WBWilliam Byrne

William Byrne

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


William Byrne has a total of 23 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Constraining Geophysical Properties of Europa’s Ice Shell from the Depth to Eutectic Interfaces

    by William Byrne, Ana-Catalina Plesa, Frank Postberg, Hauke Hussman, Dustin Schroeder, Gregor Steinbrügge, Natalie Wolfenbarger, Gael Cascioli

    Europa is a prime target for planetary exploration due to its strong astrobiological potential. Slightly smaller than Earth’s moon, Europa harbors a liquid water ocean beneath an ice shell. The ice shell thickness is poorly constrained and values of less than 1 km to up to 90 km have been suggested in previous studies employing a combination of thermal, impact, and mechanical models [1,2]. Low ice thickness values were derived from mechanical models, which can generally only estimate the thickness of the brittle mechanical lid. Thermal and impact models, which are able to consider the entire ice shell, suggest higher end-member values. Ice-penetrating radars on NASA’s Europa-CLIPPER (REASON, [3]) and ESA’s JUICE (RIME, [4]) missions aim to determine the thickness of Europa's ice shell. Recent studies have suggested that constraints on the thickness of Europa’s ice shell can be obtained through the detection of eutectic interfaces, defined as the depth where brines become thermodynamically stable [5]. In fact, the detection of eutectic interfaces within an ice shell is likely easier than that of the ice-ocean interface, given their shallower depths [6,7,8]. Their depth depends on the thermal state of the ice shell, which is closely linked to the ice shell viscosity and large-scale internal dynamics [6]. Thus, the detection of eutectic interfaces represents a promising strategy to constrain the thermophysical and geodynamic properties of the ice shell [5,6]. In this study we use the geodynamic code GAIA-v2 [9] to investigate the dynamics within Europa's ice shell. GAIA-v2 is a finite volume fluid flow solver. It numerically solves the conservation equations of mass, linear momentum, and thermal energy in order to determine the thermal state and fluid flow within the interior of planetary bodies. The code was originally developed to model solid-state convection in the interior of rocky bodies [10,11,12], but was recently adapted to treat large-scale dynamics in the ice shell of icy moons in the outer Solar System [13]. Our models use a 2D cylindrical geometry, and we vary the ice shell thickness and the reference viscosity. While free-slip is implemented as a condition on all boundaries, the top layer naturally arrives at a no-slip boundary condition due to the strong temperature-dependent viscosity (which follows an Arrhenius law). The reference viscosity, which is based on the viscosity at the ice-ocean interface, is varied over several orders of magnitude between the different models. We set the surface temperature to the temperature at the equator of Europa (110 K), and the temperature at the base of our model to the melting temperature of water-ice at the respective pressure. Our models include a large parameter study in which we vary ice shell thickness between 20 and 60 kilometers, the reference viscosity between 10^12 and 10^15 Pascal seconds, and a single deformation mechanism, namely diffusion creep. Additionally, we test models that consider a temperature-dependent thermal conductivity, temperature- and depth-dependent thermal expansivity, as well as more complex deformation mechanisms including dislocation creep, grain boundary sliding, and basal slip. Figure 1 Captions:End-member Zolotov and Shock eutectic interfaces (237 K) for simulations with 20 km ice shell (left) and 60 km (right), varying reference viscosity by color. The dashed line represents the average eutectic depth (km) for the given eutectic interface. Figure 2 Captions:Ice shell thickness (D, km) plotted against average eutectic depth (km) for each simula- tion and for each eutectic temperature. A consistent positive relationship holds between ice shell thickness and average eutectic depth for all simulations and the two colder eutectic temperatures. The eutectic temperature for MgSO4 is close to the pressure-dependent melting temperature of water ice (ice-ocean interface temperature), such that the average eutectic depth will consistently be equivalent to ice shell depth. Once a simulation has reached a statistical (quasi-)steady state, we determine the eutectic pattern by identifying the depths of the eutectic temperature. We treat this sequence of eutectic depths as a signal (Figure 1) and identify key characteristics of the interface like the number and location of upwellings and downwellings (peaks and troughs), average eutectic depth, and dominant signal frequency. Once these key characteristics are determined, we use them to develop scaling laws that link them to key geodynamic parameters. While our preliminary results have struggled to demonstrate consistent relationships between global convective cell count and viscosity, they do show a close relation between the average eutectic depth and the total ice shell depth (Figure 2). By increasing the number and complexity of our simulations, we aim to fully develop these initial scaling laws which relate the convection structure with the viscosity and thickness of Europa’s ice shell. This will provide a framework that will help to interpret the detection of eutectic interfaces in future radar measurements in thecontext of large-scale dynamics of Europa’s ice shell. In future work, we will evaluate the ability to reconstruct patterns of the ice shell by using sparse radar echoes, similar to melt detection on terrestrial glaciers, and create a more realistic signal resolution based on terrestrial and non-terrestrial sounding studies. References[1] Billings et al., 2005, Icarus, [2] Vilella et al., 2020, JGR: Planets, [3] Blankenship et al., 2024, Space Sci. Rev., [4] Bruzzone et al., 2013, IEEE IGARSS, [5] Schroeder et al., 2024, GRL, [6] Kalousova et al., 2017, JGR: Planets, [7] Soucek et al., 2023, JGR: Planets, [8] Byrne et al., 2024, JGR: Planets, [9] Huettig et al., 2013, PEPI, [10] Laneuville et al., 2013, JGR: Planets, [11] Tosi et al., 2013, JGR: Planets, [12] Plesa et al., 2016, JGR: Planets, [13] Rueckriemen-Bez...

