MSMikhailo Shcherbakovskyi

Mikhailo Shcherbakovskyi

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Mikhailo Shcherbakovskyi has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Evaluation of Expert Research Results Based on the Probabilistic Approach (on Published Foreign Papers)

    by Mykhailo Shcherbakovskyi, Anna Protsenko

    The Research Paper Purpose is to analyze the genesis of procedural and scientific principles of modern foreign standards for evaluating expert research results; clarify uncertainty sources that result in ambiguous expert conclusions; substantiate the need to use the probabilistic (Bayesian) approach while formulation of forensic experts’ answers. To fulfil this goal, the following research methods have been chosen: historical and legal; systemic and structural; comparative legal; formal and legal. The procedural, epistemological and doctrinal factors complicating evaluation of the objectivity and veracity of the expert conclusion in domestic law enforcement practice are named. Evaluation standards of expert evidence at different times throughout the world have been analyzed (universal adoption of the Frye standard, substantiation and validation of the Daubert standard, prove beyond a reasonable doubt). It is emphasized that provision of probable conclusions by the forensic expert is due to a continuum of uncertainties, which source are peculiarities of the formation of crime traces and methods of collecting traces at the scene, the level of expertise development and methodologies of expert research, interpretation and evaluation of forensic examination results. To shape the expert’s conviction in research findings, a statistical Bayesian method of establishing the likelihood ratio is proposed, which enables to evaluate significance of versions proposed by the forensic expert and is the basis for the court to take a reasoned decision. The probabilistic approach is proposed to be applied both for evaluation of a random coincidence of features when identifying forensic examination objects, as well as in relation to possible errors in laboratory tests and interpretation of results drawn by a forensic expert.


  • Open Access

    Problems of investigation of medical crimes in Ukraine

    by Ruslan Stepaniuk, Mikhailo Shcherbakovskyi, Vasyl Kikinchuk, Iryna Petrova, Vadym Babakin

    In the article, the authors identified the main reasons for the low level of investigation of medical crimes in Ukraine based on the analysis of 78 criminal cases of medical malpractice considered by courts since 2013, the study of statistical information, scientific literature on the problems of investigating medical crimes, national legislation. It was concluded there are significant problems with the investigation of medical crimes in Ukraine. Less than one percent of the number of initiated criminal cases is sent to court. Most of the cases sent to court end with a guilty verdict, however, medical workers are released from real deprivation or restriction of freedom for various reasons. According to the specialties of medical workers, the most criminogenic are obstetrics and gynecology, surgery, anesthesiology, and emergency care for injuries and internal diseases. Methods of committing medical crimes are associated with using incorrect methods of providing medical care and with the untimely or incorrect diagnosis of the disease. The problems of investigating medical crimes in Ukraine are due to a number of reasons, including the closeness of the results of the post-mortem examination of the corpse to relatives of the deceased, the lack of independent forensic medical examination institutions in Ukraine, and gaps in the legal regulation of the protection of medical records from unauthorized access. This greatly complicates the establishment of a causal relationship between the actions or inaction of medical workers and the negative consequences that have occurred.


  • Open Access

    Verification of the expert’s opinion

    by M. H. Shcherbakovskyi, M. V. Dementiev

    The expert’s opinion must be checked and evaluated by the subject of the evidence in accordance with the procedural law. The analysis of the literature shows that scientists mainly focus on assessment problems, neglecting the issue of verifying the expert’s opinion. This is due to the fact that processual scientists perceive verification as a type of collection, research, and evaluation of evidence in the theory of evidence. It has been proven that the verification of evidence in general and the expert’s opinion in particular differ from other elements of the proof process in terms of objects, purpose, and methods of implementation. The objects of examination of the expert’s opinion are doubtful circumstances regarding certain aspects of the conducted examination and contradictions between the expert's conclusions and other evidence. The purpose of checking the expert’s opinion is to confirm or eliminate, to refute doubts about the admissibility and reliability of the expert’s opinion and contradictions of the results of the examination with the circumstances already established in the criminal proceedings. The subject of the inspection coincides with the assessment and consists in determining the admissibility and reliability of the expert’s conclusion as a source of evidence and factual data established by expert research. Verification of the expert’s opinion is carried out by conducting procedural and non-procedural measures aimed at obtaining new data. Procedural measures include: appointment of a new examination to resolve the same questions from the study of the same objects under inspection; interrogation of the expert and other participants in the criminal proceedings in order to establish the circumstances relating to the subject of the examination, as well as information on the peculiarities of the origin, existence, exploitation, seizure, storage of objects of examination; demand for objects and documents that can establish the factual data necessary in the case; receiving oral consultations and written explanations from a specialist (non-procedural measures provide indicative information through consultations with specialists and receiving a review of the expert’s opinion from them); familiarization of the initiator of the appointment of expertise with the scientific and methodical literature for comparison of the conducted expert research in accordance with the requirements existing in the expert field.


