Martina Rosskopf
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Martina Rosskopf has a total of 104 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Anne Obermann
Swiss Seismological Service ETH Zurich Zurich Switzerland
15 shared publications - Kai Bröker
Center For Hydrogeology and Geothermics, University of Neuchâtel, Neuchâtel, Switzerland
12 shared publications - Antonio Pio Rinaldi
Swiss Seismological Service, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
11 shared publications Nima Gholizadeh Doonechaly
Institute for Geophysics ETH Zurich Zurich Switzerland
10 shared publicationsDomenico Giardini
9 shared publications- Linus Villiger
Swiss Seismological Service, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
9 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 19 July 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
- Vol. 131 (7)
Hydraulic Stimulation Experiments Attempting to Enhance Induced Seismicity for Earthquake Physics Research
Improving our understanding of induced and natural earthquakes benefits from controlled experiments in insitu laboratories. To investigate the processes during an Mw∼0 earthquake, we performed the “ Mzero ” experiments in a densely instrumented testbed of the Bedretto Underground Laboratory. These multi‐day hydraulic stimulation experiments went the opposite direction to typical induced seismicity research in that they were designed to enhance seismic rupture. In the first experiment, MzeroA, the rock mass was preconditioned by injecting water for 4 days at a pressure just below fracture reactivation pressure followed by a hydraulic stimulation above reactivation pressure. This strategy aimed at increasing the fractures area near critical stress conditions for shear failure, thus facilitating larger ruptures. During MzeroA, an event with Mw–0.54 was induced, followed by a distinct aftershock sequence. This event was one magnitude unit larger than any preceding event. In the second experiment, MzeroB, stimulation was initiated directly, without preconditioning. Compared to MzeroA, MzeroB exhibited higher seismicity rates, a larger seismicity cloud, and a pronounced migrating seismicity front. Combining seismological and hydromechanical observations, we discuss mechanisms that may have influenced the contrasting seismicity responses. In addition to fluid preconditiong, stress transfer from the Mw–0.54 mainshock, and natural seasonal pressure changes, may have contributed to modulating the seismogenic response. However, the relative importance of these processes remains uncertain given experimental limitations. Our results highlight both the potential and challenge of designing hydraulic stimulations to enhance or suppress seismic rupture, with implications for earthquake physics and induced seismicity.
- 19 July 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
- Vol. 131 (7)
Open AccessHydraulic Stimulation Experiments Attempting to Enhance Induced Seismicity for Earthquake Physics Research
Improving our understanding of induced and natural earthquakes benefits from controlled experiments in insitu laboratories. To investigate the processes during an Mw∼0 earthquake, we performed the “ Mzero ” experiments in a densely instrumented testbed of the Bedretto Underground Laboratory. These multi‐day hydraulic stimulation experiments went the opposite direction to typical induced seismicity research in that they were designed to enhance seismic rupture. In the first experiment, MzeroA, the rock mass was preconditioned by injecting water for 4 days at a pressure just below fracture reactivation pressure followed by a hydraulic stimulation above reactivation pressure. This strategy aimed at increasing the fractures area near critical stress conditions for shear failure, thus facilitating larger ruptures. During MzeroA, an event with Mw–0.54 was induced, followed by a distinct aftershock sequence. This event was one magnitude unit larger than any preceding event. In the second experiment, MzeroB, stimulation was initiated directly, without preconditioning. Compared to MzeroA, MzeroB exhibited higher seismicity rates, a larger seismicity cloud, and a pronounced migrating seismicity front. Combining seismological and hydromechanical observations, we discuss mechanisms that may have influenced the contrasting seismicity responses. In addition to fluid preconditiong, stress transfer from the Mw–0.54 mainshock, and natural seasonal pressure changes, may have contributed to modulating the seismogenic response. However, the relative importance of these processes remains uncertain given experimental limitations. Our results highlight both the potential and challenge of designing hydraulic stimulations to enhance or suppress seismic rupture, with implications for earthquake physics and induced seismicity.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Multi-Scale On-Fault Seismic Monitoring at the Bedretto Underground Laboratory: An Operational Framework
The Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geosciences and Geoenergies (BULGG, ETH Zurich) operates a dense, multi-scale seismic monitoring framework for on-fault observation of induced seismicity during underground stimulation experiments. The system integrates permanent seismic stations (500 to 10k samples per second, sps), high-rate experimental deployments (up to 200k sps), and distributed acoustic sensing (DAS; up to 4000 sps), providing high spatial and temporal data coverage at the reservoir and local scale. This contribution documents real-time seismic monitoring during underground experiments and the generation of associated post-processed earthquake catalogues.The combined instrumentation is used for monitoring of hydraulic stimulation and geothermal project experiments, including the Fault Activation and Earthquake Rupture (FEAR) ERC project and Geothermal Test-Bed (GTB) activities. Permanent monitoring provides manually reviewed earthquake locations and magnitudes in a continuous reference earthquake catalogue, continuously updated since 2021. Experimental deployments enable near real-time event detection, characterization, and Traffic Light System (TLS) alerting, including borehole DAS observations since 2024.For the FEAR and GTB experiments, additional post-processed catalogues provide optimal yet conventional event parameters based on the final instrumentation configuration, optimized phase picking and hypocenter locations. The resulting catalogues provide consistent absolute locations and high-resolution double-difference relocations based on fully repicked waveform data.Event magnitudes are estimated using multiple complementary approaches. The backbone national network provides a Swiss-specific local magnitude (Mlhc) using station corrections, while the permanent BedrettoLab network applies conventional local magnitude (MLc) from Wood–Anderson amplitudes. Experimental catalogues include relative moment magnitudes derived from acoustic emission amplitude ratios (MwA) calibrated against collocated accelerometers. Ongoing developments include spectral moment magnitudes and DAS strain-rate-based magnitude estimates to improve characterization of small-magnitude events.The BedrettoLab monitoring framework, implemented in SeisComP, addresses challenges such as electromagnetic noise, tunnel operations, and heterogeneous sensor coverage while ensuring continuous acquisition, archiving, and FDSN-compliant data access. Beyond Bedretto, this on-fault, densely instrumented approach demonstrates how integrated DAS, permanent, and experimental monitoring can substantially improve event detection, location accuracy, and magnitude estimation, providing a transferable framework for induced seismicity monitoring, operational decision-making, and risk mitigation in geothermal and underground engineering applications.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessMulti-Scale On-Fault Seismic Monitoring at the Bedretto Underground Laboratory: An Operational Framework
The Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geosciences and Geoenergies (BULGG, ETH Zurich) operates a dense, multi-scale seismic monitoring framework for on-fault observation of induced seismicity during underground stimulation experiments. The system integrates permanent seismic stations (500 to 10k samples per second, sps), high-rate experimental deployments (up to 200k sps), and distributed acoustic sensing (DAS; up to 4000 sps), providing high spatial and temporal data coverage at the reservoir and local scale. This contribution documents real-time seismic monitoring during underground experiments and the generation of associated post-processed earthquake catalogues.The combined instrumentation is used for monitoring of hydraulic stimulation and geothermal project experiments, including the Fault Activation and Earthquake Rupture (FEAR) ERC project and Geothermal Test-Bed (GTB) activities. Permanent monitoring provides manually reviewed earthquake locations and magnitudes in a continuous reference earthquake catalogue, continuously updated since 2021. Experimental deployments enable near real-time event detection, characterization, and Traffic Light System (TLS) alerting, including borehole DAS observations since 2024.For the FEAR and GTB experiments, additional post-processed catalogues provide optimal yet conventional event parameters based on the final instrumentation configuration, optimized phase picking and hypocenter locations. The resulting catalogues provide consistent absolute locations and high-resolution double-difference relocations based on fully repicked waveform data.Event magnitudes are estimated using multiple complementary approaches. The backbone national network provides a Swiss-specific local magnitude (Mlhc) using station corrections, while