AAAlaeddin Acar

Alaeddin Acar

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Alaeddin Acar has a total of 15 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • From feasibility to consolidation: a bibliometric analysis of robot-assisted stereoelectroencephalography (2011–2025)

    by Alaeddin Acar, Bahadır Kaya, Eray Tekirdaş, Selçuk Yazıcı, Sacide Kalaycıoğlu, Diaa Yahya

    Robot-assisted stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG) has become an established technique for localising the epileptogenic zone in drug-resistant focal epilepsy, yet its literature has not been mapped bibliometrically. To characterise the structure, dynamics, and thematic evolution of this literature, we analysed 151 publications (118 articles, 33 reviews) indexed in the Web of Science Core Collection between 2011 and 2025, using Bibliometrix for performance and thematic analysis and VOSviewer for co-authorship networks. The corpus grew at a compound annual rate of 21.90% and reached a corpus h-index of 33; segmented Poisson regression identified a single change in regime at 2020, after which annual output was higher but showed no further trend. Author productivity was steeply skewed (Lotka β = 3.37). The United States led in both volume (72 publications) and impact (national h-index 22), whereas Italy recorded the highest per-document citation rate (164.4) on only five publications. The intellectual foundation rested on accuracy- and safety-validation studies, led by Cardinale et al. and González-Martínez et al. A stable SEEG core persisted while the field evolved from early depth-electrode themes toward a recent reorganisation around robotics, the learning curve, and expanded indications such as deep brain stimulation and radiofrequency thermocoagulation. These findings chart how the literature consolidated around a narrow validation base and then shifted toward delivery and training, identifying training standardisation, comparative-effectiveness research, and wider global access as its principal open priorities.

  • Open Access

    Generative versus discriminative diagnostic performance of large multimodal models in intracranial and spinal neuroradiology

    by Alaeddin Acar, Bahadir Kaya, Diaa Yahya, Selcuk Yazici, Sacide Kalaycioglu, Eray Tekirdas, Burcak Bilginer

    This study evaluated three large multimodal models (LMMs), GPT-5.2, Gemini 3 Pro, and Claude Opus 4.5, on 252 intracranial and spinal neuroradiology cases from the paywall-protected RSNA Case Collection using a two-stage paradigm comparing open-ended generative reasoning with multiple-choice discriminative recognition from a neurosurgical perspective. Generative primary diagnostic accuracy ranged from 51.6% to 62.7%, rising to 75.4–81.0% when answer options were provided, revealing a 15.1–23.8 percentage point gap. Among completely incorrect diagnoses, 43-59% were self-corrected upon provision of answer choices. Clinical impact grading by a neurosurgical panel demonstrated that clinically significant errors occurred in 17.8–26.9% of all cases. In a stratified 100-case subcohort with four models and repeated runs, and in a fresh-session re-evaluation, the same gap persisted and was not inflated by the within-session design. The low open-ended accuracy and the clinical error burden do not support autonomous diagnostic use; whether the stronger discriminative performance can support an assistive role will require prospective human-AI evaluation, and assessment should move beyond multiple-choice accuracy.

  • Open Access

    Evaluation of GPT-4o and GPT o1 pro in answering Turkish Neurosurgical Society proficiency board exam questions: A comparative study

    by Alaeddin Acar, Eray Tekirdaş

    Purpose: This study aims to evaluate and compare the answering capabilities and accuracy of GPT-4o and GPT o1 pro for a set of 98 questions, including image-based questions, from the 2024 neurosurgery board certification examination.Materials and methods: Answers to 98 questions, including image-based questions, were generated using GPT-4o and GPT o1 pro. We evaluated their performance through both one-shot and multiple-attempt methods, calculating accuracy and consistency rates. Comparisons were made between text-based and image-based questions to assess multimodal reasoning.Results: GPT o1 pro achieved a one-shot accuracy of 92.9%, while GPT-4o reached 71.4% (p<0.001). Over three attempts, GPT o1 pro maintained 91.8% accuracy compared to GPT-4o’s 72.4% (p<0.001). GPT o1 pro also showed higher consistency (91.8% vs 78.6%, p=0.009). For text-only questions, GPT o1 pro reached 96.3% one-shot accuracy, compared to GPT-4o’s 72.8%. For image-based questions, GPT o1 pro scored 76.5%, and GPT-4o scored 64.7%, though this difference was not statistically significant (p=0.68). These results suggest that GPT o1 pro outperforms GPT-4o, especially for text-based items, but both models need further improvement for image-based tasks.Conclusion: Both GPT o1 pro and GPT-4o successfully passed the 2024 Turkish Neurosurgical Society Board Certification Examination. GPT o1 pro showed notably higher accuracy and consistency than GPT-4o, suggesting a promising role for chain-of-thought reasoning in medical education.