  • Open Access

    Leveraging Eutectic Interfaces in Geodynamic models of Europa’s Ice shell to constrain Physical Parameters

    by William Byrne, Ana-Catalina Plesa, Natalie Wolfenbarger, Hauke Hussmann, Dustin Schroeder, Gregor Steinbrügge

    Jupiter’s moon Europa is one of the prime targets for planetary exploration due to its high astrobiological potential. Slightly smaller than Earth’s moon, Europa harbors a liquid water ocean beneath an ice shell. The thickness of Europa’s ice shell is poorly constrained and values of less than 1 km to up to 90 km have been suggested in previous studies that investigated shell thickness via a combination of thermal, impact, and mechanical models [2,3]. Low thickness values were derived from mechanical models, which can generally only estimate the thickness of the brittle layer. Thermal and impact models can consider the entire ice shell and estimates using such models suggest the higher thickness end-member values.Ice-penetrating radars on NASA’s Europa-CLIPPER (REASON, [4]) and ESA’s JUICE (RIME, [5]) missions aim to determine the thickness of Europa's ice shell. Recent studies have suggested that constraints on the thickness of Europa’s ice shell can be obtained through the detection of eutectic interfaces, defined as the depth where brine becomes thermodynamically stable in the ice shell [6]. In fact, previous studies have shown that the detection of eutectic horizons within an ice shell is likely easier than detecting the ice-ocean interface, given their shallower depths and therefore lower total signal attenuation [7,8,9]. The depth of the eutectic interfaces depends on the thermal state of the ice shell, which is closely linked to the ice shell viscosity and large-scale dynamics [7]. As suggested by previous authors [6,7], detection of eutectic interfaces therefore represents a promising strategy to constrain the thermophysical properties of the ice shell through characterization of its convective pattern.In this study we use the geodynamic code GAIA-v2 [1] to investigate the ice shell dynamics on Europa. GAIA-v2 is a finite volume fluid flow solver. It numerically solves the conservation equations of mass, linear momentum, and thermal energy in order to determine the thermal state and fluid flow within the interior or planetary bodies. The code was originally developed to model solid-state convection in the interior of rocky bodies [10,11,12], but was recently adapted to treat large-scale dynamics in the ice shell of moons in the outer solar system [13,14].We vary the ice shell thickness and ice shell viscosity that largely affect the convection pattern and in particular the number of hot upwellings and cold downwellings that can develop. In our models, we use a 2D cylindrical geometry. While free-slip is implemented as a condition on all boundaries, the top layer naturally arrives at a no-slip boundary condition due to the strong temperature-dependent viscosity (which follows an Arrhenius law). We choose a reference value for the viscosity at the ice-ocean interface and vary this over several orders of magnitude between the different models. We set the surface temperature to the temperature at the equator of Europa (110 K), and the temperature at the base of our model to the melting temperature of water-ice at the respective pressure. In our simulations, we only include diffusion creep as a deformation mechanism and vary the reference viscosity over several orders of magnitude.Figure 1: End-member Zoltov and Shock eutectic interfaces (237 K) for simulations with 20 km ice shell (left) and 60 km (right), varying reference viscosity by color. The dashed line represents the average eutectic depth (km) for the given eutectic interface.Once a simulation has reached a statistical (quasi-)steady state, we determine the eutectic pattern by identifying the depths of the eutectic temperature. We treat this sequence of eutectic depths as a signal (Figure 1) and identify key characteristics of the interface like the number and location of upwellings and downwellings (peaks and troughs), average eutectic depth, and dominant signal frequency. The number of local maxima and minima are used in conjunction with the dominant frequency to estimate the global number of convective cells in the ice shell. Once these key characteristics are determined, we use them to develop scaling laws to key geodynamic parameters.Figure 2: Ice shell thickness (D, km) plotted against average eutectic depth (km) for each simulation, for each eutectic temperature. A consistent positive relationship holds between Ice shell thickness and average eutectic depth for all simulations and the two colder eutectic temperatures. The eutectic temperature for MgSO4 is so close to the pressure-dependent solidus of water ice (ice-ocean interface temperature) that the average eutectic temperature will consistently be equivalent to ice shell depth.While our preliminary results have struggled to demonstrate consistent relationships between global convective cell count and viscosity, they do show a close relation between the average eutectic depth and the total ice shell depth (Figure 2). By increasing the number and complexity of our simulations, we aim to fully develop these initial scaling laws which relate the convection structure with the viscosity and thickness of Europa’s ice shell. This will provide a framework that will help to interpret the detection of eutectic interfaces in future radar measurements in the context of large-scale dynamics of the deep ice shell. In future work, we will evaluate the ability to reconstructure patterns of the ice shell by using sparse radar echoes by analyzing cases of melt detection on terrestrial glaciers, and create a more realistic signal resolution based on terrestrial and non-terrestrial sounding studies.References:[1] Hüttig et al., 2013, PEPI. [2] Billings and Kattenhorn et al., 2005, Icarus. [3] Vilella et al., 2020, JGR:Planets. [4] Blankenship et al., 2024, Nature. [5] Bruzzone et al., 2013, IEEE:IGARSS. [6] Schroeder et al., 2024, GRL. [7] Kalousova et al., 2017, JGR:Planets. [8] Soucek et al., 2023, GRL. [9] Byrne et al., 2024,...

