Vincent Lee
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Vincent Lee has a total of 14 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Bala Muralikrishnan
Sensor Science Division, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD 20899, USA
3 shared publications - Meghan Shilling
Sensor Science Division, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD 20899, USA
3 shared publications - Bala Muralikrishnan
National Institute of Standards and Technology, Physical Measurement Laboratory, Sensor Science Division, Gaithersburg, MD 20899, USA
2 shared publications - Daniel Sawyer
National Institute of Standards and Technology, Physical Measurement Laboratory, Sensor Science Division, Gaithersburg, MD 20899, USA
2 shared publications - Braden Czapla
National Institute of Standards and Technology
1 shared publication - Craig M. Shakarji
Mem. ASME Physical Measurement Laboratory, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD 20899
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
A Method to Calibrate Angular Positioning Errors Using a Laser Tracker and a Plane Mirror
We describe a method to calibrate angular positioning errors of a rotation stage using a laser tracker (LT), a plane mirror mounted on the stage, and stationary registration nests placed around the stage. Our technique involves determining the direction of the normal vector to the plane of the mirror at each angular step by performing two LT measurements—one directly to a stationary spherically mounted retroreflector (SMR), and another to the same SMR by bouncing the laser off a mirror mounted on the rotation stage. Because the angular range that can be measured from a single LT station is limited by the angle of incidence on the mirror, multiple LT stations are necessary to cover the full 360°, hence the need for stationary registration nests to tie the LT data into a common coordinate frame. We compare this technique against a direct approach involving a rigid bar with two SMRs mounted on the rotation stage so that we can measure the direction of the line joining the SMRs at each angular position using the LT and, therefore, the angle between positions. Through experiments, we demonstrate that our mirror-based approach provides errors on the order of ±0.5″, smaller than the ±1.5″ for the direct approach, when compared against a reference instrument with accuracy better than 0.3″. Through simulations, we estimate the uncertainty in our mirror-based angle measurements to be 0.4″ (k = 2). Placing the LT close to and the SMR away from the rotation stage results in lower uncertainty for our mirror-based angle measurements.
Open AccessA Method to Calibrate Angular Positioning Errors Using a Laser Tracker and a Plane Mirror
We describe a method to calibrate angular positioning errors of a rotation stage using a laser tracker (LT), a plane mirror mounted on the stage, and stationary registration nests placed around the stage. Our technique involves determining the direction of the normal vector to the plane of the mirror at each angular step by performing two LT measurements—one directly to a stationary spherically mounted retroreflector (SMR), and another to the same SMR by bouncing the laser off a mirror mounted on the rotation stage. Because the angular range that can be measured from a single LT station is limited by the angle of incidence on the mirror, multiple LT stations are necessary to cover the full 360°, hence the need for stationary registration nests to tie the LT data into a common coordinate frame. We compare this technique against a direct approach involving a rigid bar with two SMRs mounted on the rotation stage so that we can measure the direction of the line joining the SMRs at each angular position using the LT and, therefore, the angle between positions. Through experiments, we demonstrate that our mirror-based approach provides errors on the order of ±0.5″, smaller than the ±1.5″ for the direct approach, when compared against a reference instrument with accuracy better than 0.3″. Through simulations, we estimate the uncertainty in our mirror-based angle measurements to be 0.4″ (k = 2). Placing the LT close to and the SMR away from the rotation stage results in lower uncertainty for our mirror-based angle measurements.
- Open Access
Laser Tracker and Terrestrial Laser Scanner Range Error Evaluation by Stitching
Laser trackers (LTs) are dimensional measurement instruments commonly employed in the manufacture and assembly of large structures. Terrestrial laser scanners (TLSs) are a related class of dimensional measurement instruments more commonly employed in surveying, reverse engineering, and forensics. Commercially available LTs typically have measurement ranges of up to 80 m. The measurement ranges of TLSs vary from about 50 m to several hundred meters, with some extending as far as several kilometers. It is difficult, if not impossible, to construct long reference lengths to evaluate the ranging performances of these instruments over that distance. In this context, we explore the use of stitching errors (i.e., stacking errors in adjoining or overlapping short lengths) and stitching lengths (i.e., constructing long reference lengths from multiple positions of a reference instrument by registration) to evaluate these instruments. Through experimental data and a discussion on uncertainty, we show that stitching is indeed a viable option to evaluate the ranging performances of LTs and TLSs.
