N. N. Utkin
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
N. N. Utkin has a total of 15 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Evgeniy S. Netesin
Russian Medical Academy of Continuous Professional Education, Irkutsk, Russia
8 shared publications - Vladimir Ilych Gorbachev
Russian Medical Academy of Continuous Professional Education, Irkutsk, Russia
8 shared publications - Светлана Михайловна Горбачева
Irkutsk State Medical Academy of Postgraduate Education — branch of the Russian Medical Academy of Continuous Professional Education
4 shared publications - S. V. Gorbachev
Russian Medical Academy of Continuous Professional Education, Irkutsk, Russia
3 shared publications - Konstantin Gennadyevich Shapovalov
Chita State Medical Academy, Chita, Russia
2 shared publications - Pavel V. Dunts
Regional Clinical Hospital No 2, Vladivostok, Russia
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 25 February 2025
- Published by Chita State Medical Academy in Transbaikalian Medical Bulletin
- No. 4,p. 36-44
ON THE MOST SIGNIFICANT DEFECTS IN INTENSIVE CARE FOR PATIENTS WITH THE NEW CORONAVIRUS INFECTION COVID-19 BASED ON AN EXPERT ASSESSMENT
Background. There are now a sufficient number of published papers devoted to the study of various factors influencing theoutcomeofthe disease. The significance of these predictors in thenewcoronavirus infection varies depending on various anthropological factors: including regional, age, gender and medical characteristics.The objective. To assess the significance of defects in the provision of intensive care to patients with a new coronavirus infection, presented on the basis of expert opinions, and to determine their impact on the outcome of the disease.Materials and methods. An analysis of 93 inpatient records with the primary diagnosis of "Community- acquired bilateral polysegmental viral pneumonia, ARDS" was conducted. A simple blind sampling method was used of the medical records of patients who were treated in the intensive care unit from 01.04.2021 to 31.10.2021. A power analysis showed that a minimum sample size of 15 patients per group is sufficient to detect significant differences between the groups of survivors and deceased (power 95% and α = 0.05). The presented study was carried out as a cohort retrospective single-center study stratified into groups by the following criterion: survivors and deceased. Statistical data processing was performed using STATISTICA 10.0 and MedCalc programs. The following statistical analysis methods were used: odds ratio method, Kaplan-Meier survival analysis, log-rank test, ROC analysis.Results. The study did not reveal any effect on the timing of death of the area of lung tissue damage upon admission. The most significant defects of intensive care affecting the chance of death in patients with a new coronavirus infection were identified. Untimely testing of a number of laboratory parameters leads to late administration of the necessary corrective therapy. The chance of an unfavorable outcome increases with a late test for ferritin, d-dimer, and procalcitonin levels. The ROC analysis showed that increased mortality is affected by: irrational and untimely antibacterial therapy – AUC equal to 0,7 with a sensitivity of 45,83% and a specificity of 94,2%, as well as untimely targeted therapy, AUC was 0.967, with a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 92,75%.Conclusion. The development of an unfavorable outcome during intensive care is influenced by factors such as the untimely prescription of targeted and antibacterial therapy to patients with COVID-19 and untimely diagnostic measures, which occurred due to the incomplete material and technical equipment of medical organizations.
