NMNatalia Muzykantova

Natalia Muzykantova

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Natalia Muzykantova has a total of 16 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • PROFESSIONAL SATISFACTION AND ORGANIZATIONAL WORKING CONDITIONS OF DISTRICT THERAPISTS AS FACTORS OF WORKFORCE STABILITY IN STATE POLYCLINICS

    by Irina Arshukova, Igor Akulin, Elena Dobretsova, Igor Platonov, Oleg Kalinichenko, Irina Nam, Ekaterina Chesnokova, Natalia Muzykantova

    Significance. District therapists are pivotal to the effective operation of the primary healthcare. Their level of professional satisfaction is considered an important factor of workforce stability of medical organizations and quality of medical care provided. Unfavorable working conditions, high administrative burdens, and insufficient organizational support can lead to decreased professional satisfaction, burnout, and increased turnover. Therefore, identifying organizational factors associated with the professional satisfaction of district therapists is an important task for improving workforce stability in state polyclinics. Purpose. To identify differences between district physicians satisfied and dissatisfied with their work, based on key characteristics of work organization, workload, and perceptions of working conditions. Material and methods. The study was conducted from November 2024 to May 2025 using an anonymized online survey. 582 district physicians working in state polyclinics and representing various regions of the Russian Federation participated in the survey. Statistical data processing was performed using the Python programming language. Results. Statistically significant differences were found between district therapists satisfied and dissatisfied with their work across a number of work organization and workload characteristics. Among those satisfied, 48.5% (95% CI: 43.1-53.9%) chose a state polyclinic as their preferred place of work, while among those dissatisfied, only 4.0% (95% CI: 2.2-7.2%), p < 0.001. Organizational characteristics such as allocated time for maintaining medical records, admitting patients on sick leave, and breaks during outpatient appointments, as well as the presence of dedicated medical teams responsible for conducting medical examinations, were associated with higher levels of professional satisfaction among district therapists. In addition, in polyclinics where doctors are characterized by a higher level of satisfaction with working conditions, according to experts, there is a higher proportion of young doctors continuing to work a year after employment (p < 0.001). Conclusion. Professional satisfaction of district therapists is significantly linked to the work organization in state polyclinics. The presence of structured workflow elements, a more rational distribution of workload, and the availability of specialists of key specialties can be considered as factors contributing to increased professional satisfaction and high workforce stability in primary care. Keywords: state polyclinic; district therapist; professional satisfaction; working conditions; workforce stability

  • THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SELF-ASSESSMENTS OF HEALTH AND ATTITUDES TOWARDS IT AND THE LEVEL OF EDUCATION IN INDIVIDUALS OF REPRODUCTIVE AGE

    by Natalia Muzykantova, Vyacheslav Zaporozhchenko, Galina Evdokushkina

    Significance. Demographic policy issues receive considerable attention, and the health of individuals of reproductive age is of paramount importance in shaping healthy offspring. Therefore, issues related to the health of the reproductive-age population are particularly pressing. Heterogeneity in self-assessed health responses depends on gender, marital status, education, place of residence, and age. However, it is not entirely clear whether this impact of educational level is the same for young people as it is for older individuals of reproductive age. Purpose. To assess the impact of education level on the perception of one's health and attitudes towards its maintenance in individuals of early and late reproductive age. Material and methods. Data from the 2020 "Demographic Well-Being of Russia" research project, conducted in 10 constituent entities of the Russian Federation, were used. The total sample size was 4,300 people aged 20-49 (2,136 men and 2,164 women). Responses about health maintenance were compared across two age groups of men and women, depending on three levels of education. Results. Among young respondents of reproductive age, men with a primary education are most likely to rate their health as good, while women with a higher education are more likely to rate their health as good. Compared to young adults, the proportion of poor health ratings among women over 35 with a primary education is significantly higher, while in other age groups, these proportions vary little across age groups. Men with a primary education and women with a primary education aged 35 and older are the least likely to consider their lifestyle healthy, while respondents with a higher education are the most likely to rate their lifestyle as healthy. The proportion of respondents who smoke decreases with increasing education level, regardless of age. Young men with a secondary education and men aged 35-49 with a higher education are the most likely to abuse smoking. A direct correlation is observed between young respondents' attitudes toward maintaining and improving their health and their level of education. The higher the level of education, the lower the proportion of those who take no special steps to maintain and improve their health, and those who, when health problems arise, do not seek treatment, hoping they will resolve themselves. Among young respondents, the higher the level of education, the better their reproductive health. Among the older respondents, those with a secondary education were the least likely to affirm their fertility, while men with higher education and women with primary education were the most likely. Among women, the lowest rates of childlessness were observed in the group with primary education and the highest in the group with higher education. Conclusion. It seems appropriate to take measures to encourage university students to have children and strengthen socioeconomic support for student families. Guaranteed opportunities to continue education after maternity leave could help reduce the incidence of delayed first births, which, along with a more attentive attitude among those with higher education toward maintaining and improving their health, will lead to improved health for the population as a whole. Keywords: healthy lifestyle; self-preservation behavior; behavioral risk factors; reproductive health; having children

