APA. M. Protsenko

A. M. Protsenko

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


A. M. Protsenko has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Biological samples for examination: concepts, conditions, sampling tactics

    by M. H. Shcherbakovskyi, A. M. Protsenko, A. E. Volkova

    During the commission of crimes, traces of biological origin are left on the objects of the environment, tools, clothing, and the body of the participants. To conduct an identification study, an expert needs to compare the traces of the crime with biological samples of the person being tested. Criteria for determining biological samples are proposed. The biological criterion means that the samples reflect the internal and external properties of a person as a biological organism. The informational criterion is that the samples meet certain requirements: undoubted origin, required quantity, proper quality, compatibility with traces of crime. The identification criterion establishes that the human properties reflected by the samples are individual, stable, cannot be deliberately altered by a person and are suitable for identification. The procedural criterion means that biological samples must be collected in a lawful manner. Based on these criteria, biological samples for examination include: body parts; secretions as products of human activity; imprints of the skin relief of the human body. The mandatory participants in the collection of biological samples as a procedural action are: persons from whom biological samples are collected; officials who conduct the collection of samples and are responsible for its legality and validity; a specialist or expert; witnesses; employees of the relevant law enforcement agencies (in the case of compulsory collection of biological samples). Optional participants are a defence counsel, legal representative, representative, lawyer, doctor at their request. During the compulsory collection of biological samples, in order to ensure the legality, objectivity, reliability of the objects of expert research, preservation of health and observance of human rights, it is necessary to comply with legal, ethical, medical and forensic conditions. The author proposes a general algorithm for the tactics of obtaining biological samples for examination at the stage of pre-trial investigation, which includes the preparatory, working and final stages.

  • Open Access

    Evaluation of Expert Research Results Based on the Probabilistic Approach (on Published Foreign Papers)

    by Mykhailo Shcherbakovskyi, Anna Protsenko

    The Research Paper Purpose is to analyze the genesis of procedural and scientific principles of modern foreign standards for evaluating expert research results; clarify uncertainty sources that result in ambiguous expert conclusions; substantiate the need to use the probabilistic (Bayesian) approach while formulation of forensic experts’ answers. To fulfil this goal, the following research methods have been chosen: historical and legal; systemic and structural; comparative legal; formal and legal. The procedural, epistemological and doctrinal factors complicating evaluation of the objectivity and veracity of the expert conclusion in domestic law enforcement practice are named. Evaluation standards of expert evidence at different times throughout the world have been analyzed (universal adoption of the Frye standard, substantiation and validation of the Daubert standard, prove beyond a reasonable doubt). It is emphasized that provision of probable conclusions by the forensic expert is due to a continuum of uncertainties, which source are peculiarities of the formation of crime traces and methods of collecting traces at the scene, the level of expertise development and methodologies of expert research, interpretation and evaluation of forensic examination results. To shape the expert’s conviction in research findings, a statistical Bayesian method of establishing the likelihood ratio is proposed, which enables to evaluate significance of versions proposed by the forensic expert and is the basis for the court to take a reasoned decision. The probabilistic approach is proposed to be applied both for evaluation of a random coincidence of features when identifying forensic examination objects, as well as in relation to possible errors in laboratory tests and interpretation of results drawn by a forensic expert.


  • Критерії та види процесуальних порушень як підстави недопустимості висновку експерта

    by М. Г. Щербаковський, М. В. Дементьєв, А. М. Проценко

    У статті розглянуто питання допустимості висновку експерта у кримінальному провадженні. Допустимість визначено як характеристикy доказів, до якої висуваються певні вимоги. Допустимість висновку експерта має особливості, оскільки у процесуальній формі проводиться дослідження спеціальним суб'єктом, а результатом є доказ як вивідне знання. Доведено, що допустимість висновку експерта визначається не тільки процесуальною формою, але й змістом документу. На підставі узагальнення правозастосовної практики процесуальні порушення, що є підставами визнання експертного висновку недопустимим, класифіковані за двома критеріями: відповідно до етапів проведення експертизи (підготовка та призначення експертизи, провадження експертизи, використання висновку експерта в доказуванні) й тяжкістю наслідків. Порушеннями на етапі підготовки та призначення експертизи є: процесуальні порушення у збиранні об’єктів експертного дослідження; невідомість походження зразків порівняння, несправжність наданих на експертизу об’єктів; неуповноважений суб’єкт призначення та проведення експертизи. Порушеннями на етапі провадження експертизи бувають: невідповідність експерта вимогам до нього як учасника процесу, вихід експерта за межі компетенції; недотримання форми висновку експерта. Порушення на етапі використання висновку експерта в доказуванні – це невідкриття слідчими органами стороні захисту висновку експерта наприкінці досудового розслідування. За критерієм тяжкості наслідків виокремлені три групи процесуальних порушень допустимості висновку експерта: 1) очевидні порушення, які включають й істотні порушення, що не можуть бути усунені та викликають безумовне визнання висновку експерта недопустимим; 2) умовні порушення, які можуть бути усунуті процесуальними діями й дозволяють визнати висновок експерта допустимим джерелом доказів; 3) несуттєві порушення, які не вимагають усунення та дозволяють визнати висновок експерта допустимим, незважаючи на те, що окремі його складові формально порушують процесуальні вимоги.


  • Open Access

    Comparative legal analysis of the expertise in court under the criminal law of Ukraine and CIS countries

    by A. N. Protsenko

    A comparative analysis of the expertise during the criminal proceedings in accordance with the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine and the Republics of Azerbaijan, Belarus, Armenia, Kyrgyzstan, Estonia, Kazakhstan, Moldova, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan and the Russian Federation has been carried out. Proposals were submitted to the domestic Criminal Procedure Code to increase the efficiency of the expertise in court. It is proved that in a situation of passivity of the parties to the criminal proceedings and the victim to make an informed decision in case it is necessary to establish certain circumstances of the offense, the court has the right to appoint an examination on its own initiative without any restrictions. The expertise appointed in court in respect of the expertise carried out in the pre-trial investigation may be additional, repeated or new. The expert is summoned to court for expertise, when: new circumstances have been established in the court proceedings that require research; several examinations were conducted at the pre-trial stage and experts came to the opposite conclusion; previously conducted expert research is incomplete. Expertise in court may be conducted by an expert (experts) who gave an opinion during the pre-trial investigation, or another expert (experts) appointed by the court, or both experts together. The expert who conducted the expertise during the pre-trial investigation, or the specialist to whom the expertise will be assigned, summoned to court, have the right to participate in the expertise of objects and documents, conduct court proceedings related to the subject of expertise, discuss issues and objects for expertise, to specify the term of expertise. After the examination, the expert must announce the opinion in court and may be questioned to supplement and clarify the opinion. The presiding judge at the request of the parties should provide an opportunity to study in detail the conclusion of the expertise conducted in court.