BSBrendan James Smith

Brendan James Smith

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Brendan James Smith has a total of 18 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Quantitative estimate of several sources of uncertainty in drone-based methane emission measurements

    by Tannaz H. Mohammadloo, Matthew Jones, Bas van de Kerkhof, Kyle Dawson, Brendan J. Smith, Stephen Conley, Abigail Corbett, Rutger Ijzermans

    Site-level measurements of methane emissions are used by operators for reconciliation with bottom-up emission inventories with the aim to improve accuracy, thoroughness, and confidence in reported emissions. In that context it is of critical importance to avoid measurement errors and to understand the measurement uncertainty. Remotely piloted aircraft systems (commonly referred to as “drones”) can play a pivotal role in the quantification of site-level methane emissions. Typical implementations use the “mass balance method” to quantify emissions, with a high-precision methane sensor mounted on a quadcopter drone flying in a vertical curtain pattern; the total mass emission rate can then be computed post hoc from the measured methane concentration data and simultaneous wind data. Controlled-release tests have shown that errors with the mass balance method can be considerable. For example, Liu et al. (2024) report absolute errors for more than 100 % for the two drone solutions tested; on the other hand, errors can be much smaller, of the order of 16 % root-mean-square errors in Corbett and Smith (2022), if additional constraints are placed on the data, restricting the analysis to cases where the wind field was steady. In this paper we present a systematic error analysis of physical phenomena affecting the error in the mass balance method for parameters related to the acquisition of methane concentration data and to postprocessing. The sources of error are analyzed individually, and it must be realized that individual errors can accumulate in practice, and they can also be augmented by other sources that are not included in the present work. Examples of these sources include the uncertainty in methane concentration measurements by a sensor with finite precision or the method used to measure the unperturbed wind velocity at the position of the drone. We find that the most important source of error considered is the horizontal and vertical spacings in the data acquisition, as a coarse spacing can result in missing a methane plume. The potential error can be as high as 100 % in situations where the wind speed is steady and the methane plume has a coherent shape, contradicting the intuition of some operators in the industry. The likelihood of the extent of this error can be expressed in terms of a dimensionless number defined by the spatial resolution of the methane concentration measurements and the downwind distance from the main emission sources. What is learned from our theoretical error analysis is then applied to a number of historical measurements in a controlled-release setting. We show how what is learned about the main sources of error can be used to eliminate potential errors during the postprocessing of flight data. Second, we evaluate an aggregated data set of 1001 historical drone flights; our analysis shows that the potential errors in the mass balance method can be of the order of 100 % on occasion, even though the individual errors can be much smaller in the vast majority of the flights. The Discussion section provides some guidelines for industry on how to avoid or minimize potential errors in drone measurements for methane emission quantification.


  • Open Access

    Reply on RC1

    by Rutger Ijzermans, Tannaz H. Mohammadloo, Matthew Jones, Bas van de Kerkhof, Kyle Dawson, Brendan James Smith, Stephen Conley, Abigail Corbett

    Site level measurements of methane emissions are used by operators for reconciliation with bottom-up emission inventories with the aim to improve accuracy, thoroughness and confidence in reported emissions. In that context it is of critical importance to avoid measurement errors, and to understand the measurement uncertainty. Remotely piloted aircraft systems (commonly referred to as ‘drones’) can play a pivotal role in the quantification of site-level methane emissions. Typical implementations use the ‘mass balance method’ to quantify emissions, with a high-precision methane sensor mounted on a quadcopter drone flying in a vertical curtain pattern; the total mass emission rate can then be computed post hoc from the measured methane concentration data and simultaneous wind data. Controlled release tests have shown that errors with the mass balance method can be considerable. For example, Liu et al. (2023) report absolute errors for more than 100 % for the two drone solutions tested; on the other hand, errors can be much smaller, of the order of 16 % root-mean-square errors in Corbett & Smith (2022), if additional constraints are placed on the data, restricting the analysis to cases where the wind field was steady. In this paper we present a systematic error analysis of physical phenomena affecting the error in the mass balance method for parameters related to the acquisition of methane concentration data and to postprocessing. The sources of error are analysed individually, and it must be realised that individual errors can accumulate in practice, and they can also be augmented by other sources that are not included in the present work. Examples of these sources include the uncertainty in methane concentration measurements by a sensor with finite precision or the method used to measure the unperturbed wind velocity at the position of the drone. We find that the most important source of error considered is the horizontal and vertical spacings in the data acquisition as a coarse spacings can results in missing a methane plume. The potential error can be as high as 100 % in situations where the wind speed is steady and the methane plume has a coherent shape, contradicting the intuition of some operators in the industry. The likelihood of the extent of this error can be expressed in terms of a dimensionless number defined by the spatial resolution of the methane concentration measurements and the downwind distance from the main emission sources. The learnings from our theoretical error analysis are then applied to a number of historical measurements in a controlled release setting. We show how the learnings on the main sources of error can be used to eliminate potential errors during the postprocessing of flight data. Second, we evaluate an aggregated data set of 1,001 historical drone flights; our analysis shows that the potential errors in the mass balance method can be of the order of 100 % on occasions, even though the individual errors can be much smaller in the vast majority of the flights. The discussion section provides some guidelines to industry on how to avoid or minimize potential errors in drone measurements for methane emission quantification.

