EQEnas Qutieshat

Enas Qutieshat

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Enas Qutieshat has a total of 13 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Civil litigation management between Algerian and Emirati legislation: a comparative analytical study of mechanisms for achieving effective justice

    by Yassine Chami, Enas Qutieshat

    1. Due to the structural changes that are changing modern legal jurisprudence, the right to litigation is no longer seen as just a formal way to get to the courts. Instead, it is seen as a qualitat...

  • Open Access

    Artificial Intelligence in Islamic Law: Ethics, Governance, and Accountability

    by Enas Qutieshat, Majed Al Adwan, Maya Khater

    Muslim countries increasingly adopt Artificial Intelligence technologies, creating challenges related to accountability, explainability, discrimination, and oversight, while existing regulatory frameworks remain insufficient to govern high risk Artificial Intelligence systems comprehensively. This study examines the regulatory shortcomings of Artificial Intelligence governance in selected Muslim countries and formulates an Islamic governance framework based on the principles of Maqāṣid al Sharīʿah. The study applies normative legal research through statutory, comparative, and Islamic legal philosophical approaches to evaluate existing regulatory models and identify normative gaps. The analysis demonstrates three principal findings. First, existing regulatory frameworks do not adequately regulate explainability standards, algorithmic auditing mechanisms, judicial review procedures, and legal liability for automated decisions. Second, the widespread use of opaque algorithmic systems in digital surveillance, financial technology, and public administration increases the potential for indirect discrimination, unequal legal relationships, and disproportionate exercises of discretionary authority. Third, the principles of ḥifẓ al ʿaql, ḥifẓ al māl, and ḥifẓ al ʿird establish normative foundations that support explainability, meaningful human oversight, privacy protection, and economic justice within Artificial Intelligence governance.

  • Open Access

    Reconstructing Institutional Governance Capabilities to Accelerate the Sustainable Bioeconomy Transformation in Indonesia

    by Mohamad Hidayat Muhtar, Alaa Abouahmed, Arief Fahmi Lubis, Enas Qutieshat

    The transition toward a sustainable bioeconomy in Indonesia is severely hindered by institutional governance failures rather than regulatory deficits. This study evaluates the structural bottlenecks within centralized governance and the policy capacity deficits of the state apparatus in driving circular economy transformations. Utilizing a multi-method qualitative design, this research integrates institutional policy analysis and socio-legal normative approaches. The findings reveal that extractive path dependence, scalar mismatches, and semantic hijacking have triggered severe policy lock-ins. Furthermore, the state bureaucracy exhibits acute analytical, operational, and political capacity deficits, rendering it captive to the hegemony of extractive industries. As a prescriptive intervention, this paper proposes the capability-based institutional reconstruction model. This framework advocates for executive meta-governance, durable legally binding designs, and polycentric tenure restitution for indigenous communities. Ultimately, accelerating this sustainable bioeconomy necessitates a shackled leviathan, a mission-oriented state rigorously constrained by democratic civic oversight to guarantee long-term ecological justice across the nation.

  • Open Access

    Algorithmic justice and the challenges of the digital rule of law

    by Enas Qutieshat, Muhamad Khairun Kurniawan Kadir, Driss Ed.DAran, Sofyan Piyo, Nurul Fazri Elfikri, Mohamad Hidayat Muhtar, Ramadhan Usman

    The development of digital technologies, especially artificial intelligence, offers both advantages and challenges within the legal system. While AI improves efficiency and consistency in public administration and justice, it raises issues such as algorithmic bias, less transparency and legal accountability problems. Over-reliance on algorithms may worsen inequities and threaten legal legitimacy. This article advocates for a hybrid regulatory model that combines strict and flexible laws, judicial oversight of algorithmic decisions, and the use of Explainable AI (XAI) to enhance transparency. The Constitution should guide AI regulation, prioritizing human rights and the rule of law to position algorithms as beneficial tools for a fair digital legal system.

