Michael Nicholas Stagnaro
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Interests
Michael Nicholas Stagnaro has a total of 26 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- David Gertler Rand
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
8 shared publications - Robb Willer
Department of Sociology, Stanford University
7 shared publications - James Druckman
Department of Political Science, University of Rochester
6 shared publications - James Chu
Department of Sociology, Columbia University
5 shared publications - Jan G. Voelkel
Jeb E. Brooks School of Public Policy, Cornell University
5 shared publications - Adam J. Berinsky
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 27 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Reducing belief in conspiracy theories as they unfold using large language models
The emergence of conspiracy theories in the wake of major events is a significant societal challenge. Here we test whether conversational dialogues with a large language model (LLM) can reduce belief in immediately unfolding conspiracies. In experiments conducted in the days following the July 2024 assassination attempt on Donald Trump and the September 2025 assassination of Charlie Kirk, U.S. adults (Experiment 1: N = 472; Experiment 2: N = 1042) holding conspiratorial views about the crisis event engaged in a multi-turn conversation with an LLM prompted to reduce their conspiracy belief. Compared to control participants who either discussed an irrelevant topic with an LLM or viewed a static fact sheet, participants in the LLM treatment showed significantly reduced conspiracy beliefs in both experiments. We also found some suggestive evidence of downstream effects of the LLM treatment, observing reduced belief in some—but not all—analyses of different conspiratorial beliefs one to two months later. These results shed light on the psychology of emerging conspiracies and highlight the potential for scalable, cognitively-focused interventions to counteract misinformation in the immediate aftermath of high-profile societal events.
- 27 October 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessReducing belief in conspiracy theories as they unfold using large language models
The emergence of conspiracy theories in the wake of major events is a significant societal challenge. Here we test whether conversational dialogues with a large language model (LLM) can reduce belief in immediately unfolding conspiracies. In experiments conducted in the days following the July 2024 assassination attempt on Donald Trump and the September 2025 assassination of Charlie Kirk, U.S. adults (Experiment 1: N = 472; Experiment 2: N = 1042) holding conspiratorial views about the crisis event engaged in a multi-turn conversation with an LLM prompted to reduce their conspiracy belief. Compared to control participants who either discussed an irrelevant topic with an LLM or viewed a static fact sheet, participants in the LLM treatment showed significantly reduced conspiracy beliefs in both experiments. We also found some suggestive evidence of downstream effects of the LLM treatment, observing reduced belief in some—but not all—analyses of different conspiratorial beliefs one to two months later. These results shed light on the psychology of emerging conspiracies and highlight the potential for scalable, cognitively-focused interventions to counteract misinformation in the immediate aftermath of high-profile societal events.
- Open Access
- 28 September 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Can Accurate Information Change Identity-Linked Political Beliefs? Evidence From Republicans’ Attitudes Towards Election Integrity
Psychological research suggests that identity shapes beliefs and impedes updating in response to contrary evidence. A prominent example is many Republicans’ persistence in believing that the 2020 election was stolen. We test whether credible factual information can shift Republicans' beliefs about election integrity. Immediately before the 2024 presidential election, we randomly assigned 861 conservative Republicans to an intensive informational intervention or a control matched with civic content. The intervention presented extensive, accurate, politically balanced evidence and encouraged sustained engagement. Treated participants reported stronger beliefs in US election integrity overall, greater confidence in the 2020 election, and more positive expectations for the 2024 election (.5 < ds < .8), including those who started lower in electoral confidence (.5 < ds < .97). Effects were still detectable two weeks later, after Trump’s victory. Though learning was incentivized, belief reporting was not – showing that when attended to, credible balanced evidence can change minds.