  • SELF-PRESERVATION BEHAVIOR OF WORKING-AGE PATIENTS WITH A HISTORY OF MYOCARDIAL INFARCTION AND HYPERTENSION

    by Aleksandr Zubko, Tamara Sabgayda, Natalia Muzykantova

    Significance. To reduce the risk of complications of circulatory diseases, a healthy lifestyle is required. It is logical to assume that after a myocardial infarction, which is often accompanied by severe pain and physical limitations, patients will become more responsible for their health and more likely to follow a healthy lifestyle than patients with hypertension, which is often asymptomatic. Purpose. For people of working age, to compare the spread of behavioral risk factors for the development of complications of cardiovascular diseases in patients with myocardial infarction and patients with hypertension. Materials and methods. The analysis of data obtained by Rosstat in 2023 during a sample observation of the health status of the population was carried out. The answers of men aged 18-64 and women aged 18-59 to 29 questions from different sections of the questionnaire related to risk factors for developing cardiovascular diseases were analyzed. The response rates were compared between 4,582 men and 5,184 women who indicated a diagnosis of hypertension, and 378 men and 91 women who indicated a history of myocardial infarction. On the basis of the contingency tables, the odds ratio and their confidence intervals were calculated in the Statistica-6 program. Results. Statistically significant differences in self-assessments of health and psychological well-being of the respondents of the compared groups (p<0.0001) were revealed. Differences in the frequency of adherence of groups to risk factors for the development of cardiovascular diseases were found only for men. Men with hypertension are more likely to: use tobacco products daily (p=0.0005), constantly add salt to ready-made food (p=0.04), have high physical activity at work (p<0.0001), drink alcohol on a regular basis (p=0.02), self-medicate in case of health problems (p<0.0001), do not adhere to the prescribed treatment (p=0.01). There were no differences in the frequency of: eating foods with high salt content, physical inactivity, excessive consumption of bakery products and sugary carbonated drinks, simultaneous consumption of large doses of alcohol, visits to doctors. The prevalence of behavioral risk factors is lower among women with hypertension who consider their health to be good, and higher among women with myocardial infarction who consider their health to be poor. Conclusion. The hypothesis of increased motivation to lead a healthy lifestyle in patients who have suffered a myocardial infarction is not rejected: behavioral risk factors for developing cardiovascular complications are somewhat more common among men with hypertension than among men who have suffered a myocardial infarction. The lower frequency of some bad habits is more associated with the respondents' poor health than with past pain associated with a myocardial infarction. The only exception is the lower proportion of daily smokers among men with myocardial infarction, which does not depend on their health status. Considering the dependence of respondents' responses on their self-assessments of their health status, it can be concluded that the high frequency of food poisoning in the group of men with hypertension is due to the fact that this behavior was initially the cause of the disease, and that the recommended change in working hours in order to reduce physical exertion is not the recommendations of doctors, but the current well-being of patients. Respondents with myocardial infarction are more likely to regularly take medications for the treatment of arterial hypertension prescribed by their doctors, which is more likely to be explained by the worse health of people with myocardial infarction on average. Compared to men, smoking and alcohol abuse in women are presumably more likely to be the initial causes of myocardial infarction than other risk factors. Keywords: myocardial infarction; arterial hypertension; risk factors; self-preservation behavior; self-assessment of health

