Yassine Chami
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Yassine Chami has a total of 51 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Maya Khater
5 shared publications- Enas Qutieshat
College of Law, Sohar University
3 shared publications - Maya Khater
Collage of Law Al Ain Abu Dhabi 00000 United Arab Emirates University
3 shared publications - Novendri Mohamad Nggilu
Faculty of Law, Universitas Negeri Gorontalo
3 shared publications Dina Imad
Abu Dhabi University
2 shared publicationsEnas Qutieshat
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 9 July 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Cogent Social Sciences
- Vol. 12 (1)
Civil litigation management between Algerian and Emirati legislation: a comparative analytical study of mechanisms for achieving effective justice
1. Due to the structural changes that are changing modern legal jurisprudence, the right to litigation is no longer seen as just a formal way to get to the courts. Instead, it is seen as a qualitat...
- 9 July 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Cogent Social Sciences
- Vol. 12 (1)
Open AccessCivil litigation management between Algerian and Emirati legislation: a comparative analytical study of mechanisms for achieving effective justice
1. Due to the structural changes that are changing modern legal jurisprudence, the right to litigation is no longer seen as just a formal way to get to the courts. Instead, it is seen as a qualitat...
- Open Access
- 14 June 2026
- Published by IAIN Manado in Jurnal Ilmiah Al-Syir'ah
- Vol. 24 (1) , 180
Procedural Formalities versus Substantive Protection (Reconciliation and Child Welfare in Divorce under Algerian and Indonesian Legal Systems)
This study aims to analyze the role of judges in promoting reconciliation and protecting children's rights during divorce proceedings, as regulated by the Algerian Family Code and the Civil and Administrative Procedure Code. The research employs a normative legal approach by examining statutory provisions and relevant literature to evaluate the practical implementation of legal norms. The findings reveal that although reconciliation is mandated by law, the failure to undertake such efforts does not invalidate the divorce judgment. This suggests that reconciliation serves as a procedural formality rather than a substantive requirement within the legal framework. The research further underscores the need for a more integrated legal approach that balances legal certainty with child protection. In practice, judicial focus during reconciliation hearings tends to prioritize the interests of the divorcing parties while insufficiently addressing the implications for children. Consequently, the study emphasizes the importance of active judicial intervention to safeguard children's rights to custody, maintenance, and protection during divorce. It advocates for legal reform to transform reconciliation into a meaningful mechanism, ensuring that the child's best interests are at the center of divorce proceedings.
- 14 June 2026
- Published by IAIN Manado in Jurnal Ilmiah Al-Syir'ah
- Vol. 24 (1) , 180
Open AccessProcedural Formalities versus Substantive Protection (Reconciliation and Child Welfare in Divorce under Algerian and Indonesian Legal Systems)
This study aims to analyze the role of judges in promoting reconciliation and protecting children's rights during divorce proceedings, as regulated by the Algerian Family Code and the Civil and Administrative Procedure Code. The research employs a normative legal approach by examining statutory provisions and relevant literature to evaluate the practical implementation of legal norms. The findings reveal that although reconciliation is mandated by law, the failure to undertake such efforts does not invalidate the divorce judgment. This suggests that reconciliation serves as a procedural formality rather than a substantive requirement within the legal framework. The research further underscores the need for a more integrated legal approach that balances legal certainty with child protection. In practice, judicial focus during reconciliation hearings tends to prioritize the interests of the divorcing parties while insufficiently addressing the implications for children. Consequently, the study emphasizes the importance of active judicial intervention to safeguard children's rights to custody, maintenance, and protection during divorce. It advocates for legal reform to transform reconciliation into a meaningful mechanism, ensuring that the child's best interests are at the center of divorce proceedings.