the permanent BedrettoLab network applies conventional local magnitude (MLc) from Wood–Anderson amplitudes. Experimental catalogues include relative moment magnitudes derived from acoustic emission amplitude ratios (MwA) calibrated against collocated accelerometers. Ongoing developments include spectral moment magnitudes and DAS strain-rate-based magnitude estimates to improve characterization of small-magnitude events.The BedrettoLab monitoring framework, implemented in SeisComP, addresses challenges such as electromagnetic noise, tunnel operations, and heterogeneous sensor coverage while ensuring continuous acquisition, archiving, and FDSN-compliant data access. Beyond Bedretto, this on-fault, densely instrumented approach demonstrates how integrated DAS, permanent, and experimental monitoring can substantially improve event detection, location accuracy, and magnitude estimation, providing a transferable framework for induced seismicity monitoring, operational decision-making, and risk mitigation in geothermal and underground engineering applications.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Fault Network Activation During Controlled Hydraulic Stimulation Experiments in the BedrettoLab
Understanding how faults are activated and earthquakes are triggered is still a central challenge in seismology and seismic hazard assessment. Controlled hydraulic stimulation experiments offer a valuable opportunity to study these processes under well-constrained conditions and at spatial and temporal resolutions that are rarely achievable in natural settings. In this study, we present the results of three hydraulic stimulations experiments conducted at the Bedretto Underground Laboratory and monitored by a dense, high-sensitivity seismic network.These experiments revealed a complex spatio-temporal evolution of induced seismicity, characterized by the activation of a multi-segment fault network. Two dominant seismic clusters were activated early on and show a clear spatial connection to the injection borehole, suggesting that pore pressure is the main driver of seismicity within these clusters. At later stages, a third cluster with a different orientation was activated, despite showing no obvious direct hydraulic connection to the injection interval. Seismicity within this cluster occurred with a temporal delay compared to the other two clusters. This suggests that the fault activation was likely driven by indirect processes such as aseismic deformation, stress transfer, and delayed fluid migration.The observed fault network activation closely resembles patterns commonly reported in natural earthquake sequences. These findings suggest that the physical mechanisms controlling fault reactivation and earthquake triggering are largely independent of scale, linking controlled field experiments and natural earthquakes. Our results emphasize the importance of fault network geometry and stress interactions in understanding induced and natural seismicity.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessFault Network Activation During Controlled Hydraulic Stimulation Experiments in the BedrettoLab
Understanding how faults are activated and earthquakes are triggered is still a central challenge in seismology and seismic hazard assessment. Controlled hydraulic stimulation experiments offer a valuable opportunity to study these processes under well-constrained conditions and at spatial and temporal resolutions that are rarely achievable in natural settings. In this study, we present the results of three hydraulic stimulations experiments conducted at the Bedretto Underground Laboratory and monitored by a dense, high-sensitivity seismic network.These experiments revealed a complex spatio-temporal evolution of induced seismicity, characterized by the activation of a multi-segment fault network. Two dominant seismic clusters were activated early on and show a clear spatial connection to the injection borehole, suggesting that pore pressure is the main driver of seismicity within these clusters. At later stages, a third cluster with a different orientation was activated, despite showing no obvious direct hydraulic connection to the injection interval. Seismicity within this cluster occurred with a temporal delay compared to the other two clusters. This suggests that the fault activation was likely driven by indirect processes such as aseismic deformation, stress transfer, and delayed fluid migration.The observed fault network activation closely resembles patterns commonly reported in natural earthquake sequences. These findings suggest that the physical mechanisms controlling fault reactivation and earthquake triggering are largely independent of scale, linking controlled field experiments and natural earthquakes. Our results emphasize the importance of fault network geometry and stress interactions in understanding induced and natural seismicity.
