Swamini Khurana
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Swamini Khurana has a total of 21 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Falk Heße
Institute of Earth and Environmental Sciences‐Geoecology University of Potsdam Potsdam Germany
11 shared publications- Martin Thullner
UFZ – Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research, Department of Environmental Microbiology, Leipzig, Germany
11 shared publications - Anke Hildebrandt
Department of Computational Hydrosystems, Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research (UFZ), Leipzig, Germany
10 shared publications - Stefano Manzoni
Department of Physical Geography and Bolin Centre for Climate Research, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden
3 shared publications - Bertrand Guenet
Laboratoire de Géologie ENS, PSL Research University, CNRS, UMR 8538, IPSL, Paris, France
2 shared publications - Boris Ťupek
Natural Resources Institute Finland (LUKE), Helsinki, 00790, Finland
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Vadose Zone Journal
- Vol. 24 (2)
Machine‐learning based spatiotemporal prediction of soil moisture in a grassland hillslope
Soil moisture (SM) plays a significant role in the earth's water balance and in optimizing land management practices. However, SM at the field scale is difficult to map from available point measurements due to the inherent heterogeneity of soil and terrain properties and temporal dynamics of weather conditions. In this study, we explored the potential of four machine learning (ML) methods (random forest, gradient boosted regression trees, support vector regression, and neural networks) to predict SM in a grassland hillslope in space and time using auxiliary variables on soil and terrain properties and weather conditions. For training and testing the ML models, we used SM point measurements obtained by a sensor network. Performance metrics varied between the ML methods and the training‐test data split ( R 2 = 0.48–0.69, root‐mean‐square error [RMSE] = 0.06–0.10). Random forests and gradient‐boosted regression trees turned out to be promising and easy to parametrize as first choices to explore the potential of ML techniques. The day of the year emerged as an important feature to predict SM across models and can thus serve as a proxy for seasonal hydroclimatic variability. To enable the transfer of the application to other contexts or sites, we provide the modeling workflow as an open‐source computational Python module.
- 22 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Vadose Zone Journal
- Vol. 24 (2)
Open AccessMachine‐learning based spatiotemporal prediction of soil moisture in a grassland hillslope
Soil moisture (SM) plays a significant role in the earth's water balance and in optimizing land management practices. However, SM at the field scale is difficult to map from available point measurements due to the inherent heterogeneity of soil and terrain properties and temporal dynamics of weather conditions. In this study, we explored the potential of four machine learning (ML) methods (random forest, gradient boosted regression trees, support vector regression, and neural networks) to predict SM in a grassland hillslope in space and time using auxiliary variables on soil and terrain properties and weather conditions. For training and testing the ML models, we used SM point measurements obtained by a sensor network. Performance metrics varied between the ML methods and the training‐test data split ( R 2 = 0.48–0.69, root‐mean‐square error [RMSE] = 0.06–0.10). Random forests and gradient‐boosted regression trees turned out to be promising and easy to parametrize as first choices to explore the potential of ML techniques. The day of the year emerged as an important feature to predict SM across models and can thus serve as a proxy for seasonal hydroclimatic variability. To enable the transfer of the application to other contexts or sites, we provide the modeling workflow as an open‐source computational Python module.
- Open Access
- 28 February 2024
- Published by Wiley in Vadose Zone Journal
- Vol. 23 (2)
Microbial mediated carbon and nitrogen cycling in the spatially heterogeneous vadose zone: A modeling study
Spatially distributed properties of the subsurface result in varying water saturation and preferential flow paths, which lead to heterogeneous solute transport patterns and heterogeneous microbial environments. This, in turn, influences the distribution of nutrients and energy gradients, microbial biomass, and activity thereof. By their very nature, current field sampling techniques do not resolve subsampling scale heterogeneities in microbial biomass and activity, resulting in inaccurate estimates of microbially mediated carbon and nitrogen turnover in the heterogeneous subsurface. Thus, in this study, we undertook a numerical modeling approach to study the impact of spatial heterogeneity on microbially mediated carbon and nitrogen turnover in the vadose zone. We adapted an established biogeochemical process network that captures a variety of respiration pathways, carbon decomposition strategies, and microbial life processes to simulate microbially mediated carbon and nitrogen turnover in variably saturated spatially heterogeneous settings, using an established numerical tool (OGS#BRNS). The fractionation of microbial communities into active and inactive states, as well as immobile and mobile states followed could be linked to the bulk average saturation. Lastly, we identified three reactive systems, distinguished by the rate ratio of aerobic respiration and transfer of oxygen from the air to the water phase, to evaluate the impact of spatial heterogeneity on carbon and nitrogen removal in subsurface heterogeneous domains. Specifically, when this ratio is approximately 1, there is no impact on carbon removal, while when this ratio is very high, then carbon removal decreases as the domain tends to be oxygen limited.