- Open Access
- 7 May 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Lex Scientia Law Review
- Vol. 10 (1) , 259-302
The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Enhancing the Cyber Notary Concept in the Digital Era: Opportunities, Challenges, and Implications
The rapid advancement of Artificial Intelligence (AI) is reshaping the landscape of legal services, with particular consequences for the practice of notarization. The concept of the Cyber Notary, a digital notarial service enabling remote and secure authentication of legal documents, has emerged as a critical institutional innovation in response to growing demand for efficient digital legal infrastructure. Yet, despite its transformative potential, the integration of AI into Cyber Notary systems continues to generate unresolved tensions between technological capability and legal permissibility. This study examines the role of AI in strengthening the Cyber Notary concept in the digital era, with particular emphasis on Indonesia's normative framework. Through a normative legal research methodology combining statutory, comparative, and conceptual approaches, this paper identifies a fundamental conflict between the physical-presence requirements embedded in Law Number 2 of 2014 on Notarial Positions (UUJN) and the digitalization imperatives recognized under the ITE Law and Law Number 27 of 2022 on Personal Data Protection (PDPL). Drawing on comparative insights from Japan, the European Union, and the United States, the study demonstrates that the adoption of AI in notarial practice is legally feasible only where supportive regulatory infrastructure exists, a condition that Indonesia has not yet fully met. The findings underscore the necessity of targeted legislative reform, enhanced algorithmic transparency, and formal professional guidance to bridge the current regulatory vacuum. This research contributes to the broader discourse on the responsible integration of AI in civil law jurisdictions, offering concrete recommendations for policymakers, legal practitioners, and technology developers.
- 7 May 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Lex Scientia Law Review
- Vol. 10 (1) , 259-302
Open AccessThe Role of Artificial Intelligence in Enhancing the Cyber Notary Concept in the Digital Era: Opportunities, Challenges, and Implications
The rapid advancement of Artificial Intelligence (AI) is reshaping the landscape of legal services, with particular consequences for the practice of notarization. The concept of the Cyber Notary, a digital notarial service enabling remote and secure authentication of legal documents, has emerged as a critical institutional innovation in response to growing demand for efficient digital legal infrastructure. Yet, despite its transformative potential, the integration of AI into Cyber Notary systems continues to generate unresolved tensions between technological capability and legal permissibility. This study examines the role of AI in strengthening the Cyber Notary concept in the digital era, with particular emphasis on Indonesia's normative framework. Through a normative legal research methodology combining statutory, comparative, and conceptual approaches, this paper identifies a fundamental conflict between the physical-presence requirements embedded in Law Number 2 of 2014 on Notarial Positions (UUJN) and the digitalization imperatives recognized under the ITE Law and Law Number 27 of 2022 on Personal Data Protection (PDPL). Drawing on comparative insights from Japan, the European Union, and the United States, the study demonstrates that the adoption of AI in notarial practice is legally feasible only where supportive regulatory infrastructure exists, a condition that Indonesia has not yet fully met. The findings underscore the necessity of targeted legislative reform, enhanced algorithmic transparency, and formal professional guidance to bridge the current regulatory vacuum. This research contributes to the broader discourse on the responsible integration of AI in civil law jurisdictions, offering concrete recommendations for policymakers, legal practitioners, and technology developers.
- Open Access
- 30 April 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Journal of Law and Legal Reform
- Vol. 7 (2) , 863-902
Reconstructing Alternative Dispute Resolution for Land Disputes Based on Local Wisdom in the Coastal Area of Tomini Bay
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) has long been recognized as an effective mechanism for resolving land disputes in Indonesia due to its emphasis on consensus and social harmony. However, the increasing reliance on formal legal procedures has marginalized local wisdom-based dispute resolution practices, particularly in coastal communities. Despite extensive studies on ADR, limited research has examined the integration of local wisdom into land dispute resolution in regions such as Tomini Bay. This study aims to reconstruct ADR mechanisms by incorporating local wisdom in resolving land disputes in the coastal area of Tomini Bay. It employs a normative legal approach, combining empirical data with analysis of statutory regulations, legal doctrines, and field data, using qualitative methods. The findings indicate that local wisdom-based mechanisms, particularly deliberation (musyawarah) and consensus (mufakat), remain effective in resolving disputes and maintaining social cohesion, yet are not fully integrated into the formal legal system. Therefore, this study argues that ADR should be reconstructed by integrating local wisdom and living law into Indonesia’s legal framework to ensure more culturally responsive and sustainable dispute resolution.