- 28 September 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessCan Accurate Information Change Identity-Linked Political Beliefs? Evidence From Republicans’ Attitudes Towards Election Integrity
Psychological research suggests that identity shapes beliefs and impedes updating in response to contrary evidence. A prominent example is many Republicans’ persistence in believing that the 2020 election was stolen. We test whether credible factual information can shift Republicans' beliefs about election integrity. Immediately before the 2024 presidential election, we randomly assigned 861 conservative Republicans to an intensive informational intervention or a control matched with civic content. The intervention presented extensive, accurate, politically balanced evidence and encouraged sustained engagement. Treated participants reported stronger beliefs in US election integrity overall, greater confidence in the 2020 election, and more positive expectations for the 2024 election (.5 < ds < .8), including those who started lower in electoral confidence (.5 < ds < .97). Effects were still detectable two weeks later, after Trump’s victory. Though learning was incentivized, belief reporting was not – showing that when attended to, credible balanced evidence can change minds.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 22 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Human Behaviour
- Vol. 10 (8) , 1441-1454
Representativeness and response validity across nine opt-in online samples
The study of human behaviour has shifted in the past 15 years. It increasingly relies on opt-in non-probability online data sources. Here we offer an analysis of nine such sources (N = 13,053), aiming to inform researchers conducting experiments or correlational studies. We assess response validity (attentiveness, effort, honesty, speeding and attrition), the extent to which samples represent the underlying population (demographics, attitude representativeness and experimental treatment effects) and professionalism (number and frequency of studies taken and modality of device on which studies are taken). We document substantial variation across samples on each dimension. Samples using demographic quotas display relatively higher amounts of representativeness across multiple indicators (beyond demographics) but often exhibit less response validity. However, inclusion of two attention checks early in a survey can enhance response validity without negatively impacting representativeness. We offer guidance for choosing opt-in samples, depending on the purpose of the research and resource constraints.
- 22 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Human Behaviour
- Vol. 10 (8) , 1441-1454
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessRepresentativeness and response validity across nine opt-in online samples
The study of human behaviour has shifted in the past 15 years. It increasingly relies on opt-in non-probability online data sources. Here we offer an analysis of nine such sources (N = 13,053), aiming to inform researchers conducting experiments or correlational studies. We assess response validity (attentiveness, effort, honesty, speeding and attrition), the extent to which samples represent the underlying population (demographics, attitude representativeness and experimental treatment effects) and professionalism (number and frequency of studies taken and modality of device on which studies are taken). We document substantial variation across samples on each dimension. Samples using demographic quotas display relatively higher amounts of representativeness across multiple indicators (beyond demographics) but often exhibit less response validity. However, inclusion of two attention checks early in a survey can enhance response validity without negatively impacting representativeness. We offer guidance for choosing opt-in samples, depending on the purpose of the research and resource constraints.
- Open Access
- 20 March 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Conversations with a large language model improve attitudes toward Muslims and Islam without harming attitudes toward Jews or Christians
Can a brief conversation with a large language model (LLM) measurably improve attitudes toward a stigmatized religious minority? We investigate this question in the context of Americans’ attitudes towards Muslims and Islam. We also ask whether doing so worsens attitudes towards Jews and Judaism, given the current high-salience conflict between Muslims and Jews in the Middle East. To answer these questions, N=604 participants had a three-round dialogue with an LLM that either (i) corrected participants’ misconceptions about Islam and Muslims (treatment) or (ii) discussed sports (control). As expected, we find that the treatment significantly improved attitudes towards Islam and Muslims relative to the control. Furthermore, we do not find that improving attitudes towards Islam and Muslims comes at the cost of worsening attitudes towards Jews or Christians. On the contrary, we find some evidence that the treatment also improves attitudes towards Jews, Judaism, and Christianity. Thus, customized LLM chatbots may help address religious prejudice.
- 20 March 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessConversations with a large language model improve attitudes toward Muslims and Islam without harming attitudes toward Jews or Christians
Can a brief conversation with a large language model (LLM) measurably improve attitudes toward a stigmatized religious minority? We investigate this question in the context of Americans’ attitudes towards Muslims and Islam. We also ask whether doing so worsens attitudes towards Jews and Judaism, given the current high-salience conflict between Muslims and Jews in the Middle East. To answer these questions, N=604 participants had a three-round dialogue with an LLM that either (i) corrected participants’ misconceptions about Islam and Muslims (treatment) or (ii) discussed sports (control). As expected, we find that the treatment significantly improved attitudes towards Islam and Muslims relative to the control. Furthermore, we do not find that improving attitudes towards Islam and Muslims comes at the cost of worsening attitudes towards Jews or Christians. On the contrary, we find some evidence that the treatment also improves attitudes towards Jews, Judaism, and Christianity. Thus, customized LLM chatbots may help address religious prejudice.
