Aigul Yessentemirova
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Aigul Yessentemirova has a total of 27 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Dina Kalmaganbetova
L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University
3 shared publications - Zulfiya Torebekova
Center for Research and Evaluation
2 shared publications - A. B. Saktaganova
L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University
1 shared publication - A.D. Zhussupov
Esil University
1 shared publication - Aigerim Amirova
Astana IT University
1 shared publication - Aigerim Moldabayeva
Academy of Public Administration under the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 22 July 2025
- Published by Kh.Dosmukhamedov Atyrau University in Bulletin of Kh.Dosmukhamedov Atyrau University
- Vol. 77 (2) , 476-485
LEGAL PROBLEMS OF ATTRACTING INVESTMENTS THROUGH THE ENDOWMENT FUND SYSTEM IN KAZAKHSTAN
The creation of endowment funds in Kazakhstan is a relatively new direction. We notice that today, there is an active discussion of the draft law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On endowment funds”. The presence of endowment funds at non-profit organizations is designed to increase the share of annual income and financial stability, raise the university's prestige, and provide an opportunity to improve the nation's science position. In this article, the authors address the pressing issue of attracting philanthropists to the activities of endowment funds. Additionally, the importance of creating favorable conditions for them. It is necessary to eliminate organizational and legal obstacles. The relevance of this study lies in the fact that universities continue to receive state funds. At the same time, there is a global practice of organizing the self-financing of higher education institutions through trust management. This experience is necessary for the active and correct further development of endowment funds. The theoretical significance of this study lies in its proposals for addressing specific scientific issues related to donor involvement. The practical significance of this study lies in the potential application of this material in the educational process and future research in this area. Building a clearly regulated system for creating endowment funds will provide an impetus for innovative development in addressing large-scale problems in the field of education.
- 22 July 2025
- Published by Kh.Dosmukhamedov Atyrau University in Bulletin of Kh.Dosmukhamedov Atyrau University
- Vol. 77 (2) , 476-485
LEGAL PROBLEMS OF ATTRACTING INVESTMENTS THROUGH THE ENDOWMENT FUND SYSTEM IN KAZAKHSTAN
The creation of endowment funds in Kazakhstan is a relatively new direction. We notice that today, there is an active discussion of the draft law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On endowment funds”. The presence of endowment funds at non-profit organizations is designed to increase the share of annual income and financial stability, raise the university's prestige, and provide an opportunity to improve the nation's science position. In this article, the authors address the pressing issue of attracting philanthropists to the activities of endowment funds. Additionally, the importance of creating favorable conditions for them. It is necessary to eliminate organizational and legal obstacles. The relevance of this study lies in the fact that universities continue to receive state funds. At the same time, there is a global practice of organizing the self-financing of higher education institutions through trust management. This experience is necessary for the active and correct further development of endowment funds. The theoretical significance of this study lies in its proposals for addressing specific scientific issues related to donor involvement. The practical significance of this study lies in the potential application of this material in the educational process and future research in this area. Building a clearly regulated system for creating endowment funds will provide an impetus for innovative development in addressing large-scale problems in the field of education.
- Open Access
- 25 June 2025
- Published by LLC CPC Business Perspectives in Problems and Perspectives in Management
- Vol. 23 (2) , 814-825
Comparative analysis of public administration tools in special economic zones of China and Kazakhstan
This study examines the role of public administration tools in special economic zones (SEZs) in China and Kazakhstan. The aim of this study is to conduct a comparative analysis of public administration tools in SEZs of both countries, focusing on governance models, regulatory frameworks, investment incentives, and their impact on economic performance. The methodology includes a review of the historical development and current practices of SEZs in both nations, especially comparing the special economic zones of Shenzhen and Astana. This involves analyzing governance structures, tax incentives, and policies impacting FDI and technology transfer using both qualitative and quantitative data. The study concludes that the effectiveness of public administration tools in SEZs depends on governance structures and alignment with national economic goals, highlighting the need for flexible governance models to maximize the economic benefits of SEZs. Findings indicate that China’s decentralized governance was a key factor in its significant and rapid economic growth, providing an example for Kazakhstan to study further and potentially implement, as it grants more decision-making autonomy to local SEZ authorities. The key recommendations are that the adaptivity of public administration strategies plays a vital role in fostering the efficiency of SEZs and attracting high technological industries for Kazakhstan. AcknowledgmentThis research is funded by the Committee of Science of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan (Project No. BR24993082).
