Andrew R. Stone
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Andrew R. Stone has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Albert H. Rivero
University of Virginia
3 shared publications - Jaclyn Kaslovsky
Department of Political Science Washington University in St. Louis St. Louis Missouri USA
2 shared publications - Christopher N. Krewson
Brigham Young University
1 shared publication - Jeffrey Ziegler
Trinity College Dublin
1 shared publication - Joshua Boston
Bowling Green State University
1 shared publication - Marcy Shieh
Miami University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 14 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Political Research Quarterly
- Vol. 79 (4) , 1133-1148
Depictions of Partisan Bias at Oral Argument and Public Evaluations of the U.S. Supreme Court
The Supreme Court relies on public goodwill for its authority, yet its decision-making processes are often hidden from the public eye. Media coverage of oral arguments in prominent cases provides an opportunity for Americans to assess how the Court carries out its procedures. Using a survey experiment conducted around the oral arguments in Trump v. Anderson , we show that depictions of partisan bias by the justices in their oral argument questioning patterns reduce perceptions of procedural fairness, decrease approval of oral argument, and undermine views about the Court’s authority. While these effects are driven by bias against copartisans, bias favoring copartisans does not improve evaluations. Our findings illustrate the responsiveness of the American public to depictions of the Court’s decision-making behavior and highlight procedural fairness as an avenue for the Court to maintain institutional support.
- 14 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Political Research Quarterly
- Vol. 79 (4) , 1133-1148
Depictions of Partisan Bias at Oral Argument and Public Evaluations of the U.S. Supreme Court
The Supreme Court relies on public goodwill for its authority, yet its decision-making processes are often hidden from the public eye. Media coverage of oral arguments in prominent cases provides an opportunity for Americans to assess how the Court carries out its procedures. Using a survey experiment conducted around the oral arguments in Trump v. Anderson , we show that depictions of partisan bias by the justices in their oral argument questioning patterns reduce perceptions of procedural fairness, decrease approval of oral argument, and undermine views about the Court’s authority. While these effects are driven by bias against copartisans, bias favoring copartisans does not improve evaluations. Our findings illustrate the responsiveness of the American public to depictions of the Court’s decision-making behavior and highlight procedural fairness as an avenue for the Court to maintain institutional support.
- Open Access
- 24 June 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Experimental Political Science
- p. 1-14
Do the Audio and Video from Public Hearings Impact High Court Legitimacy?
Judges may express underlying political preferences when speaking that can only be captured with audio and not text. Yet, it is unclear if audio or video recordings of judicial proceedings shape high courts’ legitimacy differently than written transcripts. We address this question with two survey experiments using short, real-world case excerpts from the US and UK. In sum, we do not find evidence that the method of delivery is associated with evaluations of court legitimacy as predicted by past studies. These null results persist when we account for the emotions that judges convey, perceived political inclinations of judges, and participants’ political preferences. Our findings offer novel insight into the relationship between high court attitudes and the medium through which judicial decisions are communicated.
- 24 June 2026
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Experimental Political Science
- p. 1-14
Open AccessDo the Audio and Video from Public Hearings Impact High Court Legitimacy?
Judges may express underlying political preferences when speaking that can only be captured with audio and not text. Yet, it is unclear if audio or video recordings of judicial proceedings shape high courts’ legitimacy differently than written transcripts. We address this question with two survey experiments using short, real-world case excerpts from the US and UK. In sum, we do not find evidence that the method of delivery is associated with evaluations of court legitimacy as predicted by past studies. These null results persist when we account for the emotions that judges convey, perceived political inclinations of judges, and participants’ political preferences. Our findings offer novel insight into the relationship between high court attitudes and the medium through which judicial decisions are communicated.
