Zulfiya Torebekova
Zulfiya Torebekova has a total of 28 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Baurzhan Bokayev
Syracuse University
7 shared publications - Asset Baktiyarov
L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University
3 shared publications - Zhuldyz Davletbayeva
Academy of Public Administration under the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan
3 shared publications - Aigerim Amirova
Astana IT University
2 shared publications - Aigul Yessentemirova
L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University
2 shared publications - Madina Nauryzbek
LLP “Center for Research and Development of Intellectual Potential
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 February 2026
- Published by OpenEd Network in Journal of Culture and Values in Education
- Vol. 9 (1) , 183-224
Policies, Intellectual Capital, and Competitiveness in Higher Education Institutions of Kazakhstan
The purpose of the present study is to examine the role of policy implementation and intellectual capital dynamics in the processes of achieving sustainable competitive advantage in higher education institutions in Kazakhstan. The study combines bibliometric analysis and systematic review covering publications from the Web of Science and Scopus databases between 2011 and 2025. Inclusion and exclusion criteria were defined using the PRISMA flow; data from 145 studies were analyzed using keyword and co-citation maps using VOSviewer, and thematized using qualitative content analysis. The findings indicate that publication and citation trends are increasing, production is largely concentrated in articles, and visibility is clustered at specific research universities. Features such as "internationalization," "quality assurance," "digital transformation," and "global rankings" are centralized within thematic networks. Bologna alignment, accreditation, academic autonomy, and performance-based funding practices are observed to strengthen institutional capacity, while ranking-focused incentives can increase short-termism. Within the intellectual capital dimension, human capital (faculty competencies, early career support, graduate employment), structural capital (digitalization, AI, governance, and innovation systems), and relational capital (university-industry collaboration, regional partnerships) stand out as the primary determinants of competitive advantage. Triangulation of local databases with internal, qualitative data, ethical and metric balance, and strengthening of regional collaborations are recommended for future studies.
- 16 February 2026
- Published by OpenEd Network in Journal of Culture and Values in Education
- Vol. 9 (1) , 183-224
Open AccessPolicies, Intellectual Capital, and Competitiveness in Higher Education Institutions of Kazakhstan
The purpose of the present study is to examine the role of policy implementation and intellectual capital dynamics in the processes of achieving sustainable competitive advantage in higher education institutions in Kazakhstan. The study combines bibliometric analysis and systematic review covering publications from the Web of Science and Scopus databases between 2011 and 2025. Inclusion and exclusion criteria were defined using the PRISMA flow; data from 145 studies were analyzed using keyword and co-citation maps using VOSviewer, and thematized using qualitative content analysis. The findings indicate that publication and citation trends are increasing, production is largely concentrated in articles, and visibility is clustered at specific research universities. Features such as "internationalization," "quality assurance," "digital transformation," and "global rankings" are centralized within thematic networks. Bologna alignment, accreditation, academic autonomy, and performance-based funding practices are observed to strengthen institutional capacity, while ranking-focused incentives can increase short-termism. Within the intellectual capital dimension, human capital (faculty competencies, early career support, graduate employment), structural capital (digitalization, AI, governance, and innovation systems), and relational capital (university-industry collaboration, regional partnerships) stand out as the primary determinants of competitive advantage. Triangulation of local databases with internal, qualitative data, ethical and metric balance, and strengthening of regional collaborations are recommended for future studies.