- Open Access
- 27 October 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Solid Earth
- Vol. 16 (10) , 1153-1180
Updating induced seismic hazard assessments during hydraulic stimulation experiments in underground laboratories: workflow and limitations
Advancing technologies to harvest deep geothermal energy has seen backlash related to unacceptable levels of induced seismic hazard during hydraulic stimulations. A thorough analysis of induced seismic hazard before these operations has recently become standard practice in the last decade. Additionally, more process understanding of the underlying causes of induced seismicity as well as novel approaches to develop geomechanical reservoirs are being explored in controlled underground laboratory experiments worldwide. Here, we present a probabilistic analysis of the seismic hazard induced by the ongoing hectometre-scale stimulation experiments at the Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geoenergies and Geosciences (BULGG). Our workflow allows for fast updates of the hazard computation as soon as new site-specific information on the seismogenic response (expressed primarily by the feedback a fb value and the Gutenberg–Richter b value) and ground motion models (GMMs) become available. We present a sequence of hazard analyses corresponding to different project stages at the BULGG. These reveal the large uncertainty in a priori hazard estimations that only reduces once site-specific GMMs and information on the seismic response of specific stimulation stages are considered. The sources of uncertainty are (1) the large variability in the seismogenic response recorded across all stimulation case studies and (2) uncertain GMMs on the underground laboratory scale. One implication for large-scale hydraulic stimulations is that hazard computation must be updated at different project stages. Additionally, stimulations have to be closely accompanied by a mitigation scheme, ideally in the form of an adaptive traffic light system (ATLS), which reassesses seismic hazard in near-real time. Our study also shows that the observed seismogenic responses in underground laboratories differ from large-scale stimulations at greater depth in that the seismogenic response is substantially more variable and tends to be weaker. Reasons may be lower stress levels, but also smaller injected volumes accessing a more limited fracture network than large-scale stimulations. Controlled underground laboratory experiments can contribute to improving our understanding of the the physical reasons leading to such variable seismogenic responses. The presented analysis implied that such experiments may be limited in terms of upscaling but are likely to be safe in terms of induced seismic hazard.
- 27 October 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Solid Earth
- Vol. 16 (10) , 1153-1180
Open AccessUpdating induced seismic hazard assessments during hydraulic stimulation experiments in underground laboratories: workflow and limitations
Advancing technologies to harvest deep geothermal energy has seen backlash related to unacceptable levels of induced seismic hazard during hydraulic stimulations. A thorough analysis of induced seismic hazard before these operations has recently become standard practice in the last decade. Additionally, more process understanding of the underlying causes of induced seismicity as well as novel approaches to develop geomechanical reservoirs are being explored in controlled underground laboratory experiments worldwide. Here, we present a probabilistic analysis of the seismic hazard induced by the ongoing hectometre-scale stimulation experiments at the Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geoenergies and Geosciences (BULGG). Our workflow allows for fast updates of the hazard computation as soon as new site-specific information on the seismogenic response (expressed primarily by the feedback a fb value and the Gutenberg–Richter b value) and ground motion models (GMMs) become available. We present a sequence of hazard analyses corresponding to different project stages at the BULGG. These reveal the large uncertainty in a priori hazard estimations that only reduces once site-specific GMMs and information on the seismic response of specific stimulation stages are considered. The sources of uncertainty are (1) the large variability in the seismogenic response recorded across all stimulation case studies and (2) uncertain GMMs on the underground laboratory scale. One implication for large-scale hydraulic stimulations is that hazard computation must be updated at different project stages. Additionally, stimulations have to be closely accompanied by a mitigation scheme, ideally in the form of an adaptive traffic light system (ATLS), which reassesses seismic hazard in near-real time. Our study also shows that the observed seismogenic responses in underground laboratories differ from large-scale stimulations at greater depth in that the seismogenic response is substantially more variable and tends to be weaker. Reasons may be lower stress levels, but also smaller injected volumes accessing a more limited fracture network than large-scale stimulations. Controlled underground laboratory experiments can contribute to improving our understanding of the the physical reasons leading to such variable seismogenic responses. The presented analysis implied that such experiments may be limited in terms of upscaling but are likely to be safe in terms of induced seismic hazard.