- 9 March 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Political Research Quarterly
- Vol. 79 (2) , 674-688
Communicating the Politics of the Law: Legal and Legislative Rhetoric About High Court Decisions
Politicians engage in messaging in attempts to score points with their constituencies and, if possible, mobilize them in support of political outcomes. For members of the U.S. Congress (especially senators, who have a constitutionally designated role in staffing the U.S. Supreme Court), major court cases provide an ideal opportunity for this behavior. In this paper, we examine when senators communicate with the public about salient Court cases and how they employ legal rhetoric and legislative rhetoric when doing so. We argue that these behaviors depend on a legislator’s constituency, personal traits, and institutional position. We conduct two complementary analyses of rates of messaging about salient cases and the language used in abortion cases from 2012 to 2024 and find support for our argument. Our findings contribute to scholarly understanding of how legislators represent their constituencies, illuminate the sources of American attitudes toward the judiciary, and shed light on an understudied form of separation-of-powers interactions between two branches of American government.
- 9 March 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Political Research Quarterly
- Vol. 79 (2) , 674-688
Communicating the Politics of the Law: Legal and Legislative Rhetoric About High Court Decisions
Politicians engage in messaging in attempts to score points with their constituencies and, if possible, mobilize them in support of political outcomes. For members of the U.S. Congress (especially senators, who have a constitutionally designated role in staffing the U.S. Supreme Court), major court cases provide an ideal opportunity for this behavior. In this paper, we examine when senators communicate with the public about salient Court cases and how they employ legal rhetoric and legislative rhetoric when doing so. We argue that these behaviors depend on a legislator’s constituency, personal traits, and institutional position. We conduct two complementary analyses of rates of messaging about salient cases and the language used in abortion cases from 2012 to 2024 and find support for our argument. Our findings contribute to scholarly understanding of how legislators represent their constituencies, illuminate the sources of American attitudes toward the judiciary, and shed light on an understudied form of separation-of-powers interactions between two branches of American government.
- Open Access
- 3 March 2026
- Vol. 90 (1) , 218-237
Ideological Cues, Partisanship, and Prejudice Against LGBTQ Judges
How does the gender and sexual identity of a prospective judge shape public support for their nomination? We build upon recent scholarship on instrumental inclusivity and argue that, after accounting for nominee ideology, Americans of all partisan stripes will penalize LGBTQ nominees. Using a conjoint experiment, we randomly vary a prospective Biden US Supreme Court nominee’s gender and sexual identity. Crucially, we also randomize the nominee’s ideology, enabling us to disentangle LGBTQ identity from the ideological signal it sends and differentiate between genuine and instrumental support for LGBTQ nominees. Contrary to recent findings suggesting that Democrats reward minority judges, we find that respondents from both parties penalize LGBTQ nominees. The magnitude of these effects—roughly 14 percentage points for transgender nominees and 8 percentage points for gay or lesbian nominees—is considerable and second only to shared partisanship. Our study underscores that ideological alignment does not necessarily foster genuine inclusivity for LGBTQ individuals and highlights the persistent challenges of representation for marginalized groups in an era of polarized judicial nominations.
- 3 March 2026
- Vol. 90 (1) , 218-237
Open AccessIdeological Cues, Partisanship, and Prejudice Against LGBTQ Judges
How does the gender and sexual identity of a prospective judge shape public support for their nomination? We build upon recent scholarship on instrumental inclusivity and argue that, after accounting for nominee ideology, Americans of all partisan stripes will penalize LGBTQ nominees. Using a conjoint experiment, we randomly vary a prospective Biden US Supreme Court nominee’s gender and sexual identity. Crucially, we also randomize the nominee’s ideology, enabling us to disentangle LGBTQ identity from the ideological signal it sends and differentiate between genuine and instrumental support for LGBTQ nominees. Contrary to recent findings suggesting that Democrats reward minority judges, we find that respondents from both parties penalize LGBTQ nominees. The magnitude of these effects—roughly 14 percentage points for transgender nominees and 8 percentage points for gay or lesbian nominees—is considerable and second only to shared partisanship. Our study underscores that ideological alignment does not necessarily foster genuine inclusivity for LGBTQ individuals and highlights the persistent challenges of representation for marginalized groups in an era of polarized judicial nominations.
