Haley Horbaly
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Haley Horbaly has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Mark Hubbe
Department of Anthropology The Ohio State University Columbus Ohio USA
2 shared publications - Adam D. Sylvester
Center for Functional Anatomy and Evolution Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine Baltimore Maryland USA
1 shared publication - Benjamin M. Auerbach
Department of Ecology & Evolutionary Biology The University of Tennessee Knoxville Tennessee USA
1 shared publication Daniel T. Tarara
Department of Health and Human Performance High Point University High Point North Carolina USA
1 shared publicationDawnie Wolfe Steadman
Department of Anthropology The University of Tennessee Knoxville Tennessee USA
1 shared publication- James D. Pampush
Department of Health and Human Performance High Point University High Point North Carolina USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 26 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in The Anatomical Record
Humans and platyrrhines share a pattern of articular variance
Previous work has identified a pattern of articular shape variation in modern human limb joints, in which convex joint surfaces exhibit constrained variance relative to their more variable concave conarticulars. This pattern is notable given that joint morphogenesis is influenced by local biomechanical environments, which vary substantially across joints and throughout development. Whether this biased variance pattern reflects generalizable developmental or biomechanical constraints, or instead represents a human‐specific phenomenon, remains unclear. Here, we test the generalizability of this pattern by examining the humeroulnar joint in New World monkeys (Platyrrhini), a diverse radiation of primates that retain many aspects of the ancestral anthropoid bauplan while exhibiting wide variation in body size, locomotor behavior, and limb‐loading regimes. We analyzed three‐dimensional geometric morphometric landmark data from the humeroulnar joints of 84 adult platyrrhines. Phylogenetic comparative analyses identified moderate but significant phylogenetic signal in both distal humeral and proximal ulnar articular shape, and two‐block partial least squares analysis demonstrated strong humeroulnar covariance. Mean pairwise landmark distance distributions were used to compare relative variance between conarticular surfaces across the pooled sample and within groups. Distal humeri consistently exhibited significantly lower morphological variance than associated proximal ulnae, indicating that this pattern is not unique to humans, despite differences in posture, gait, and locomotor loading. These results demonstrate that biased constraint of convex articular surfaces may be conserved across a wide range of locomotor strategies. This suggests the involvement of shared underlying developmental or biomechanical mechanisms in joint morphogenesis and highlights the utility of comparative variance analyses for inferring processes of morphogenesis.
- 26 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in The Anatomical Record
Open AccessHumans and platyrrhines share a pattern of articular variance
Previous work has identified a pattern of articular shape variation in modern human limb joints, in which convex joint surfaces exhibit constrained variance relative to their more variable concave conarticulars. This pattern is notable given that joint morphogenesis is influenced by local biomechanical environments, which vary substantially across joints and throughout development. Whether this biased variance pattern reflects generalizable developmental or biomechanical constraints, or instead represents a human‐specific phenomenon, remains unclear. Here, we test the generalizability of this pattern by examining the humeroulnar joint in New World monkeys (Platyrrhini), a diverse radiation of primates that retain many aspects of the ancestral anthropoid bauplan while exhibiting wide variation in body size, locomotor behavior, and limb‐loading regimes. We analyzed three‐dimensional geometric morphometric landmark data from the humeroulnar joints of 84 adult platyrrhines. Phylogenetic comparative analyses identified moderate but significant phylogenetic signal in both distal humeral and proximal ulnar articular shape, and two‐block partial least squares analysis demonstrated strong humeroulnar covariance. Mean pairwise landmark distance distributions were used to compare relative variance between conarticular surfaces across the pooled sample and within groups. Distal humeri consistently exhibited significantly lower morphological variance than associated proximal ulnae, indicating that this pattern is not unique to humans, despite differences in posture, gait, and locomotor loading. These results demonstrate that biased constraint of convex articular surfaces may be conserved across a wide range of locomotor strategies. This suggests the involvement of shared underlying developmental or biomechanical mechanisms in joint morphogenesis and highlights the utility of comparative variance analyses for inferring processes of morphogenesis.