Open AccessLaser Tracker and Terrestrial Laser Scanner Range Error Evaluation by Stitching
Laser trackers (LTs) are dimensional measurement instruments commonly employed in the manufacture and assembly of large structures. Terrestrial laser scanners (TLSs) are a related class of dimensional measurement instruments more commonly employed in surveying, reverse engineering, and forensics. Commercially available LTs typically have measurement ranges of up to 80 m. The measurement ranges of TLSs vary from about 50 m to several hundred meters, with some extending as far as several kilometers. It is difficult, if not impossible, to construct long reference lengths to evaluate the ranging performances of these instruments over that distance. In this context, we explore the use of stitching errors (i.e., stacking errors in adjoining or overlapping short lengths) and stitching lengths (i.e., constructing long reference lengths from multiple positions of a reference instrument by registration) to evaluate these instruments. Through experimental data and a discussion on uncertainty, we show that stitching is indeed a viable option to evaluate the ranging performances of LTs and TLSs.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2022
- Published by National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) in Journal of Research of the National Institute of Standards and Technology
- Vol. 126
ASME B89.4.23 Performance Evaluation Tests and Geometry Errors in X-Ray Computed Tomography Systems
A documentary standard produced by the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) for performance evaluation of industrial X-ray computed tomography (XCT) systems for dimensional measurements was released in early 2021. This standard, ASME B89.4.23-2020, specifies test procedures that may be performed to determine whether a system meets the manufacturer’s accuracy specifications for acceptance before or after purchase, or for periodic reverification. While there are some core testing requirements in the standard, there is also some flexibility, allowing for a variety of testing configurations that meet the requirements of the standard. It is important that the chosen testing configuration be sensitive to the different systematic sources of error in XCT systems to provide confidence that the system will meet the manufacturer’s accuracy specifications for measurements performed by the user subsequent to testing. In this paper, we provide guidance on how to optimally apply the ASME 89.4.23 standard in industry to achieve high sensitivity to geometry errors in cone-beam XCT systems. Through simulation studies, we present some examples of testing configurations that meet the requirements of the ASME B89.4.23 standard and discuss their sensitivity to geometry errors of the detector and the rotation stage. We show that there are some testing configurations that achieve maximal sensitivity to these errors, while other configurations do not capture these error sources with adequate sensitivity.
- 20 January 2022
- Published by National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) in Journal of Research of the National Institute of Standards and Technology
- Vol. 126
Open AccessASME B89.4.23 Performance Evaluation Tests and Geometry Errors in X-Ray Computed Tomography Systems
A documentary standard produced by the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) for performance evaluation of industrial X-ray computed tomography (XCT) systems for dimensional measurements was released in early 2021. This standard, ASME B89.4.23-2020, specifies test procedures that may be performed to determine whether a system meets the manufacturer’s accuracy specifications for acceptance before or after purchase, or for periodic reverification. While there are some core testing requirements in the standard, there is also some flexibility, allowing for a variety of testing configurations that meet the requirements of the standard. It is important that the chosen testing configuration be sensitive to the different systematic sources of error in XCT systems to provide confidence that the system will meet the manufacturer’s accuracy specifications for measurements performed by the user subsequent to testing. In this paper, we provide guidance on how to optimally apply the ASME 89.4.23 standard in industry to achieve high sensitivity to geometry errors in cone-beam XCT systems. Through simulation studies, we present some examples of testing configurations that meet the requirements of the ASME B89.4.23 standard and discuss their sensitivity to geometry errors of the detector and the rotation stage. We show that there are some testing configurations that achieve maximal sensitivity to these errors, while other configurations do not capture these error sources with adequate sensitivity.