- Open Access
- 12 January 2026
- Published by Kh.Dosmukhamedov Atyrau University in Bulletin of Kh.Dosmukhamedov Atyrau University
- Vol. 79 (4) , 320-329
DIGITAL NOMADS AS A GLOBAL PHENOMENON: AN ANALYSIS OF ECONOMIC IMPACTS ON HOST COUNTRIES
The article examines the economic impact of digital nomads. The purpose of the study was to identify the positive and negative consequences of the presence of digital nomads on the local economies of host regions. The methodological basis of the research was the mixed approach of quantitative and qualitative data analysis, as well as the study of the experience of the most popular destinations for digital nomads — Indonesia, Portugal, Mexico, Thailand and Estonia. Indicators of employment, the price level, the state of infrastructure, and the dynamics of small and medium businesses were considered. The results show that digital nomads are becoming an essential factor in local economic growth. They contribute to increased income in sectors such as rental housing, public catering, co-working, and related services, stimulating entrepreneurship and employment among residents. At the same time, negative consequences emerged: rising real estate and rent prices, an additional burden on transport and communal services, and increased social segregation between residents and foreign specialists. Based on the analysis, recommendations for a balanced policy to attract and regulate digital nomads are provided. Such a policy should aim to maximise the region's economic benefits while minimising social risks.
- 12 January 2026
- Published by Kh.Dosmukhamedov Atyrau University in Bulletin of Kh.Dosmukhamedov Atyrau University
- Vol. 79 (4) , 320-329
Open AccessDIGITAL NOMADS AS A GLOBAL PHENOMENON: AN ANALYSIS OF ECONOMIC IMPACTS ON HOST COUNTRIES
The article examines the economic impact of digital nomads. The purpose of the study was to identify the positive and negative consequences of the presence of digital nomads on the local economies of host regions. The methodological basis of the research was the mixed approach of quantitative and qualitative data analysis, as well as the study of the experience of the most popular destinations for digital nomads — Indonesia, Portugal, Mexico, Thailand and Estonia. Indicators of employment, the price level, the state of infrastructure, and the dynamics of small and medium businesses were considered. The results show that digital nomads are becoming an essential factor in local economic growth. They contribute to increased income in sectors such as rental housing, public catering, co-working, and related services, stimulating entrepreneurship and employment among residents. At the same time, negative consequences emerged: rising real estate and rent prices, an additional burden on transport and communal services, and increased social segregation between residents and foreign specialists. Based on the analysis, recommendations for a balanced policy to attract and regulate digital nomads are provided. Such a policy should aim to maximise the region's economic benefits while minimising social risks.
- Open Access
- 20 September 2025
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of actual problems of jurisprudence
- Vol. 115 (3)
LEGAL STATUS AND REGULATORY FRAMEWORK OF DIGITAL NOMADS: AN ANALYSIS IN THE CONTEXT OF GLOBAL MIGRATION
In the context of rapidly accelerating global digitalization and increasing workforce mobility, the phenomenon of digital nomads has gained growing relevance for contemporary legal scholarship and migration policy. Digital nomads constitute a distinct category of remote workers who perform most of their work online while traveling continuously between countries. Despite their expanding numbers and significance in the global economy, the legal regulation of this phenomenon remains fragmented and underexplored. This study aims to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the legal, socio-economic, and institutional aspects related to digital nomads within the context of global migration. Employing methods such as comparative legal analysis, content analysis of international normative documents, and case studies, the research examines practices in several leading countries that have introduced special visa regimes for digital nomads, including Estonia, Portugal, Croatia, and Kazakhstan. The results highlight key legal challenges: ambiguity in determining tax residency, the absence of unified international standards, and the risk of informal or shadow employment models. Recommendations are offered to harmonize international and domestic legal norms and to establish mechanisms protecting both digital nomads and host states. The findings offer valuable insights for migration policy makers, international organizations, and employers relying on remote work frameworks. Keywords: digital nomads, remote workers, workforce mobility, visa regulation, migration.