- 30 April 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Journal of Law and Legal Reform
- Vol. 7 (2) , 863-902
Open AccessReconstructing Alternative Dispute Resolution for Land Disputes Based on Local Wisdom in the Coastal Area of Tomini Bay
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) has long been recognized as an effective mechanism for resolving land disputes in Indonesia due to its emphasis on consensus and social harmony. However, the increasing reliance on formal legal procedures has marginalized local wisdom-based dispute resolution practices, particularly in coastal communities. Despite extensive studies on ADR, limited research has examined the integration of local wisdom into land dispute resolution in regions such as Tomini Bay. This study aims to reconstruct ADR mechanisms by incorporating local wisdom in resolving land disputes in the coastal area of Tomini Bay. It employs a normative legal approach, combining empirical data with analysis of statutory regulations, legal doctrines, and field data, using qualitative methods. The findings indicate that local wisdom-based mechanisms, particularly deliberation (musyawarah) and consensus (mufakat), remain effective in resolving disputes and maintaining social cohesion, yet are not fully integrated into the formal legal system. Therefore, this study argues that ADR should be reconstructed by integrating local wisdom and living law into Indonesia’s legal framework to ensure more culturally responsive and sustainable dispute resolution.
- Open Access
- 31 March 2026
- Published by Yayasan Cerdas Pedia Indonesia in Siyasah Dusturiyah: State Law Review
- Vol. 1 (5) , 41-62
The Legal Politics of the Establishment and Governance of the National Nutrition Agency
The establishment of the National Nutrition Agency as a massive budget entity through Presidential Regulation triggers constitutional anomalies by disregarding legislative hierarchy and expertise meritocracy. This doctrinal legal research deconstructed executive legal politics pathology and government ethics implications using conceptual parameters, structural regulation, and comparative constitutional law. The analysis conclusively proves that founding giant institutions without constitutional delegation represents executive dominance paralyzing power limitation mechanisms, while institutional legitimacy is engineered through parliamentary budget pragmatism. Lacking meritocratic instruments that prevent medical nonexpert leadership appointments demonstrably creates epistemological dissonance, triggers jurisdictional disharmony, and fatally degrades public health safety standards. This study asserts that mass nutrition interventions fundamentally require absolute comprehensive institutional restructuring. This research offers prescriptive novelty by recommending an independent medical oversight committee under legislative frameworks to secure accountability systems, critically enriching global constitutionalism discourses regarding contemporary administrative law resilience and public health governance for universal social welfare policy formulations internationally.
- 31 March 2026
- Published by Yayasan Cerdas Pedia Indonesia in Siyasah Dusturiyah: State Law Review
- Vol. 1 (5) , 41-62
Open AccessThe Legal Politics of the Establishment and Governance of the National Nutrition Agency
The establishment of the National Nutrition Agency as a massive budget entity through Presidential Regulation triggers constitutional anomalies by disregarding legislative hierarchy and expertise meritocracy. This doctrinal legal research deconstructed executive legal politics pathology and government ethics implications using conceptual parameters, structural regulation, and comparative constitutional law. The analysis conclusively proves that founding giant institutions without constitutional delegation represents executive dominance paralyzing power limitation mechanisms, while institutional legitimacy is engineered through parliamentary budget pragmatism. Lacking meritocratic instruments that prevent medical nonexpert leadership appointments demonstrably creates epistemological dissonance, triggers jurisdictional disharmony, and fatally degrades public health safety standards. This study asserts that mass nutrition interventions fundamentally require absolute comprehensive institutional restructuring. This research offers prescriptive novelty by recommending an independent medical oversight committee under legislative frameworks to secure accountability systems, critically enriching global constitutionalism discourses regarding contemporary administrative law resilience and public health governance for universal social welfare policy formulations internationally.