- 25 February 2025
- Published by Chita State Medical Academy in Transbaikalian Medical Bulletin
- No. 4,p. 36-44
Open AccessON THE MOST SIGNIFICANT DEFECTS IN INTENSIVE CARE FOR PATIENTS WITH THE NEW CORONAVIRUS INFECTION COVID-19 BASED ON AN EXPERT ASSESSMENT
Background. There are now a sufficient number of published papers devoted to the study of various factors influencing theoutcomeofthe disease. The significance of these predictors in thenewcoronavirus infection varies depending on various anthropological factors: including regional, age, gender and medical characteristics.The objective. To assess the significance of defects in the provision of intensive care to patients with a new coronavirus infection, presented on the basis of expert opinions, and to determine their impact on the outcome of the disease.Materials and methods. An analysis of 93 inpatient records with the primary diagnosis of "Community- acquired bilateral polysegmental viral pneumonia, ARDS" was conducted. A simple blind sampling method was used of the medical records of patients who were treated in the intensive care unit from 01.04.2021 to 31.10.2021. A power analysis showed that a minimum sample size of 15 patients per group is sufficient to detect significant differences between the groups of survivors and deceased (power 95% and α = 0.05). The presented study was carried out as a cohort retrospective single-center study stratified into groups by the following criterion: survivors and deceased. Statistical data processing was performed using STATISTICA 10.0 and MedCalc programs. The following statistical analysis methods were used: odds ratio method, Kaplan-Meier survival analysis, log-rank test, ROC analysis.Results. The study did not reveal any effect on the timing of death of the area of lung tissue damage upon admission. The most significant defects of intensive care affecting the chance of death in patients with a new coronavirus infection were identified. Untimely testing of a number of laboratory parameters leads to late administration of the necessary corrective therapy. The chance of an unfavorable outcome increases with a late test for ferritin, d-dimer, and procalcitonin levels. The ROC analysis showed that increased mortality is affected by: irrational and untimely antibacterial therapy – AUC equal to 0,7 with a sensitivity of 45,83% and a specificity of 94,2%, as well as untimely targeted therapy, AUC was 0.967, with a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 92,75%.Conclusion. The development of an unfavorable outcome during intensive care is influenced by factors such as the untimely prescription of targeted and antibacterial therapy to patients with COVID-19 and untimely diagnostic measures, which occurred due to the incomplete material and technical equipment of medical organizations.
- Open Access
- 27 April 2024
- Published by Practical Medicine Publishing House in Annals of Critical Care
- No. 2,p. 54-61
Criminal cases against anesthesiologists and intensivists in Russia for 2019–2022: a retrospective observational study
INTRODUCTION: The number of criminal cases brought against doctors — anesthesiologists and resuscitators in the Russian Federation is not decreasing. However, a detailed analysis has not been carried out in recent years, and this was primarily due to the pandemic of the new coronavirus infection COVID-19 and the restrictions that were associated with it. OBJECTIVE: To analyze criminal cases against anesthesiologists and resuscitators initiated under various articles of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation over the past four years, from 2019 to 2022. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The search for criminal cases was carried out in the following electronic databases: “Court decisions of the Russian Federation” and the State Automated System of the Russian Federation “Justice”. Based on the search results, 66 criminal cases against anesthesiologists and resuscitators were considered. RESULTS: The main articles of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation were identified, under which anesthesiologists and resuscitators are most often held accountable. The gender and territorial distribution of criminal cases by region of the Russian Federation is presented. The most significant and frequently committed defects in the provision of medical care have been identified. Examples of the most complex criminal cases are given. CONCLUSIONS: It seems that the number of criminal cases against anesthesiologists and resuscitators has decreased slightly after 2019, however, we believe that this is due to the pandemic of the new coronavirus infection, and for this reason many court cases are still under investigation and have not been completed on time.
- 27 April 2024
- Published by Practical Medicine Publishing House in Annals of Critical Care
- No. 2,p. 54-61
Open AccessCriminal cases against anesthesiologists and intensivists in Russia for 2019–2022: a retrospective observational study
INTRODUCTION: The number of criminal cases brought against doctors — anesthesiologists and resuscitators in the Russian Federation is not decreasing. However, a detailed analysis has not been carried out in recent years, and this was primarily due to the pandemic of the new coronavirus infection COVID-19 and the restrictions that were associated with it. OBJECTIVE: To analyze criminal cases against anesthesiologists and resuscitators initiated under various articles of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation over the past four years, from 2019 to 2022. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The search for criminal cases was carried out in the following electronic databases: “Court decisions of the Russian Federation” and the State Automated System of the Russian Federation “Justice”. Based on the search results, 66 criminal cases against anesthesiologists and resuscitators were considered. RESULTS: The main articles of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation were identified, under which anesthesiologists and resuscitators are most often held accountable. The gender and territorial distribution of criminal cases by region of the Russian Federation is presented. The most significant and frequently committed defects in the provision of medical care have been identified. Examples of the most complex criminal cases are given. CONCLUSIONS: It seems that the number of criminal cases against anesthesiologists and resuscitators has decreased slightly after 2019, however, we believe that this is due to the pandemic of the new coronavirus infection, and for this reason many court cases are still under investigation and have not been completed on time.