  • Open Access

    Modeling Convection Dynamics in the Ice Shell of Enceladus

    by Evan DeMers, William Byrne, Ana-Catalina Plesa, Andreas Benedikter, Hauke Hussmann

    The presence of an ocean beneath the Enceladus’ ice shell makes this Saturnian moon a high priority target for future planetary exploration [1]. Water jets that have been observed at the south pole by NASA’s Cassini mission [2] are thought to originate from a global ocean and provide a direct window into the subsurface composition [3]. These jets generate a highly porous material that, due to its low thermal conductivity, affects the thermal state of the ice shell.The analysis of pit chains on the surface of Enceladus indicates that locally the porous layer can be as thick as 700 m [4]. Such a thick porous layer can locally increase the temperature of the ice shell, leading to a low viscosity. This may promote solid-state convection in regions where the ice shell is covered by such a layer, whereas regions with thin porous layers could be characterized by conductive heat transport. Moreover, due to its effect on the ice shell temperature, the porous layer can strongly attenuate the signal of radar sounders that have been proposed to investigate the Enceladus’ subsurface [5, 6].Here, we use the geodynamical code GAIA-v2 [7] to investigate the effects of a porous layer on the thermal state and dynamics of Enceladus’ ice shell. GAIA-v2 was originally built to model convection in the rocky mantle of terrestrial planets [8,9,10] but has recently been adapted to investigate large-scale dynamics in the shells of icy moons [11,12]. Our initial simulations use a 2D cylindrical geometry with an 18° arc computational domain, free-slip boundaries, and an Arrhenius rheology with diffusion creep, dislocation creep, as well as basal slip and grain-boundary sliding deformation mechanisms.Using the resulting thermal state, we calculate the associated two-way radar attenuation at each location within the ice shell. We test different values of the ice shell thickness (5 – 35 km, [13]), porous layer thickness (d = 0 – 750 m), and its thermal conductivities (k = 0.1 – 0.001 Wm-1K-1 [14,15]). To account for chemical impurities within the ice shell we test a “low” loss scenario that considers a pure water ice shell and a “high” loss case that assumes a homogeneous mixture of water ice and chlorides in concentrations extrapolated from the particle composition of Enceladus’ plume [5].Fig. 1: Modeled convection pattern in an ice shell with an ice shell thickness of 25 km, a porous layer thickness of 250 m, and porous layer thermal conductivity of 0.025 Wm-1K-1. Fig. 2: Laterally averaged profiles for Fig. 1 showing a) temperature with depth b) 2-way radar attenuation under low-loss pure water ice assumption c) 2-way radar attenuation under high-loss 300 µmol chloride assumption. We assume here an attenuation limit of 100 dB [16].Our results show that the porous layer thickness and its distribution have a first order effect on the thermal state and dynamics of the ice shell. Regions covered by a thick porous layer are characterized by a warm ice shell temperature and thus a lower viscosity, becoming more prone to undergo solid-state convection (Fig. 1). The vigor of convection depends on both the temperature-dependent ice shell viscosity and the temperature difference across the ice shell. While a thick porous layer would result in a low ice shell viscosity, thus increasing the convection vigor, such thick porous layers lead to an almost isothermal ice shell, due to their strong insulation, which, in turn, decreases the convection vigor. In ice shell regions covered by a thick porous layer, the penetration depth of a radar sounder is limited (Fig. 2), but as discussed in a recent study that only investigated a purely conductive ice shell [6], the high temperatures obtained in this case may lead to the formation of shallow brines detectable by radar measurements.Next, we will increase the angular size of our models and allow the ice-ocean interface at the lower boundary to vary to capture spatial variations of the ice shell thickness. The upper part of the computational domain in our model will be treated as the solid ice shell, while the lower part will mimic a water ocean layer with a lower viscosity. The viscosity of the water ocean will be set to several orders of magnitude lower than that of the overlying ice shell. We will vary the viscosity contrast between the ice shell and the water layer to investigate whether ice flow can occur and possibly dampen the variations in the ice shell thickness. This will help us understand how convection can dynamically alter ice shell thickness, in contrast to previous modeling which assumes a purely conductive ice shell [6].In future models, we will extend our models to include the effects of chemical impurities and tidal forces on the thermal state of Enceladus’ ice shell. We will track the redistribution of chemical anomalies due to solid-state convection in the ice shell. To this end, we will test different initial distributions of chemical heterogeneities and include tidal heating. Both the presence of chemical anomalies and tidal heating can affect the convection vigor and the convection pattern that characterizes large-scale dynamics in the ice shell. We will compare these more complex models with previous chemically homogeneous models in order to examine the effects of chemical anomalies and tidal heating on the thermal and dynamical state of the ice shell, and on the 2-way radar attenuation. References:[1] Choblet et al. (2021), Experimental Astronomy; [2] Porco et al. (2006), Science; [3] Postberg et al. (2009), Nature; [4] Martin et al. (2023), Icarus; [5] Souček et al. (2023), GRL; [6] Byrne et al. (2024), JGR:Planets; [7] Hüttig et al., (2013), PEPI; [8] Laneuville et al. (2013), JGR:Planets; [9] Tosi et al. (2015), GRL; [10] Plesa et al. (2016), JGR:Planets; [11] Rückriemen-Bez et al. (2023), Galilean Moons Workshop; [12] Plesa et al. (2023), Galilean...