- 8 July 2025
- Published by Seismological Society of America (SSA) in Seismological Research Letters
- Vol. 96 (6) , 3814-3836
Accuracy of Picoseismic Catalogs in Hectometer-Scale In Situ Experiments
Understanding the seismicity and hydromechanical processes during hydraulic stimulation in hectometer-scale in situ experiments is crucial for bridging the gap between laboratory studies, decameter-scale in situ experiments, and large-scale geothermal projects. These insights can help to optimize the use of geothermal energy. A key example of this is the Bedretto Underground Laboratory in Switzerland, where multiple hydraulic stimulation experiments were conducted between 2021 and 2023 at a hectometer scale. In this study, we present modifications of standard seismic event processing techniques for mesoscale experiments, enabling the accurate detection and location of picoseismic events at these scales. We differentiate between the needs of seismic catalogs for rapid hazard assessment, which require real-time detection of large-magnitude events, and postprocessed catalogs, which are essential for detailed analysis of activated fracture networks, for which a complete seismic catalog is essential. In addition, we evaluate the impact of picking accuracy, background 1D velocity model, and network coverage on the final event locations within a mesoscale underground 3D seismic network, a novelty in experimental seismology.
- 8 July 2025
- Published by Seismological Society of America (SSA) in Seismological Research Letters
- Vol. 96 (6) , 3814-3836
Accuracy of Picoseismic Catalogs in Hectometer-Scale In Situ Experiments
Understanding the seismicity and hydromechanical processes during hydraulic stimulation in hectometer-scale in situ experiments is crucial for bridging the gap between laboratory studies, decameter-scale in situ experiments, and large-scale geothermal projects. These insights can help to optimize the use of geothermal energy. A key example of this is the Bedretto Underground Laboratory in Switzerland, where multiple hydraulic stimulation experiments were conducted between 2021 and 2023 at a hectometer scale. In this study, we present modifications of standard seismic event processing techniques for mesoscale experiments, enabling the accurate detection and location of picoseismic events at these scales. We differentiate between the needs of seismic catalogs for rapid hazard assessment, which require real-time detection of large-magnitude events, and postprocessed catalogs, which are essential for detailed analysis of activated fracture networks, for which a complete seismic catalog is essential. In addition, we evaluate the impact of picking accuracy, background 1D velocity model, and network coverage on the final event locations within a mesoscale underground 3D seismic network, a novelty in experimental seismology.
- Open Access
- 4 April 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-40
Comment on egusphere-2024-3882
Advancing technologies to harvest deep geothermal energy has seen backlashes related to unacceptable levels of induced seismic hazard during hydraulic stimulations. A thorough analysis of induced seismic hazard before these operations has recently become standard practice in the last decade. Additionally, more process understanding of the underlying causes of induced seismicity as well as novel approaches to develop geomechanical reservoirs are being explored in controlled underground laboratory experiments world-wide. Here, we present a probabilistic analysis of the seismic hazard induced by the ongoing hectometer scale stimulation experiments at the Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geoenergies and Geosciences (BULGG). Our workflow allows for fast updates of the hazard computation as soon as new site-specific information on the seismogenic response (expressed primarily by the feedback afb-value and the Gutenberg Richter b-value) and ground motion models (GMM) become available. We present a sequence of hazard analyses corresponding to different project stages at the BULGG. These reveal the large uncertainty in a priori hazard estimations that only reduce once site-specific GMMs and information on the seismic response of specific stimulation stages are considered. The sources of uncertainty are 1) the large variability in the seismogenic response recorded across all stimulation case studies, as well as 2) uncertain GMMs on the underground laboratory scale. One implication for large-scale hydraulic stimulations is that hazard computation must be updated at different project stages. Additionally, stimulations have to be closely accompanied by a mitigation scheme, ideally in the form of an adaptive traffic light system (ATLS), which reassesses seismic hazard in near-real-time. Our study also shows that the observed seismogenic responses in underground laboratories differ from large-scale stimulations at greater depth in that the seismogenic response is substantially more variable and tends to be weaker. Reasons may be lower stress levels, but also smaller injected volumes accessing a more limited fracture network than large-scale stimulations. Exploring the physical reasons leading to the weaker seismogenic response may reveal ways for safer exploitation of geoenergy resources. Controlled underground laboratory experiments can readily contribute to this, and – as shown in the presented analysis – are likely to be safe in terms of induced seismic hazard.