- Open Access
- 26 July 2023
- Published by FSBEI HE I.P. Pavlov SPbSMU MOH Russia in Messenger of ANESTHESIOLOGY AND RESUSCITATION
- Vol. 20 (4) , 61-67
Defects of intensive care of patients with COVID-19. Expert doctors and opinion
Background. A significant proportion of patients infected with the SARS-CoV-2 virus had a severe course of the disease required hospitalization and intensive care The objective was to analyze the defects allowed during intensive care of patients with SARS-CoV-2, and to assess the causes of their occurrence.Materials and methods. An analytical study was made on the basis of expert opinions on 60 case histories of deceased patients in the intensive care unit with the main diagnosis: “COVID-19. Community-acquired bilateral polysegmental viral pneumonia ARDS”. To identify the reasons that led to defects in the diagnosis and treatment of patients with NCI COVID-19 in intensive care units, an anonymous survey of 92 anesthesiologists-resuscitators who worked in the “red zone” during the COVID-19 pandemic was conducted.Results. The defects identified by experts can be divided into two main groups: diagnostic defects and treatment defects. ARDS in 25%, PE in 8% of cases were not diagnosed. There was no ECG control and cardiac monitoring in 22%, lung CT in 6.7%, echocardiography in 10% of cases. Consultations of specialized specialists were not held in 11.7% of patients. There were defects in the correction of EBV and ABS in 30%, unreasonable prescribing of drugs in 58%, defects in vasopressor support in 10%, defects associated with mechanical ventilation in 40% of cases. The survey of physicians showed that the defects were based on insufficient knowledge of the governing documents and the limited capabilities of medical organizations to implement the necessary research.Conclusion. The obtained results made it possible to demonstrate the limitations and subjectivity of the existing assessment of the quality of medical care, which sometimes does not take into account the existing conditions for treating patients and the material and technical capabilities of a medical organization.
- 26 July 2023
- Published by FSBEI HE I.P. Pavlov SPbSMU MOH Russia in Messenger of ANESTHESIOLOGY AND RESUSCITATION
- Vol. 20 (4) , 61-67
Open AccessDefects of intensive care of patients with COVID-19. Expert doctors and opinion
Background. A significant proportion of patients infected with the SARS-CoV-2 virus had a severe course of the disease required hospitalization and intensive care The objective was to analyze the defects allowed during intensive care of patients with SARS-CoV-2, and to assess the causes of their occurrence.Materials and methods. An analytical study was made on the basis of expert opinions on 60 case histories of deceased patients in the intensive care unit with the main diagnosis: “COVID-19. Community-acquired bilateral polysegmental viral pneumonia ARDS”. To identify the reasons that led to defects in the diagnosis and treatment of patients with NCI COVID-19 in intensive care units, an anonymous survey of 92 anesthesiologists-resuscitators who worked in the “red zone” during the COVID-19 pandemic was conducted.Results. The defects identified by experts can be divided into two main groups: diagnostic defects and treatment defects. ARDS in 25%, PE in 8% of cases were not diagnosed. There was no ECG control and cardiac monitoring in 22%, lung CT in 6.7%, echocardiography in 10% of cases. Consultations of specialized specialists were not held in 11.7% of patients. There were defects in the correction of EBV and ABS in 30%, unreasonable prescribing of drugs in 58%, defects in vasopressor support in 10%, defects associated with mechanical ventilation in 40% of cases. The survey of physicians showed that the defects were based on insufficient knowledge of the governing documents and the limited capabilities of medical organizations to implement the necessary research.Conclusion. The obtained results made it possible to demonstrate the limitations and subjectivity of the existing assessment of the quality of medical care, which sometimes does not take into account the existing conditions for treating patients and the material and technical capabilities of a medical organization.
