Kateryna V. Bortniak
Kateryna V. Bortniak has a total of 33 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
N. Dobrianska
4 shared publicationsN. V. Dobrianska
2 shared publicationsV. Yu. Horielova
2 shared publications- Valerii Bortniak
Rector, V. I. Vernadsky Taurida National University, 01042, Kyiv, Ukraine
2 shared publications - Alina Yevhenivna Liasota
Department of Politology, Faculty of Social Sciences and International Relations, Oles Honchar Dnipro National University, 49010, Dnipro, Ukraine
1 shared publication - Anna M. Fedorova
National University of Life and Environmental Sciences of Ukraine
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 September 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 4,p. 417-421
The right to self-determination of indigenous peoples and national minorities: correlation between international legal standards and the national legislation of Ukraine
The article examines the relationship between international legal standards and the national legislation of Ukraine concerning the right to self-determination of indigenous peoples and the related rights of national minorities. The study proceeds from the assumption that contemporary international law does not establish one single normative regime of equal intensity for indigenous peoples and national minorities. Common Article 1 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights recognizes the right of all peoples to self-determination; however, the further institutional and case-law development of this right reveals a functional differentiation. In relation to indigenous peoples, the legal framework has evolved towards internal self-determination, autonomy or self-government, representative institutions, consultation, free, prior and informed consent, and protection of the links with lands, resources, language and culture. In relation to national minorities, the dominant legal model remains centred on identity, language, culture, education, religion, association, effective participation in decision-making and protection against discrimination. On the basis of an analysis of United Nations instruments, Council of Europe standards, ILO Convention No. 169, as well as the case-law of the International Court of Justice, the European Court of Human Rights and regional human rights bodies in the Americas and Africa, the article argues that external self-determination is not a general legal entitlement of minorities within existing European states, whereas the internal dimension of self-determination receives increasingly explicit recognition for indigenous peoples. The article further demonstrates that the Constitution of Ukraine and special legislation adopted in 2021-2025 reflect this asymmetry only partially. The Law of Ukraine «On the Indigenous Peoples of Ukraine» expressly recognizes the right of indigenous peoples to self-determination within Ukraine, whereas the Law of Ukraine «On National Minorities (Communities) of Ukraine» is structured mainly as a framework of identity and participation rights rather than a law of self-determination. The study concludes that the Ukrainian model has achieved important normative progress, especially under the influence of EU accession conditionality and the opinions of the Venice Commission, but still requires further harmonization through better consultation procedures, a more coherent language and education regime, stronger institutional guarantees of representation, and constitutional refinement of the model of indigenous internal self-determination in the context of the future de-occupation and reintegration of Crimea.
- 1 September 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 4,p. 417-421
Open AccessThe right to self-determination of indigenous peoples and national minorities: correlation between international legal standards and the national legislation of Ukraine
The article examines the relationship between international legal standards and the national legislation of Ukraine concerning the right to self-determination of indigenous peoples and the related rights of national minorities. The study proceeds from the assumption that contemporary international law does not establish one single normative regime of equal intensity for indigenous peoples and national minorities. Common Article 1 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights recognizes the right of all peoples to self-determination; however, the further institutional and case-law development of this right reveals a functional differentiation. In relation to indigenous peoples, the legal framework has evolved towards internal self-determination, autonomy or self-government, representative institutions, consultation, free, prior and informed consent, and protection of the links with lands, resources, language and culture. In relation to national minorities, the dominant legal model remains centred on identity, language, culture, education, religion, association, effective participation in decision-making and protection against discrimination. On the basis of an analysis of United Nations instruments, Council of Europe standards, ILO Convention No. 169, as well as the case-law of the International Court of Justice, the European Court of Human Rights and regional human rights bodies in the Americas and Africa, the article argues that external self-determination is not a general legal entitlement of minorities within existing European states, whereas the internal dimension of self-determination receives increasingly explicit recognition for indigenous peoples. The article further demonstrates that the Constitution of Ukraine and special legislation adopted in 2021-2025 reflect this asymmetry only partially. The Law of Ukraine «On the Indigenous Peoples of Ukraine» expressly recognizes the right of indigenous peoples to self-determination within Ukraine, whereas the Law of Ukraine «On National Minorities (Communities) of Ukraine» is structured mainly as a framework of identity and participation rights rather than a law of self-determination. The study concludes that the Ukrainian model has achieved important normative progress, especially under the influence of EU accession conditionality and the opinions of the Venice Commission, but still requires further harmonization through better consultation procedures, a more coherent language and education regime, stronger institutional guarantees of representation, and constitutional refinement of the model of indigenous internal self-determination in the context of the future de-occupation and reintegration of Crimea.