- 20 September 2025
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Journal of actual problems of jurisprudence
- Vol. 115 (3)
Open AccessLEGAL STATUS AND REGULATORY FRAMEWORK OF DIGITAL NOMADS: AN ANALYSIS IN THE CONTEXT OF GLOBAL MIGRATION
In the context of rapidly accelerating global digitalization and increasing workforce mobility, the phenomenon of digital nomads has gained growing relevance for contemporary legal scholarship and migration policy. Digital nomads constitute a distinct category of remote workers who perform most of their work online while traveling continuously between countries. Despite their expanding numbers and significance in the global economy, the legal regulation of this phenomenon remains fragmented and underexplored. This study aims to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the legal, socio-economic, and institutional aspects related to digital nomads within the context of global migration. Employing methods such as comparative legal analysis, content analysis of international normative documents, and case studies, the research examines practices in several leading countries that have introduced special visa regimes for digital nomads, including Estonia, Portugal, Croatia, and Kazakhstan. The results highlight key legal challenges: ambiguity in determining tax residency, the absence of unified international standards, and the risk of informal or shadow employment models. Recommendations are offered to harmonize international and domestic legal norms and to establish mechanisms protecting both digital nomads and host states. The findings offer valuable insights for migration policy makers, international organizations, and employers relying on remote work frameworks. Keywords: digital nomads, remote workers, workforce mobility, visa regulation, migration.
- Open Access
- 2 March 2025
- Published by OpenEd Network in Journal of Curriculum Studies Research
- Vol. 7 (1) , 66-88
Evaluating Language Competencies of Kazakhstan’s Civil Servants: A Data-Driven Analysis and Development Model
The aim of this article is to analyze the current state of language competencies among Kazakhstan’s civil servants and to develop a model for enhancing these skills. Based on survey data from Kazakhstani civil servants, the authors assess Kazakh, Russian, and English proficiency. The results show that socio-demographic factors account for only a small portion of the variation of language proficiency levels. Language competencies are positively, though weakly, correlated with civil servants’ educational attainment. Based on an analysis of Kazakhstan’s language policy and the training and retraining programs for civil servants, the authors propose a model for developing language competencies. The proposed model offers a valuable framework for enhancing education and training programs for civil servants in countries facing similar challenges. This contribution adds to the broader discourse on professional development in the public sector, highlighting the critical role of targeted education in strengthening governance and public administration effectiveness.
- 2 March 2025
- Published by OpenEd Network in Journal of Curriculum Studies Research
- Vol. 7 (1) , 66-88
Open AccessEvaluating Language Competencies of Kazakhstan’s Civil Servants: A Data-Driven Analysis and Development Model
The aim of this article is to analyze the current state of language competencies among Kazakhstan’s civil servants and to develop a model for enhancing these skills. Based on survey data from Kazakhstani civil servants, the authors assess Kazakh, Russian, and English proficiency. The results show that socio-demographic factors account for only a small portion of the variation of language proficiency levels. Language competencies are positively, though weakly, correlated with civil servants’ educational attainment. Based on an analysis of Kazakhstan’s language policy and the training and retraining programs for civil servants, the authors propose a model for developing language competencies. The proposed model offers a valuable framework for enhancing education and training programs for civil servants in countries facing similar challenges. This contribution adds to the broader discourse on professional development in the public sector, highlighting the critical role of targeted education in strengthening governance and public administration effectiveness.
- Open Access
- 5 February 2025
- Published by Virtus Interpress in Corporate Law and Governance Review
- Vol. 7 (1) , 100
Reforming the state governance: A perspective of project management innovations and contract service expertise.
The article examines current conditions and prerequisites for the development of project management and contract employment in the civil service system with a specific view of the Republic of Kazakhstan experience. Global innovative trends and the Industry 5.0 paradigm have significantly changed approaches to project management in recent years. The innovative value creation allows successfully implementing projects, optimizing the costs of time, money, and human resources, without deviating from the planned quality of the final product of the project (Malik et al., 2019). The research implies several methods (retrospective and comparative analysis, scenario forecasting) to analyze data received from surveys (10,942 civil servants) and interviews with 24 experts from governmental and non-governmental organizations. The findings highlight the main emphasis on improving the quality of human capital and transitioning to “flexible” management tools. However, opponents assume that new methods will bring “chaos” to state apparatus, undermine the foundation of national security, and change the achieved level of checks and balances. Thus, the proposed solutions with two scenarios in mind could be a potential benefit or introduce uncertainty for the country. Based on this assumption, the article proposes key recommendations for the full implementation of these new innovative institutions for the Kazakhstani civil service.