  • ZONING THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION BY CAUSE OF DEATH

    by Tamara Sabgaida, Aleksandr Zubko, Natalia Muzykantova

    Significance. Regional mortality differences are determined by a large number of factors, among which the issues related to regional health systems are not always the leading ones. To ensure a rapid increase in life expectancy in Russia, identifying a group of regions with an objective possibility of reducing mortality through efforts of medical organizations is relevant. The purpose of the study is to develop a methodology for operational zoning of the Russian Federation by cause of death to identify possible problems in regional healthcare. Material and methods. The study used Rosstat data on the number of deaths, population and life expectancy at birth in 83 constituent entities of the Russian Federation (excluding Crimea and new territories) in 2022. Standardized mortality rates from main causes of death and all causes were calculated. Potential years of life lost (PYLL) per 1000 population were calculated. Ranks of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation by mortality and PYLL were determined. Spearman's rank correlation coefficients of mortality rates and PYLL with life expectancy for the entire population, age groups of 20-59 years and 60 + were calculated. The methodology was based on the difference in the ranks of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation by various basis. The study did not include the Republic of Crimea and the city of Sevastopol, since statistics on these regions for the study period is not complete. Results. In case the region's rank in terms of mortality from a certain class of causes differs significantly from its rank in terms of mortality from all causes (more than 30 points), we conclude that there are factors that can be eliminated. The highest number of regions with mortality above the expected level was noted for diseases of the endocrine system (23 regions), infectious and parasitic diseases (13) and diseases of the nervous system (8). For the same classes of diseases, there is the highest number of regions with mortality below the expected level (18, 14 and 14, respectively). The discrepancy between the ranks of the regions in terms of mortality and YPLL indicates a younger or older average age at death than is expected at a given mortality rate under current conditions. The highest number of regions with an average age at death younger than expected and a rank difference of more than 5 points were noted for diseases of the endocrine system (8), respiratory diseases (5) and diseases of the nervous system (4). The highest number of regions with YPLL lower than expected is noted for diseases of the endocrine system (15), diseases of the nervous system (7) and neoplasms (5). Regions with possible problems in healthcare by main class of diseases have been identified. In most cases, the number of regions with a discrepancy in ranks towards lower mortality or YPLL is greater than the number of regions with a discrepancy in ranks towards higher mortality rates or YPLL. The exceptions include diseases of the endocrine system and diseases of the respiratory system. A correlation analysis shows that mortality rate from diseases of the nervous system and from infectious diseases at working age significantly affects YPLL with a relatively small impact on death in old ages. Discussion. For diseases of the endocrine system and diseases of the nervous system, the most frequent discrepancy in ranks in both directions was noted, both in terms of mortality rates and YPLL, which may indicate different approaches to disease coding. This conclusion is consistent with the results of other studies. The inconsistency of ranks in the analysis of mortality from diseases of the endocrine system can also be explained by a diverse situation with risk factors associated with endocrine morbidity, while a higher number of regions with a discrepancy in ranks towards higher YPLL is most likely to be due to peculiarities of the organization of medical care delivery to patients with respiratory diseases, which is confirmed by the results of a study by other authors. Conclusion. The proposed methodology rather adequately allows us to identify situations with a possible problem in the region related to prevention of mortality from any class of death causes, as well as to identify missed opportunities for increasing life expectancy of the Russian population. Combining the results of comparing ranks by mortality rate and YPLL makes it possible to identify weaknesses in health protection in a region.

  • MORTALITY ASSOCIATED WITH PREVENTABLE CAUSES OF DEATHS FROM CARDIO-VASCULAR DISEASES IN THE PRE-COVID PERIOD AND DURING THE PANDEMIC IN RUSSIA