- 12 August 2026
- Published by Publishing House Helvetica (Publications) in "Scientific Notes of Taurida V.I. Vernadsky University", series "Public Administration"
- No. 3,p. 60-65
TRANSFORMATION OF FINANCIAL AND MOTIVATION TOOLS OF PERSONNEL POLICY IN THE CIVIL SERVICE SYSTEM OF UKRAINE UNDER THE CONDITIONS OF COMBINATION OF MILITARY AND ECONOMIC CRISIS
- 12 August 2026
- Published by Publishing House Helvetica (Publications) in "Scientific Notes of Taurida V.I. Vernadsky University", series "Public Administration"
- No. 3,p. 60-65
TRANSFORMATION OF FINANCIAL AND MOTIVATION TOOLS OF PERSONNEL POLICY IN THE CIVIL SERVICE SYSTEM OF UKRAINE UNDER THE CONDITIONS OF COMBINATION OF MILITARY AND ECONOMIC CRISIS
- Open Access
- 30 June 2026
- Published by FinTechAlliance in Financial and credit activity: problems of theory and practice
- Vol. 3 (68) , 24-47
FINANCIAL MONITORING IN THE BANKING SYSTEM AS A TOOL FOR ENSURING THE ECONOMIC SECURITY OF THE STATE: SYSTEMATIC REVIEW
The rapid digital transformation of the global banking sector, combined with the growing complexity of geopolitical instability, cyber threats, and cross-border financial flows, has significantly increased the strategic importance of financial monitoring systems for ensuring state economic security. Contemporary financial monitoring extends beyond its traditional compliance-oriented role and increasingly functions as an integrated mechanism of systemic risk management, financial resilience, and institutional stability. Despite extensive research on anti-money laundering (AML), counter-terrorist financing (CFT), financial technologies, and cybersecurity, existing studies remain fragmented and insufficiently integrated within a unified economic security framework. This study aims to systematize contemporary scholarly approaches to financial monitoring in the banking system and to identify the systemic relationships between financial monitoring mechanisms, technological transformation, cyber resilience, and national economic security. The research employs a systematic literature review methodology based on PRISMA principles. Academic publications, analytical reports, and institutional studies indexed in major scientific databases were analyzed using thematic synthesis and comparative analytical approaches. A total of 79 studies meeting predefined inclusion criteria were selected for in-depth analysis. The findings demonstrate that modern financial monitoring systems are evolving toward adaptive, technology-driven, and data-intensive architectures characterized by the integration of artificial intelligence, machine learning, RegTech, and predictive analytics tools. Five dominant thematic clusters were identified: technological transformation of monitoring systems; AML/CFT regulatory evolution; cyber resilience and operational security; institutional and governance mechanisms; and geopolitical determinants of financial stability. The analysis reveals several systemic contradictions shaping the contemporary monitoring environment, including tensions between innovation and regulation, transparency and privacy, automation and explainability, and globalization and economic sovereignty. The study contributes to the literature by developing an integrated conceptual framework that positions financial monitoring as a strategic component of state economic security architecture under conditions of digitalization and geopolitical uncertainty. The practical significance of the research lies in identifying strategic directions for improving monitoring effectiveness, strengthening cyber resilience, and enhancing coordination between public authorities, financial institutions, and international regulatory organizations.