  • Open Access

    Enceladus' Subsurface Secrets: Scientific Rationale for Future Radar Sounder Measurements

    by Ana-Catalina Plesa, Hauke Hussmann, Andreas Benedikter, William Byrne, Tina Rückriemen-Bez

    An outstanding question in planetary exploration addresses the habitability of icy moons in the outer Solar System. These bodies can harbor liquid water in substantial amounts over long time-scales, a necessary ingredient for habitable environments (Nimmo, 2018). Water on icy moons is located in a subsurface ocean covered by a global ice shell, and/or in local reservoirs within the ice shell itself. Moreover, for some of the satellites, in particular Europa and Enceladus and perhaps also Triton and the largest moons of Uranus, their oceans are in contact with the silicate interior. This allows for water-rock interactions potentially similar to those at the ocean floor on Earth. Such interactions would bring chemical compounds, in particular Carbon, Hydrogen, Nitrogen, Oxygen, Phosphorus, and Sulphur (CHNOPS) in contact with liquid water, creating the ‘right’ chemistry for a habitable environment. Due to tidal friction, which can be an important heat source in the moons’ interiors, energy that drives chemical cycles would be available and sustained over time, providing stable conditions for thermal and chemical reservoirs over billions of years.Among the icy moons, Enceladus has been recommended as the top priority target in ESA’s Voyage 2050 plan covering the science theme “Moons of the Giant Planets” (Martins et al., 2024), because of its high astrobiological potential. Based on the current knowledge from mission data and theoretical modelling, Enceladus provides compelling evidence for habitable conditions. The presence of a global ocean is supported by the combined analysis of low-order gravity field and topography data (Iess et al., 2014), and by independent measurements of forced physical librations (Thomas et al., 2016). The subsurface ocean is kept in a liquid state due to tidal energy that represents an important source of heat in Enceladus’s interior. Tidal deformation is also thought to drive the water plume activity at Enceladus’ south pole that was observed by the Cassini spacecraft (Porco et al., 2006). Constraints on the composition of Enceladus’ ocean and ice chemistry come from the plume material sampled during NASA’s Cassini mission, suggesting that within the ocean and ice, chloride and carbonate salts, as well as ammonia/ammonium and silica are present, the latter with lower concentrations (Postberg et al., 2018). The detection of nanometer-size silica grains in Enceladus’ plume material supports the presence of high-temperature hydrothermal alteration that is thought to occur at the ocean floor (Hsu et al., 2015). Moreover, local topographic depressions observed by Cassini using stereo imaging analysis could indicate the presence of regional liquid water reservoirs at shallow depths (Shenk & McKinnon, 2009). A subsurface radar sounder has been suggested to be part of the core payload of a future mission to Enceladus (Martins et al., 2024), as radar sounders are the obvious means to detect and characterize subsurface water reservoirs in the interior of icy moons (Benedikter et al., 2022). The scientific goals for radar sounder measurements on icy moons can be summarized as follows:Detection of global oceans by determining the ice-water interface and the spatial variation of the ice layer thickness Detection of near-surface water reservoirs that could be embedded in the ice shell The study of dynamic processes at active regions, in particular the connection of the ocean with the shallow subsurface/surface Characterization the layering of the upper ice crust, e.g. snow, ice regolith, compact ice for determining the past evolution (intensity of jet activity and geological history) In this study we focus on the scientific goals of a radar sounder at Enceladus. We discuss the ice shell characteristics (thickness and variations, thermal structure, and layering) and their effects on the radar attenuation. We calculate the two-way radar attenuation on Enceladus considering a porous thermally insulating surface layer generated by the plume material that falls back onto Enceladus’ surface. Our models show that for regions with a thin ice shell, most likely in a thermal conductive state, such as the south pole of Enceladus, the ice-ocean interface is detectable independent of the ice shell composition (Byrne et al., 2024). In regions covered by a thick insulating porous surface layer as suggested at least regionally, by the analysis of pit chains on the surface of Enceladus (Martin et al. 2023) a radar signal will not be able to reach the ice-ocean interface. However, for these same regions the high subsurface temperatures caused by a strong insulation due to the thick porous layer increase the likelihood that shallow brines are present (Byrne et al., 2024). Such brine reservoirs are fundamental to characterize potential habitable environments in the shallow subsurface, and the potential to directly access them with future measurements is much greater when compared to the accessibility of subsurface oceans (Wolfenbarger et al., 2022).References:Benedikter, A., Wickhusen, K., Hussmann, H., Stark, A., Damme, F., Rodriguez-Cassola, M., Krieger, G. (2022). Acta Astronautica.Byrne, W., Plesa, A.-C., Rückriemen-Bez, T., Hussmann, H., Benedikter, A. (2024). JGR:PlanetsHsu, H. W., Postberg, F., Sekine, Y., Shibuya, T., Kempf, S., Horányi, M., ... & Srama, R. (2015). Nature.Iess, L., Stevenson, D. J., Parisi, M., Hemingway, D., Jacobson, R. A., Lunine, J. I., ... & Tortora, P. (2014). Science.Martins, Z. et al. (2024)Martins, Z., Bunce, E., Grasset, O., Hamp, R., Jones, G., Le Gall, A., Lucchetti, A., Postberg, F., Prieto-Ballesteros, O., Roth, L., Tortora, P., & Vorburger, A. (2024) Expert Committee for the Large-class mission covering the science theme “Moons of the Giant Planets”.Martin, E.S., Whitten, J.L., Kattenhorn, S.A., Collins, G.C., Southworth, B.S., Wiser, L.S., Prindle, S....