- 4 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 190 (3) , e70304
The Typical Body Segment: An Anatomy Teaching Paradigm Created by Matt Cartmill and Others While Teaching Gross Anatomy at Duke University
Within allied‐health programs, gross anatomy is widely regarded as a foundational and content‐dense course challenging instructors and students alike to manage an overwhelming volume of information within an increasingly constrained curriculum. In the late 1960's, the Duke University medical curriculum was redesigned to produce ‘scientists‐doctors’ intensifying the instructional challenges of gross anatomy. In the wake of a series of unsuccessful experiments, comparative anatomists Matt Cartmill and James Shafland were recruited to develop and teach a medical gross anatomy course at Duke. Drawing on comparative anatomy, embryology, and evolutionary theory, Cartmill and colleagues developed a distinctive pedagogical framework organized around an idealized vertebrate metameric Bauplan —the Typical Body Segment (TBS)—with an accompanying textbook: Human Structure . Rather than trying to memorize details about sprawling sets of isolated structures, the TBS approach transforms learning gross anatomy into a series of stories about how evolution and development regionally pattern and differentiate Typical Body Segments into functionally specialized, interconnected modules. This article discusses the circumstances leading to the emergence of Cartmill's course‐directorship and the TBS approach to teaching gross anatomy at Duke. We argue that the consistent use of a central homological schema as a starting point for narratives about the complex human form offers many pedagogical advantages, including reduced cognitive load, improved organization of anatomical knowledge, as well as a better grasp on patterns of interaction and variation among parts. Drawing on qualitative data from student course evaluations at High Point University, we further illustrate how this approach appears to shift students' orientation from rote memorization toward a conceptual understanding of anatomy. Finally, we document the diffusion and transformation of the TBS paradigm through faculty lineages, postdoctoral training, and allied health programs, highlighting its enduring influence on contemporary anatomy education. Together, this history and analysis underscore the value of centering evolutionary and developmental narratives in the teaching of human anatomy and documents the major contributions from Cartmill and other gross anatomists who taught with the TBS approach at Duke University.
- 4 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 190 (3) , e70304
The Typical Body Segment: An Anatomy Teaching Paradigm Created by Matt Cartmill and Others While Teaching Gross Anatomy at Duke University
Within allied‐health programs, gross anatomy is widely regarded as a foundational and content‐dense course challenging instructors and students alike to manage an overwhelming volume of information within an increasingly constrained curriculum. In the late 1960's, the Duke University medical curriculum was redesigned to produce ‘scientists‐doctors’ intensifying the instructional challenges of gross anatomy. In the wake of a series of unsuccessful experiments, comparative anatomists Matt Cartmill and James Shafland were recruited to develop and teach a medical gross anatomy course at Duke. Drawing on comparative anatomy, embryology, and evolutionary theory, Cartmill and colleagues developed a distinctive pedagogical framework organized around an idealized vertebrate metameric Bauplan —the Typical Body Segment (TBS)—with an accompanying textbook: Human Structure . Rather than trying to memorize details about sprawling sets of isolated structures, the TBS approach transforms learning gross anatomy into a series of stories about how evolution and development regionally pattern and differentiate Typical Body Segments into functionally specialized, interconnected modules. This article discusses the circumstances leading to the emergence of Cartmill's course‐directorship and the TBS approach to teaching gross anatomy at Duke. We argue that the consistent use of a central homological schema as a starting point for narratives about the complex human form offers many pedagogical advantages, including reduced cognitive load, improved organization of anatomical knowledge, as well as a better grasp on patterns of interaction and variation among parts. Drawing on qualitative data from student course evaluations at High Point University, we further illustrate how this approach appears to shift students' orientation from rote memorization toward a conceptual understanding of anatomy. Finally, we document the diffusion and transformation of the TBS paradigm through faculty lineages, postdoctoral training, and allied health programs, highlighting its enduring influence on contemporary anatomy education. Together, this history and analysis underscore the value of centering evolutionary and developmental narratives in the teaching of human anatomy and documents the major contributions from Cartmill and other gross anatomists who taught with the TBS approach at Duke University.