- 30 June 2026
- Published by FinTechAlliance in Financial and credit activity: problems of theory and practice
- Vol. 3 (68) , 24-47
Open AccessFINANCIAL MONITORING IN THE BANKING SYSTEM AS A TOOL FOR ENSURING THE ECONOMIC SECURITY OF THE STATE: SYSTEMATIC REVIEW
The rapid digital transformation of the global banking sector, combined with the growing complexity of geopolitical instability, cyber threats, and cross-border financial flows, has significantly increased the strategic importance of financial monitoring systems for ensuring state economic security. Contemporary financial monitoring extends beyond its traditional compliance-oriented role and increasingly functions as an integrated mechanism of systemic risk management, financial resilience, and institutional stability. Despite extensive research on anti-money laundering (AML), counter-terrorist financing (CFT), financial technologies, and cybersecurity, existing studies remain fragmented and insufficiently integrated within a unified economic security framework. This study aims to systematize contemporary scholarly approaches to financial monitoring in the banking system and to identify the systemic relationships between financial monitoring mechanisms, technological transformation, cyber resilience, and national economic security. The research employs a systematic literature review methodology based on PRISMA principles. Academic publications, analytical reports, and institutional studies indexed in major scientific databases were analyzed using thematic synthesis and comparative analytical approaches. A total of 79 studies meeting predefined inclusion criteria were selected for in-depth analysis. The findings demonstrate that modern financial monitoring systems are evolving toward adaptive, technology-driven, and data-intensive architectures characterized by the integration of artificial intelligence, machine learning, RegTech, and predictive analytics tools. Five dominant thematic clusters were identified: technological transformation of monitoring systems; AML/CFT regulatory evolution; cyber resilience and operational security; institutional and governance mechanisms; and geopolitical determinants of financial stability. The analysis reveals several systemic contradictions shaping the contemporary monitoring environment, including tensions between innovation and regulation, transparency and privacy, automation and explainability, and globalization and economic sovereignty. The study contributes to the literature by developing an integrated conceptual framework that positions financial monitoring as a strategic component of state economic security architecture under conditions of digitalization and geopolitical uncertainty. The practical significance of the research lies in identifying strategic directions for improving monitoring effectiveness, strengthening cyber resilience, and enhancing coordination between public authorities, financial institutions, and international regulatory organizations.
- Open Access
- 31 May 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 2 (3) , 263-268
Administrative and legal regulation of balancing in the natural gas market: conflicts and ways to overcome them
The article is devoted to a comprehensive study of the administrative and legal regulation of balancing in the natural gas market in Ukraine, in particular, to identifying conflicts and gaps in the relevant regulatory and legal support. It is proved that effective balancing in the natural gas market is a necessary prerequisite for uninterrupted supply of energy resources, while the imperfection of legal regulation in this area leads to the emergence of numerous disputes, legal uncertainty and complications in law enforcement practice. The article also examines the essence and content of the concept of balancing in the natural gas market as a specific type of activity in the energy market, combining technical and legal aspects. The features of the administrative and legal influence of the state on relations in the field of balancing are analyzed, in particular through the activities of authorized bodies, regulatory and legal regulation and the application of imperative requirements. Special attention is paid to the analysis of judicial practice in disputes related to the regulatory and legal regulation of the balancing procedure and the establishment of the procedure for settlements for imbalances. Based on the conducted scientific and legal analysis, a number of significant problems of administrative and legal regulation of natural gas balancing in Ukraine were identified. In particular, the presence of regulatory conflicts between various acts, insufficient coordination of legislative provisions regulating the procedure for determining imbalances, as well as the absence of clear procedures for exercising the powers of the regulator were established. It was found that the existing gaps in legal regulation cause ambiguity in the interpretation of norms, create prerequisites for abuse by individual market participants and complicate effective state control. Taking into account the conducted research, a number of specific directions for improving the administrative and legal regulation of balancing in the natural gas market in Ukraine were proposed. In particular, the need to systematize the regulatory framework, eliminate existing conflicts and introduce clear and transparent procedures for interaction between market entities and the regulator was substantiated. The author also formulated proposals for improving control and liability mechanisms, increasing the level of legal certainty and ensuring effective law enforcement in the field of natural gas balancing.