  • Open Access

    Reply on RC2

    by Rutger Ijzermans, Tannaz H. Mohammadloo, Matthew Jones, Bas van de Kerkhof, Kyle Dawson, Brendan James Smith, Stephen Conley, Abigail Corbett

    Site level measurements of methane emissions are used by operators for reconciliation with bottom-up emission inventories with the aim to improve accuracy, thoroughness and confidence in reported emissions. In that context it is of critical importance to avoid measurement errors, and to understand the measurement uncertainty. Remotely piloted aircraft systems (commonly referred to as ‘drones’) can play a pivotal role in the quantification of site-level methane emissions. Typical implementations use the ‘mass balance method’ to quantify emissions, with a high-precision methane sensor mounted on a quadcopter drone flying in a vertical curtain pattern; the total mass emission rate can then be computed post hoc from the measured methane concentration data and simultaneous wind data. Controlled release tests have shown that errors with the mass balance method can be considerable. For example, Liu et al. (2023) report absolute errors for more than 100 % for the two drone solutions tested; on the other hand, errors can be much smaller, of the order of 16 % root-mean-square errors in Corbett & Smith (2022), if additional constraints are placed on the data, restricting the analysis to cases where the wind field was steady. In this paper we present a systematic error analysis of physical phenomena affecting the error in the mass balance method for parameters related to the acquisition of methane concentration data and to postprocessing. The sources of error are analysed individually, and it must be realised that individual errors can accumulate in practice, and they can also be augmented by other sources that are not included in the present work. Examples of these sources include the uncertainty in methane concentration measurements by a sensor with finite precision or the method used to measure the unperturbed wind velocity at the position of the drone. We find that the most important source of error considered is the horizontal and vertical spacings in the data acquisition as a coarse spacings can results in missing a methane plume. The potential error can be as high as 100 % in situations where the wind speed is steady and the methane plume has a coherent shape, contradicting the intuition of some operators in the industry. The likelihood of the extent of this error can be expressed in terms of a dimensionless number defined by the spatial resolution of the methane concentration measurements and the downwind distance from the main emission sources. The learnings from our theoretical error analysis are then applied to a number of historical measurements in a controlled release setting. We show how the learnings on the main sources of error can be used to eliminate potential errors during the postprocessing of flight data. Second, we evaluate an aggregated data set of 1,001 historical drone flights; our analysis shows that the potential errors in the mass balance method can be of the order of 100 % on occasions, even though the individual errors can be much smaller in the vast majority of the flights. The discussion section provides some guidelines to industry on how to avoid or minimize potential errors in drone measurements for methane emission quantification.

  • Open Access

    Quantitative estimate of sources of uncertainty in drone-based methane emission measurements

    by Tannaz H. Mohammadloo, Matthew Jones, Bas van de Kerkhof, Kyle Dawson, Brendan James Smith, Stephen Conley, Abigail Corbett, Rutger Ijzermans