- 5 February 2025
- Published by Virtus Interpress in Corporate Law and Governance Review
- Vol. 7 (1) , 100
Open AccessReforming the state governance: A perspective of project management innovations and contract service expertise.
The article examines current conditions and prerequisites for the development of project management and contract employment in the civil service system with a specific view of the Republic of Kazakhstan experience. Global innovative trends and the Industry 5.0 paradigm have significantly changed approaches to project management in recent years. The innovative value creation allows successfully implementing projects, optimizing the costs of time, money, and human resources, without deviating from the planned quality of the final product of the project (Malik et al., 2019). The research implies several methods (retrospective and comparative analysis, scenario forecasting) to analyze data received from surveys (10,942 civil servants) and interviews with 24 experts from governmental and non-governmental organizations. The findings highlight the main emphasis on improving the quality of human capital and transitioning to “flexible” management tools. However, opponents assume that new methods will bring “chaos” to state apparatus, undermine the foundation of national security, and change the achieved level of checks and balances. Thus, the proposed solutions with two scenarios in mind could be a potential benefit or introduce uncertainty for the country. Based on this assumption, the article proposes key recommendations for the full implementation of these new innovative institutions for the Kazakhstani civil service.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Center for Analytical Research and Evaluation in «МЕМЛЕКЕТТІК АУДИТ – ГОСУДАРСТВЕННЫЙ АУДИТ»
- Vol. 68 (3) , 204-213
INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY RANKINGS AND THEIR IMPACT ON HIGHER EDUCATION EFFECTIVENESS: ANALYSIS AND CASE STUDY
This article analyzes the impact of international university rankings (QS, THE, ARWU, WURI) on the strategic development of higher education systems. It examines institutional transformations caused by universities' desire to improve their positions in global rankings, as well as the risks associated with the dominance of reputational and research metrics. Particular attention is paid to the case analysis of universities in Australia, South Korea, Kazakhstan, and the UK, demonstrating the diversity of strategies for adapting to the ranking logic. Using a qualitative and comparative analytical approach, the authors discuss the prospects for alternative models for assessing university effectiveness focused on pedagogical quality, social inclusion, and sustainable development. According to the study results, although international ratings have a significant impact on the strategy of higher education, alternative approaches based on social responsibility and quality education are necessary to overcome their limitations. Keywords: international rankings, university strategy, quality of education, institutional reforms, social responsibility, reputation, higher education. В данной статье анализируется влияние международных рейтингов университетов (QS, THE, ARWU, WURI) на стратегическое развитие систем высшего образования. Рассматриваются институциональные изменения, которые претерпевают университеты в стремлении улучшить свои позиции в глобальных рейтингах, а также риски, связанные с доминированием показателей репутации и исследовательской деятельности. Особое внимание уделяется кейсам университетов Австралии, Южной Кореи, Казахстана и Великобритании, которые демонстрируют разнообразие стратегий адаптации к логике рейтингов. Используя качественный и сравнительный аналитический подход, авторы рассматривают перспективы альтернативных моделей оценки эффективности университетов, ориентированных на качество педагогического образования, социальную инклюзивность и устойчивое развитие. Исследование показало, что, хотя международные рейтинги оказывают значительное влияние на стратегию высшего образования, для преодоления их ограничений необходимы альтернативные подходы, основанные на социальной ответственности и качественном образовании. Ключевые слова: международные рейтинги, стратегия университета, качество образования, институциональные реформы, социальная ответственность, репутация, высшее образование. Бұл мақалада халықаралық университет рейтингтерінің (QS, THE, ARWU, WURI) жоғары білім беру жүйесінің стратегиялық дамуына әсері талданады. Ол университеттердің жаһандық рейтингтердегі