- Open Access
- 30 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Legislative Studies Quarterly
- Vol. 50 (4)
Promoting a Diverse Bench: An Analysis of Elite Messaging About Descriptive Representation
Existing work documents how senators use their official communications to explain their Washington activities and build support in the district. However, relatively little remains known about how senators communicate about one of their most important constitutional duties—providing advice and consent on Supreme Court nominees. In this paper, we investigate how senators discuss Supreme Court nominations with their constituents, focusing on one common rhetorical strategy: highlighting the descriptive traits of nominees. Using a new dataset of press releases about nominee race and gender, we demonstrate that senators of both parties frequently discuss the descriptive traits of nominees. Next, we systematically investigate the determinants of this rhetoric, finding that shared characteristics with the nominee, copartisanship, and institutional position predict discussion of descriptive representation. Then, we use the CES to demonstrate the impact of these messages on constituent evaluations of senators; we find a modest boost in using such messages. Finally, we conduct a preliminary investigation of discussion of nominee religion using our framework. Our findings provide important insight into how senators use rhetorical appeals to appeal to constituents and make the case for diversity in governing.
- 30 August 2025
- Published by Wiley in Legislative Studies Quarterly
- Vol. 50 (4)
Open AccessPromoting a Diverse Bench: An Analysis of Elite Messaging About Descriptive Representation
Existing work documents how senators use their official communications to explain their Washington activities and build support in the district. However, relatively little remains known about how senators communicate about one of their most important constitutional duties—providing advice and consent on Supreme Court nominees. In this paper, we investigate how senators discuss Supreme Court nominations with their constituents, focusing on one common rhetorical strategy: highlighting the descriptive traits of nominees. Using a new dataset of press releases about nominee race and gender, we demonstrate that senators of both parties frequently discuss the descriptive traits of nominees. Next, we systematically investigate the determinants of this rhetoric, finding that shared characteristics with the nominee, copartisanship, and institutional position predict discussion of descriptive representation. Then, we use the CES to demonstrate the impact of these messages on constituent evaluations of senators; we find a modest boost in using such messages. Finally, we conduct a preliminary investigation of discussion of nominee religion using our framework. Our findings provide important insight into how senators use rhetorical appeals to appeal to constituents and make the case for diversity in governing.
- Open Access
- 10 January 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Law and Courts
- p. 1-23
Elections Improve Support for State Trial Court Judges in the United States
Do constituents care how judges are chosen? We conduct two nationally representative survey experiments focusing on state trial courts. Our first study indicates that respondents prefer judges who are elected to those who are appointed, though this does not affect their perceptions of the judiciary’s legitimacy. Our second study explores three potential mechanisms: efficacy, experience with democracy, and perceived ideological proximity. We find evidence that real-world experience with judicial elections is associated with a preference for such elections, but we do not find evidence for other mechanisms. Our study offers important new evidence for assessing proposed reforms to judicial selection.
- 10 January 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Law and Courts
- p. 1-23
Open AccessElections Improve Support for State Trial Court Judges in the United States
Do constituents care how judges are chosen? We conduct two nationally representative survey experiments focusing on state trial courts. Our first study indicates that respondents prefer judges who are elected to those who are appointed, though this does not affect their perceptions of the judiciary’s legitimacy. Our second study explores three potential mechanisms: efficacy, experience with democracy, and perceived ideological proximity. We find evidence that real-world experience with judicial elections is associated with a preference for such elections, but we do not find evidence for other mechanisms. Our study offers important new evidence for assessing proposed reforms to judicial selection.