- 4 April 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-40
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-3882
Advancing technologies to harvest deep geothermal energy has seen backlashes related to unacceptable levels of induced seismic hazard during hydraulic stimulations. A thorough analysis of induced seismic hazard before these operations has recently become standard practice in the last decade. Additionally, more process understanding of the underlying causes of induced seismicity as well as novel approaches to develop geomechanical reservoirs are being explored in controlled underground laboratory experiments world-wide. Here, we present a probabilistic analysis of the seismic hazard induced by the ongoing hectometer scale stimulation experiments at the Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geoenergies and Geosciences (BULGG). Our workflow allows for fast updates of the hazard computation as soon as new site-specific information on the seismogenic response (expressed primarily by the feedback afb-value and the Gutenberg Richter b-value) and ground motion models (GMM) become available. We present a sequence of hazard analyses corresponding to different project stages at the BULGG. These reveal the large uncertainty in a priori hazard estimations that only reduce once site-specific GMMs and information on the seismic response of specific stimulation stages are considered. The sources of uncertainty are 1) the large variability in the seismogenic response recorded across all stimulation case studies, as well as 2) uncertain GMMs on the underground laboratory scale. One implication for large-scale hydraulic stimulations is that hazard computation must be updated at different project stages. Additionally, stimulations have to be closely accompanied by a mitigation scheme, ideally in the form of an adaptive traffic light system (ATLS), which reassesses seismic hazard in near-real-time. Our study also shows that the observed seismogenic responses in underground laboratories differ from large-scale stimulations at greater depth in that the seismogenic response is substantially more variable and tends to be weaker. Reasons may be lower stress levels, but also smaller injected volumes accessing a more limited fracture network than large-scale stimulations. Exploring the physical reasons leading to the weaker seismogenic response may reveal ways for safer exploitation of geoenergy resources. Controlled underground laboratory experiments can readily contribute to this, and – as shown in the presented analysis – are likely to be safe in terms of induced seismic hazard.
- Open Access
- 15 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Hydraulic Stimulations with Hydro-Mechanical Pre-Conditioning at the BedrettoLab
The heterogenous nature of geological formations is further complicated by natural and induced discontinuities such as fractures and faults. These geological features introduce a complex network of pathways and barriers that alter the local in-situ stresses as well as fluid flow dynamics. A comprehensive understanding of hydro-mechanical (HM) interactions during fluid injection experiments may provide insights into the effective manipulation of underground for energy extraction (e.g., hydraulic stimulation) as well as prediction and mitigation of induced seismicity in response to various stimulation techniques. Significant effort has been devoted to understand the rock-fluid interactions in energy contexts (e.g., shale gas, enhanced geothermal system) and earthquake seismology through various methodologies including laboratory studies, in-situ experiments and numerical simulations over the last decades. However, systematic studies of such interactions under in-situ conditions with natural heterogeneity require systematic manipulation of injection parameters in a well-characterized reservoir or underground research laboratory.The BedrettoLab (Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geosciences and Geoenergies) with a local overburden of over 1000 m, located in the Swiss Alps, is a suitable site for conducting such studies, as the rock volume has been well instrumented and characterized [Plenkers et al., 2023]. In a close collaboration between two running projects in BedrettoLab, i.e., VALTER (Validating of Technologies for Reservoir Engineering) and FEAR (Fault Activation and Earthquake Rupture), a series of controlled hydraulic stimulations were conducted where various HM pre-conditioning steps were included (or left out) in the injection protocol. The main objective of the HM pre-conditioning was to understand and control microseismicity by pre-determining the pressurized patch on the fault/fracture volume via the injection protocol prior to the main injection. The installed monitoring system captured ongoing HM processes during each hydraulic stimulation, enabling systematic testing of these pre-conditioning hypothesis across various fractures. In the next step, similar protocols were applied to the first stimulation experiment as part of the project which provided a comprehensive insight of the HM and seismogenic characteristics of the stimulated fault, in response to pre-conditioning.