- Open Access
- 24 July 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Representativeness and Response Validity Across Nine Opt-In Online Samples
The study of human behavior has shifted in the last fifteen years, with increasing reliance on opt-in non-probability online data sources. We offer an analysis of nine such data sources (total N = 13,053), aiming to inform researchers conducting experiments or correlational studies. We assess response validity (attentiveness, effort, honesty, speeding, and attrition), the extent to which samples represent the underlying population (observable demographics, measured attitude representativeness, and responding to experimental treatments), and professionalism (number of studies taken, frequency of taking studies, and modality of device on which the study is taken). We document substantial variation across these samples on each dimension. Samples that employ demographic quotas display relatively higher amounts of representativeness across multiple indicators (beyond demographics) but often exhibit less response validity. However, the inclusion of two attention checks early in a study enhances response validity without negatively impacting representativeness. We offer guidance for choosing opt-in samples, depending on the purpose of the research and resource constraints.
- 24 July 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessRepresentativeness and Response Validity Across Nine Opt-In Online Samples
The study of human behavior has shifted in the last fifteen years, with increasing reliance on opt-in non-probability online data sources. We offer an analysis of nine such data sources (total N = 13,053), aiming to inform researchers conducting experiments or correlational studies. We assess response validity (attentiveness, effort, honesty, speeding, and attrition), the extent to which samples represent the underlying population (observable demographics, measured attitude representativeness, and responding to experimental treatments), and professionalism (number of studies taken, frequency of taking studies, and modality of device on which the study is taken). We document substantial variation across these samples on each dimension. Samples that employ demographic quotas display relatively higher amounts of representativeness across multiple indicators (beyond demographics) but often exhibit less response validity. However, the inclusion of two attention checks early in a study enhances response validity without negatively impacting representativeness. We offer guidance for choosing opt-in samples, depending on the purpose of the research and resource constraints.
- Open Access
- 9 May 2025
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 122 (19)
Durably reducing partisan animosity through multiple scalable treatments
Recent research has identified several effective strategies for reducing Americans’ animosity toward supporters of opposing political parties. However, whether these strategies can durably reduce partisan animosity in a scalable manner and in everyday life remains unclear. We bridge the gap between prior research and useful application by assessing whether exposure to multiple, scalable treatments that portray inparty and outparty members interacting positively, receiving accurate information about one another’s views, and learning about cross-party similarities can a) durably shift partisans’ sentiments and b) influence partisans’ sentiments toward specific, personally known others encountered in everyday life—not only general, hypothetical, or one-off rival partisans. In a longitudinal survey experiment, we find that exposure to three brief, scalable treatments over a week reduces partisan animosity, with effects persisting for at least a month. Moreover, the treatments durably ameliorate animosity toward both general outparty members and a personally known outparty member, specified prior to the treatments. These findings suggest promising avenues for redressing social divisions in real-world contexts.
- 9 May 2025
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 122 (19)
Open AccessDurably reducing partisan animosity through multiple scalable treatments
Recent research has identified several effective strategies for reducing Americans’ animosity toward supporters of opposing political parties. However, whether these strategies can durably reduce partisan animosity in a scalable manner and in everyday life remains unclear. We bridge the gap between prior research and useful application by assessing whether exposure to multiple, scalable treatments that portray inparty and outparty members interacting positively, receiving accurate information about one another’s views, and learning about cross-party similarities can a) durably shift partisans’ sentiments and b) influence partisans’ sentiments toward specific, personally known others encountered in everyday life—not only general, hypothetical, or one-off rival partisans. In a longitudinal survey experiment, we find that exposure to three brief, scalable treatments over a week reduces partisan animosity, with effects persisting for at least a month. Moreover, the treatments durably ameliorate animosity toward both general outparty members and a personally known outparty member, specified prior to the treatments. These findings suggest promising avenues for redressing social divisions in real-world contexts.
- Open Access
- 23 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 16 (1) , 1-10
Factual knowledge can reduce attitude polarization
It is commonly argued that factual knowledge about a political issue increases attitude polarization due to politically motivated reasoning. By this account, individuals ignore counter-attitudinal facts and direct their attention to pro-attitudinal facts; reject counter-attitudinal facts when directly confronted with them; and use pro-attitudinal facts to counterargue, all making them more polarized. The observation that more knowledgeable partisans are often more polarized is widely taken as support for this account. Yet these data are only correlational. Here, we directly test the causal effect of increasing issue-relevant knowledge on attitude polarization. Specifically, we randomize whether N = 1,011 participants receive a large, credible set of both pro- and counter-attitudinal facts on a contentious political issue – gun control – and provide a modest incentive for them to learn this information. We find evidence that people are willing to engage with and learn policy-relevant facts both for and against their initial attitudes; and that this increased factual knowledge shifts individuals towards more moderate policy attitudes, a durable effect that is still visible after one month. Our results suggest that the impact of directionally motivated reasoning on the processing of political information might be more limited than previously thought.