  • Open Access

    Constraining the Viscosity of Europa’s Ice Shell from Eutectic Interfaces in Geodynamic Models

    by William Byrne, Ana-Catalina Plesa, Hauke Hussmann, Natalie Wolfenbarger, Dustin Schroeder, Gregor Steinbruegge

    Jupiter’s moon Europa is one of the prime targets for planetary exploration due to its high astrobiological potential. Slightly smaller than Earth’s moon, Europa harbors a liquid water ocean beneath an ice shell. The thickness of Europa’s ice shell is poorly constrained and values of less than 1 km to up to 90 km have been suggested in previous studies (e.g., Billings and Kattenhorn, 2005, Vilella et al., 2020). Ice-penetrating radars on NASA’s Europa Clipper (REASON, Blankenship et al., 2024) and ESA’s JUICE (RIME, Bruzzone et al., 2013) missions aim to determine the thickness of Europa's ice shell. Recent studies have suggested that constraints on the thickness of Europa’s ice shell can be obtained through the detection of eutectic interfaces, defined as the depth where brine becomes thermodynamically stable in the ice shell (Schroeder et al., 2024). In fact, previous studies have shown that the detection of eutectic horizons within an ice shell is likely easier than detecting the ice-ocean interface, given their shallower depths and therefore lower total signal attenuation (Kalousova et al., 2017, Soucek et al., 2023, Byrne et al., 2024). The depth of the eutectic interfaces depends on the thermal state of the ice shell, which is closely linked to the ice shell viscosity and large-scale dynamics (Kalousova et al., 2017). As suggested by previous authors (Kalousova et al., 2017, Schroeder et al., 2024), detection of eutectic interfaces therefore represents a promising strategy to constrain the thermophysical properties of the ice shell through characterization of its convective pattern. In this study we use the geodynamic code GAIA (Hüttig et al., 2013) to investigate the ice shell dynamics on Europa. We vary the ice shell thickness and ice shell viscosity that largely affect the convection pattern and in particular the number of hot upwellings and cold downwellings that can develop. In our models, the viscosity is temperature dependent and follows an Arrhenius law. We choose a reference value for the viscosity at the ice-ocean interface and vary this over several orders of magnitude between the different models. Once a simulation has reached a statistical (quasi-)steady state, we determine the eutectic pattern by identifying the depths of the eutectic temperature. We treat this sequence of eutectic depths as a signal and identify the peaks of each local maxima (or peak) in the signal. The number of local maxima in the simulation is used to estimate the global number of convection cells in the ice shell. Our preliminary results show a close relation between the number of plumes that develop in the ice shell of Europa and the viscosity at the ice-ocean interface. By increasing the number and complexity of our simulations, we aim to derive so-called scaling laws that will relate the convection structure with the viscosity and thickness of Europa’s ice shell. This will provide a framework that will help to interpret the detection of eutectic interfaces in future radar measurements in the context of large-scale dynamics of the deep ice shell.