- 28 February 2024
- Published by Wiley in Vadose Zone Journal
- Vol. 23 (2)
Open AccessMicrobial mediated carbon and nitrogen cycling in the spatially heterogeneous vadose zone: A modeling study
Spatially distributed properties of the subsurface result in varying water saturation and preferential flow paths, which lead to heterogeneous solute transport patterns and heterogeneous microbial environments. This, in turn, influences the distribution of nutrients and energy gradients, microbial biomass, and activity thereof. By their very nature, current field sampling techniques do not resolve subsampling scale heterogeneities in microbial biomass and activity, resulting in inaccurate estimates of microbially mediated carbon and nitrogen turnover in the heterogeneous subsurface. Thus, in this study, we undertook a numerical modeling approach to study the impact of spatial heterogeneity on microbially mediated carbon and nitrogen turnover in the vadose zone. We adapted an established biogeochemical process network that captures a variety of respiration pathways, carbon decomposition strategies, and microbial life processes to simulate microbially mediated carbon and nitrogen turnover in variably saturated spatially heterogeneous settings, using an established numerical tool (OGS#BRNS). The fractionation of microbial communities into active and inactive states, as well as immobile and mobile states followed could be linked to the bulk average saturation. Lastly, we identified three reactive systems, distinguished by the rate ratio of aerobic respiration and transfer of oxygen from the air to the water phase, to evaluate the impact of spatial heterogeneity on carbon and nitrogen removal in subsurface heterogeneous domains. Specifically, when this ratio is approximately 1, there is no impact on carbon removal, while when this ratio is very high, then carbon removal decreases as the domain tends to be oxygen limited.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Modelling soil organic carbon stocks and greenhouse gases in European forests with multi-model ensembles
State-of-the-art soil models can be used to monitor and predict the evolution of soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks and greenhouse gas (GHG) fluxes at national, sub-national, and supernational levels. This can help predict the effect of disturbances on the soil and facilitate the development of sustainable management practices to prevent further soil degradation and GHG losses under climate change.However, model simulations are still highly uncertain due to many factors. For instance, the lack of understanding of many soil processes, the way processes are represented in the models, and the parametrization, initialization, and forcing variables used to run them. One way to consider these uncertainties is to use multi-model ensembles, thus simulating the evolution of SOC stocks and GHG fluxes according to models with different structures and mechanistic assumptions.In this work, we show a webtool that enables the simulation of SOC stocks and GHG gases in European forests under different climate and land-use change scenarios, using a multi-model ensemble. In the absence of on-site measurements, the webtool directly accesses online databases of pedo-climatic data that is required to run the models.Models also need to be correctly parameterized and evaluated before their application. For that, we build a map of model parameters that can be used to force the models, and which is evaluated on the European LUCAS database. Uncertainties linked to the initialization method used are also discussed.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessModelling soil organic carbon stocks and greenhouse gases in European forests with multi-model ensembles
State-of-the-art soil models can be used to monitor and predict the evolution of soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks and greenhouse gas (GHG) fluxes at national, sub-national, and supernational levels. This can help predict the effect of disturbances on the soil and facilitate the development of sustainable management practices to prevent further soil degradation and GHG losses under climate change.However, model simulations are still highly uncertain due to many factors. For instance, the lack of understanding of many soil processes, the way processes are represented in the models, and the parametrization, initialization, and forcing variables used to run them. One way to consider these uncertainties is to use multi-model ensembles, thus simulating the evolution of SOC stocks and GHG fluxes according to models with different structures and mechanistic assumptions.In this work, we show a webtool that enables the simulation of SOC stocks and GHG gases in European forests under different climate and land-use change scenarios, using a multi-model ensemble. In the absence of on-site measurements, the webtool directly accesses online databases of pedo-climatic data that is required to run the models.Models also need to be correctly parameterized and evaluated before their application. For that, we build a map of model parameters that can be used to force the models, and which is evaluated on the European LUCAS database. Uncertainties linked to the initialization method used are also discussed.