  • Open Access

    The standard of forensic report veracity in criminal proceedings

    by Mykhailo Shcherbakovskyi

    Procedural (relevance and admissibility) and epistemological (due quality of objects, accuracy of source data, approved research methodology was applied) conditions and criteria (epistemological: scientific, methodological and logical substantiation of expert conclusions, procedural: compliance with other case files) that together determine veracity of the expert conclusion are outlined. The Article Purpose is to analyze views of scientists concerning veracity of evidence in general and the expert conclusion in particular; clarify circumstances preceding the expert conclusion and conditioning its accuracy; emphasize epistemological and procedural criteria for this characteristic and compare with the procedure for determining veracity of forensic examination in the countries of the Anglo-Saxon Legal Family and develop a standard based on which veracity of the forensic report can be established by results of performed research. The scientific and methodological substantiation presupposes general and specific substantiation of research results of submitted objects. The logical substantiation is argumentation of the expert’s interim and final conclusions. The criterion for procedural veracity of the forensic report is in its consistency, compliance with other pieces of evidence. It is advisable to use the standard of proof “beyond a reasonable doubt” to determine conformity of the forensic report with objective reality. The standard of forensic report veracity implies that conditions of relevance and admissibility of the forensic report are met, objects submitted for forensic examination are of appropriate quality, expert conclusions are based on general scientific and methodological provisions and results of a particular expert research stemming from them, logically reasoned, conformed with other pieces of evidence in a criminal proceeding and recognized as corresponding to actual circumstances of the offense beyond any reasonable doubt.


  • Open Access

    Evidentiary problems in the investigation of corruption crimes in Ukraine

    by Mikhailo Shcherbakovskyi, Ruslan Stepaniuk, Vasyl Kikinchuk, Oleksiy Oderiy, Liudmyla Svyrydova

    The fight against corruption in Ukraine is one of the main tasks of law enforcement agencies. However, the process of proving corruption crimes in criminal cases is accompanied by problems that negatively affect the quality of the pre-trial investigation. The purpose of the article is to identify and study typical investigative errors and develop recommendations on the proper use of means and methods of proof in criminal cases of corruption crimes, taking into account the norms of national legislation and international criteria for ensuring human rights in criminal proceedings. To achieve this goal, a comparative and systemic structural analysis of international and domestic regulatory legal acts and court decisions, a selective study of materials from criminal cases on corruption crimes were made. It has been established that the process of proving in cases of corruption crimes in Ukraine will fully comply with international standards for ensuring human rights, provided that operational officers, investigators, and prosecutors comply with the admissibility criterion of evidence, especially when using secret measures. Investigative errors that take place at the stage of pre-trial investigation in this category of criminal cases lead to the restriction of human rights and freedoms and consist in significant violations of the criminal procedural law when collecting, checking, and evaluating evidence, as well as when opening the collected materials to the defense. Preventing such violations requires strict adherence to the general requirements for conducting undercover activities, formulated in the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights and domestic courts. The proof must take into account the "fruit of the poisonous tree" doctrine of the inadmissibility of evidence derived from materials collected in violation of the law. The defense side should be provided with timely access to the materials of covert events, including the documents that served as the basis for their implementation. It is important not to allow actions that are regarded as a provocation (incitement) of the suspect to commit a corruption offense.