    by Aleksandr Zubko, Tamara Sabgaida, Viktoriya Semyonova, Nataliya Muzykantova

    Significance. The healthcare system can manage preventable causes of death if timely and effective interventions are in place including interventions aimed at improving living conditions and lifestyle of the population. Which diseases of the circulatory system are preventable? These are chronic rheumatic heart diseases and arterial hypertension at least in ages 5-64, and cerebrovascular diseases. The updated list of treatable diseases includes ischemic heart disease originally considered as a non-manageable cause. In the pre-COVID period the mortality structure underwent quality changes in terms of diseases and age distribution since the impact of preventive measures can manifest itself both in the decreased share of preventable causes and increased life expectancy of patients with cardio-vascular diseases. Did the gain in the age structure of preventable mortality from cardio-vascular diseases (CVD) sustain during the pandemic? The purpose of the study is to analyze contribution of preventable causes to cardio-vascular diseases mortality in the pre-COVID period and during the pandemic in Russia. Material and methods. The study used ROSSTAT data (Russian Federal State Statistics Service) to analyze data on cardio-vascular diseases mortality in the Russian Federation in 1999-2021. Male and female mortality was calculated for ages 5-64 years – the age interval of preventability. Since access to health care and risk factors of cardio-vascular diseases differ among urban and rural settings, rural and urban mortality was analyzed separately. Potential years of life lost (PYLL) were calculated as the sum products of the absolute number of deaths and potential years lost in each age group divided by 10 000 population of the corresponding age. Results. In most cases, the contribution of preventable causes to cardio-vascular diseases mortality in ages 5-64 has been steadily decreasing since 2003. The share of chronic rheumatic heart diseases equaling to less than one percent in males in the beginning of the century has decreased more than 3-fold during the pandemic. Similar trends are registered in female mortality, yet at higher rates. It should be emphasized here that mortality from chronic rheumatic heart diseases has been reducing since the end of the last century including throughout the period of social and economic collapse. The contribution of arterial hypertension to cardio-vascular diseases mortality is also low. The highest contribution to cardio-vascular diseases mortality is made by ischemic heart disease. Unlike other diseases under study, its contribution is higher among male urban population. Heart failure is associated with the lowest contribution to cardio-vascular diseases mortality. During the pandemic, its share has decreased in male mortality while hardly changed in females. The contribution of cerebrovascular diseases to cardio-vascular diseases mortality has significantly decreased sustaining this decline throughout the pandemic. In general, the contribution of preventable causes to cardio-vascular diseases mortality in ages 5-64 has been steadily reducing in males from 79.9% in 2003 to 72.7% in 2019 and to 71.6% in 2021 and in females from 80.5%% to 69.5% and 69.8%, respectively. The contribution of preventable causes in male mortality is higher among urban population compared to rural one (73.1% versus 71.3% in 2019, 71.9% versus 70.7% in 2021), while mortality in urban and rural females is almost the same. Conclusion. Analysis of preventable causes of cardio-vascular diseases mortality concludes as follows: First, it is those causes that have contributed the most to the decrease in mortality; Second, at the preventability age interval, the impact of preventive measures manifests itself in changes in mortality from ischemic heart disease and cerebrovascular diseases. Third, to ensure reduction in male mortality from cerebrovascular diseases it is necessary to intensify measures aimed at preventing alcohol use. Forth, it makes sense to analyze effectiveness of measures aimed at preventing avoidable mortality from diseases of the circulatory system using PYLL-70.


  • COMMITMENT TO PHYSICAL EXERCISES AMONG STUDENTS WITH DIFFERENT SELF-ASSESSMENT OF HEALTH

    by T.P. Sabgayda, A.V. Zubko, E.V. Zemlyanova, O.V. Khodakova, N.N. Muzykantova, S.V. Gubarev, A.N. Redko

    Significance. Regular physical activity strengthens health and improves well-being, therefore, increasing commitment to physical activity among population is rather relevant. Students of medical universities will become guides to a healthy lifestyle for their future patients, which implies their commitment to regular physical activity. Personal interest in promoting health through physical exercises presumably depends upon the health status of students. Purpose: to analyze commitment to physical exercises among students with different self-assessment of health. Material and Methods. The analysis of 1732 questionnaires collected during the survey of students of the Kuban State Medical University was carried out. Responders included 25.7% of young males, 35.0% of the first-year students and 11.9% of the sixth-year students. The average age of males and females is the same (21.9 years). The analysis of commitment to physical exercises was carried out among all respondents in general and with a breakdown on gender, year in the University (first and sixth year students), health self-assessment (“good health and very good” and “bad health and very bad”), self-assessment of the concern for health (“I care a lot” and “I care little or not at all”), and presence of chronic diseases (yes/no). The Chi-square test was used to compare distribution of different opinions. Conclusion. Commitment to physical exercises among students is associated with health self-estimation rather than the state of health. The state of health increases motivation to exercise only among a small share of students with poor health. Awareness of the impact of physical activity on the risk of chronic diseases is not sufficient to increase commitment of the young people to exercise, sports or fitness. The highest impact on the commitment is made by the "fashion trend" for a healthy lifestyle. Students who define their state of health as good are more concerned about their health and significantly more often practice regular physical activity of high intensity. For young males with good health social contacts are more significant in physical exercises both in comparison with females who define their state of health as good and in comparison with young men with lower self-estimation of health. For students with low health self-estimation, the main incentive for physical activities, sports or fitness is the desire to look better. Doctor's recommendations are a twice more effective incentive for females compared to males.