- 31 May 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 2 (3) , 263-268
Open AccessAdministrative and legal regulation of balancing in the natural gas market: conflicts and ways to overcome them
The article is devoted to a comprehensive study of the administrative and legal regulation of balancing in the natural gas market in Ukraine, in particular, to identifying conflicts and gaps in the relevant regulatory and legal support. It is proved that effective balancing in the natural gas market is a necessary prerequisite for uninterrupted supply of energy resources, while the imperfection of legal regulation in this area leads to the emergence of numerous disputes, legal uncertainty and complications in law enforcement practice. The article also examines the essence and content of the concept of balancing in the natural gas market as a specific type of activity in the energy market, combining technical and legal aspects. The features of the administrative and legal influence of the state on relations in the field of balancing are analyzed, in particular through the activities of authorized bodies, regulatory and legal regulation and the application of imperative requirements. Special attention is paid to the analysis of judicial practice in disputes related to the regulatory and legal regulation of the balancing procedure and the establishment of the procedure for settlements for imbalances. Based on the conducted scientific and legal analysis, a number of significant problems of administrative and legal regulation of natural gas balancing in Ukraine were identified. In particular, the presence of regulatory conflicts between various acts, insufficient coordination of legislative provisions regulating the procedure for determining imbalances, as well as the absence of clear procedures for exercising the powers of the regulator were established. It was found that the existing gaps in legal regulation cause ambiguity in the interpretation of norms, create prerequisites for abuse by individual market participants and complicate effective state control. Taking into account the conducted research, a number of specific directions for improving the administrative and legal regulation of balancing in the natural gas market in Ukraine were proposed. In particular, the need to systematize the regulatory framework, eliminate existing conflicts and introduce clear and transparent procedures for interaction between market entities and the regulator was substantiated. The author also formulated proposals for improving control and liability mechanisms, increasing the level of legal certainty and ensuring effective law enforcement in the field of natural gas balancing.
- 11 May 2026
- Published by Publishing House Helvetica (Publications) in Scientific notes of Taurida National V.I. Vernadsky University. Series: Juridical Sciences
- No. 2,p. 34-39
DEVELOPMENT OF LEGISLATION IN THE FIELD OF REGULATION OF THE SUBJECT OF JUDICIAL CONTROL IN ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS OF UKRAINE
- 11 May 2026
- Published by Publishing House Helvetica (Publications) in Scientific notes of Taurida National V.I. Vernadsky University. Series: Juridical Sciences
- No. 2,p. 34-39
DEVELOPMENT OF LEGISLATION IN THE FIELD OF REGULATION OF THE SUBJECT OF JUDICIAL CONTROL IN ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS OF UKRAINE
- Open Access
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 2 (2) , 74-78
Evolution of the development of regulatory and legal support for asset securitization in Ukraine
The article is devoted to the study of the evolution of the development of regulatory and legal support for asset securitization in Ukraine. It is determined that today our state is going through a stage of harmonization of domestic legislation with European standards. One of the most difficult, but most promising areas of such harmonization is the creation of an open and stable market for asset securitization. In modern conditions, we are observing the process of forming a legislative field for “green” securitization and asset digitization, which is coordinated by the National Securities and Stock Market Commission with the assistance of European partners. This indicates a paradigm shift: from formal implementation of regulations to the concrete implementation of digital capital market infrastructure. Therefore, in domestic conditions, asset securitization requires a thorough study of its evolution, which will allow us to clearly identify the main obstacles to its formation in order to resolve them for its further development. Four stages of the evolution of the development of regulatory and legal support for asset securitization in Ukraine are distinguished, in particular, the stage of formation (2003-2010), the stage of fragmentary reforms (2011-2019), the stage of systemic modernization of capital markets (2020-2023) and the stage of European integration and implementation of international standards in the context of implementing the conditions for candidacy for membership in the European Union (2024-2025). It has been established that the evolution has gone from segmental regulation of exclusively mortgage instruments to the creation of a holistic legal framework, which currently contributes to the use of securitization as an important means of attracting international investment for the post-war reconstruction of Ukraine. It is determined that throughout the evolution, a fundamental revision of the civil law essence of the assignment of rights of claim has been carried out. It is noted that despite significant progress, there is still a need for further liberalization of tax legislation for specialized institutions and automation of supervisory procedures using regulatory technologies. Therefore, the regulatory and legal support created throughout the development is sufficient to launch a full-fledged securitization market, which is consistent with the best world experience and can become an important lever for the financial recovery of Ukraine in the post-war period.