- Open Access
- 16 July 2021
- Published by ASME International
Standards for Evaluating the Influence of Materials on the Performance of X-Ray Computed Tomography in Measuring Geometric Variability
The use of X-ray Computed Tomography (known briefly as XCT or sometimes CT) is on the rise due to several reasons. Firstly, a single XCT scan can measure an arbitrary number of features. For a conventional contact Coordinate Measuring Machine (CMM) the amount of measuring time increases predictably with the number of features that need to be measured. But greater complexity
- 16 July 2021
- Published by ASME International
Open AccessStandards for Evaluating the Influence of Materials on the Performance of X-Ray Computed Tomography in Measuring Geometric Variability
The use of X-ray Computed Tomography (known briefly as XCT or sometimes CT) is on the rise due to several reasons. Firstly, a single XCT scan can measure an arbitrary number of features. For a conventional contact Coordinate Measuring Machine (CMM) the amount of measuring time increases predictably with the number of features that need to be measured. But greater complexity
- Open Access
- 28 May 2020
- Published by National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) in Journal of Research of the National Institute of Standards and Technology
- Vol. 125
Improvised Long Test Lengths via Stitching Scale Bar Method:
Periodic performance evaluation is a critical issue for ensuring the reliability of data from terrestrial laser scanners (TLSs). With the recent introduction of the ASTM E3125-17 standard, there now exist standardized test procedures for this purpose. Point-to-point length measurement is one test method described in that documentary standard. This test is typically performed using a long scale bar (typically 2 m or longer) with spherical targets mounted on both ends. Long scale bars can become unwieldy and vary in length due to gravity loading, fixture forces, and environmental changes. In this paper, we propose a stitching scale bar (SSB) method in which a short scale bar (approximately 1 m or smaller) can provide a spatial length reference several times its length. The clear advantages of a short scale bar are that it can be calibrated in a laboratory and has potential long-term stability. An essential requirement when stitching a short scale bar is that the systematic errors in TLSs do not change significantly over short distances. We describe this requirement in this paper from both theoretical and experimental perspectives. Based on this SSB method, we evaluate the performance of a TLS according to the ASTM E3125-17 standard by stitching a 1.15 m scale bar to form a 2.3 m reference length. For comparison, a single 2.3 m scale bar is also employed for direct measurements without stitching. Experimental results show a maximum deviation of 0.072 mm in length errors between the two approaches, which is an order of magnitude smaller than typical accuracy specifications for TLSs.
- 28 May 2020
- Published by National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) in Journal of Research of the National Institute of Standards and Technology
- Vol. 125
Open AccessImprovised Long Test Lengths via Stitching Scale Bar Method:
Periodic performance evaluation is a critical issue for ensuring the reliability of data from terrestrial laser scanners (TLSs). With the recent introduction of the ASTM E3125-17 standard, there now exist standardized test procedures for this purpose. Point-to-point length measurement is one test method described in that documentary standard. This test is typically performed using a long scale bar (typically 2 m or longer) with spherical targets mounted on both ends. Long scale bars can become unwieldy and vary in length due to gravity loading, fixture forces, and environmental changes. In this paper, we propose a stitching scale bar (SSB) method in which a short scale bar (approximately 1 m or smaller) can provide a spatial length reference several times its length. The clear advantages of a short scale bar are that it can be calibrated in a laboratory and has potential long-term stability. An essential requirement when stitching a short scale bar is that the systematic errors in TLSs do not change significantly over short distances. We describe this requirement in this paper from both theoretical and experimental perspectives. Based on this SSB method, we evaluate the performance of a TLS according to the ASTM E3125-17 standard by stitching a 1.15 m scale bar to form a 2.3 m reference length. For comparison, a single 2.3 m scale bar is also employed for direct measurements without stitching. Experimental results show a maximum deviation of 0.072 mm in length errors between the two approaches, which is an order of magnitude smaller than typical accuracy specifications for TLSs.