- 25 June 2025
- Published by LLC CPC Business Perspectives in Problems and Perspectives in Management
- Vol. 23 (2) , 814-825
Open AccessComparative analysis of public administration tools in special economic zones of China and Kazakhstan
This study examines the role of public administration tools in special economic zones (SEZs) in China and Kazakhstan. The aim of this study is to conduct a comparative analysis of public administration tools in SEZs of both countries, focusing on governance models, regulatory frameworks, investment incentives, and their impact on economic performance. The methodology includes a review of the historical development and current practices of SEZs in both nations, especially comparing the special economic zones of Shenzhen and Astana. This involves analyzing governance structures, tax incentives, and policies impacting FDI and technology transfer using both qualitative and quantitative data. The study concludes that the effectiveness of public administration tools in SEZs depends on governance structures and alignment with national economic goals, highlighting the need for flexible governance models to maximize the economic benefits of SEZs. Findings indicate that China’s decentralized governance was a key factor in its significant and rapid economic growth, providing an example for Kazakhstan to study further and potentially implement, as it grants more decision-making autonomy to local SEZ authorities. The key recommendations are that the adaptivity of public administration strategies plays a vital role in fostering the efficiency of SEZs and attracting high technological industries for Kazakhstan. AcknowledgmentThis research is funded by the Committee of Science of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan (Project No. BR24993082).
- Open Access
- 19 March 2025
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of actual problems of jurisprudence
- Vol. 113 (1)
DIGITAL FORMAT OF ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS: REALITIES AND PROSPECTS
One of the key objectives of administrative proceedings is the digital transformation of public administration. In line with this principle, the administrative court system has initiated automation, the integration of artificial intelligence elements, and robotic process implementation. The adoption of digital justice has become a global trend, ensuring accessibility and transparency of court decisions while reducing time and resource costs for both courts and other participants in judicial proceedings. Automated case distribution also minimizes corruption risks. Countries such as Singapore, the United States, the United Kingdom, Russia, and Kazakhstan showcase various approaches to the digitalization of justice, including online filing systems, automation, and artificial intelligence applications. At the same time, the digitalization of judicial proceedings raises legal concerns regarding essential aspects such as digital privacy, security, and maintaining a balance between efficiency and the protection of citizens' rights. The successful operation of the digital justice format requires further improvements in regulatory frameworks. The primary aim of this study is to analyze the current realities of digital technology utilization in administrative proceedings, compare scientific approaches, and conduct an analytical review. Observations have shown that aspects of judicial digitalization are a subject of research in the works of most civil law scholars, experts, analysts, and researchers in the fields of civil and criminal procedure. However, in the sphere of administrative proceedings, the use of digital technologies within the administrative court system remains insufficiently explored. Based on existing scientific approaches and an analytical review, this article attempts to conduct an independent study. Keywords: digital technologies, judicial proceedings, digital justice, accessibility, electronic format, e-justice, digital security.
- 19 March 2025
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of actual problems of jurisprudence
- Vol. 113 (1)
Open AccessDIGITAL FORMAT OF ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS: REALITIES AND PROSPECTS
One of the key objectives of administrative proceedings is the digital transformation of public administration. In line with this principle, the administrative court system has initiated automation, the integration of artificial intelligence elements, and robotic process implementation. The adoption of digital justice has become a global trend, ensuring accessibility and transparency of court decisions while reducing time and resource costs for both courts and other participants in judicial proceedings. Automated case distribution also minimizes corruption risks. Countries such as Singapore, the United States, the United Kingdom, Russia, and Kazakhstan showcase various approaches to the digitalization of justice, including online filing systems, automation, and artificial intelligence applications. At the same time, the digitalization of judicial proceedings raises legal concerns regarding essential aspects such as digital privacy, security, and maintaining a balance between efficiency and the protection of citizens' rights. The successful operation of the digital justice format requires further improvements in regulatory frameworks. The primary aim of this study is to analyze the current realities of digital technology utilization in administrative proceedings, compare scientific approaches, and conduct an analytical review. Observations have shown that aspects of judicial digitalization are a subject of research in the works of most civil law scholars, experts, analysts, and researchers in the fields of civil and criminal procedure. However, in the sphere of administrative proceedings, the use of digital technologies within the administrative court system remains insufficiently explored. Based on existing scientific approaches and an analytical review, this article attempts to conduct an independent study. Keywords: digital technologies, judicial proceedings, digital justice, accessibility, electronic format, e-justice, digital security.
