LZLisbeth Zimmermann

Lisbeth Zimmermann

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Lisbeth Zimmermann has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Repurposing international organizations? Far-right funding in the field of migration governance

    by Alexandros Tokhi, Lisbeth Zimmermann

    The rise of far-right governments has put international organizations under pressure. The recent financial cuts to the United Nations system by the United States have highlighted how member states can influence international organizations through funding decisions. Yet, far-right governments do not simply withdraw from international organizations or withhold all their money. Instead, we argue, they aim at repurposing international organizations to implement their international policy priorities. Based on data on earmarked funding to the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and the International Organization for Migration between 2004 and 2023, we show that far-right governments aim to align international organizations’ operational work with their anti-immigration policies: They shift funding between organizations, preferring International Organization for Migration over United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, relative to non-far-right governments, because of its broader focus on migration and return management. They also allocate funding to operational activities that better align with their preferences, thereby shifting United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees project activities outside its core mandate.


  • Open Access

    The far right and international organizations: How the far right in government affects foreign aid funding

    by Alexandros Tokhi, Lisbeth Zimmermann

    The far right is on the rise, winning elections, entering governments globally, and politicizing international cooperation. Existing research finds only very limited effects of far-right governments on international organizations (IOs), however.. We argue that the far right in government undermines IOs by systematically reducing their earmarked funding, as it cannot fully align its anti-migration agenda with the liberal mandates and purposes of most IOs. Using new data on earmarked funding to IOs from 37 OECD donor states between 1990 and 2020, we examine how far-right participation in government affects IO funding. Expanding the data on far-right parties beyond Western Europe, we employ three-way fixed effects and dynamic balancing weights to address both static and dynamic confounding with marginal structural models. Our results show that governments with far-right parties reduce earmarked funding contributions to IOs by almost 30%, without affecting bilateral aid commitments. This suggests that the far right not only politicizes IOs but also attempts to directly undermine their operation when IOs cannot be aligned with their anti-migration agenda.


  • Introduction

    by Lisbeth Zimmermann, Nicole Deitelhoff, Max Lesch, Antonio Arcudi, Anton Peez

    How does contestation affect the robustness of international norms? When and why are they weakened? We begin by illustrating the relevance of these questions to the much-heralded “crisis” of the liberal international order. Existing scholarship on international norms in international relations does not satisfactorily explain the link between contestation and norm robustness. We present a typology, differentiate validity from applicatory contestation, and explain how the two relate to norm robustness. We also show that the legal character and the power of norm challengers are less significant than assumed. The contestation trends observed in contemporary cases—the torture prohibition, the responsibility to protect, the commercial whaling moratorium, and the duty to prosecute—are explained by the embeddedness of norms in norm clusters and by perceptions of the procedural fairness of international institutions. In contrast, in the historical case studies on privateering and the transatlantic slave trade, direct power was also decisive.


  • Bad pirates, good privateers?

    by Lisbeth Zimmermann, Nicole Deitelhoff, Max Lesch, Antonio Arcudi, Anton Peez

    Today, privateering—the practice of states commissioning private ships to seize foreign vessels—is often equated with piracy. But from the Middle Ages until the nineteenth century, under different names and with different objectives, privateering was seen as legitimate and was widely practiced. Rules for privateering, as well as the line between it and piracy, were highly contested. But the practice itself was barely questioned. Only in the first half of the nineteenth century was the validity of privateering seriously contested—and in 1856, it was replaced by a formal ban. This chapter explores why the permissive norm of privateering long remained robust and then eroded completely in the nineteenth century. We show that European states’ shift to more validity contestation was brought about by more general normative shifts: from mercantilism to capitalism and liberalism. The United Kingdom, the main country that challenged the norm, ensured its replacement internationally.

  • International norm disputes

    by Lisbeth Zimmermann, Nicole Deitelhoff, Max Lesch, Antonio Arcudi, Anton Peez

    This final chapter in the book summarizes and compares the main findings in our six case studies of the link between contestation and norm robustness. We analyze the key factors of law, the relative power of norm challengers, and institutions in order to explain when contestation radicalizes and weakens international norms. Additionally, we discuss how this project relates to recent debates on issues such as norm complexity and change, practice, silence, and critique. We conclude by outlining how our findings and insights into the dynamics of international norms advance the current debate about the “crisis” of the liberal international order.