- Open Access
- 22 March 2026
- Published by Royallite Global in Research Journal in Advanced Humanities
- Vol. 7 (2)
Legal discourse analysis: Foundations of forensic linguistics and its applications in legislation and litigation
Forensic linguistics has become an exciting area that combines law and linguistics. This study highlights how language, through its precise analysis, can act as valid judicial evidence in resolving legal cases. This paper examines how this field has developed over time, starting with Jan Svartvik’s important contributions in 1968, moving into the professionalisation of the discipline during the 1980s and 1990s, and highlighting its growth in the digital age today. It also examines forensic phonetics, author attribution, discourse analysis, and linguistic profiling, showing how they can be applied in criminal investigations, civil lawsuits, contract interpretation, and safeguarding intellectual property. The authors use a descriptive-analytical approach, supported by comparative case studies, and examine global examples in which linguistic evidence has played an important role. Artificial Intelligence and Large Language Models are able to process a huge amount of data in shorter time compared to humans, yet they still raise important legal and ethical challenges regarding their fairness, transparency, and comprehensibility. This paper had concluded that forensic linguistics has evolved and became a significant component of the legal system. It enhances justice by providing people with the resources to uncover the truth, protect their rights, and comprehend laws more easily.
- 22 March 2026
- Published by Royallite Global in Research Journal in Advanced Humanities
- Vol. 7 (2)
Open AccessLegal discourse analysis: Foundations of forensic linguistics and its applications in legislation and litigation
Forensic linguistics has become an exciting area that combines law and linguistics. This study highlights how language, through its precise analysis, can act as valid judicial evidence in resolving legal cases. This paper examines how this field has developed over time, starting with Jan Svartvik’s important contributions in 1968, moving into the professionalisation of the discipline during the 1980s and 1990s, and highlighting its growth in the digital age today. It also examines forensic phonetics, author attribution, discourse analysis, and linguistic profiling, showing how they can be applied in criminal investigations, civil lawsuits, contract interpretation, and safeguarding intellectual property. The authors use a descriptive-analytical approach, supported by comparative case studies, and examine global examples in which linguistic evidence has played an important role. Artificial Intelligence and Large Language Models are able to process a huge amount of data in shorter time compared to humans, yet they still raise important legal and ethical challenges regarding their fairness, transparency, and comprehensibility. This paper had concluded that forensic linguistics has evolved and became a significant component of the legal system. It enhances justice by providing people with the resources to uncover the truth, protect their rights, and comprehend laws more easily.
- Open Access
- 26 January 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Journal of Law and Legal Reform
- Vol. 7 (1) , 337-376
Integrating AI into Small Claims Courts: Lessons from Global Practices for Legal Reform in Indonesia
Indonesia’s civil judicial system persists in facing procedural inefficiencies, especially with small claims, notwithstanding the implementation of the e-Court system. The lack of intelligent assistance in this digital infrastructure obstructs the achievement of efficient, rapid, and cost-effective adjudication as required by law. This study seeks to investigate the potential incorporation of artificial intelligence (AI) into Indonesia’s small claims process as a tool for legislative and institutional change. The research used a normative legal methodology, incorporating statutory and comparative analyses, to derive insights from the regulatory frameworks and judicial innovations of China, Singapore, and Canada. These jurisdictions have effectively utilized AI for claim classification, procedural assistance, and facilitating access for self-represented litigants, according to the results. In contrast to traditional digital technologies, AI facilitates cognitive capabilities like pattern identification and legal triage, which can substantially reduce administrative burdens and improve judicial uniformity. The study presents a reform approach for Indonesia that integrates AI in the initial procedural phases—specifically in claim registration and preliminary review—while maintaining judicial independence and due process. This study’s originality resides in its integration of comparative law, legal technology, and Indonesian procedural realities to present a contextually relevant, ethically informed paradigm for AI-enhanced adjudication. If properly regulated and strategically implemented, this integration can convert small claims courts into more accessible, efficient, and equitable institutions, reinforcing the judiciary’s constitutional responsibility in providing substantive justice.
