‘paradigmático’, (5) organismo como estado límite al que tienden los individuos biológicos durante la evolución y el desarrollo, (6) organismo como instanciación del todo en una jerarquía parte-todo de individuos biológicos, (7) organismo como equivalente a individuo fisiológico y (8) organismo como un tipo especial de individuo fisiológico. Muestro que, en la mayoría de estas posturas, el concepto de organismo es demasiado impreciso como para ser demarcado de otros individuos biológicos, lo cual promueve alguna forma de eliminativismo. También argumento que las comparaciones entre organismos e individuos biológicos son llevadas a cabo de dos modos: ‘horizontalmente’ (i.e., entre individuos no relacionados jerárquicamente) o ‘verticalmente’ (i.e., entre individuos pertenecientes a diferentes niveles de la misma jerarquía). Finalmente, explico los desafíos que enfrentan cada una de estas formas de comparar y sugiero que el modo de comparación ‘vertical’ deja entrever un posible camino a seguir.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Unknotting reciprocal causation between organism and environment

    by Jan Baedke, Alejandro Fábregas-Tejeda, Guido I. Prieto

    In recent years, biologists and philosophers of science have argued that evolutionary theory should incorporate more seriously the idea of ‘reciprocal causation.’ This notion refers to feedback loops whereby organisms change their experiences of the environment or alter the physical properties of their surroundings. In these loops, in particular niche constructing activities are central, since they may alter selection pressures acting on organisms, and thus affect their evolutionary trajectories. This paper discusses long-standing problems that emerge when studying such reciprocal causal processes between organisms and environments. By comparing past approaches to reciprocal causation from the early twentieth century with contemporary ones in niche construction theory, we identify two central reoccurring problems: All of these approaches have not been able to provide a conceptual framework that allows (i) maintaining meaningful boundaries between organisms and environments, instead of merging the two, and (ii) integrating experiential and physical kinds of reciprocal causation. By building on case studies of niche construction research, we provide a model that is able to solve these two problems. It allows distinguishing between mutually interacting organisms and environments in complex scenarios, as well as integrating various forms of experiential and physical niche construction.


  • Open Access

    Caution ahead: reassessing the functional morphology of the respiratory organs in amphibious snails

    by Guido I. Prieto

    After a long hiatus, interest in the morphology of the respiratory organs in apple snails (Ampullariidae, Caenogastropoda) and its functional and evolutionary bearings is making a comeback. The variability in the morphology of the gill and lung and its link to different lifestyles and patterns of air dependency within the Ampullariidae make research on the morphology of the respiratory organs particularly suitable for approaching the evolution of terrestriality in animals. Additionally, morphology is a valuable source of hypotheses regarding the several functions the ampullariid respiratory organs have besides respiration. However, this is an underexplored field that only recently has incorporated ultrastructural and three-dimension visualization tools and in which more research is much needed, particularly, comparisons between species representing the diversity within the Ampullariidae. In this paper, I examine Mueck, Deaton & Lee’s (2020a) assessment of the morphology of the gill and lung of Pomacea maculata and compare it with earlier and contemporary studies on other ampullariid species. I show that Mueck, Deaton & Lee’s paper combines significant morphological misinterpretations, conceptual and terminological mistakes, and crucial literature omissions. I also reinterpret their results and point to the similarities and differences between them and available data on other ampullariids.


  • Open Access

    Morphological grounds for the obligate aerial respiration of an aquatic snail: functional and evolutionary perspectives

    by Cristian Rodriguez, Guido I. Prieto, Israel A. Vega, Alfredo Castro-Vazquez

    The freshwater caenogastropod family Ampullariidae is emerging as a model for a variety of studies, among them, the evolution of terrestriality. A common character of the family is that all its members bear a lung while retaining the ancestral gill. This ensures that many ampullariids are able to inhabit poorly oxygenated waters, to bury in the mud during estivation, and to temporarily leave the water, in some species for oviposition. To these charactersPomacea canaliculata(Caenogastropoda, Ampullariidae) adds that is an obligate air-breather. In a recent paper, we showed the gill epithelium ofP. canaliculatahas a set of characteristics that suggest its role for oxygen uptake may be less significant than its role in ionic/osmotic regulation and immunity. We complement here our morphological investigation on the respiratory organs ofP. canaliculataby studying the lung of this species at the anatomical (3D reconstructions of the blood system and nerve supply), histological and ultrastructural levels. The circulation of the gill and the lung are interconnected so that the effluence of blood from the gill goes to the lung where it completes oxygenation. Besides that, we found the lung cavity is lined by a pavement epithelium that encloses an anastomosing network of small blood spaces resting over a fibromuscular layer, which altogether form the respiratory lamina. The pavement cells form a blood-gas barrier that is 80–150 nm thick and thus fulfils the requirements for an efficient gas exchanger. Tufts of ciliary cells, together with some microvillar and secretory cells, are interspersed in the respiratory lamina. Rhogocytes, which have been proposed to partake in metal depuration and in the synthesis of hemocyanin in other gastropods, were found below the respiratory lamina, in close association with the storage cell tissue. In light of these findings, we discuss the functional role of the lung inP. canaliculataand compare it with that of other gastropods. Finally, we point to some similarities in the pattern of the evolution of air dependence in this family.


  • Open Access

    Functional and evolutionary perspectives on gill structures of an obligate air-breathing, aquatic snail

    by Cristian Rodriguez, Guido I. Prieto, Israel A. Vega, Alfredo Castro-Vazquez

    Ampullariids are freshwater gastropods bearing a gill and a lung, thus showing different degrees of amphibiousness. In particular,Pomacea canaliculata(Caenogastropoda, Ampullariidae) is an obligate air-breather that relies mainly or solely on the lung for dwelling in poorly oxygenated water, for avoiding predators, while burying in the mud during aestivation, and for oviposition above water level. In this paper, we studied the morphological peculiarities of the gill in this species. We found (1) the gill and lung vasculature and innervation are intimately related, allowing alternation between water and air respiration; (2) the gill epithelium has features typical of a transporting rather than a respiratory epithelium; and (3) the gill has resident granulocytes within intraepithelial spaces that may serve a role for immune defence. Thus, the role in oxygen uptake may be less significant than the roles in ionic/osmotic regulation and immunity. Also, our results provide a morphological background to understand the dependence on aerial respiration ofPomacea canaliculata. Finally, we consider these findings from a functional perspective in the light of the evolution of amphibiousness in the Ampullariidae, and discuss that master regulators may explain the phenotypic convergence of gill structures amongst this molluscan species and those in other phyla.