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Disentangling the effects of microbial functional diversity and carbon availability on soil organic carbon decomposition
The factors governing stability of soil organic carbon vary from chemical characteristics to physical occlusion from either biotic (such as plant roots, soil fauna and microorganisms) or abiotic agents (such as water). By mediating the decomposition potential, microbial community diversity and structure may play an important role in the fate of soil organic carbon. In this theoretical study, we aim to understand the role of the microbial community diversity and composition in soil organic carbon storage and decomposition. We constructed a model describing a microbial process network incorporating diverse organic matter compounds and microbial groups. The microbial groups varied from each other with respect to their affinity to depolymerise, take-up, metabolise and assimilate organic compounds. We allowed for adaptation of microbial communities to available carbon, and competition among microbial groups. We tested this process network with functionally diverse microbial communities which were subjected to varying carbon availability. This framework allowed us to explore organic carbon decomposition rates and their temporal evolution under different conditions of microbial diversity and carbon availability, as well as the tendency of a soil microbial system to store carbon. We found that the microbial community functional diversity is a good predictor of organic carbon decomposition rates. This result suggests that an organic carbon decomposition rate modifier could be defined based on functional diversity and then included in soil carbon models. Furthermore, we observed that organic carbon decomposition by functionally similar communities in carbon poor conditions slowed down after approximately half of the initial carbon was consumed. In the same conditions, functionally diverse communities with a higher number of biotic agents allowed a more complete decomposition. However, with increasing initial carbon availability, the functional diversity of the microbial community ceased to play a role in soil carbon storage. These results link microbial community diversity and carbon availability to decomposition potential and thus organic carbon stability in soils.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessDisentangling the effects of microbial functional diversity and carbon availability on soil organic carbon decomposition
The factors governing stability of soil organic carbon vary from chemical characteristics to physical occlusion from either biotic (such as plant roots, soil fauna and microorganisms) or abiotic agents (such as water). By mediating the decomposition potential, microbial community diversity and structure may play an important role in the fate of soil organic carbon. In this theoretical study, we aim to understand the role of the microbial community diversity and composition in soil organic carbon storage and decomposition. We constructed a model describing a microbial process network incorporating diverse organic matter compounds and microbial groups. The microbial groups varied from each other with respect to their affinity to depolymerise, take-up, metabolise and assimilate organic compounds. We allowed for adaptation of microbial communities to available carbon, and competition among microbial groups. We tested this process network with functionally diverse microbial communities which were subjected to varying carbon availability. This framework allowed us to explore organic carbon decomposition rates and their temporal evolution under different conditions of microbial diversity and carbon availability, as well as the tendency of a soil microbial system to store carbon. We found that the microbial community functional diversity is a good predictor of organic carbon decomposition rates. This result suggests that an organic carbon decomposition rate modifier could be defined based on functional diversity and then included in soil carbon models. Furthermore, we observed that organic carbon decomposition by functionally similar communities in carbon poor conditions slowed down after approximately half of the initial carbon was consumed. In the same conditions, functionally diverse communities with a higher number of biotic agents allowed a more complete decomposition. However, with increasing initial carbon availability, the functional diversity of the microbial community ceased to play a role in soil carbon storage. These results link microbial community diversity and carbon availability to decomposition potential and thus organic carbon stability in soils.