- Open Access
- 27 August 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Law and Courts
- Vol. 12 (2) , 369-391
The Political Determinants of Public Support for Obstruction of Supreme Court Nominees
Despite increased political attention to instances of legislative obstruction in recent years, little is known about the public’s attitudes toward these procedural techniques. I evaluate these attitudes in the context of the last two decades of nominations to the U.S. Supreme Court with three complementary analyses. In the first, nationally representative survey evidence reveals an overriding political dimension to Americans’ attitudes over the use of tactics to delay the confirmation process. The president’s copartisans express considerably higher levels of opposition to delayed consideration of a nominee than individuals politically opposed to the president. In the second and third, evidence from observational surveys and a survey experiment shows that these attitudes vary depending on the type of the obstruction under consideration, with Americans less supportive of the use of forms of obstruction that entirely preclude procedural consideration of a nominee, such as refusing to hold hearings, than more established methods that do not, like the filibuster or document requests. These findings reveal that the American public has internalized the political stakes of judicial nominations and suggest that obstruction may have electoral consequences in an era of extreme polarization.
- 27 August 2024
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Law and Courts
- Vol. 12 (2) , 369-391
Open AccessThe Political Determinants of Public Support for Obstruction of Supreme Court Nominees
Despite increased political attention to instances of legislative obstruction in recent years, little is known about the public’s attitudes toward these procedural techniques. I evaluate these attitudes in the context of the last two decades of nominations to the U.S. Supreme Court with three complementary analyses. In the first, nationally representative survey evidence reveals an overriding political dimension to Americans’ attitudes over the use of tactics to delay the confirmation process. The president’s copartisans express considerably higher levels of opposition to delayed consideration of a nominee than individuals politically opposed to the president. In the second and third, evidence from observational surveys and a survey experiment shows that these attitudes vary depending on the type of the obstruction under consideration, with Americans less supportive of the use of forms of obstruction that entirely preclude procedural consideration of a nominee, such as refusing to hold hearings, than more established methods that do not, like the filibuster or document requests. These findings reveal that the American public has internalized the political stakes of judicial nominations and suggest that obstruction may have electoral consequences in an era of extreme polarization.
- 16 July 2024
- Published by Wiley in Legislative Studies Quarterly
- Vol. 50 (1) , 22-37
Geographic representation and requests for federal funds in the U.S. senate
An essential component of a representative's job centers on deciding where to allocate scarce resources. How do legislators attempt to allocate spending across the geographic units of their constituencies, and what determines a legislator's success in securing these resources? To answer these questions, we create a new dataset of all earmark requests made by U.S. senators in the 117th Congress. This data was recently made available as part of reforms, allowing researchers to examine both requests and outcomes. We show that senators prioritize seeking earmarks for areas of their constituencies critical to their electoral success. We then match these requests to earmarks funded by the Appropriations Committee and show that a legislator's institutional standing and the behavior of their same‐state colleague—but not electoral concerns—shape whether projects are successfully funded. We provide insight into a behind‐the‐scenes aspect of representation and illuminate the strategic dynamics that shape federal spending.
- 16 July 2024
- Published by Wiley in Legislative Studies Quarterly
- Vol. 50 (1) , 22-37
Geographic representation and requests for federal funds in the U.S. senate
An essential component of a representative's job centers on deciding where to allocate scarce resources. How do legislators attempt to allocate spending across the geographic units of their constituencies, and what determines a legislator's success in securing these resources? To answer these questions, we create a new dataset of all earmark requests made by U.S. senators in the 117th Congress. This data was recently made available as part of reforms, allowing researchers to examine both requests and outcomes. We show that senators prioritize seeking earmarks for areas of their constituencies critical to their electoral success. We then match these requests to earmarks funded by the Appropriations Committee and show that a legislator's institutional standing and the behavior of their same‐state colleague—but not electoral concerns—shape whether projects are successfully funded. We provide insight into a behind‐the‐scenes aspect of representation and illuminate the strategic dynamics that shape federal spending.