- 26 January 2026
- Published by Universitas Negeri Semarang in Journal of Law and Legal Reform
- Vol. 7 (1) , 337-376
Open AccessIntegrating AI into Small Claims Courts: Lessons from Global Practices for Legal Reform in Indonesia
Indonesia’s civil judicial system persists in facing procedural inefficiencies, especially with small claims, notwithstanding the implementation of the e-Court system. The lack of intelligent assistance in this digital infrastructure obstructs the achievement of efficient, rapid, and cost-effective adjudication as required by law. This study seeks to investigate the potential incorporation of artificial intelligence (AI) into Indonesia’s small claims process as a tool for legislative and institutional change. The research used a normative legal methodology, incorporating statutory and comparative analyses, to derive insights from the regulatory frameworks and judicial innovations of China, Singapore, and Canada. These jurisdictions have effectively utilized AI for claim classification, procedural assistance, and facilitating access for self-represented litigants, according to the results. In contrast to traditional digital technologies, AI facilitates cognitive capabilities like pattern identification and legal triage, which can substantially reduce administrative burdens and improve judicial uniformity. The study presents a reform approach for Indonesia that integrates AI in the initial procedural phases—specifically in claim registration and preliminary review—while maintaining judicial independence and due process. This study’s originality resides in its integration of comparative law, legal technology, and Indonesian procedural realities to present a contextually relevant, ethically informed paradigm for AI-enhanced adjudication. If properly regulated and strategically implemented, this integration can convert small claims courts into more accessible, efficient, and equitable institutions, reinforcing the judiciary’s constitutional responsibility in providing substantive justice.
- Open Access
- 7 January 2026
- Published by Institute of Research and Community Services Diponegoro University (LPPM UNDIP) in LAW REFORM
- Vol. 22 (1) , 238-260
Justice in the Balance: Activating Legislative-Reality Harmony to Ensure Fair Judicial Rulings Between Sharia And Modern Legal Systems
Achieving judicial fairness requires harmonizing legal texts with evolving societal realities. This research aims to explore the factors that enhance the fairness of judicial rulings by analyzing the interplay between abstract legal texts and practical reality. The method used involves a comparative analytical approach between modern legal systems and Islamic Sharia, supplemented by a review of judicial precedents. The results obtained indicate that legislative coherence and judicial discretion are critical for aligning rulings with justice objectives. Specifically, the study finds that rigid procedural adherence often undermines equity, whereas flexible interpretation grounded in contextual circumstances enhances fairness. Conclusions that can be drawn emphasize the necessity of developing legislative mechanisms that balance stability with equity, alongside promoting judicial transparency.
- 7 January 2026
- Published by Institute of Research and Community Services Diponegoro University (LPPM UNDIP) in LAW REFORM
- Vol. 22 (1) , 238-260
Open AccessJustice in the Balance: Activating Legislative-Reality Harmony to Ensure Fair Judicial Rulings Between Sharia And Modern Legal Systems
Achieving judicial fairness requires harmonizing legal texts with evolving societal realities. This research aims to explore the factors that enhance the fairness of judicial rulings by analyzing the interplay between abstract legal texts and practical reality. The method used involves a comparative analytical approach between modern legal systems and Islamic Sharia, supplemented by a review of judicial precedents. The results obtained indicate that legislative coherence and judicial discretion are critical for aligning rulings with justice objectives. Specifically, the study finds that rigid procedural adherence often undermines equity, whereas flexible interpretation grounded in contextual circumstances enhances fairness. Conclusions that can be drawn emphasize the necessity of developing legislative mechanisms that balance stability with equity, alongside promoting judicial transparency.