- Open Access
- 27 September 2022
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Environmental Science & Technology
- Vol. 56 (20) , 14427-14438
Spatial Control of Microbial Pesticide Degradation in Soil: A Model-Based Scenario Analysis
Microbial pesticide degraders are heterogeneously distributed in soil. Their spatial aggregation at the millimeter scale reduces the frequency of degrader-pesticide encounter and can introduce transport limitations to pesticide degradation. We simulated reactive pesticide transport in soil to investigate the fate of the widely used herbicide 4-chloro-2-methylphenoxyacetic acid (MCPA) in response to differently aggregated distributions of degrading microbes. Four scenarios were defined covering millimeter scale heterogeneity from homogeneous (pseudo-1D) to extremely heterogeneous degrader distributions and two precipitation scenarios with either continuous light rain or heavy rain events. Leaching from subsoils did not occur in any scenario. Within the topsoil, increasing spatial heterogeneity of microbial degraders reduced macroscopic degradation rates, increased MCPA leaching, and prolonged the persistence of residual MCPA. In heterogeneous scenarios, pesticide degradation was limited by the spatial separation of degrader and pesticide, which was quantified by the spatial covariance between MCPA and degraders. Heavy rain events temporarily lifted these transport constraints in heterogeneous scenarios and increased degradation rates. Our results indicate that the mild millimeter scale spatial heterogeneity of degraders typical for arable topsoil will have negligible consequences for the fate of MCPA, but strong clustering of degraders can delay pesticide degradation.
- 27 September 2022
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Environmental Science & Technology
- Vol. 56 (20) , 14427-14438
Open AccessSpatial Control of Microbial Pesticide Degradation in Soil: A Model-Based Scenario Analysis
Microbial pesticide degraders are heterogeneously distributed in soil. Their spatial aggregation at the millimeter scale reduces the frequency of degrader-pesticide encounter and can introduce transport limitations to pesticide degradation. We simulated reactive pesticide transport in soil to investigate the fate of the widely used herbicide 4-chloro-2-methylphenoxyacetic acid (MCPA) in response to differently aggregated distributions of degrading microbes. Four scenarios were defined covering millimeter scale heterogeneity from homogeneous (pseudo-1D) to extremely heterogeneous degrader distributions and two precipitation scenarios with either continuous light rain or heavy rain events. Leaching from subsoils did not occur in any scenario. Within the topsoil, increasing spatial heterogeneity of microbial degraders reduced macroscopic degradation rates, increased MCPA leaching, and prolonged the persistence of residual MCPA. In heterogeneous scenarios, pesticide degradation was limited by the spatial separation of degrader and pesticide, which was quantified by the spatial covariance between MCPA and degraders. Heavy rain events temporarily lifted these transport constraints in heterogeneous scenarios and increased degradation rates. Our results indicate that the mild millimeter scale spatial heterogeneity of degraders typical for arable topsoil will have negligible consequences for the fate of MCPA, but strong clustering of degraders can delay pesticide degradation.
- Open Access
- 28 March 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Linking soil microbial biodiversity to soil carbon dynamics
Carbon emissions from soil are large contributors to the global carbon cycle, but depend on processes occurring at a small scale. Carbon cycling in the soils is mediated by plant roots, soil fauna, and microorganisms including fungi and bacteria. Sophisticated molecular analytical techniques have been developed to characterize soil microbial communities, resulting in discovery of new microbial species that are not yet culturable in the laboratory. The unculturable fraction of soil microbial communities make for a large data gap since we are not able to characterize their activity, and even less so their role in the microbial community. As a result, soil carbon models cannot be readily parameterized from the bottom up—essentially, we cannot quantify functions at low taxonomic level and then scale up to the community level. In this numerical study, we aim to explore how soil carbon model predictions are affected by microbial diversity as characterized in silico by distribution of traits.The resilience of soil microbial communities is related to distance to the surface and diversity. Diverse microbial communities that are closer to the surface, experiencing regular temporal fluctuations in environmental conditions are more resilient to disturbances than microbial communities deeper down in the subsurface. However, forest management practices and extreme climate conditions impose conditions that may be hitherto unforeseen. This makes prediction of response of soil microbial communities to new disturbances and soil carbon respiration thereof to be uncertain. In this contribution, we developed a microbial process network incorporating diverse organic matter compounds, and bacterial and fungal species characterized by distributions of trait values (including co-variations and trade-offs). With this framework, we explore if soil microbial diversity is a good predictor for soil carbon stocks and study diversity effect on community-level responses to disturbance and variations in environmental conditions. These results will assist in the development of a rate expression to capture the contribution of soil microbial community composition to carbon dynamics in soil.