позицияларын жақсартуға ұмтылуынан туындаған институционалдық өзгерістерді, сондай-ақ бедел мен зерттеу көрсеткіштерінің үстемдігімен байланысты тәуекелдерді зерттейді. Зерттеуде рейтингтік логикаға бейімделу стратегияларының әртүрлілігін көрсететін Австралия, Оңтүстік Корея, Қазақстан және Ұлыбритания университеттерінің кейс талдауына ерекше назар аударылады. Сапалы және салыстырмалы аналитикалық тәсілді пайдалана отырып, авторлар педагогикалық сапаға, әлеуметтік инклюзияға және тұрақты дамуға бағытталған университет тиімділігін бағалаудың баламалы үлгілерінің перспективаларын талқылайды. Зерттеу нәтижесінде халықаралық рейтингтер жоғары білім беру стратегиясына айтарлықтай әсер еткенімен, олардың шектеулерін еңсеру үшін әлеуметтік жауапкершілік пен сапалы білімге негізделген балама тәсілдер қажет екені анықталды.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by Center for Analytical Research and Evaluation in «МЕМЛЕКЕТТІК АУДИТ – ГОСУДАРСТВЕННЫЙ АУДИТ»
- Vol. 68 (3) , 204-213
INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY RANKINGS AND THEIR IMPACT ON HIGHER EDUCATION EFFECTIVENESS: ANALYSIS AND CASE STUDY
This article analyzes the impact of international university rankings (QS, THE, ARWU, WURI) on the strategic development of higher education systems. It examines institutional transformations caused by universities' desire to improve their positions in global rankings, as well as the risks associated with the dominance of reputational and research metrics. Particular attention is paid to the case analysis of universities in Australia, South Korea, Kazakhstan, and the UK, demonstrating the diversity of strategies for adapting to the ranking logic. Using a qualitative and comparative analytical approach, the authors discuss the prospects for alternative models for assessing university effectiveness focused on pedagogical quality, social inclusion, and sustainable development. According to the study results, although international ratings have a significant impact on the strategy of higher education, alternative approaches based on social responsibility and quality education are necessary to overcome their limitations. Keywords: international rankings, university strategy, quality of education, institutional reforms, social responsibility, reputation, higher education. В данной статье анализируется влияние международных рейтингов университетов (QS, THE, ARWU, WURI) на стратегическое развитие систем высшего образования. Рассматриваются институциональные изменения, которые претерпевают университеты в стремлении улучшить свои позиции в глобальных рейтингах, а также риски, связанные с доминированием показателей репутации и исследовательской деятельности. Особое внимание уделяется кейсам университетов Австралии, Южной Кореи, Казахстана и Великобритании, которые демонстрируют разнообразие стратегий адаптации к логике рейтингов. Используя качественный и сравнительный аналитический подход, авторы рассматривают перспективы альтернативных моделей оценки эффективности университетов, ориентированных на качество педагогического образования, социальную инклюзивность и устойчивое развитие. Исследование показало, что, хотя международные рейтинги оказывают значительное влияние на стратегию высшего образования, для преодоления их ограничений необходимы альтернативные подходы, основанные на социальной ответственности и качественном образовании. Ключевые слова: международные рейтинги, стратегия университета, качество образования, институциональные реформы, социальная ответственность, репутация, высшее образование. Бұл мақалада халықаралық университет рейтингтерінің (QS, THE, ARWU, WURI) жоғары білім беру жүйесінің стратегиялық дамуына әсері талданады. Ол университеттердің жаһандық рейтингтердегі позицияларын жақсартуға ұмтылуынан туындаған институционалдық өзгерістерді, сондай-ақ бедел мен зерттеу көрсеткіштерінің үстемдігімен байланысты тәуекелдерді зерттейді. Зерттеуде рейтингтік логикаға бейімделу стратегияларының әртүрлілігін көрсететін Австралия, Оңтүстік Корея, Қазақстан және Ұлыбритания университеттерінің кейс талдауына ерекше назар аударылады. Сапалы және салыстырмалы аналитикалық тәсілді пайдалана отырып, авторлар педагогикалық сапаға, әлеуметтік инклюзияға және тұрақты дамуға бағытталған университет тиімділігін бағалаудың баламалы үлгілерінің перспективаларын талқылайды. Зерттеу нәтижесінде халықаралық рейтингтер жоғары білім беру стратегиясына айтарлықтай әсер еткенімен, олардың шектеулерін еңсеру үшін әлеуметтік жауапкершілік пен сапалы білімге негізделген балама тәсілдер қажет екені анықталды.