- Open Access
- 30 December 2025
- Published by Revista de Direito Administrativo and Constitucional in A&C - Revista de Direito Administrativo & Constitucional
- Vol. 25 (102) , 61-87
The Eternity of the Constitution: A Study of the Unamendable Clauses in Southeast Asian Countries
Constitutions, as the highest legal documents, often include Eternity clauses to protect core values that remain unalterable. In Southeast Asia, countries implement these clauses in various ways, reflecting the region’s complex social, political, and historical contexts. This study examines how Southeast Asia countries apply immutability clauses and assesses their impact on legal stability and political reform. Using a multidisciplinary comparative approach, the research focuses on the Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia, and Myanmar, analyzing the variations in their design and implementation. The study finds that Unamendable clauses help protect fundamental values such as the rule of law, democracy, and territorial integrity. However, these clauses also generate tensions between the need for stability and the demand for legal flexibility. The study’s novelty lies in its multidimensional analysis, which links law, politics, and culture, offering insights into the relevance of unamendable clauses amid modern challenges such as globalization and democratic pressures. By integrating legal, political, and social dimensions, the research shows that legal stability requires not only formal protection through unamendable clauses but also strong institutions and active public participation. These findings provide important insights for policymakers in Southeast Asia countries and contribute to the global literature on constitutional law.
- 30 December 2025
- Published by Revista de Direito Administrativo and Constitucional in A&C - Revista de Direito Administrativo & Constitucional
- Vol. 25 (102) , 61-87
Open AccessThe Eternity of the Constitution: A Study of the Unamendable Clauses in Southeast Asian Countries
Constitutions, as the highest legal documents, often include Eternity clauses to protect core values that remain unalterable. In Southeast Asia, countries implement these clauses in various ways, reflecting the region’s complex social, political, and historical contexts. This study examines how Southeast Asia countries apply immutability clauses and assesses their impact on legal stability and political reform. Using a multidisciplinary comparative approach, the research focuses on the Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia, and Myanmar, analyzing the variations in their design and implementation. The study finds that Unamendable clauses help protect fundamental values such as the rule of law, democracy, and territorial integrity. However, these clauses also generate tensions between the need for stability and the demand for legal flexibility. The study’s novelty lies in its multidimensional analysis, which links law, politics, and culture, offering insights into the relevance of unamendable clauses amid modern challenges such as globalization and democratic pressures. By integrating legal, political, and social dimensions, the research shows that legal stability requires not only formal protection through unamendable clauses but also strong institutions and active public participation. These findings provide important insights for policymakers in Southeast Asia countries and contribute to the global literature on constitutional law.
- Open Access
- 28 December 2025
- Published by LP2M Universitas Islam Negeri (UIN) Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta in AHKAM : Jurnal Ilmu Syariah
- Vol. 25 (2) , 415-428
Abuse of Rights: A Comparative Study between Mālikī Jurisprudence & Positive Law
This paper offers a comparative analytical evaluation of the theory of abuse of rights as articulated within Mālikī jurisprudence and in positive law. It highlights the doctrinal foundations of this theory within the Mālikī school, characterized by the extensive application of this concept to encompass all types of harm, supported by evidence from the Holy Quran and Sunnah. The research also employs a qualitative method based on a comparative analysis of classic jurisprudential texts, such as al-Muwāfaqāt, al-Furūq, and al-Mudawwanah, while specifically focusing on contemporary positive law, such as the civil codes of Egypt and Algeria. The study demonstrates that there is a high degree of overlap between the core criteria laid down by Mālikī jurisprudence related