  • Losing Africa?

    by Lisbeth Zimmermann, Nicole Deitelhoff, Max Lesch, Antonio Arcudi, Anton Peez

    The International Criminal Court (ICC) is the first permanent international court mandated to prosecute individuals “for the gravest crimes of concern to the international community”—genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity, and, more recently, also the crime of aggression—when individual states are unwilling, or unable, to prosecute. The United States contested the ICC since the adoption of the Rome Statute in 1998. Since the mid-2000s, the African Union and several African states have also challenged the ICC’s validity and application. These challenges culminated in threats and even notifications of withdrawal by African states. Cooperation with the ICC is decreasing and non-compliance is less criticized, weakening the duty to prosecute, at least on the African continent. This can be attributed to African states’ perception that their critique has not been recognized by the international community and that they have been betrayed by the court and the United Nations Security Council.


  • Contesting the international moratorium on commercial whaling

    by Lisbeth Zimmermann, Nicole Deitelhoff, Max Lesch, Antonio Arcudi, Anton Peez

    In 1986, the International Whaling Commission (IWC) moratorium on commercial whaling came into force. Since then, it has been considerably weakened. While in the late 1980s and early 1990s, there was little whaling of any type, a considerable rise in whaling activities has been observed since the mid-2000s—while condemnations of these activities have lessened. These trends are linked to IWC members making more validity contestations and to applicatory contestation becoming permanent—mostly due to challengers’ perception that international institutions are unfair: They are seen as hierarchical and blocking effective channels for normative change. Moreover, the lack of adjudication resulted in informal sanctions by the anti-whaling coalition—radicalizing the pro-whaling positions of a group of states and weakening the norm.

  • Coding schemes for applicatory and validity contestation

    by Lisbeth Zimmermann, Nicole Deitelhoff, Max Lesch, Antonio Arcudi, Anton Peez

    27410.1093/oso/9780198873235.007.0001Table A.1 Coding scheme for the international torture prohibitionCategoriesDimensionsThemesDescriptionValidity contestation

  • Open Access

    Contestation and norm change in whale and elephant conservation: Non-use or sustainable use?

    by Anton Peez, Lisbeth Zimmermann

    Elephants and whales took center stage in the environmental movements of the 1980s. As flagship species, they were the poster children of global initiatives: international ivory trading and commercial whaling were banned in the 1980s in the context of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) and the International Whaling Commission (IWC), respectively. While the conservation of both species is contested, we observe a change of existing norms in one case but not in the other: A moratorium on commercial whaling remains in place. Meanwhile, a limited shift to sustainable use regarding ivory was passed in 1997/2000. We ask why norm change occurred in one case but not the other, given their similarities. We argue that the difference can be explained by the perceived legitimacy of the claims of norm challengers using arguments of “affectedness” and the breadth of issues covered by CITES. In contrast, other factors commonly discussed in norms research do not explain this puzzle: the relative power and strategies of norm advocates and challengers, and the degree of legalization. This shows the interplay of discursive aspects and concrete institutional opportunities for norm change, even in the face of otherwise inopportune conditions.


  • On our terms! How domestic elites localised the International Commission Against Impunity in Guatemala

    by Lisbeth Zimmermann

    In summer 2004, an UN-sponsored international rule of law commission based on an initiative of the Guatemalan human rights community was rejected by Guatemalan political elites. In 2007, a new version, the International Commission against Impunity (CICIG), was approved by the Guatemalan Congress and has since been active in the country, supporting the modernisation of the Guatemalan judicial system and the investigation and prosecution of criminal networks. The CICIG has been hailed as part of a new generation of rule of law promotion that addresses the problems of post-conflict states. How did this change in elite support come about? Neither increased pressure from the international community nor changes in the elite groups in power can fully explain this shift. Rather, Guatemalan elites actively reshaped the commission; in addition, the human rights community reframed it to better fit the risk perceptions of the general public.