  • Open Access

    Critical Limitations in Comparing ChatGPT and DeepSeek for Orthopedic Assessment

    by Orhan Ayas, Alaeddin Acar

    We read with great interest the study by Anusitviwat et al [1], which compared the performance of ChatGPT and DeepSeek in orthopedic examinations. While the study provides timely insights into the utility of Large Language Models (LLMs) in medical education, we identified specific methodological and terminological limitations that warrant clarification to ensure the validity and reproducibility of the findings. Misinterpretation of Reliability Statistics The authors state that the "interrater reliability between the two LLMs" was evaluated using the Cohen κ coefficient [1]. Mathematically, measuring the agreement between two independent raters (inter-rater) yields a single coefficient. However, the results report two separate values: κ=0.81 for ChatGPT and κ=0.78 for DeepSeek [1]. This finding, combined with the methodology stating questions were input on "separate days [1], indicates that the study actually measured intra-model consistency (test-retest reliability) rather than the agreement between the models. Labeling internal consistency as "interrater reliability" is terminologically inaccurate and misrepresents the statistical relationship between the two models. Linguistic Ambiguity and Generalizability The manuscript does not specify the language of the input MCQs (Thai or English) used in the assessments. This omission is critical, as the impact of input language on LLM performance is well-documented. For instance, Noda et al (2024) [2] demonstrated that GPT-4V's accuracy on the Japanese Otolaryngology Board Examination significantly improved from 24.7% (Japanese input) to 47.3% when translated into English. This finding underscores that models optimized for English exhibit distinct performance disparities in non-English languages. Without clarifying whether the assessments were administered in the local language or English, it is impossible to determine if the reported accuracy gap between ChatGPT (80.4%) and DeepSeek (74.2%) stems from medical reasoning capabilities or linguistic processing proficiency. Reproducibility and Interface Transparency The methodology reports the use of "Reason" and "DeepThink" functions but does not explicitly state whether the models were accessed via Web User Interfaces (UI) or Application Programming Interfaces (API) [1]. This distinction is vital for reproducibility. Web UIs are subject to opaque updates and lack the stability of controlled API environments. Without defining the access method and the specific prompt structures used, the experimental conditions cannot be replicated. Risk of Data Contamination The authors note that the MCQs "have been used in orthopedic examinations for more than 5 years". This longevity significantly increases the risk of data contamination, as older items likely exist in public repositories within LLM training corpora, potentially conflating memorization with reasoning. To ensure validity, recent benchmarks employ private datasets (Busch et al [3]) or questions post-dating the model’s training cut-off (Noda et al [2]). The absence of such controls in this study undermines the internal validity of the comparison Data Reporting Discrepancy Finally, we noted a minor discrepancy in Table 2. In the "Pelvic and spine injury" category (n=19), the accuracy for the Reason function is listed as 16 (68.8%) [1]. Mathematically, 16 out of 19 corresponds to approximately 84.2%, not 68.8%. We respectfully invite the authors to clarify this value to ensure the precision of the tabulated data.