- Open Access
- 22 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in The Anatomical Record
- Vol. 309 (5) , 1394-1405
Distal femoral morphology as a risk factor for osteoarthritis
Osteoarthritis (OA) is a leading cause of disability affecting millions of adults in the United States, commonly resulting in the need for total knee arthroplasty (TKA) to restore mobility and quality of life. This study investigates potential differences in baseline distal femoral shape between individuals who received TKA due to OA and a control group representing a healthy population. Using three‐dimensional geometric morphometrics, distal femoral shape was examined in 43 adult skeletons from the University of Tennessee Donated Skeletal Collection. Results suggest that natural femoral shape in TKA‐receiving individuals may differ from that of the control group, with some individuals in the TKA sample occupying more extreme regions of the femoral shape space. In particular, the landmarks of the medial condyle appear anteriorly shifted in the TKA sample, identifying this region as a candidate location for future exploration into group differences. While future longitudinal studies are required to determine direct causal links between morphology and OA as a health outcome, existing clinical literature has identified that even minor mismatch in conarticular shape can alter the biomechanical environment of the joint. These results are a first step in identifying outliers for femoral morphology and potential regions of femoral anatomy that may predispose individuals to OA, highlighting the importance of evaluating morphological variations as potential risk factors. This study further contributes to our understanding of the boundaries of articular morphospace and its implications for arthropathy, underscoring the need for further research to establish direct links between baseline articular shape and OA onset.
- 22 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in The Anatomical Record
- Vol. 309 (5) , 1394-1405
Open AccessDistal femoral morphology as a risk factor for osteoarthritis
Osteoarthritis (OA) is a leading cause of disability affecting millions of adults in the United States, commonly resulting in the need for total knee arthroplasty (TKA) to restore mobility and quality of life. This study investigates potential differences in baseline distal femoral shape between individuals who received TKA due to OA and a control group representing a healthy population. Using three‐dimensional geometric morphometrics, distal femoral shape was examined in 43 adult skeletons from the University of Tennessee Donated Skeletal Collection. Results suggest that natural femoral shape in TKA‐receiving individuals may differ from that of the control group, with some individuals in the TKA sample occupying more extreme regions of the femoral shape space. In particular, the landmarks of the medial condyle appear anteriorly shifted in the TKA sample, identifying this region as a candidate location for future exploration into group differences. While future longitudinal studies are required to determine direct causal links between morphology and OA as a health outcome, existing clinical literature has identified that even minor mismatch in conarticular shape can alter the biomechanical environment of the joint. These results are a first step in identifying outliers for femoral morphology and potential regions of femoral anatomy that may predispose individuals to OA, highlighting the importance of evaluating morphological variations as potential risk factors. This study further contributes to our understanding of the boundaries of articular morphospace and its implications for arthropathy, underscoring the need for further research to establish direct links between baseline articular shape and OA onset.
- Open Access
- 30 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in The Anatomical Record
- Vol. 307 (11) , 3519-3528
Systemic versus local patterns of limb joint articular morphology inferred from relative distances from morphological centroid
Joint morphogenesis is a complex process known to require the interaction of developmental cascades and mechanical loading, yet many details of this interaction are incompletely understood. While prior work has established populational patterns of joint morphological (co)variance, exploring how these patterns manifest within the individual provides information on the deployment of morphogenic processes as either systemic or local influences on joint shape. To better identify the patterns of variance‐generating morphogenic processes, this study investigates the degree to which individual joint shapes deviate from population averages systematically across the body. Using three‐dimensional landmark data from 200 adult skeletons, we ranked individuals based on their distances from morphological centroids for eight major joints. Spearman correlations assessed associations between ranks across various articular pairings, testing hypotheses regarding systemic versus localized variance. Results reveal low coordination between deviations observed in conarticular surfaces, functional analogs, and same‐bone surfaces; however strong associations exist between antimeres, suggesting the left–right deployment of variance‐generating morphogenic patterns is highly consistent. These results support a model of localized rather than systemic processes driving variation in joint shape. While more remains to be elucidated about the specifics of articular surface morphogenesis, these findings advance our understanding of the systems of variance generation at play during development and growth of our definitive joint morphology.