- 23 April 2023
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Anesthesiology and Reanimatology
- No. 3
Legal knowledge of anesthesiologists and intensive care specialists. A multiple-center initiative survey
Objective. To assess legal knowledge in anesthesiologists and intensive care specialists. Material and methods. An interactive survey of 262 physicians was performed in 5 regions of the Russian Federation. There were 30 questions related to knowledge of legal documents in anesthesiology and intensive care. Results. There was no significant differences in knowledge depending on the region of the country. Doctors with 5-10-year experience have somewhat worse knowledge compared to other groups. No significant gender differences were found. Conclusion. We found uneven professional competencies in anesthesiologists and intensive care specialists regarding regulatory and legal aspects of medical activity. Significant difficulties are caused by issues related to examination of temporary disability, medical and social examination, issuance of sheets of temporary disability and establishment of diagnosis.
- 23 April 2023
- Published by Media Sphere Publishing Group in Russian Journal of Anesthesiology and Reanimatology
- No. 3
Legal knowledge of anesthesiologists and intensive care specialists. A multiple-center initiative survey
Objective. To assess legal knowledge in anesthesiologists and intensive care specialists. Material and methods. An interactive survey of 262 physicians was performed in 5 regions of the Russian Federation. There were 30 questions related to knowledge of legal documents in anesthesiology and intensive care. Results. There was no significant differences in knowledge depending on the region of the country. Doctors with 5-10-year experience have somewhat worse knowledge compared to other groups. No significant gender differences were found. Conclusion. We found uneven professional competencies in anesthesiologists and intensive care specialists regarding regulatory and legal aspects of medical activity. Significant difficulties are caused by issues related to examination of temporary disability, medical and social examination, issuance of sheets of temporary disability and establishment of diagnosis.
- Open Access
- 28 October 2022
- Published by Practical Medicine Publishing House in Annals of Critical Care
- No. 4
Legal regulations of errors and complications in anesthesiology and intensive care in Russian Federation: a review
The literature review reflects the existing approaches to the structural organization of medical care in Russia and its provision with regulatory legal acts. A critical analysis of the list of medical services in the profile of anesthesiology and intensive care is being carried out, which requires significant adjustments and optimization. A variant of the formation and structuring of medical services as a purposeful concretized process of medical care is proposed. Various options for the development of the classification of complications of anesthesia and intensive care are presented. The paper substantiates the urgent need to form a database of various complications and adverse reactions of anesthesia and intensive care, which currently does not exist, as there are no official documents regulating and obliging to conduct this monitoring, and some documents on this issue are related exclusively to the undesirable effects of drugs.
- 28 October 2022
- Published by Practical Medicine Publishing House in Annals of Critical Care
- No. 4
Open AccessLegal regulations of errors and complications in anesthesiology and intensive care in Russian Federation: a review
The literature review reflects the existing approaches to the structural organization of medical care in Russia and its provision with regulatory legal acts. A critical analysis of the list of medical services in the profile of anesthesiology and intensive care is being carried out, which requires significant adjustments and optimization. A variant of the formation and structuring of medical services as a purposeful concretized process of medical care is proposed. Various options for the development of the classification of complications of anesthesia and intensive care are presented. The paper substantiates the urgent need to form a database of various complications and adverse reactions of anesthesia and intensive care, which currently does not exist, as there are no official documents regulating and obliging to conduct this monitoring, and some documents on this issue are related exclusively to the undesirable effects of drugs.