  • Open Access

    The Effects of a Porous Layer on the Dynamics and Two-way Radar Attenuation of Enceladus’ Ice Shell

    by Evan DeMers, William Byrne, Ana-Catalina Plesa

    The presence of an ocean beneath the Enceladus’ ice shell makes this Saturnian moon a high priority target for future planetary exploration [1]. Water jets that have been observed at the south pole by NASA’s Cassini mission [2] are thought to originate from the ocean and provide a direct window into the subsurface composition [3]. These jets generate a highly porous material that, due to its low thermal conductivity, affects the thermal state of the ice shell.The analysis of pit chains on the surface of Enceladus indicates that locally the porous layer can be as thick as 700 m [4]. Such a thick porous layer can locally increase the temperature of the ice shell, leading to a low viscosity. This may promote solid-state convection in regions where the ice shell is covered by such a layer, whereas regions with thin porous layers could be characterized by conductive heat transport. Moreover, due to its effect on the ice shell temperature, the porous layer can strongly attenuate the signal of radar sounders that have been proposed to investigate the Enceladus’ subsurface [5, 6].Here, we use the geodynamical code GAIA [7] to investigate the effects of a porous layer on the thermal state and dynamics of Enceladus’ ice shell. Using the resulting thermal state we calculate the associated two-way radar attenuation at each location within the ice shell. We test different values of the ice shell thickness (5 – 35 km, [8]), porous layer thickness (d = 0 – 750 m), and its thermal conductivities (k = 0.1 – 0.001 Wm-1K-1 [9,10]). To account for chemical impurities within the ice shell we test a “low” loss scenario that considers a pure water ice shell and a “high” loss case that assumes a homogeneous mixture of water ice and chlorides in concentrations extrapolated from the particle composition of Enceladus’ plume [5].Our results show that the porous layer thickness and its distribution have a first order effect on the thermal state and dynamics of the ice shell. Regions covered by a thick porous layer are characterized by a warm ice shell temperature and thus a lower viscosity, becoming more prone to convect. The vigor of convection depends on both the temperature-dependent ice shell viscosity and the temperature difference across the ice shell. While a thick porous layer would result in a low ice shell viscosity, thus increasing the convection vigor, such thick porous layers lead to an almost isothermal ice shell, due to their strong insulation, which, in turn, decreases the convection vigor. As discussed in a recent study that only investigated a purely conductive ice shell [6], the high temperatures may lead to the formation of shallow brines detectable by radar measurements.References:[1] Choblet et al. (2021); [2] Porco et al. (2006); [3] Postberg et al. (2009); [4] Martin et al. (2023); [5] Souček et al. (2023). [6] Byrne et al. (2024); [7] Hüttig et al., (2013); [8] Hemingway & Mittal (2019); [9] Seiferlin et al. (1996); [10] Ferrari et al. (2021).

  • Open Access

    Exploring Enceladus: The Science Case for Future Radar Sounder Measurements

    by Hauke Hussmann, William Byrne, Ana-Catalina Plesa, Tina Rückriemen-Bez, Andreas Benedikter

    One of the major questions in planetary exploration concerns the habitability of icy moons in the outer Solar System. These bodies can harbor liquid water in substantial amounts over long time-scales, a necessary ingredient for habitable environments. Water on icy moons is located in global oceans in the subsurface, beneath a global ice shell, and/or in local reservoirs within this ice shell. Moreover, some of the satellites, in particular Europa and Enceladus and perhaps also Triton and the largest Moons of Uranus, may provide the ‘right’ chemistry because of an ocean-silicate interface in their interior. The latter allows for rock-water interaction potentially bringing chemical compounds (CHNOPS) in contact with liquid water. Due to tidal friction, which can be an important heat source in the moons’ interiors, energy that drives chemical cycles would be available and sustained over time. Among the icy moons, Enceladus is a high priority target for planetary explorations due to its high astrobiological potential. Based on the current knowledge from mission data and theoretical modeling, Enceladus provides compelling evidence for the presence of a global ocean, tidal energy as a heat source, hydrothermal processes at the ocean floor, current surface activity and a young surface, as well as possible existence of shallow water reservoirs and complex chemistry. In fact, Enceladus is recommended as the top priority target in ESA’s Voyage 2050 plan covering the science theme “Moons of the Giant Planets” [1], with a subsurface radar sounder in the core payload of such a mission. Radar sounders are the obvious means to detect and characterize subsurface water reservoirs on icy moons [2]. They can determine the ice-water interface and variations thereof, detect near-surface water reservoirs, study the connection of the ocean with the shallow subsurface/surface, and characterize the layering of the upper ice crust, e.g. snow, ice regolith, or compact ice that can help to understand the past evolution (intensity of jet activity and geological history).In this study we focus on the scientific goals of a radar sounder at Enceladus. We discuss the ice shell characteristics (thickness and variations, thermal structure, and layering) and their effects on the radar attenuation. We calculate the two-way radar attenuation on Enceladus considering a conductive ice shell covered by a porous thermally insulating surface layer. Our models show that for regions covered by a thick insulating porous surface layer (∼700 m, [3]) a radar signal will not be able to reach the ice-ocean interface. However, for these same regions the high subsurface temperatures caused by a strong insulation due to the thick porous layer increase the likelihood that shallow brines are present [4]. Such brine reservoirs are fundamental to characterize habitable environments in the shallow subsurface, and the potential to directly access them with future measurements is much greater when compared to the accessibility of subsurface oceans [5].References:[1] Martins et al. (2024); [2] Benedikter et al., this meeting; [3] Martin et al. (2023); [4] Byrne et al. (2024); [5] Wolfenbarger et al. (2022).