- 30 May 2024
- Published by Wiley in The Anatomical Record
- Vol. 307 (11) , 3519-3528
Open AccessSystemic versus local patterns of limb joint articular morphology inferred from relative distances from morphological centroid
Joint morphogenesis is a complex process known to require the interaction of developmental cascades and mechanical loading, yet many details of this interaction are incompletely understood. While prior work has established populational patterns of joint morphological (co)variance, exploring how these patterns manifest within the individual provides information on the deployment of morphogenic processes as either systemic or local influences on joint shape. To better identify the patterns of variance‐generating morphogenic processes, this study investigates the degree to which individual joint shapes deviate from population averages systematically across the body. Using three‐dimensional landmark data from 200 adult skeletons, we ranked individuals based on their distances from morphological centroids for eight major joints. Spearman correlations assessed associations between ranks across various articular pairings, testing hypotheses regarding systemic versus localized variance. Results reveal low coordination between deviations observed in conarticular surfaces, functional analogs, and same‐bone surfaces; however strong associations exist between antimeres, suggesting the left–right deployment of variance‐generating morphogenic patterns is highly consistent. These results support a model of localized rather than systemic processes driving variation in joint shape. While more remains to be elucidated about the specifics of articular surface morphogenesis, these findings advance our understanding of the systems of variance generation at play during development and growth of our definitive joint morphology.
- Open Access
- 13 September 2023
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 182 (3) , 401-411
Covariance in human limb joint articular morphology
Objectives: Limb synovial joints exhibit complex shapes that must accommodate often‐antagonistic demands of function, mobility, and stability. These demands presumably dictate coordination among joint articular shapes, but the structure of morphological covariance within and among joints is unknown. This study analyzes the human shoulder, elbow, hip, and knee to determine how articular covariance is structured in relation to joint structure, accessory cartilage, and function.Materials and Methods: Surface models were created from the CT scans of 200 modern skeletons from the University of Tennessee Donated Skeletal Collection. Three‐dimensional landmarks were collected on the shoulder, elbow, hip, and knee joints. Two‐block partial least squares were conducted to determine associations between surfaces of conarticular shapes, functionally analogous articulations, and articulations belonging to the same bone.Results: Except for the components of the shoulder, all conarticular pairs exhibit covariance, though the strength of these relationships appears unrelated to the amount of accessory cartilage in the joint. Only the analogous articulations of the humerus and femur exhibit significant covariance, but it is unlikely that this pattern is due to function alone. Stronger covariance within the lower limb than the upper limb is consistent broader primate patterns of within‐limb integration.Discussion: With the exception of the elbow, complementary joint function does not appear to promote strong covariance between articulations. Analogous humeral and femoral surfaces are also serially homologous, which may result in the articular associations observed between these bones. Broadly, these patterns highlight the indirect relationship between joint congruence and covariance.