- Open Access
- 2 March 2025
- Published by OpenEd Network in Journal of Curriculum Studies Research
- Vol. 7 (1) , 66-88
Evaluating Language Competencies of Kazakhstan’s Civil Servants: A Data-Driven Analysis and Development Model
The aim of this article is to analyze the current state of language competencies among Kazakhstan’s civil servants and to develop a model for enhancing these skills. Based on survey data from Kazakhstani civil servants, the authors assess Kazakh, Russian, and English proficiency. The results show that socio-demographic factors account for only a small portion of the variation of language proficiency levels. Language competencies are positively, though weakly, correlated with civil servants’ educational attainment. Based on an analysis of Kazakhstan’s language policy and the training and retraining programs for civil servants, the authors propose a model for developing language competencies. The proposed model offers a valuable framework for enhancing education and training programs for civil servants in countries facing similar challenges. This contribution adds to the broader discourse on professional development in the public sector, highlighting the critical role of targeted education in strengthening governance and public administration effectiveness.
- 2 March 2025
- Published by OpenEd Network in Journal of Curriculum Studies Research
- Vol. 7 (1) , 66-88
Open AccessEvaluating Language Competencies of Kazakhstan’s Civil Servants: A Data-Driven Analysis and Development Model
The aim of this article is to analyze the current state of language competencies among Kazakhstan’s civil servants and to develop a model for enhancing these skills. Based on survey data from Kazakhstani civil servants, the authors assess Kazakh, Russian, and English proficiency. The results show that socio-demographic factors account for only a small portion of the variation of language proficiency levels. Language competencies are positively, though weakly, correlated with civil servants’ educational attainment. Based on an analysis of Kazakhstan’s language policy and the training and retraining programs for civil servants, the authors propose a model for developing language competencies. The proposed model offers a valuable framework for enhancing education and training programs for civil servants in countries facing similar challenges. This contribution adds to the broader discourse on professional development in the public sector, highlighting the critical role of targeted education in strengthening governance and public administration effectiveness.
- Open Access
- 5 February 2025
- Published by Virtus Interpress in Corporate Law and Governance Review
- Vol. 7 (1) , 100
Reforming the state governance: A perspective of project management innovations and contract service expertise.
The article examines current conditions and prerequisites for the development of project management and contract employment in the civil service system with a specific view of the Republic of Kazakhstan experience. Global innovative trends and the Industry 5.0 paradigm have significantly changed approaches to project management in recent years. The innovative value creation allows successfully implementing projects, optimizing the costs of time, money, and human resources, without deviating from the planned quality of the final product of the project (Malik et al., 2019). The research implies several methods (retrospective and comparative analysis, scenario forecasting) to analyze data received from surveys (10,942 civil servants) and interviews with 24 experts from governmental and non-governmental organizations. The findings highlight the main emphasis on improving the quality of human capital and transitioning to “flexible” management tools. However, opponents assume that new methods will bring “chaos” to state apparatus, undermine the foundation of national security, and change the achieved level of checks and balances. Thus, the proposed solutions with two scenarios in mind could be a potential benefit or introduce uncertainty for the country. Based on this assumption, the article proposes key recommendations for the full implementation of these new innovative institutions for the Kazakhstani civil service.
- 5 February 2025
- Published by Virtus Interpress in Corporate Law and Governance Review
- Vol. 7 (1) , 100
Open AccessReforming the state governance: A perspective of project management innovations and contract service expertise.
The article examines current conditions and prerequisites for the development of project management and contract employment in the civil service system with a specific view of the Republic of Kazakhstan experience. Global innovative trends and the Industry 5.0 paradigm have significantly changed approaches to project management in recent years. The innovative value creation allows successfully implementing projects, optimizing the costs of time, money, and human resources, without deviating from the planned quality of the final product of the project (Malik et al., 2019). The research implies several methods (retrospective and comparative analysis, scenario forecasting) to analyze data received from surveys (10,942 civil servants) and interviews with 24 experts from governmental and non-governmental organizations. The findings highlight the main emphasis on improving the quality of human capital and transitioning to “flexible” management tools. However, opponents assume that new methods will bring “chaos” to state apparatus, undermine the foundation of national security, and change the achieved level of checks and balances. Thus, the proposed solutions with two scenarios in mind could be a potential benefit or introduce uncertainty for the country. Based on this assumption, the article proposes key recommendations for the full implementation of these new innovative institutions for the Kazakhstani civil service.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by L. N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University in BULLETIN of L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University Law Series
- Vol. 151 (2) , 79-87
The constitutional court as a foundation of legal defense in Kazakhstan