- Open Access
- 2 November 2024
- Published by University of Saints Cyril and Methodius in Central European Journal of Public Policy
- Vol. 18 (2) , 2-16
An Examination of Civil Servants’ Assessment of the New Civil Service Reforms in Kazakhstan
In recent years, Kazakhstan has demonstrated a strong commitment to make the civil service system open and transparent to its citizens. The country has introduced an e-government system to improve access to information and allow public consultation on civil service. Reforms of the civil service aim to reduce corruption in the civil service and to ensure a transition to a career-based model, meritocracy, and result-based remuneration. This study aims to expand the literature on the civil servants’ appraisal toward new civil service reforms both in Kazakhstan and in worldwide. As a part of the broad investigation, this research provides the results of a sociological survey examining the assessment of civil servants toward recent civil service reforms in Kazakhstan. The survey has been conducted among 14,250 respondents aged 20 years and older from 14 regions of Kazakhstan, including three cities of republican significance and the capital city of the country – Astana. According to the survey results, civil servants are satisfied with the current state of the civil service system in Kazakhstan. The items on satisfaction mainly refer to the working conditions in the government agencies like work schedules and organizational climate. The research further reveals factors influencing the general evaluation of civil servants, as well as the most critical problems in the national civil service system.
- 2 November 2024
- Published by University of Saints Cyril and Methodius in Central European Journal of Public Policy
- Vol. 18 (2) , 2-16
Open AccessAn Examination of Civil Servants’ Assessment of the New Civil Service Reforms in Kazakhstan
In recent years, Kazakhstan has demonstrated a strong commitment to make the civil service system open and transparent to its citizens. The country has introduced an e-government system to improve access to information and allow public consultation on civil service. Reforms of the civil service aim to reduce corruption in the civil service and to ensure a transition to a career-based model, meritocracy, and result-based remuneration. This study aims to expand the literature on the civil servants’ appraisal toward new civil service reforms both in Kazakhstan and in worldwide. As a part of the broad investigation, this research provides the results of a sociological survey examining the assessment of civil servants toward recent civil service reforms in Kazakhstan. The survey has been conducted among 14,250 respondents aged 20 years and older from 14 regions of Kazakhstan, including three cities of republican significance and the capital city of the country – Astana. According to the survey results, civil servants are satisfied with the current state of the civil service system in Kazakhstan. The items on satisfaction mainly refer to the working conditions in the government agencies like work schedules and organizational climate. The research further reveals factors influencing the general evaluation of civil servants, as well as the most critical problems in the national civil service system.
- Open Access
- 20 September 2024
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in The Journal of Economic Research & Business Administration
- Vol. 149 (3) , 150-160
Enhancing the professionalism of civil servants: the experience of the OECD countries
Professionalization of official activities is an important link in the process of strengthening the public service and increasing customer focus in relations between the public and private sectors. Time dictates higher demands on the professional and personal qualities of managers and ordinary employees of government agencies. Communication skills, flexibility in decision making, and analytical skills come to the fore. The aim of this article is to study the experience of OECD countries in this area, the main trends in the training and retraining of officials, with the development of recommendations for improving approaches to the professionalization of the state apparatus in Kazakhstan. The study examines and summarizes cases from countries such as the UK, USA, Canada, Japan, France, Lithuania, and Australia. In addition to the educational component, the policy of civil servants professionalization within the OECD countries is based on the meritocracy principles, gender equality, and continuous improvement of skills. Overall, the core principles for improving public service in OECD countries are professional, strategic and innovative. The paper concludes with recommendations aimed at advancing the professionalization of Kazakhstan's state apparatus, drawing on current practices and lessons learned from international best practices. Key words: professionalization, training, retraining, government apparatus, Kazakhstan, OECD.