- 13 September 2023
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 182 (3) , 401-411
Open AccessCovariance in human limb joint articular morphology
Objectives: Limb synovial joints exhibit complex shapes that must accommodate often‐antagonistic demands of function, mobility, and stability. These demands presumably dictate coordination among joint articular shapes, but the structure of morphological covariance within and among joints is unknown. This study analyzes the human shoulder, elbow, hip, and knee to determine how articular covariance is structured in relation to joint structure, accessory cartilage, and function.Materials and Methods: Surface models were created from the CT scans of 200 modern skeletons from the University of Tennessee Donated Skeletal Collection. Three‐dimensional landmarks were collected on the shoulder, elbow, hip, and knee joints. Two‐block partial least squares were conducted to determine associations between surfaces of conarticular shapes, functionally analogous articulations, and articulations belonging to the same bone.Results: Except for the components of the shoulder, all conarticular pairs exhibit covariance, though the strength of these relationships appears unrelated to the amount of accessory cartilage in the joint. Only the analogous articulations of the humerus and femur exhibit significant covariance, but it is unlikely that this pattern is due to function alone. Stronger covariance within the lower limb than the upper limb is consistent broader primate patterns of within‐limb integration.Discussion: With the exception of the elbow, complementary joint function does not appear to promote strong covariance between articulations. Analogous humeral and femoral surfaces are also serially homologous, which may result in the articular associations observed between these bones. Broadly, these patterns highlight the indirect relationship between joint congruence and covariance.
- Open Access
- 13 September 2023
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 182 (3) , 388-400
Variation in human limb joint articular morphology
Objectives: Synovial joints in human limbs strike a balance between mobility, stability, and articular fit, yet little is known about how these conflicting demands pattern intraspecific variation in articular shape. In this study, we use geometric morphometrics to establish the apportionment and magnitude of morphological variance of the articular surfaces of the human shoulder, elbow, hip, and knee. We hypothesize that variances will be comparable between articulating surfaces within a joint and will be larger in joints with smaller ranges of motion, given their plurality of functional demands.Materials and Methods: Three‐dimensional landmarks were taken on the articular surfaces of the glenohumeral, humeroulnar, acetabulofemoral, and tibiofemoral joints from CT scans of 200 skeletons from the University of Tennessee Donated Skeletal Collection (84 females, 116 males). Root mean‐squared distances between articulations calculated from Procrustes shape coordinates were used to determine variance distributions.Results: We found no difference in variances for each articular surface between the sexes or between left and right articular surfaces. A high range of motion is associated with greater morphological variance; however, this pattern is largely driven by the concave articular surfaces of each joint, which consistently exhibit statistically greater variance than their convex counterparts.Discussion: The striking pattern of differential variance between articulating morphologies points to potential disparities in development between them. Consistently higher variance in concave surfaces may relate to chondral modeling theory for the formation of joints. Establishing intraspecific morphological variance patterns is a first step in understanding coordinated evolution among articular features.
- 13 September 2023
- Published by Wiley in American Journal of Biological Anthropology
- Vol. 182 (3) , 388-400
Open AccessVariation in human limb joint articular morphology
Objectives: Synovial joints in human limbs strike a balance between mobility, stability, and articular fit, yet little is known about how these conflicting demands pattern intraspecific variation in articular shape. In this study, we use geometric morphometrics to establish the apportionment and magnitude of morphological variance of the articular surfaces of the human shoulder, elbow, hip, and knee. We hypothesize that variances will be comparable between articulating surfaces within a joint and will be larger in joints with smaller ranges of motion, given their plurality of functional demands.Materials and Methods: Three‐dimensional landmarks were taken on the articular surfaces of the glenohumeral, humeroulnar, acetabulofemoral, and tibiofemoral joints from CT scans of 200 skeletons from the University of Tennessee Donated Skeletal Collection (84 females, 116 males). Root mean‐squared distances between articulations calculated from Procrustes shape coordinates were used to determine variance distributions.Results: We found no difference in variances for each articular surface between the sexes or between left and right articular surfaces. A high range of motion is associated with greater morphological variance; however, this pattern is largely driven by the concave articular surfaces of each joint, which consistently exhibit statistically greater variance than their convex counterparts.Discussion: The striking pattern of differential variance between articulating morphologies points to potential disparities in development between them. Consistently higher variance in concave surfaces may relate to chondral modeling theory for the formation of joints. Establishing intraspecific morphological variance patterns is a first step in understanding coordinated evolution among articular features.