- 15 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessHydraulic Stimulations with Hydro-Mechanical Pre-Conditioning at the BedrettoLab
The heterogenous nature of geological formations is further complicated by natural and induced discontinuities such as fractures and faults. These geological features introduce a complex network of pathways and barriers that alter the local in-situ stresses as well as fluid flow dynamics. A comprehensive understanding of hydro-mechanical (HM) interactions during fluid injection experiments may provide insights into the effective manipulation of underground for energy extraction (e.g., hydraulic stimulation) as well as prediction and mitigation of induced seismicity in response to various stimulation techniques. Significant effort has been devoted to understand the rock-fluid interactions in energy contexts (e.g., shale gas, enhanced geothermal system) and earthquake seismology through various methodologies including laboratory studies, in-situ experiments and numerical simulations over the last decades. However, systematic studies of such interactions under in-situ conditions with natural heterogeneity require systematic manipulation of injection parameters in a well-characterized reservoir or underground research laboratory.The BedrettoLab (Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geosciences and Geoenergies) with a local overburden of over 1000 m, located in the Swiss Alps, is a suitable site for conducting such studies, as the rock volume has been well instrumented and characterized [Plenkers et al., 2023]. In a close collaboration between two running projects in BedrettoLab, i.e., VALTER (Validating of Technologies for Reservoir Engineering) and FEAR (Fault Activation and Earthquake Rupture), a series of controlled hydraulic stimulations were conducted where various HM pre-conditioning steps were included (or left out) in the injection protocol. The main objective of the HM pre-conditioning was to understand and control microseismicity by pre-determining the pressurized patch on the fault/fracture volume via the injection protocol prior to the main injection. The installed monitoring system captured ongoing HM processes during each hydraulic stimulation, enabling systematic testing of these pre-conditioning hypothesis across various fractures. In the next step, similar protocols were applied to the first stimulation experiment as part of the project which provided a comprehensive insight of the HM and seismogenic characteristics of the stimulated fault, in response to pre-conditioning.