- 23 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Communications
- Vol. 16 (1) , 1-10
Open AccessFactual knowledge can reduce attitude polarization
It is commonly argued that factual knowledge about a political issue increases attitude polarization due to politically motivated reasoning. By this account, individuals ignore counter-attitudinal facts and direct their attention to pro-attitudinal facts; reject counter-attitudinal facts when directly confronted with them; and use pro-attitudinal facts to counterargue, all making them more polarized. The observation that more knowledgeable partisans are often more polarized is widely taken as support for this account. Yet these data are only correlational. Here, we directly test the causal effect of increasing issue-relevant knowledge on attitude polarization. Specifically, we randomize whether N = 1,011 participants receive a large, credible set of both pro- and counter-attitudinal facts on a contentious political issue – gun control – and provide a modest incentive for them to learn this information. We find evidence that people are willing to engage with and learn policy-relevant facts both for and against their initial attitudes; and that this increased factual knowledge shifts individuals towards more moderate policy attitudes, a durable effect that is still visible after one month. Our results suggest that the impact of directionally motivated reasoning on the processing of political information might be more limited than previously thought.
- 21 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Human Behaviour
- Vol. 8 (12) , 2257-2260
How to design and conduct a megastudy
- 21 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Human Behaviour
- Vol. 8 (12) , 2257-2260
How to design and conduct a megastudy
- Open Access
- 14 January 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Academics Are More Specific, and Practitioners More Sensitive, in Forecasting Interventions to Strengthen Democratic Attitudes
Concern over democratic erosion has led to a proliferation of proposed interventions to strengthen democratic attitudes in the United States. Resource constraints, however, prevent implementing all proposed interventions. One approach to identify promising interventions entails leveraging domain experts, who have knowledge regarding a given field, to forecast the effectiveness of candidate interventions. We recruit experts who develop general knowledge about a social problem (academics), experts who directly intervene on the problem (practitioners), and non-experts from the public to forecast the effectiveness of interventions to reduce partisan animosity, support for undemocratic practices, and support for partisan violence. Comparing 14,076 forecasts submitted by 1,181 forecasters against the results of a mega-experiment (n=32,059) that tested 75 hypothesized effects of interventions, we find that both types of experts outperformed members of the public, though experts differed in how they were accurate. While academics’ predictions were more specific (i.e., they identified a larger proportion of ineffective interventions, and had fewer false positive forecasts), practitioners’ predictions were more sensitive (i.e., they identified a larger proportion of effective interventions, and had fewer false negative forecasts). Consistent with this, practitioners were better at predicting best-performing interventions, while academics were superior in predicting which interventions performed worst. Our paper highlights the importance of differentiating types of experts and types of accuracy. We conclude by discussing factors that affect whether sensitive or specific forecasters are preferable, such as the relative cost of false positives and negatives, and the expected rate of intervention success.
- 14 January 2024
- Published by Center for Open Science in OSF Preprints
Open AccessAcademics Are More Specific, and Practitioners More Sensitive, in Forecasting Interventions to Strengthen Democratic Attitudes
Concern over democratic erosion has led to a proliferation of proposed interventions to strengthen democratic attitudes in the United States. Resource constraints, however, prevent implementing all proposed interventions. One approach to identify promising interventions entails leveraging domain experts, who have knowledge regarding a given field, to forecast the effectiveness of candidate interventions. We recruit experts who develop general knowledge about a social problem (academics), experts who directly intervene on the problem (practitioners), and non-experts from the public to forecast the effectiveness of interventions to reduce partisan animosity, support for undemocratic practices, and support for partisan violence. Comparing 14,076 forecasts submitted by 1,181 forecasters against the results of a mega-experiment (n=32,059) that tested 75 hypothesized effects of interventions, we find that both types of experts outperformed members of the public, though experts differed in how they were accurate. While academics’ predictions were more specific (i.e., they identified a larger proportion of ineffective interventions, and had fewer false positive forecasts), practitioners’ predictions were more sensitive (i.e., they identified a larger proportion of effective interventions, and had fewer false negative forecasts). Consistent with this, practitioners were better at predicting best-performing interventions, while academics were superior in predicting which interventions performed worst. Our paper highlights the importance of differentiating types of experts and types of accuracy. We conclude by discussing factors that affect whether sensitive or specific forecasters are preferable, such as the relative cost of false positives and negatives, and the expected rate of intervention success.