    Site level measurements of methane emissions are used by operators for reconciliation with bottom-up emission inventories with the aim to improve accuracy, thoroughness and confidence in reported emissions. In that context it is of critical importance to avoid measurement errors, and to understand the measurement uncertainty. Remotely piloted aircraft systems (commonly referred to as ‘drones’) can play a pivotal role in the quantification of site-level methane emissions. Typical implementations use the ‘mass balance method’ to quantify emissions, with a high-precision methane sensor mounted on a quadcopter drone flying in a vertical curtain pattern; the total mass emission rate can then be computed post hoc from the measured methane concentration data and simultaneous wind data. Controlled release tests have shown that errors with the mass balance method can be considerable. For example, Liu et al. (2023) report absolute errors for more than 100 % for the two drone solutions tested; on the other hand, errors can be much smaller, of the order of 16 % root-mean-square errors in Corbett & Smith (2022), if additional constraints are placed on the data, restricting the analysis to cases where the wind field was steady.In this paper we present a systematic error analysis of physical phenomena affecting the error in the mass balance method for parameters related to the acquisition of methane concentration data and to postprocessing. The sources of error are analysed individually, and it must be realised that individual errors can accumulate in practice, and they can also be augmented by other sources that are not included in the present work. Examples of these sources include the uncertainty in methane concentration measurements by a sensor with finite precision or the method used to measure the unperturbed wind velocity at the position of the drone. We find that the most important source of error considered is the horizontal and vertical spacings in the data acquisition as a coarse spacings can results in missing a methane plume. The potential error can be as high as 100 % in situations where the wind speed is steady and the methane plume has a coherent shape, contradicting the intuition of some operators in the industry. The likelihood of the extent of this error can be expressed in terms of a dimensionless number defined by the spatial resolution of the methane concentration measurements and the downwind distance from the main emission sources. The learnings from our theoretical error analysis are then applied to a number of historical measurements in a controlled release setting. We show how the learnings on the main sources of error can be used to eliminate potential errors during the postprocessing of flight data. Second, we evaluate an aggregated data set of 1,001 historical drone flights; our analysis shows that the potential errors in the mass balance method can be of the order of 100 % on occasions, even though the individual errors can be much smaller in the vast majority of the flights. The discussion section provides some guidelines to industry on how to avoid or minimize potential errors in drone measurements for methane emission quantification.


  • Development of Methods for Top-Down Methane Emission Measurements of Oil and Gas Facilities in an Offshore Environment Using a Miniature Methane Spectrometer and Long-Endurance Uncrewed Aerial System

    by Brendan J. Smith, Stuart Buckingham, Daniel F. Touzel, Abigail M. Corbett, Charles Tavner

    Summary: With atmospheric methane concentrations rising and spurring increased social concern, there is a renewed focus in the oil and gas industry on methane emission monitoring and control. In 2019, a methane emission survey at a bp asset west of Shetland was conducted using a closed-cavity methane spectrometer mounted onboard a long-endurance fixed-wing uncrewed aerial vehicle (UAV). This flight represents the first methane emissions survey of an offshore facility with a miniature methane spectrometer onboard a UAV with subsequent flights performed. A small laser spectrometer was modified from an open-cavity system to a closed-cavity onboard the aircraft and yielded in-flight detection limits (3 seconds) of 1,065 ppb methane above background for the 2019/2020 sensor version and 150 ppb for the 2021 sensor versions. Through simulation, the minimum detection limits of sensors in mass flow rate were determined to be 50 kg/h for the 2019/2020 campaign and 2.5 kg/h for the 2021 campaigns, translating to an obtainable measurement for 23% and 82% of assets reporting higher than 1 kg/h according to the 2019 Environmental Emissions Monitoring System (EEMS) data set, respectively. To operationalize the approach, a simulation tool for flight planning was developed using a Gaussian plume model and a scaled coefficient of variation to invoke expected methane concentration fluctuations at short time intervals. Two methods were developed to calculate offshore facility-level emission rates from the geolocated methane concentration data acquired during the emission surveys. Furthermore, a Gaussian plume simulator was developed to predict plume behavior and aid in error analysis. These methods are under evaluation, but all allow for the rapid processing (<24 hours) of results upon landing the aircraft. Additional flights were conducted in 2020 and 2021 with bp and several UK North Sea operators through a Net Zero Technology Centre (NZTC)-funded project, resulting in a total of 18 methane emission survey flights to 11 offshore assets between 2019 and 2021. The 2019 flight, and subsequent 2020–2021 flights, demonstrated the potential of the technology to derive facility-level emission rates to verify industry emission performance and data.