- 28 March 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessLinking soil microbial biodiversity to soil carbon dynamics
Carbon emissions from soil are large contributors to the global carbon cycle, but depend on processes occurring at a small scale. Carbon cycling in the soils is mediated by plant roots, soil fauna, and microorganisms including fungi and bacteria. Sophisticated molecular analytical techniques have been developed to characterize soil microbial communities, resulting in discovery of new microbial species that are not yet culturable in the laboratory. The unculturable fraction of soil microbial communities make for a large data gap since we are not able to characterize their activity, and even less so their role in the microbial community. As a result, soil carbon models cannot be readily parameterized from the bottom up—essentially, we cannot quantify functions at low taxonomic level and then scale up to the community level. In this numerical study, we aim to explore how soil carbon model predictions are affected by microbial diversity as characterized in silico by distribution of traits.The resilience of soil microbial communities is related to distance to the surface and diversity. Diverse microbial communities that are closer to the surface, experiencing regular temporal fluctuations in environmental conditions are more resilient to disturbances than microbial communities deeper down in the subsurface. However, forest management practices and extreme climate conditions impose conditions that may be hitherto unforeseen. This makes prediction of response of soil microbial communities to new disturbances and soil carbon respiration thereof to be uncertain. In this contribution, we developed a microbial process network incorporating diverse organic matter compounds, and bacterial and fungal species characterized by distributions of trait values (including co-variations and trade-offs). With this framework, we explore if soil microbial diversity is a good predictor for soil carbon stocks and study diversity effect on community-level responses to disturbance and variations in environmental conditions. These results will assist in the development of a rate expression to capture the contribution of soil microbial community composition to carbon dynamics in soil.
- Open Access
- 24 March 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Water
- Vol. 4
Should We Worry About Surficial Dynamics When Assessing Nutrient Cycling in the Groundwater?
The fluxes of water and solutes in the subsurface compartment of the Critical Zone are temporally dynamic and it is unclear how this impacts microbial mediated nutrient cycling in the spatially heterogeneous subsurface. To investigate this, we undertook numerical modeling, simulating the transport in a wide range of spatially heterogeneous domains, and the biogeochemical transformation of organic carbon and nitrogen compounds using a complex microbial community with four (4) distinct functional groups, in water saturated subsurface compartments. We performed a comprehensive uncertainty analysis accounting for varying residence times and spatial heterogeneity. While the aggregated removal of chemical species in the domains over the entire simulation period was approximately the same as that in steady state conditions, the sub-scale temporal variation of microbial biomass and chemical discharge from a domain depended strongly on the interplay of spatial heterogeneity and temporal dynamics of the forcing. We showed that the travel time and the Damköhler number (Da) can be used to predict the temporally varying chemical discharge from a spatially heterogeneous domain. In homogeneous domains, chemical discharge in temporally dynamic conditions could be double of that in the steady state conditions while microbial biomass varied up to 75% of that in steady state conditions. In heterogeneous domains, the interquartile range of uncertainty in chemical discharge in reaction dominated systems (log10Da > 0) was double of that in steady state conditions. However, high heterogeneous domains resulted in outliers where chemical discharge could be as high as 10–20 times of that in steady state conditions in high flow periods. And in transport dominated systems (log10Da < 0), the chemical discharge could be half of that in steady state conditions in unusually low flow conditions. In conclusion, ignoring spatio-temporal heterogeneities in a numerical modeling approach may exacerbate inaccurate estimation of nutrient export and microbial biomass. The results are relevant to long-term field monitoring studies, and for homogeneous soil column-scale experiments investigating the role of temporal dynamics on microbial redox dynamics.
- 24 March 2022
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Water
- Vol. 4
Open AccessShould We Worry About Surficial Dynamics When Assessing Nutrient Cycling in the Groundwater?