- Open Access
- 22 February 2022
- Published by Practical Medicine Publishing House in Annals of Critical Care
- No. 1
Legal aspects of assessing the quality of medical care
Introduction. The analysis of adverse outcomes of medical care allows to identify the causes and eliminate the possibility of their further recurrence, and contributes to the accumulation of practical experience. Objectives. To determine the degree of correlation of examinations of the quality of medical care conducted by medical organizations, insurance companies and investigating authorities, and to assess the validity of using the expression “defect in the provision of medical care”. Materials and methods. The main research method was the analysis of the conclusions of the Commission for the Study of Lethal Outcomes (CSLO), acts of inspections of the quality examination conducted by insurance companies and the conclusions of forensic medical examinations for the frequency of use of the expression “defect in the provision of medical care”, “medical error”, “shortcomings in the provision of medical help”. The data was obtained from the results of a study of 24 CSLO protocols, 15 acts of quality examination inspections conducted by insurance companies and 12 forensic medical examination reports. In all cases, the studied documents were associated with adverse outcomes of medical care, with the participation of anesthesiologists-resuscitators. Results. When analyzing these documents, it was found that the expression “defect in the provision of medical care” is more often found in the conclusions of forensic medical examinations — 91.7 %. When examining the quality of medical care, this term is found in only 13.3 % and in the protocols of CSLO in 54.2 %, and “deficiencies in the provision of medical care” — in 41.6 %. Conclusions. The analysis revealed that in the documents reflecting the quality of care, there is a terminology that is different in meaning and content, which does not allow to objectively reflect the degree of the admitted deficiency and its impact on the outcome of the disease.
- 22 February 2022
- Published by Practical Medicine Publishing House in Annals of Critical Care
- No. 1
Open AccessLegal aspects of assessing the quality of medical care
Introduction. The analysis of adverse outcomes of medical care allows to identify the causes and eliminate the possibility of their further recurrence, and contributes to the accumulation of practical experience. Objectives. To determine the degree of correlation of examinations of the quality of medical care conducted by medical organizations, insurance companies and investigating authorities, and to assess the validity of using the expression “defect in the provision of medical care”. Materials and methods. The main research method was the analysis of the conclusions of the Commission for the Study of Lethal Outcomes (CSLO), acts of inspections of the quality examination conducted by insurance companies and the conclusions of forensic medical examinations for the frequency of use of the expression “defect in the provision of medical care”, “medical error”, “shortcomings in the provision of medical help”. The data was obtained from the results of a study of 24 CSLO protocols, 15 acts of quality examination inspections conducted by insurance companies and 12 forensic medical examination reports. In all cases, the studied documents were associated with adverse outcomes of medical care, with the participation of anesthesiologists-resuscitators. Results. When analyzing these documents, it was found that the expression “defect in the provision of medical care” is more often found in the conclusions of forensic medical examinations — 91.7 %. When examining the quality of medical care, this term is found in only 13.3 % and in the protocols of CSLO in 54.2 %, and “deficiencies in the provision of medical care” — in 41.6 %. Conclusions. The analysis revealed that in the documents reflecting the quality of care, there is a terminology that is different in meaning and content, which does not allow to objectively reflect the degree of the admitted deficiency and its impact on the outcome of the disease.
- Open Access
- 26 October 2021
- Published by Practical Medicine Publishing House in Annals of Critical Care
- No. 3
Criminal cases against doctors — anesthesiologists-reseanimators under articles: 109, 118, 238, 290, 293 of the criminal code of the Russian Federation: observational study
Introduction. In the past few years, there has been a steady increase in citizens’ appeals to law enforcement agencies regarding inadequate and unsatisfactory medical care, which has led to an increase in the number of criminal cases brought against anesthesiologists-resuscitators. Objectives. Conduct an analysis of criminal cases against anesthesiologists-resuscitators initiated under Articles 109, 118, 238, 290 and 293 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation over the past 5 years. Materials and methods. In observational study performed analysis of court decisions on various articles of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation against anesthesiologists-resuscitators for the period from January 2016 to December 2020, available in open databases. Results. The most significant and frequently committed defects in the provision of medical care related to the manipulations carried out, the main types of punishments under the presented articles are determined. The most illustrative examples from court decisions on criminal cases against anesthesiologists-resuscitators are given. Conclusions. Certain proposals were made on the procedure for conducting a forensic medical examination and conducting court records in relation to medical workers.