The year 2022 is becoming a landmark year for Kazakhstan, radically transforming the legal system and making fundamental changes. Political events that took place in the republic itself prompted President K. Tokayev to change the course of political reforms. In 2023, the Constitutional Court was revived in the country. The Constitutional Court is a necessity inspired by modern realities. The current Constitutional Court is a relatively "young" institution, maintaining continuity, and is based on the experience of other countries and previous constitutional institutions of the country. The article analyzes all constitutional institutions that have functioned or are operating in the country. The historical prerequisites for the creation of these institutions, their features, and specifics. The role of the Constitutional Court is defined and analyzed its activities. In addition, indicated the positive outcomes of the Constitutional Court's activities. The activities of the Constitutional Court aimed, first, at eliminating gaps and ensuring effective protection of the Constitution. The new model of constitutional review assumes the supremacy of the Constitution. This paper analyzes judicial practice and its role in solving current problems of the socio-legal development of the country. Presented the aspects of the importance of deciding on the revival of the constitutional court.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by L. N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University in BULLETIN of L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University Law Series
- Vol. 151 (2) , 79-87
Open AccessThe constitutional court as a foundation of legal defense in Kazakhstan
The year 2022 is becoming a landmark year for Kazakhstan, radically transforming the legal system and making fundamental changes. Political events that took place in the republic itself prompted President K. Tokayev to change the course of political reforms. In 2023, the Constitutional Court was revived in the country. The Constitutional Court is a necessity inspired by modern realities. The current Constitutional Court is a relatively "young" institution, maintaining continuity, and is based on the experience of other countries and previous constitutional institutions of the country. The article analyzes all constitutional institutions that have functioned or are operating in the country. The historical prerequisites for the creation of these institutions, their features, and specifics. The role of the Constitutional Court is defined and analyzed its activities. In addition, indicated the positive outcomes of the Constitutional Court's activities. The activities of the Constitutional Court aimed, first, at eliminating gaps and ensuring effective protection of the Constitution. The new model of constitutional review assumes the supremacy of the Constitution. This paper analyzes judicial practice and its role in solving current problems of the socio-legal development of the country. Presented the aspects of the importance of deciding on the revival of the constitutional court.
- Open Access
- 19 September 2024
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of actual problems of jurisprudence
- Vol. 111 (3) , 129-136
THE PLACE OF NORMATIVE RESOLUTIONS OF THE SUPREME COURT IN THE FIELD OF CRIMINAL LAW
This study seeks to investigate the impact and relevance of Supreme Court normative decrees in criminal law practice in Kazakhstan. Our objective is to explore their influence on law enforcement practices as well as harmonization between national laws and international standards. Among the primary directions of inquiry lies theoretical analysis of legal nature decrees as well as historical development studies and comparative legal research. Scientific and practical significance of this work lies in its comprehensive examination of how normative decrees affect uniform judicial practice and law enforcement stability. Research methodology included content analysis, comparative legal method interpretation legal interpretation as well as statistical analysis. The primary findings of this research indicated that normative decrees of the Supreme Court play an essential role in shaping law enforcement practices and guaranteeing uniform and stable interpretations of criminal law. These findings underscore the necessity of further aligning Kazakhstani legislation with international standards to enhance law enforcement efficiency and promote human rights protection. Research's value lies in filling gaps in existing literature and offering recommendations to enhance law enforcement practices in Kazakhstan. Practical applications of research results include their potential use by judges, lawyers, and others practicing criminal law. Keywords: normative resolutions of the Supreme Court, normative legal act, sphere of criminal law, legal institute, concept of normative resolution.
- 19 September 2024
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of actual problems of jurisprudence
- Vol. 111 (3) , 129-136
Open AccessTHE PLACE OF NORMATIVE RESOLUTIONS OF THE SUPREME COURT IN THE FIELD OF CRIMINAL LAW
This study seeks to investigate the impact and relevance of Supreme Court normative decrees in criminal law practice in Kazakhstan. Our objective is to explore their influence on law enforcement practices as well as harmonization between national laws and international standards. Among the primary directions of inquiry lies theoretical analysis of legal nature decrees as well as historical development studies and comparative legal research. Scientific and practical significance of this work lies in its comprehensive examination of how normative decrees affect uniform judicial practice and law enforcement stability. Research methodology included content analysis, comparative legal method interpretation legal interpretation as well as statistical analysis. The primary findings of this research indicated that normative decrees of the Supreme Court play an essential role in shaping law enforcement practices and guaranteeing uniform and stable interpretations of criminal law. These findings underscore the necessity of further aligning Kazakhstani legislation with international standards to enhance law enforcement efficiency and promote human rights protection. Research's value lies in filling gaps in existing literature and offering recommendations to enhance law enforcement practices in Kazakhstan. Practical applications of research results include their potential use by judges, lawyers, and others practicing criminal law. Keywords: normative resolutions of the Supreme Court, normative legal act, sphere of criminal law, legal institute, concept of normative resolution.