The fluxes of water and solutes in the subsurface compartment of the Critical Zone are temporally dynamic and it is unclear how this impacts microbial mediated nutrient cycling in the spatially heterogeneous subsurface. To investigate this, we undertook numerical modeling, simulating the transport in a wide range of spatially heterogeneous domains, and the biogeochemical transformation of organic carbon and nitrogen compounds using a complex microbial community with four (4) distinct functional groups, in water saturated subsurface compartments. We performed a comprehensive uncertainty analysis accounting for varying residence times and spatial heterogeneity. While the aggregated removal of chemical species in the domains over the entire simulation period was approximately the same as that in steady state conditions, the sub-scale temporal variation of microbial biomass and chemical discharge from a domain depended strongly on the interplay of spatial heterogeneity and temporal dynamics of the forcing. We showed that the travel time and the Damköhler number (Da) can be used to predict the temporally varying chemical discharge from a spatially heterogeneous domain. In homogeneous domains, chemical discharge in temporally dynamic conditions could be double of that in the steady state conditions while microbial biomass varied up to 75% of that in steady state conditions. In heterogeneous domains, the interquartile range of uncertainty in chemical discharge in reaction dominated systems (log10Da > 0) was double of that in steady state conditions. However, high heterogeneous domains resulted in outliers where chemical discharge could be as high as 10–20 times of that in steady state conditions in high flow periods. And in transport dominated systems (log10Da < 0), the chemical discharge could be half of that in steady state conditions in unusually low flow conditions. In conclusion, ignoring spatio-temporal heterogeneities in a numerical modeling approach may exacerbate inaccurate estimation of nutrient export and microbial biomass. The results are relevant to long-term field monitoring studies, and for homogeneous soil column-scale experiments investigating the role of temporal dynamics on microbial redox dynamics.
- Open Access
- 3 February 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Biogeosciences
- Vol. 19 (3) , 665-688
Predicting the impact of spatial heterogeneity on microbially mediated nutrient cycling in the subsurface
The subsurface is a temporally dynamic and spatially heterogeneous compartment of the Earth's critical zone, and biogeochemical transformations taking place in this compartment are crucial for the cycling of nutrients. The impact of spatial heterogeneity on such microbially mediated nutrient cycling is not well known, which imposes a severe challenge in the prediction of in situ biogeochemical transformation rates and further of nutrient loading contributed by the groundwater to the surface water bodies. Therefore, we used a numerical modelling approach to evaluate the sensitivity of groundwater microbial biomass distribution and nutrient cycling to spatial heterogeneity in different scenarios accounting for various residence times. The model results gave us an insight into domain characteristics with respect to the presence of oxic niches in predominantly anoxic zones and vice versa depending on the extent of spatial heterogeneity and the flow regime. The obtained results show that microbial abundance, distribution, and activity are sensitive to the applied flow regime and that the mobile (i.e. observable by groundwater sampling) fraction of microbial biomass is a varying, yet only a small, fraction of the total biomass in a domain. Furthermore, spatial heterogeneity resulted in anaerobic niches in the domain and shifts in microbial biomass between active and inactive states. The lack of consideration of spatial heterogeneity, thus, can result in inaccurate estimation of microbial activity. In most cases this leads to an overestimation of nutrient removal (up to twice the actual amount) along a flow path. We conclude that the governing factors for evaluating this are the residence time of solutes and the Damköhler number (Da) of the biogeochemical reactions in the domain. We propose a relationship to scale the impact of spatial heterogeneity on nutrient removal governed by the log10Da. This relationship may be applied in upscaled descriptions of microbially mediated nutrient cycling dynamics in the subsurface thereby resulting in more accurate predictions of, for example, carbon and nitrogen cycling in groundwater over long periods at the catchment scale.