- 3 April 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 2 (2) , 74-78
Open AccessEvolution of the development of regulatory and legal support for asset securitization in Ukraine
The article is devoted to the study of the evolution of the development of regulatory and legal support for asset securitization in Ukraine. It is determined that today our state is going through a stage of harmonization of domestic legislation with European standards. One of the most difficult, but most promising areas of such harmonization is the creation of an open and stable market for asset securitization. In modern conditions, we are observing the process of forming a legislative field for “green” securitization and asset digitization, which is coordinated by the National Securities and Stock Market Commission with the assistance of European partners. This indicates a paradigm shift: from formal implementation of regulations to the concrete implementation of digital capital market infrastructure. Therefore, in domestic conditions, asset securitization requires a thorough study of its evolution, which will allow us to clearly identify the main obstacles to its formation in order to resolve them for its further development. Four stages of the evolution of the development of regulatory and legal support for asset securitization in Ukraine are distinguished, in particular, the stage of formation (2003-2010), the stage of fragmentary reforms (2011-2019), the stage of systemic modernization of capital markets (2020-2023) and the stage of European integration and implementation of international standards in the context of implementing the conditions for candidacy for membership in the European Union (2024-2025). It has been established that the evolution has gone from segmental regulation of exclusively mortgage instruments to the creation of a holistic legal framework, which currently contributes to the use of securitization as an important means of attracting international investment for the post-war reconstruction of Ukraine. It is determined that throughout the evolution, a fundamental revision of the civil law essence of the assignment of rights of claim has been carried out. It is noted that despite significant progress, there is still a need for further liberalization of tax legislation for specialized institutions and automation of supervisory procedures using regulatory technologies. Therefore, the regulatory and legal support created throughout the development is sufficient to launch a full-fledged securitization market, which is consistent with the best world experience and can become an important lever for the financial recovery of Ukraine in the post-war period.
- Open Access
- 5 March 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 3 (93) , 45-51
Administrative and legal provisions for combating violations in the sphere of taxation in the conditions of martial state and post-war reconstruction
The article conducts a comprehensive scientific analysis of the mechanisms of administrative and legal support for countering violations in the field of taxation, which operate under martial law and will be reformed in the post-war period. The transformation of the legal nature of tax legal relations, which occurred as a result of the introduction of a special legal regime of taxation under martial law, is studied, and the specifics of the administrative status of entities responsible for the financial security of the state are determined. The characteristic features of modern administrative offenses in the tax sphere are identified, among which manipulations with tax reporting in conditions of limited access to state registers and abuse of the status of a single tax payer are highlighted. The legal aspects of stopping the registration of tax invoices as a preventive administrative measure aimed at preventing tax violations are studied, systemic shortcomings in the regulation of blocking are identified and ways of eliminating them are proposed through improving the risk criteria of payers. In the context of post-war restoration, strategic directions for reforming the administrative and legal regulation of taxation are determined. The transition from the fiscal pressure model to the service model of interaction is justified, where the main emphasis is shifted to remote monitoring and automation of the processes of detecting violations. The prospects for the implementation of the electronic audit system (“E-audit”) are investigated and its role in the mechanism for minimizing the subjective factor when making decisions by tax authorities in order to prevent tax violations is determined. Specific practical recommendations are formulated for amending the current legislation, in particular in the part related to expanding the rights of taxpayers during remote inspections and establishing additional guarantees for the protection of economic entities from unlawful interference by regulatory authorities. A model of the administrative and legal regime of “tax renovation” is outlined, which provides for a gradual return to standard procedures of tax control and tax regulation while maintaining incentive mechanisms in the field of tax regulation and tax control for those territories affected by hostilities.