to the abuse of rights and the related criteria adopted in contemporary positive law, especially concerning three basic criteria: the illegitimacy of the interest; the intent to harm others; and the inconsistency between the interest sought and the harm caused. The study also demonstrates that Mālikī jurisprudence was at the forefront of developing an integrated theory of abuse of rights that carefully balances private interests with broader public-interest principles. Abstrak Paper ini menyajikan evaluasi analitis komparatif terhadap teori penyalahgunaan hak sebagaimana dirumuskan dalam fikih Mālikī dan dalam hukum positif. Kajian ini menyoroti landasan doktrinal teori tersebut dalam mazhab Mālikī, yang dikenal penerapannya yang luas sehingga mencakup semua bentuk kemudaratan, didukung oleh dalil-dalil dari Al-Qur’an dan Sunnah. Penelitian ini menggunakan metode kualitatif dengan pendekatan komparatif terhadap teks-teks fikih klasik, seperti al-Muwāfaqāt, al-Furūq, dan al-Mudawwanah, serta membandingkannya dengan hukum positif kontemporer, khususnya dalam kodifikasi perdata Mesir dan Aljazair. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan adanya tingkat keselarasan yang signifikan antara prinsip dasar dalam fikih Mālikī terkait penyalahgunaan hak dan prinsip yang diadopsi dalam hukum positif modern, terutama terkait tiga prinsip utama: ketidakabsahan kepentingan yang diperjuangkan; adanya niat untuk merugikan pihak lain; dan ketidakseimbangan antara tujuan yang ingin dicapai dengan kerugian yang ditimbulkan. Studi ini juga menegaskan bahwa fikih Mālikī berada di garda terdepan dalam merumuskan teori penyalahgunaan hak yang komprehensif, yang mampu menyeimbangkan kepentingan individu dengan prinsip kemaslahatan umum.
- 28 December 2025
- Published by LP2M Universitas Islam Negeri (UIN) Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta in AHKAM : Jurnal Ilmu Syariah
- Vol. 25 (2) , 415-428
Open AccessAbuse of Rights: A Comparative Study between Mālikī Jurisprudence & Positive Law
This paper offers a comparative analytical evaluation of the theory of abuse of rights as articulated within Mālikī jurisprudence and in positive law. It highlights the doctrinal foundations of this theory within the Mālikī school, characterized by the extensive application of this concept to encompass all types of harm, supported by evidence from the Holy Quran and Sunnah. The research also employs a qualitative method based on a comparative analysis of classic jurisprudential texts, such as al-Muwāfaqāt, al-Furūq, and al-Mudawwanah, while specifically focusing on contemporary positive law, such as the civil codes of Egypt and Algeria. The study demonstrates that there is a high degree of overlap between the core criteria laid down by Mālikī jurisprudence related to the abuse of rights and the related criteria adopted in contemporary positive law, especially concerning three basic criteria: the illegitimacy of the interest; the intent to harm others; and the inconsistency between the interest sought and the harm caused. The study also demonstrates that Mālikī jurisprudence was at the forefront of developing an integrated theory of abuse of rights that carefully balances private interests with broader public-interest principles. Abstrak Paper ini menyajikan evaluasi analitis komparatif terhadap teori penyalahgunaan hak sebagaimana dirumuskan dalam fikih Mālikī dan dalam hukum positif. Kajian ini menyoroti landasan doktrinal teori tersebut dalam mazhab Mālikī, yang dikenal penerapannya yang luas sehingga mencakup semua bentuk kemudaratan, didukung oleh dalil-dalil dari Al-Qur’an dan Sunnah. Penelitian ini menggunakan metode kualitatif dengan pendekatan komparatif terhadap teks-teks fikih klasik, seperti al-Muwāfaqāt, al-Furūq, dan al-Mudawwanah, serta membandingkannya dengan hukum positif kontemporer, khususnya dalam kodifikasi perdata Mesir dan Aljazair. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan adanya tingkat keselarasan yang signifikan antara prinsip dasar dalam fikih Mālikī terkait penyalahgunaan hak dan prinsip yang diadopsi dalam hukum positif modern, terutama terkait tiga prinsip utama: ketidakabsahan kepentingan yang diperjuangkan; adanya niat untuk merugikan pihak lain; dan ketidakseimbangan antara tujuan yang ingin dicapai dengan kerugian yang ditimbulkan. Studi ini juga menegaskan bahwa fikih Mālikī berada di garda terdepan dalam merumuskan teori penyalahgunaan hak yang komprehensif, yang mampu menyeimbangkan kepentingan individu dengan prinsip kemaslahatan umum.