  • Methane Emissions Quantification and Resulting Methane Emissions Reduction in the Permian Basin Enabled by Automated Unmanned Systems

    by Jason Churchill, Brenda Wise, Iain Cooper, Brendan Smith

    Summary: Traditional methods for monitoring emissions from production operations have typically used optical gas imaging cameras or Method 21 systems, based on an intermittent basis to determine and document methane gas leaks, which are then subsequently identified for repair under the US Code of Federal Regulations (2017). These optical gas imaging emissions monitoring surveys can have a subjective bias, are highly conditional on the skill of the camera operator, and are an inexact method of measuring the quantity of the leak rate. With a renewed industry emphasis on methane emissions measurement and reduction, this paper describes a case study using a high-sensitivity sensor technology (laser absorption spectrometry) specifically targeting methane emissions, the unique capabilities engendered by its deployment on unmanned aerial systems (UAS), the leveraging of automation in field-operation and data analysis, and the system’s successful utilizationin enabling emissions limitations over several production sites in the Permian Basin. The use of automation enabled categorization of the leak type and intensity, and triage according to leak rate, facilitating prompt remedial action and directly limiting emissions. By automating the comprehensive flight paths specific to equipment groups (e.g., compressors, tanks, and flares), targeted repeat surveys confirmed that specific leaks were fixed, emphasizing a general downward trend in overall site- and asset-level emissions. These surveys were completed in 22.5 minutes, on average, at each of the five sites. Additionally, the use of high-resolution UAS-generated orthomosaic maps enabled the direct placement of emissions data into the context of the operations at the time of the survey, facilitating the generation of automated actionable reports, helping direct repair teams, and resulting in effective and necessary fixes. Furthermore, the campaign validated that following the set up of the initial survey, subsequent regular, repeat surveys could be commissioned at the “push of a button,” yielding reliable, actionable emissions data, with a direct impact on both environmental (6% reduction in emissions) and financial impact.


  • Automated Unmanned Systems Perform Safe Emissions Quantification & Reduction in Permian Operations

    by Jason Churchill, Brenda Wise, Iain Cooper, Brendan Smith

    Traditional methods for monitoring emissions from production operations have typically employed optical gas imaging (OGI) cameras or Method 21 systems, based on an intermittent basis to determine and document methane gas leaks, which are then subsequently identified for repair (CFR, 2022). These OGI emissions monitoring surveys can have a subjective bias, are highly conditional on the skill of the camera operator, and are an inexact method of measuring quantity of the leak rate. With a renewed industry emphasis on methane emissions measurement and reduction, this paper describes a case study using a high-sensitivity sensor technology specifically targeting methane emissions, the unique capabilities engendered by its deployment on unmanned aerial systems (UAS), specifically leveraging automation in field-operation and data analysis, and its successful utilization in enabling emissions limitations over several production sites in the Permian. The use of automation enabled categorization of the leak type and intensity, and triage according to leak rate, facilitating prompt remedial action, directly limiting emissions. By automating the comprehensive flight paths, specific to equipment groups, e.g., compressors, tanks, flares etc., targeted repeat surveys confirmed that specific leaks were fixed, emphasizing a general downward trend in overall site- and asset-level emissions. Additionally, the use of high resolution UAS-generated orthomosaic maps enabled the direct placement of emissions data into the context of the actual operations at the time of the survey. also facilitating the generation of automated actionable reports, enabling repair teams to be directed, resulting in effective and necessary fixes. Furthermore, the campaign validated that following the set-up of the initial survey, subsequent regular, repeat surveys could be commissioned at the "push of a button", yielding reliable, actionable emissions data, with a direct impact on both environmental and financial impact.


  • Open Access

    Dynamic flight modeling of a multi-mode flying wing quadrotor aircraft

    by Peter Ferrell, Brendan Smith, Brandon Stark, YangQuan Chen

    As the demand for versatile and efficient aerial vehicles increases, the limits of current aerial vehicles become more apparent. There is a necessity for autonomous unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) which can execute tasks that no manned aircraft has the ability to perform. This paper focuses on vertical take off and landing (VTOL) hybrids, a category of UAVs that encompasses features from both VTOL rotorcraft and fixed-wing aircraft. While there is a multitude of unique UAVs that can perform specific tasks, an effective autonomous UAV is one that retains the versatility of VTOL and the efficiency of a winged aircraft. The research presented demonstrates the navigation, guidance, and transition modeling of a VTOL hybrid. The research presented focuses heavily on the future of navigation models concerning this vehicle, where the full potential of a VTOL hybrid will be most useful in real world situations. The models developed are low fidelity to focus on the development of a navigation algorithm.