- 5 March 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
- Vol. 3 (93) , 45-51
Open AccessAdministrative and legal provisions for combating violations in the sphere of taxation in the conditions of martial state and post-war reconstruction
The article conducts a comprehensive scientific analysis of the mechanisms of administrative and legal support for countering violations in the field of taxation, which operate under martial law and will be reformed in the post-war period. The transformation of the legal nature of tax legal relations, which occurred as a result of the introduction of a special legal regime of taxation under martial law, is studied, and the specifics of the administrative status of entities responsible for the financial security of the state are determined. The characteristic features of modern administrative offenses in the tax sphere are identified, among which manipulations with tax reporting in conditions of limited access to state registers and abuse of the status of a single tax payer are highlighted. The legal aspects of stopping the registration of tax invoices as a preventive administrative measure aimed at preventing tax violations are studied, systemic shortcomings in the regulation of blocking are identified and ways of eliminating them are proposed through improving the risk criteria of payers. In the context of post-war restoration, strategic directions for reforming the administrative and legal regulation of taxation are determined. The transition from the fiscal pressure model to the service model of interaction is justified, where the main emphasis is shifted to remote monitoring and automation of the processes of detecting violations. The prospects for the implementation of the electronic audit system (“E-audit”) are investigated and its role in the mechanism for minimizing the subjective factor when making decisions by tax authorities in order to prevent tax violations is determined. Specific practical recommendations are formulated for amending the current legislation, in particular in the part related to expanding the rights of taxpayers during remote inspections and establishing additional guarantees for the protection of economic entities from unlawful interference by regulatory authorities. A model of the administrative and legal regime of “tax renovation” is outlined, which provides for a gradual return to standard procedures of tax control and tax regulation while maintaining incentive mechanisms in the field of tax regulation and tax control for those territories affected by hostilities.
- Open Access
- 2 February 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (1) , 325-329
Legal regulation of compliance control as a new form of interaction between tax authorities and payers
The article is devoted to a comprehensive study of the administrative and legal mechanism for implementing compliance control as an innovative model of interaction between tax authorities and taxpayers in Ukraine. The author has studied the essence and content of the concept of «tax compliance control», which is considered as a multi-faceted administrative category that encompasses not only monitoring compliance with tax legislation, but also a system of preventive measures aimed at identifying and minimizing legal risks even before the offense is committed. A thorough analysis of the legal status of the subjects of such interaction has been conducted, in particular, the limits of discretionary powers of tax authorities during compliance procedures have been determined. Particular attention is paid to methodological approaches to classifying taxpayers by risk level, which allows differentiating the intensity of control measures and ensuring the targeting of state intervention. The article analyzes the procedural boundaries of horizontal monitoring and remote support of large taxpayers, which are key elements of modern compliance control. Based on the analysis, a number of systemic problems were identified that hinder the effective implementation of the compliance model in national practice. It was found that the lack of a clear legislative definition of the term «compliance control» in the Tax Code of Ukraine creates risks of subjectivity and abuse by regulatory authorities. It was found that the procedural unregulated stage of preliminary coordination of tax positions often leads to the emergence of latent conflicts and a decrease in the level of legal certainty for business. It is proven that without proper administrative and legal support for the protection of confidential information that the payer voluntarily provides during compliance procedures, it is impossible to ensure a high level of trust in state institutions and stimulate the economy to emerge from the shadows. Taking into account the analysis, specific and justified ways of improving the administrative legislation of Ukraine in terms of regulating tax control are proposed.
- 2 February 2026
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 3 (1) , 325-329
Open AccessLegal regulation of compliance control as a new form of interaction between tax authorities and payers
The article is devoted to a comprehensive study of the administrative and legal mechanism for implementing compliance control as an innovative model of interaction between tax authorities and taxpayers in Ukraine. The author has studied the essence and content of the concept of «tax compliance control», which is considered as a multi-faceted administrative category that encompasses not only monitoring compliance with tax legislation, but also a system of preventive measures aimed at identifying and minimizing legal risks even before the offense is committed. A thorough analysis of the legal status of the subjects of such interaction has been conducted, in particular, the limits of discretionary powers of tax authorities during compliance procedures have been determined. Particular attention is paid to methodological approaches to classifying taxpayers by risk level, which allows differentiating the intensity of control measures and ensuring the targeting of state intervention. The article analyzes the procedural boundaries of horizontal monitoring and remote support of large taxpayers, which are key elements of modern compliance control. Based on the analysis, a number of systemic problems were identified that hinder the effective implementation of the compliance model in national practice. It was found that the lack of a clear legislative definition of the term «compliance control» in the Tax Code of Ukraine creates risks of subjectivity and abuse by regulatory authorities. It was found that the procedural unregulated stage of preliminary coordination of tax positions often leads to the emergence of latent conflicts and a decrease in the level of legal certainty for business. It is proven that without proper administrative and legal support for the protection of confidential information that the payer voluntarily provides during compliance procedures, it is impossible to ensure a high level of trust in state institutions and stimulate the economy to emerge from the shadows. Taking into account the analysis, specific and justified ways of improving the administrative legislation of Ukraine in terms of regulating tax control are proposed.