- 3 February 2022
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Biogeosciences
- Vol. 19 (3) , 665-688
Open AccessPredicting the impact of spatial heterogeneity on microbially mediated nutrient cycling in the subsurface
The subsurface is a temporally dynamic and spatially heterogeneous compartment of the Earth's critical zone, and biogeochemical transformations taking place in this compartment are crucial for the cycling of nutrients. The impact of spatial heterogeneity on such microbially mediated nutrient cycling is not well known, which imposes a severe challenge in the prediction of in situ biogeochemical transformation rates and further of nutrient loading contributed by the groundwater to the surface water bodies. Therefore, we used a numerical modelling approach to evaluate the sensitivity of groundwater microbial biomass distribution and nutrient cycling to spatial heterogeneity in different scenarios accounting for various residence times. The model results gave us an insight into domain characteristics with respect to the presence of oxic niches in predominantly anoxic zones and vice versa depending on the extent of spatial heterogeneity and the flow regime. The obtained results show that microbial abundance, distribution, and activity are sensitive to the applied flow regime and that the mobile (i.e. observable by groundwater sampling) fraction of microbial biomass is a varying, yet only a small, fraction of the total biomass in a domain. Furthermore, spatial heterogeneity resulted in anaerobic niches in the domain and shifts in microbial biomass between active and inactive states. The lack of consideration of spatial heterogeneity, thus, can result in inaccurate estimation of microbial activity. In most cases this leads to an overestimation of nutrient removal (up to twice the actual amount) along a flow path. We conclude that the governing factors for evaluating this are the residence time of solutes and the Damköhler number (Da) of the biogeochemical reactions in the domain. We propose a relationship to scale the impact of spatial heterogeneity on nutrient removal governed by the log10Da. This relationship may be applied in upscaled descriptions of microbially mediated nutrient cycling dynamics in the subsurface thereby resulting in more accurate predictions of, for example, carbon and nitrogen cycling in groundwater over long periods at the catchment scale.
- Open Access
- 23 September 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-39
Reply on RC3
The subsurface is a temporally dynamic and spatially heterogeneous compartment of the Earth's Critical Zone, and biogeochemical transformations taking place in this compartment are crucial for the cycling of nutrients. The impact of spatial heterogeneity on such microbially mediated nutrient cycling is not well known which imposes a severe challenge in the prediction of in situ biogeochemical transformation rates and further of nutrient loading contributed by the groundwater to the surface water bodies. Therefore, we undertake a numerical modelling approach to evaluate the sensitivity of groundwater microbial biomass distribution and nutrient cycling to spatial heterogeneity in different scenarios accounting for various residence times. The model results gave us an insight into domain characteristics with respect to presence of oxic niches in predominantly anaerobic zones and vice versa depending on the extent of spatial heterogeneity and the flow regime. The obtained results show that microbial abundance, distribution, and activity are sensitive to the applied flow regime and that the mobile (i.e., observable by groundwater sampling) fraction of microbial biomass is a varying, yet only a small, fraction of the total biomass in a domain. Furthermore, spatial heterogeneity resulted in anaerobic niches in the domain and shifts of microbial biomass between active and inactive states. The lack of consideration of spatial heterogeneity, thus, can result in inaccurate estimation of microbial activity. In most cases this leads to an overestimation of nutrient removal (up to twice the actual amount) along a flow path. We conclude that the governing factors for evaluating this are the residence time of solutes and the Damköhler number (Da) of the biogeochemical reactions in the domain. We propose a relationship to scale the impact of spatial heterogeneity on nutrient removal governed by the log10Da. This relationship may be applied in upscaled descriptions of microbially mediated nutrient cycling dynamics in the subsurface thereby resulting in more accurate predictions of e.g., carbon and nitrogen cycling in groundwater over long periods at the catchment scale.
- 23 September 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-39
Open AccessReply on RC3
The subsurface is a temporally dynamic and spatially heterogeneous compartment of the Earth's Critical Zone, and biogeochemical transformations taking place in this compartment are crucial for the cycling of nutrients. The impact of spatial heterogeneity on such microbially mediated nutrient cycling is not well known which imposes a severe challenge in the prediction of in situ biogeochemical transformation rates and further of nutrient loading contributed by the groundwater to the surface water bodies. Therefore, we undertake a numerical modelling approach to evaluate the sensitivity of groundwater microbial biomass distribution and nutrient cycling to spatial heterogeneity in different scenarios accounting for various residence times. The model results gave us an insight into domain characteristics with respect to presence of oxic niches in predominantly anaerobic zones and vice versa depending on the extent of spatial heterogeneity and the flow regime. The obtained results show that microbial abundance, distribution, and activity are sensitive to the applied flow regime and that the mobile (i.e., observable by groundwater sampling) fraction of microbial biomass is a varying, yet only a small, fraction of the total biomass in a domain. Furthermore, spatial heterogeneity resulted in anaerobic niches in the domain and shifts of microbial biomass between active and inactive states. The lack of consideration of spatial heterogeneity, thus, can result in inaccurate estimation of microbial activity. In most cases this leads to an overestimation of nutrient removal (up to twice the actual amount) along a flow path. We conclude that the governing factors for evaluating this are the residence time of solutes and the Damköhler number (Da) of the biogeochemical reactions in the domain. We propose a relationship to scale the impact of spatial heterogeneity on nutrient removal governed by the log10Da. This relationship may be applied in upscaled descriptions of microbially mediated nutrient cycling dynamics in the subsurface thereby resulting in more accurate predictions of e.g., carbon and nitrogen cycling in groundwater over long periods at the catchment scale.