  • Open Access

    A Distributed Radar Sounder Concept for Subsurface Exploration of Saturn's Moon Enceladus: Feasibility and Potential

    by Andreas Benedikter, Ana-Catalina Plesa, Jalal Matar, Hauke Hussmann, Masaki Nagai, Tobias Otto, Taruna Parihar, William Byrne, Tina Rückriemen-Bez, Eduardo Rodrigues-Silva, et al.

    Since the very first observations of the Moon, radars have been more and more employed as payloads of planetary exploration missions, in various operational modes like altimeters, SARs or radar sounders. Especially radar sounders provide unique measurement capabilities for the subsurface exploration of planetary bodies, as demonstrated by the MARSIS and SHARAD instruments and planned for the REASON [1] and RIME [2] instruments of the Europa Clipper and Juice missions, aimed on the exploration of Jupiter’s icy moons. Radar sounders are nadir-looking sensors that transmit pulsed electromagnetic radiation that propagates through the subsurface due to its relatively low frequency. Each dielectric discontinuity in the ground material reflects part of the signal towards the radar. The analysis of the recorded echoes provides crucial information on the subsurface structure and composition. Despite the capability of achieving good performances, the abovementioned instruments are limited by the almost omnidirectional antenna characteristic of dipole antennas that are commonly used because of the large antenna size at low frequencies. Due to the omnidirectional characteristic, surface clutter, i.e., spurious signals from off-nadir directions, is collected that potentially masks the signal of interest coming from subsurface layers in nadir direction, thus hindering the subsurface data interpretation.To overcome those limitations, we investigate the feasibility and potential of a distributed radar sounder satellite configuration for an Enceladus mission scenario, in the frame of an ESA study. Distributed radar sounding configurations have been already proposed for Earth Observation of icy regions (e.g., the STRATUS concept [3]). Such a formation flying satellite configuration allows for synthesizing a large antenna array that potentially provides the following advantages with respect to a traditional radar sounding configuration: 1) suppress the surface clutter through beamforming techniques, 2) increase the signal to noise ratio, 3) possibility of exploiting interferometric techniques for subsurface DEM generation and clutter interpretation, and 4) possibility of performing 3D tomographic imaging of the subsurface.We present an analysis of a distributed HF-band radar sounder for the subsurface exploration of Enceladus including 1) a science case derivation, 2) orbit and formation implications, 3) radar operational concepts, 4) instrument and satellite system architecture implications, and 5) performance assessment. The formation consists of up to 7 satellites, one complex mother satellite (~1.5 tons) implementing the radar signal transmission and other power and mass demanding functionalities (e.g., communication, down-link, data storage, on-board processing), and the other satellites (~200 kg) implementing transponder functionalities that receive the radar echoes and forward it to the mother satellite in a MirrorSAR [4] configuration. A main criticality is the strongly perturbed gravitational environment at Enceladus [5] posing challenges on the orbits and the formation flying capabilities. Potential orbit and formation concepts are presented as well as a performance assessment for the subsurface sounder exploration of Enceladus based on the envisioned satellite formation, attenuation and backscatter models, different operational concepts, and different beamforming approaches.References:[1] Blankenship et al., 2009. [2] Bruzzone et al., 2013. [3] Bruzzone et al., 2021. [4] Krieger et al., 2017. [5] Benedikter et al., 2022.