- Open Access
- 28 October 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 1 (5) , 65-70
Legal nihilism as a threat to the rule of law: causes and possible consequences
It is indicated that in the conditions of intensive socio-political transformations of modern times, the problem of guaranteeing the stability and effectiveness of legal mechanisms becomes critically important. Legal nihilism as a phenomenon characterized by a contemptuous attitude towards legislative provisions, a skeptical attitude towards power structures and neglect of legal requirements, constitutes one of the most dangerous threats to the construction of a legal state and the establishment of the principle of the rule of law, destroying the fundamental principles of the social order and inhibiting the progress of democratic processes. The article is devoted to the study of legal nihilism as one of the most serious threats to the rule of law and democratic institutions. The relevance of the topic is due to the fact that legal nihilism, manifested in contempt for the law, distrust of state institutions and ignoring legal norms, undermines the foundations of law and order and the stability of society. The author establishes that the roots of legal nihilism go back to historical, socio-economic and political factors. In particular, the legacy of the totalitarian past, economic instability, high levels of corruption and inefficiency of law enforcement and judicial bodies have a significant impact. Various forms of manifestation of legal nihilism are analyzed, starting from the everyday level (violation of traffic rules, tax evasion) and ending with systemic disregard for the law by representatives of the authorities. It is substantiated that the consequences of legal nihilism are extremely destructive for the state and society. It leads to an increase in crime, a decrease in investment attractiveness, a weakening of democratic principles and, ultimately, to the destruction of the rule of law. It is argued that without overcoming legal nihilism, the effective functioning of the legal system and ensuring the implementation of citizens’ rights and freedoms are impossible. Based on the analysis, proposals have been developed to counteract legal nihilism. These include: strengthening legal education of the population, starting from school age; increasing the efficiency of law enforcement agencies and the judicial system; ensuring the inevitability of punishment for committed offenses, regardless of the status of the person; carrying out systemic anti-corruption reforms; forming a positive image of law enforcement agencies and courts by increasing their transparency and accountability. The importance of developing civil society and involving the public in monitoring the activities of state institutions is also emphasized.
- 28 October 2025
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- Vol. 1 (5) , 65-70
Open AccessLegal nihilism as a threat to the rule of law: causes and possible consequences
It is indicated that in the conditions of intensive socio-political transformations of modern times, the problem of guaranteeing the stability and effectiveness of legal mechanisms becomes critically important. Legal nihilism as a phenomenon characterized by a contemptuous attitude towards legislative provisions, a skeptical attitude towards power structures and neglect of legal requirements, constitutes one of the most dangerous threats to the construction of a legal state and the establishment of the principle of the rule of law, destroying the fundamental principles of the social order and inhibiting the progress of democratic processes. The article is devoted to the study of legal nihilism as one of the most serious threats to the rule of law and democratic institutions. The relevance of the topic is due to the fact that legal nihilism, manifested in contempt for the law, distrust of state institutions and ignoring legal norms, undermines the foundations of law and order and the stability of society. The author establishes that the roots of legal nihilism go back to historical, socio-economic and political factors. In particular, the legacy of the totalitarian past, economic instability, high levels of corruption and inefficiency of law enforcement and judicial bodies have a significant impact. Various forms of manifestation of legal nihilism are analyzed, starting from the everyday level (violation of traffic rules, tax evasion) and ending with systemic disregard for the law by representatives of the authorities. It is substantiated that the consequences of legal nihilism are extremely destructive for the state and society. It leads to an increase in crime, a decrease in investment attractiveness, a weakening of democratic principles and, ultimately, to the destruction of the rule of law. It is argued that without overcoming legal nihilism, the effective functioning of the legal system and ensuring the implementation of citizens’ rights and freedoms are impossible. Based on the analysis, proposals have been developed to counteract legal nihilism. These include: strengthening legal education of the population, starting from school age; increasing the efficiency of law enforcement agencies and the judicial system; ensuring the inevitability of punishment for committed offenses, regardless of the status of the person; carrying out systemic anti-corruption reforms; forming a positive image of law enforcement agencies and courts by increasing their transparency and accountability. The importance of developing civil society and involving the public in monitoring the activities of state institutions is also emphasized.