- Open Access
- 15 September 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-39
Reply on RC2
The subsurface is a temporally dynamic and spatially heterogeneous compartment of the Earth's Critical Zone, and biogeochemical transformations taking place in this compartment are crucial for the cycling of nutrients. The impact of spatial heterogeneity on such microbially mediated nutrient cycling is not well known which imposes a severe challenge in the prediction of in situ biogeochemical transformation rates and further of nutrient loading contributed by the groundwater to the surface water bodies. Therefore, we undertake a numerical modelling approach to evaluate the sensitivity of groundwater microbial biomass distribution and nutrient cycling to spatial heterogeneity in different scenarios accounting for various residence times. The model results gave us an insight into domain characteristics with respect to presence of oxic niches in predominantly anaerobic zones and vice versa depending on the extent of spatial heterogeneity and the flow regime. The obtained results show that microbial abundance, distribution, and activity are sensitive to the applied flow regime and that the mobile (i.e., observable by groundwater sampling) fraction of microbial biomass is a varying, yet only a small, fraction of the total biomass in a domain. Furthermore, spatial heterogeneity resulted in anaerobic niches in the domain and shifts of microbial biomass between active and inactive states. The lack of consideration of spatial heterogeneity, thus, can result in inaccurate estimation of microbial activity. In most cases this leads to an overestimation of nutrient removal (up to twice the actual amount) along a flow path. We conclude that the governing factors for evaluating this are the residence time of solutes and the Damköhler number (Da) of the biogeochemical reactions in the domain. We propose a relationship to scale the impact of spatial heterogeneity on nutrient removal governed by the log10Da. This relationship may be applied in upscaled descriptions of microbially mediated nutrient cycling dynamics in the subsurface thereby resulting in more accurate predictions of e.g., carbon and nitrogen cycling in groundwater over long periods at the catchment scale.
- 15 September 2021
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-39
Open AccessReply on RC2
The subsurface is a temporally dynamic and spatially heterogeneous compartment of the Earth's Critical Zone, and biogeochemical transformations taking place in this compartment are crucial for the cycling of nutrients. The impact of spatial heterogeneity on such microbially mediated nutrient cycling is not well known which imposes a severe challenge in the prediction of in situ biogeochemical transformation rates and further of nutrient loading contributed by the groundwater to the surface water bodies. Therefore, we undertake a numerical modelling approach to evaluate the sensitivity of groundwater microbial biomass distribution and nutrient cycling to spatial heterogeneity in different scenarios accounting for various residence times. The model results gave us an insight into domain characteristics with respect to presence of oxic niches in predominantly anaerobic zones and vice versa depending on the extent of spatial heterogeneity and the flow regime. The obtained results show that microbial abundance, distribution, and activity are sensitive to the applied flow regime and that the mobile (i.e., observable by groundwater sampling) fraction of microbial biomass is a varying, yet only a small, fraction of the total biomass in a domain. Furthermore, spatial heterogeneity resulted in anaerobic niches in the domain and shifts of microbial biomass between active and inactive states. The lack of consideration of spatial heterogeneity, thus, can result in inaccurate estimation of microbial activity. In most cases this leads to an overestimation of nutrient removal (up to twice the actual amount) along a flow path. We conclude that the governing factors for evaluating this are the residence time of solutes and the Damköhler number (Da) of the biogeochemical reactions in the domain. We propose a relationship to scale the impact of spatial heterogeneity on nutrient removal governed by the log10Da. This relationship may be applied in upscaled descriptions of microbially mediated nutrient cycling dynamics in the subsurface thereby resulting in more accurate predictions of e.g., carbon and nitrogen cycling in groundwater over long periods at the catchment scale.