  • Open Access

    THE HEALTHCARE SECTOR IN THE SULTANATE OF OMAN AND THE LEGAL CONTROL OF THE UTILIZATION OF AI SYSTEMS

    by Enas Qutieshat

    Integrating artificial intelligence with medicine is quickly becoming an international trend. It is understandable that medical professionals appreciate this emerging technology's potential in improving diagnosis, automating tasks, monitoring and managing medical conditions, and performing functions that were traditionally carried out by humans. The Oman Vision 2040 and The National Digital Health Strategy both consider the Digital Shift in Health Systems a main pillar of the Fourth Industrial Revolution. In the context of AI and analytics in virtual medicine, it aims to improve the provision of healthcare services. This also aligns with the Omani Health Ministry’s Health 2050 document. Rapid advances in artificial intelligence technology present a host of ethical and legal challenges, including algorithmic bias, opacity, privacy violations, diminished patient self-determination, and legal accountability gaps surrounding malpractice. This study seeks to examine the primary legislative initiatives concerning the Omani legislative response to artificial intelligence in the healthcare system and to consider the scope of artificial intelligence and its systems and entities, as well as the civil liability it may entail. This research examines these challenges and the processes of case documenting the attempts to control the use of artificial intelligence technology through a descriptive-analytical method. The study, to the extent available legal structures reach, examines the legal challenges for which, in the absence of consideration, far more robust legal structures need to be developed. Such structures need to be ethically designed centered on the principles of autonomy, justice, transparency, and accountability to safeguard the rights and safety of the patients within the frameworks of equity and social justice.


  • Open Access

    Justice in the Balance: Activating Legislative-Reality Harmony to Ensure Fair Judicial Rulings Between Sharia And Modern Legal Systems

    by Yassine Chami, Mohamed Elmadni Elsharef, Enas Qutieshat

    Achieving judicial fairness requires harmonizing legal texts with evolving societal realities. This research aims to explore the factors that enhance the fairness of judicial rulings by analyzing the interplay between abstract legal texts and practical reality. The method used involves a comparative analytical approach between modern legal systems and Islamic Sharia, supplemented by a review of judicial precedents. The results obtained indicate that legislative coherence and judicial discretion are critical for aligning rulings with justice objectives. Specifically, the study finds that rigid procedural adherence often undermines equity, whereas flexible interpretation grounded in contextual circumstances enhances fairness. Conclusions that can be drawn emphasize the necessity of developing legislative mechanisms that balance stability with equity, alongside promoting judicial transparency.

  • Open Access

    Digital Transformation and Environmental Legal Education: A Framework for Next-Generation Pedagogy in the Anthropocene

    by Enas Qutieshat

    Despite extensive scholarship on digital transformation in higher education, its application to environmental legal education remains under-examined. This article seeks to address this gap by proposing a multidisciplinary and theoretically informed framework, based on a synthesis of prior empirical studies on environmental law teaching. This study adopts a structured integrative literature synthesis approach. Relevant studies were identified through a systematic search of major academic databases using predefined keywords related to digital pedagogy, legal education, and environmental governance. The selected literature was thematically analyzed to construct a domain-specific conceptual framework for environmental legal education. Rather than reporting new empirical data, the framework is grounded in findings from existing empirical research. This article draws upon the digital competency frameworks, next-generation pedagogical models, and transformational digital learning theories of other disciplinary fields, and argues that the digital transformation of pedagogical models is not merely a technological enhancement, but is fundamentally a requirement for the teaching of environmental law in the Anthropocene. With this in mind, the article puts forward three key contributions. Firstly, it integrates frameworks of legal pedagogy and digital competence to demonstrate a particular educational model. Secondly, it collates legal pedagogy’s emerging empirical research to substantiate previous theoretical contributions. Thirdly, it examines pedagogy’s governance and quality assurance in terms of legal education in the EU and internationally. The article also outlines digital instruments for assessing competence in environmental law teaching and for supporting future empirical research on AI-enhanced environmental legal education.


  • Open Access

    Governing Legal Chatbots: Ethics, Professional Responsibility, and Liability in Comparative Perspective

    by Enas Qutieshat, Majed Al Adwan, Abdulla Alshibli, Yassine Chami, Maya Khater

    Client intake, information retrieval, document assembly, and litigation assistance, among other legal functions, have seen deployment of Artificial Intelligence legal chatbots in legal care delivery. With substantial legal efficiency and access to justice improvements, these tools also pose major legal, ethical, and liability risks. Unlike other legal technologies, legal chatbots lie at the crossroads of the practice of law, consumer protection and automation; oversight of which can have negative legal consequences. This work looks at the legal, ethical and liability issues of legal chatbots in the EU, the USA and the UK. It contends that the existing governance approaches are sub-optimal to the unique challenges posed in these chatbots. It demonstrates the EU is gravitating to a compliance-and-liability regime through the Artificial Intelligence Act and revised Product Liability Directive, whereas the US and UK have a predominantly self-regulating professional quartet, with tort, and consumer protection law. This paper advocates for ‘accountability by design’ which contemplates design, deployment, and practice of law responsibility principles through the lifecycle of a chatbot.