- 26 October 2021
- Published by Practical Medicine Publishing House in Annals of Critical Care
- No. 3
Open AccessCriminal cases against doctors — anesthesiologists-reseanimators under articles: 109, 118, 238, 290, 293 of the criminal code of the Russian Federation: observational study
Introduction. In the past few years, there has been a steady increase in citizens’ appeals to law enforcement agencies regarding inadequate and unsatisfactory medical care, which has led to an increase in the number of criminal cases brought against anesthesiologists-resuscitators. Objectives. Conduct an analysis of criminal cases against anesthesiologists-resuscitators initiated under Articles 109, 118, 238, 290 and 293 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation over the past 5 years. Materials and methods. In observational study performed analysis of court decisions on various articles of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation against anesthesiologists-resuscitators for the period from January 2016 to December 2020, available in open databases. Results. The most significant and frequently committed defects in the provision of medical care related to the manipulations carried out, the main types of punishments under the presented articles are determined. The most illustrative examples from court decisions on criminal cases against anesthesiologists-resuscitators are given. Conclusions. Certain proposals were made on the procedure for conducting a forensic medical examination and conducting court records in relation to medical workers.
- 18 April 2021
- Published by Medical Informational Agency Publishers in Clinical Medicine (Russian Journal)
- Vol. 98 (11-12) , 788-793
Analysis of surgical disciplines involved doctors’ personal responsibility for improper delivery of health care
Currently, there is a serious increase in citizens’ complaints to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation. Accordingly, there has been an increase in criminal cases initiated against health professionals. The group of specialists of maximum risk includes, first of all, doctors of surgical specialties: surgeons; anesthesiologists-resuscitators; obstetricians-gynecologists. Purpose of the study. To analyze the criminal cases against surgeons initiated under the second part of Article 109 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. Material and methods. The search for criminal cases was carried out in the following electronic databases: Court decisions of the Russian Federation (https://court decisions.rf) and the state automated system of the Russian Federation "Justice" (https://bsr.sudrf.ru/bigs/portal.html); the search covers the last 5 years period. Results. 235 court decisions in cases open under Part 2. Art. 109 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation have been found. The evaluation of territorial and gender characteristics has been carried out. Defects in the delivery of health care identified by the courts and incriminated to doctors are presented. The attitude of surgical specialties doctors to the charges brought, and the applied terms of the main types of punishment are presented: supervised release and denial of the right to practice. Attention is drawn to the aggravating and mitigating circumstances used by the courts.
- 18 April 2021
- Published by Medical Informational Agency Publishers in Clinical Medicine (Russian Journal)
- Vol. 98 (11-12) , 788-793
Analysis of surgical disciplines involved doctors’ personal responsibility for improper delivery of health care
Currently, there is a serious increase in citizens’ complaints to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation. Accordingly, there has been an increase in criminal cases initiated against health professionals. The group of specialists of maximum risk includes, first of all, doctors of surgical specialties: surgeons; anesthesiologists-resuscitators; obstetricians-gynecologists. Purpose of the study. To analyze the criminal cases against surgeons initiated under the second part of Article 109 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. Material and methods. The search for criminal cases was carried out in the following electronic databases: Court decisions of the Russian Federation (https://court decisions.rf) and the state automated system of the Russian Federation "Justice" (https://bsr.sudrf.ru/bigs/portal.html); the search covers the last 5 years period. Results. 235 court decisions in cases open under Part 2. Art. 109 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation have been found. The evaluation of territorial and gender characteristics has been carried out. Defects in the delivery of health care identified by the courts and incriminated to doctors are presented. The attitude of surgical specialties doctors to the charges brought, and the applied terms of the main types of punishment are presented: supervised release and denial of the right to practice. Attention is drawn to the aggravating and mitigating circumstances used by the courts.