- Open Access
- 6 October 2023
- Published by Brazilian Journals in Journal of Law and Sustainable Development
- Vol. 11 (9) , e1545
Parole and Early Release from Punishment: Problems of Improving Application Mechanisms in the Republic of Kazakhstan and Foreign Experience
Objective: The article provides a comparative study of the institution of parole in the Republic of Kazakhstan with current foreign legislation. The positive experience of the legislation on parole is outlined, conflicts and problems of the current legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on parole are identified, and recommendations are offered for further improvement of the institution of parole. Theoretical framework: During the study, statistical material presented on the website of the Prosecutor General's Office of the Republic of Kazakhstan, other scientific works on the presented topic, as well as foreign experience of other countries were studied Method: The following methods were used in the research process: system-theoretical and logical analysis of the problem; expert assessment of the relevant norms of national legislation and the practice of its application; constructive and critical analysis of conceptual approaches to reforming the institution of parole. Results and conclusion: Based on the current legislative acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan and foreign countries, as well as scientific literature, the article analyzes the conditions for the abolition of parole, on the basis of which proposals are made for the wording of Part 7 of Art. 72 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Also, the practice of applying preventive measures by government, law enforcement agencies, and public groups does not always properly demonstrate their effectiveness. Therefore, from our point of view, the legislation should provide for measures to improve them. Which indicate the advisability of developing a large comprehensive plan for the reintegration of parolees into life in society, which relate to all spheres of life. And regarding the principle of work of district inspectors and probation inspectors, which is identical, de-bureaucratization effect. Originality and value: Issues related to the theory and practice of applying parole to convicted persons or the non-application of certain types of punishment to a certain category of persons are quite often discussed in the scientific literature both in Kazakhstan and in foreign countries. However, taking into account the changes made to Kazakhstan's regulatory legal acts (criminal, criminal procedural, criminal executive legislation, regulatory decisions of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan) on issues of parole, in our opinion, some rough edges are revealed that require resolution. At the same time, the practice of applying the institution of parole shows that there are still issues that are subject to additional legislative regulation in order to eliminate any doubts in the interpretation of the law, which indicates the relevance of their research. Since frequent changes in legislation have caused and continue to cause difficulties for individual courts in the correct application of the above regulations. For example, issues related to the revocation of parole, or the reversal of an application for parole. The latter is what happens most often in practice.
- 6 October 2023
- Published by Brazilian Journals in Journal of Law and Sustainable Development
- Vol. 11 (9) , e1545
Open AccessParole and Early Release from Punishment: Problems of Improving Application Mechanisms in the Republic of Kazakhstan and Foreign Experience
Objective: The article provides a comparative study of the institution of parole in the Republic of Kazakhstan with current foreign legislation. The positive experience of the legislation on parole is outlined, conflicts and problems of the current legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on parole are identified, and recommendations are offered for further improvement of the institution of parole. Theoretical framework: During the study, statistical material presented on the website of the Prosecutor General's Office of the Republic of Kazakhstan, other scientific works on the presented topic, as well as foreign experience of other countries were studied Method: The following methods were used in the research process: system-theoretical and logical analysis of the problem; expert assessment of the relevant norms of national legislation and the practice of its application; constructive and critical analysis of conceptual approaches to reforming the institution of parole. Results and conclusion: Based on the current legislative acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan and foreign countries, as well as scientific literature, the article analyzes the conditions for the abolition of parole, on the basis of which proposals are made for the wording of Part 7 of Art. 72 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Also, the practice of applying preventive measures by government, law enforcement agencies, and public groups does not always properly demonstrate their effectiveness. Therefore, from our point of view, the legislation should provide for measures to improve them. Which indicate the advisability of developing a large comprehensive plan for the reintegration of parolees into life in society, which relate to all spheres of life. And regarding the principle of work of district inspectors and probation inspectors, which is identical, de-bureaucratization effect. Originality and value: Issues related to the theory and practice of applying parole to convicted persons or the non-application of certain types of punishment to a certain category of persons are quite often discussed in the scientific literature both in Kazakhstan and in foreign countries. However, taking into account the changes made to Kazakhstan's regulatory legal acts (criminal, criminal procedural, criminal executive legislation, regulatory decisions of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan) on issues of parole, in our opinion, some rough edges are revealed that require resolution. At the same time, the practice of applying the institution of parole shows that there are still issues that are subject to additional legislative regulation in order to eliminate any doubts in the interpretation of the law, which indicates the relevance of their research. Since frequent changes in legislation have caused and continue to cause difficulties for individual courts in the correct application of the above regulations. For example, issues related to the revocation of parole, or the reversal of an application for parole. The latter is what happens most often in practice.