- 20 September 2024
- Published by al-Farabi Kazakh National University in The Journal of Economic Research & Business Administration
- Vol. 149 (3) , 150-160
Open AccessEnhancing the professionalism of civil servants: the experience of the OECD countries
Professionalization of official activities is an important link in the process of strengthening the public service and increasing customer focus in relations between the public and private sectors. Time dictates higher demands on the professional and personal qualities of managers and ordinary employees of government agencies. Communication skills, flexibility in decision making, and analytical skills come to the fore. The aim of this article is to study the experience of OECD countries in this area, the main trends in the training and retraining of officials, with the development of recommendations for improving approaches to the professionalization of the state apparatus in Kazakhstan. The study examines and summarizes cases from countries such as the UK, USA, Canada, Japan, France, Lithuania, and Australia. In addition to the educational component, the policy of civil servants professionalization within the OECD countries is based on the meritocracy principles, gender equality, and continuous improvement of skills. Overall, the core principles for improving public service in OECD countries are professional, strategic and innovative. The paper concludes with recommendations aimed at advancing the professionalization of Kazakhstan's state apparatus, drawing on current practices and lessons learned from international best practices. Key words: professionalization, training, retraining, government apparatus, Kazakhstan, OECD.
- Open Access
- 4 August 2024
- Published by OpenEd Network in Journal of Curriculum Studies Research
- Vol. 6 (2) , 70-87
Building Communicative Competencies for Future Leaders: An Analysis of Public Administration Curricula in Kazakhstan
This study aims to identify issues related to developing communicative competencies among public servants by examining the educational programs, catalogs of academic disciplines, and competency models of graduate programs in Public and Local Administration at universities in Kazakhstan. We analyzed publicly available information from higher education institutions' web pages on training programs, course descriptions, and key competencies in relevant fields. It was revealed that universities in Kazakhstan provide limited information about their programs, thus we referred to comprehensive data from unified higher ed platform from Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan. The analysis indicates that program administrators often neglect communicative competencies while building curricula. In most cases, they are subject to specific courses such as Governance Psychology and Human Resources, with the content varying considerably from one university to another. The Academy of Public Administration under the President of Kazakhstan is the only institution offering robust courses dedicated to this area. The expected outcomes include skills in public speaking, interaction with the public and media, business correspondence, conflict resolution, and knowledge of organizational culture and ethical behavior. Considering the importance and growing attention to the effect of the communication skills of civil servants for public satisfaction, this study concludes that Kazakh universities should ensure the inclusion of communication competencies into Public Administration programs. Such additions could enhance the preparation of prospective public servants, aiding them in their professional roles and during employment selection processes.
- 4 August 2024
- Published by OpenEd Network in Journal of Curriculum Studies Research
- Vol. 6 (2) , 70-87
Open AccessBuilding Communicative Competencies for Future Leaders: An Analysis of Public Administration Curricula in Kazakhstan
This study aims to identify issues related to developing communicative competencies among public servants by examining the educational programs, catalogs of academic disciplines, and competency models of graduate programs in Public and Local Administration at universities in Kazakhstan. We analyzed publicly available information from higher education institutions' web pages on training programs, course descriptions, and key competencies in relevant fields. It was revealed that universities in Kazakhstan provide limited information about their programs, thus we referred to comprehensive data from unified higher ed platform from Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan. The analysis indicates that program administrators often neglect communicative competencies while building curricula. In most cases, they are subject to specific courses such as Governance Psychology and Human Resources, with the content varying considerably from one university to another. The Academy of Public Administration under the President of Kazakhstan is the only institution offering robust courses dedicated to this area. The expected outcomes include skills in public speaking, interaction with the public and media, business correspondence, conflict resolution, and knowledge of organizational culture and ethical behavior. Considering the importance and growing attention to the effect of the communication skills of civil servants for public satisfaction, this study concludes that Kazakh universities should ensure the inclusion of communication competencies into Public Administration programs. Such additions could enhance the preparation of prospective public servants, aiding them in their professional roles and during employment selection processes.