  • Open Access

    The thermal and dynamic state of Europa’s ice shell: Revealed by global-scale convection models

    by Tina Rückriemen-Bez, Ana-Catalina Plesa, William Byrne, Hauke Hussmann, Andreas Benedikter

    Europa’s hydro- and cryosphere is of primary interest in the quest for habitable environments in the solar system (e.g., [1]). The ice shell, which connects the potential subsurface ocean to the surface, may itself provide niches for life if liquid brine pockets can form and exist for extended periods of time. It is thus crucial to understand the thermal and dynamic state of the ice shell in order to characterize the existence and transport of liquid brines within the ice shell.Recent work by [2] and [3] investigated the effects of temperature dependent thermal conductivity (k) as well as heat capacity (cp) and a complex composite rheology on convection in the ice shell. In this work, we build upon these previous efforts by combining the influence of both - varying thermodynamic parameters and complex rheology - in geodynamic simulations performed with the convection code GAIA [4]. Instead of a temperature-dependent heat capacity, we investigate the effect of a temperature- and depth-dependent thermal expansivity (α), which is a crucial term in determining the buoyancy induced by temperature differences. We study the dynamic state (Nu-Ra scaling), the mechanical state (elastic thickness, brittle-to-ductile transition, deformation maps), and the thermal state (bottom and top boundary heat flux, occurrence of brines) of the ice shell for various setups (using both constant and variable α and k) and input parameters (ice shell thickness and grain size). For selected models, i.e. distinct thermal and dynamic states, we calculate the local two-way attenuation based on [5], [6]. The resulting two-way attenuation patterns will offer initial insights into the radar's ability to penetrate to the ice-ocean interface. If attenuation proves excessive due to the presence of hot thermal plumes, making the sampling of the ice-ocean interface unlikely, the patterns can still provide valuable insights into the dynamic state of Europa's ice shell. This includes parameters such as the thickness of the conductive layer (the so-called stagnant lid) that forms in the top part of the ice shell or the wavelength of convective structures deeper in the ice shell.References:[1] Coustenis & Encrenaz et al., 2013. [2] Carnahan et al. 2021. [3] Harel et al. 2020. [4] Hüttig et al., 2013. [5] Kalousova et al., 2017. [6] Soucek et al., 2023.

  • Open Access

    The effects of an icy porous layer on the two-way radar attenuation on Enceladus

    by William Byrne, Ana-Catalina Plesa, Tina Rückriemen-Bez, Andreas Benedikter, Hauke Hussmann

    Saturn's moon, Enceladus is considered a priority target for future planetary missions due to its high astrobiological potential [1]. Water jets presumably originating from a subsurface ocean have been observed at the south pole of Enceladus by NASA’s Cassini mission [2], and their analysis provides a direct window into the ocean composition [3] that, in turn, can help to understand the nature and amount of impurities that may exist within the ice shell.Enceladus’ jet activity generates a highly porous material that affects the thermal state of the ice shell. The thickness of that layer and its distribution are poorly constrained, but local thicknesses of up to 700m have been reported from the analysis of pit chains on the surface of Enceladus [4]. Such a thick porous layer can strongly attenuate the signal of radar sounders that have been proposed to investigate the Enceladus’ subsurface [5].Here, we use numerical simulations to determine the effects of a porous layer on the two-way radar attenuation. We generate a variety of steady-state one-dimensional thermal models based on proposed parameters for Enceladus’ ice shell thickness (5 - 35 km, [6]), porous layer thickness (0 - 700 m [4]) and its thermal conductivity (0.1 - 0.001 W/mK [7,8]). In addition to systematically testing parameter combinations, we use two ice shell thickness maps [6] together with local thermal profiles to provide a global spatial distribution of potential penetration depths that could be achieved by radar measurements. We use two material models ("high" and "low" loss) to identify the impact of chemical impurities on attenuation [9]. While the “low” loss scenario considers an ice shell composed of pure water ice, the “high” loss case is characterized by a homogeneous mixture of water ice and chlorides in concentrations extrapolated from the particle composition of Enceladus’ plume [5].Our results show that the presence of a porous layer has a first-order effect on the two-way radar attenuation. For regions covered by porous layers with thicknesses larger than 250 m and a thermal conductivity lower than 0.025 W/(mK) the two-way radar attenuation reaches a threshold value of 100 dB before reaching the ice-ocean interface in the low loss scenarios. In the high loss cases, for similar porous layer thicknesses and thermal conductivity, the two-way attenuation remains below 100 dB for at most 48% of the ice shell. Depending on the local ice shell thickness and properties of the snow deposits, as little as a few percent of the ice shell can be penetrated before the 100 dB limit is reached. We note, however, that the presence of a porous layer leads to high subsurface temperatures and promotes the formation of brines at shallow depth that can be detected by future radar measurements. References:[1] Choblet et al., 2021. [2] Hansen et al., 2006. [3] Postberg et al., 2008. [4] Martin et al., 2023. [5] Soucek et al., 2023. [6] Hemingway & Mittal, 2019. [7] Seiferlin et al., 1996. [8] Ferrari et al., 2021. [9] Kalousova et al., 2017.