  • Open Access

    Before the Data: Ensuring the Nanoparticle Gets Tested (Preprint)

    by Sema Nur Acar, Alaeddin Acar

    UNSTRUCTURED We read with interest the protocol by Khanadali and Ikhar [1] evaluating cerium oxide nanoparticles (CeO₂-NPs) and chlorhexidine gluconate (CHX) against Enterococcus faecalis in root canals. We identified critical concerns regarding vehicle formulation and outcome assessment. The fundamental issue lies in inconsistent vehicle formulation. Groups 2 (CeO₂-NPs) and 3 (CeO₂-NPs + CHX) contain methyl cellulose as a thickening agent, producing gel-like consistency, whereas the negative control (Group 4) is sterile water without this excipient. Consequently, any observed CFU reduction in the nanoparticle groups cannot be unambiguously attributed to CeO₂-NPs, as the gel matrix itself may contribute to the antimicrobial outcome. Methyl cellulose forms a viscous hydrogel matrix that coats biofilms, restricts oxygen and nutrient diffusion, and alters agent–dentin contact dynamics. If Groups 2 or 3 demonstrate superior bacterial reduction, it becomes impossible to distinguish whether this stems from the intrinsic antimicrobial activity of CeO₂-NPs or from the physical barrier effect of the methyl cellulose matrix itself. A second concern is the absence of outcome assessor blinding. The protocol specifies CFU counts "manually or using a digital colony counter," yet no blinding of the evaluator to group allocation is described [2]. The use of vehicle controls is well established in endodontic research. Tagelsir et al [3], evaluating antimicrobials against a 3-week-old E. faecalis biofilm, included a placebo paste (methylcellulose only) as the vehicle control—thereby isolating the physical effects of the gel matrix from the antimicrobial activity of the test agents. We recommend the same approach here: Group 4 should be reformulated as a vehicle control (sterile water + methyl cellulose) rather than sterile water alone, so that the physical effects of the gel matrix can be isolated from the antimicrobial activity of CeO₂-NPs in Groups 2 and 3. Additionally, CFU assessment should be performed by a blinded evaluator. We respectfully encourage the authors to consider these modifications, which would strengthen the study's internal validity and the interpretability of its anticipated findings.

  • Open Access

    Bridging Neurofeedback and Structural Connectivity in Chronic Pain

    by Alaeddin Acar, Diaa Yahya, Eray Tekirdaş


  • A rare brain abscess caused by co-infection with Fusobacterium nucleatum and Actinomyces meyeri

    by Abdullah Tozluyurt, Mustafa Caglar Sahin, Alaeddin Acar

    Summary Brain abscesses are rare but life-threatening infections that may result from contiguous spread or hematogenous dissemination, with odontogenic infections being an important source. We report the first case from Turkey of a polymicrobial brain abscess caused by Actinomyces meyeri and Fusobacterium nucleatum in an immunocompetent 81-year-old male with poor oral hygiene and a history of untreated dental infection. The patient presented with headache and altered mental status, and neuroimaging revealed a right frontal abscess. Surgical excision was performed, and microbiological evaluation identified both pathogens by anaerobic culture and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight (MALDI-TOF) mass spectrometry, with susceptibility testing confirming sensitivity to β‑lactams and metronidazole. Notably, follow-up oral swab culture yielded A. meyeri with an identical susceptibility profile, supporting a dental origin of infection. The patient was successfully treated with surgical drainage and high-dose penicillin G combined with metronidazole followed by oral therapy, with no recurrence observed at 3 months. This case emphasizes the role of odontogenic infections as a source of intracranial abscesses and highlights the importance of microbiological and molecular methods for accurate pathogen identification and therapeutic guidance.


  • Open Access

    Data Contamination in AI Evaluation

    by Alaeddin Acar


  • Open Access

    Data Contamination in AI Evaluation (Preprint)

    by Alaeddin Acar

    Journal of Medical Internet Research - International Scientific Journal for Medical Research, Information and Communication on the Internet #Preprint #PeerReviewMe: Warning: This is a unreviewed preprint. Readers are warned that the document has not been peer-reviewed by expert/patient reviewers or an academic editor, may contain misleading claims, and is likely to undergo changes before final publication, if accepted, or may have been rejected/withdrawn. Readers with interest and expertise are encouraged to sign up as peer-reviewer, if the paper is within an open peer-review period. Please cite this preprint only for review purposes or for grant applications and CVs (if you are the author).