- Open Access
- 15 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-40
Comment on egusphere-2024-3882
Advancing technologies to harvest deep geothermal energy has seen backlashes related to unacceptable levels of induced seismic hazard during hydraulic stimulations. A thorough analysis of induced seismic hazard before these operations has recently become standard practice in the last decade. Additionally, more process understanding of the underlying causes of induced seismicity as well as novel approaches to develop geomechanical reservoirs are being explored in controlled underground laboratory experiments world-wide. Here, we present a probabilistic analysis of the seismic hazard induced by the ongoing hectometer scale stimulation experiments at the Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geoenergies and Geosciences (BULGG). Our workflow allows for fast updates of the hazard computation as soon as new site-specific information on the seismogenic response (expressed primarily by the feedback afb-value and the Gutenberg Richter b-value) and ground motion models (GMM) become available. We present a sequence of hazard analyses corresponding to different project stages at the BULGG. These reveal the large uncertainty in a priori hazard estimations that only reduce once site-specific GMMs and information on the seismic response of specific stimulation stages are considered. The sources of uncertainty are 1) the large variability in the seismogenic response recorded across all stimulation case studies, as well as 2) uncertain GMMs on the underground laboratory scale. One implication for large-scale hydraulic stimulations is that hazard computation must be updated at different project stages. Additionally, stimulations have to be closely accompanied by a mitigation scheme, ideally in the form of an adaptive traffic light system (ATLS), which reassesses seismic hazard in near-real-time. Our study also shows that the observed seismogenic responses in underground laboratories differ from large-scale stimulations at greater depth in that the seismogenic response is substantially more variable and tends to be weaker. Reasons may be lower stress levels, but also smaller injected volumes accessing a more limited fracture network than large-scale stimulations. Exploring the physical reasons leading to the weaker seismogenic response may reveal ways for safer exploitation of geoenergy resources. Controlled underground laboratory experiments can readily contribute to this, and – as shown in the presented analysis – are likely to be safe in terms of induced seismic hazard.
- 15 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-40
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-3882
Advancing technologies to harvest deep geothermal energy has seen backlashes related to unacceptable levels of induced seismic hazard during hydraulic stimulations. A thorough analysis of induced seismic hazard before these operations has recently become standard practice in the last decade. Additionally, more process understanding of the underlying causes of induced seismicity as well as novel approaches to develop geomechanical reservoirs are being explored in controlled underground laboratory experiments world-wide. Here, we present a probabilistic analysis of the seismic hazard induced by the ongoing hectometer scale stimulation experiments at the Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geoenergies and Geosciences (BULGG). Our workflow allows for fast updates of the hazard computation as soon as new site-specific information on the seismogenic response (expressed primarily by the feedback afb-value and the Gutenberg Richter b-value) and ground motion models (GMM) become available. We present a sequence of hazard analyses corresponding to different project stages at the BULGG. These reveal the large uncertainty in a priori hazard estimations that only reduce once site-specific GMMs and information on the seismic response of specific stimulation stages are considered. The sources of uncertainty are 1) the large variability in the seismogenic response recorded across all stimulation case studies, as well as 2) uncertain GMMs on the underground laboratory scale. One implication for large-scale hydraulic stimulations is that hazard computation must be updated at different project stages. Additionally, stimulations have to be closely accompanied by a mitigation scheme, ideally in the form of an adaptive traffic light system (ATLS), which reassesses seismic hazard in near-real-time. Our study also shows that the observed seismogenic responses in underground laboratories differ from large-scale stimulations at greater depth in that the seismogenic response is substantially more variable and tends to be weaker. Reasons may be lower stress levels, but also smaller injected volumes accessing a more limited fracture network than large-scale stimulations. Exploring the physical reasons leading to the weaker seismogenic response may reveal ways for safer exploitation of geoenergy resources. Controlled underground laboratory experiments can readily contribute to this, and – as shown in the presented analysis – are likely to be safe in terms of induced seismic hazard.
- Open Access
- 27 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-40
Updating induced seismic hazard assessments during hydraulic stimulation experiments in underground laboratories: workflow and limitations
Advancing technologies to harvest deep geothermal energy has seen backlashes related to unacceptable levels of induced seismic hazard during hydraulic stimulations. A thorough analysis of induced seismic hazard before these operations has recently become standard practice in the last decade. Additionally, more process understanding of the underlying causes of induced seismicity as well as novel approaches to develop geomechanical reservoirs are being explored in controlled underground laboratory experiments world-wide. Here, we present a probabilistic analysis of the seismic hazard induced by the ongoing hectometer scale stimulation experiments at the Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geoenergies and Geosciences (BULGG). Our workflow allows for fast updates of the hazard computation as soon as new site-specific information on the seismogenic response (expressed primarily by the feedback afb-value and the Gutenberg Richter b-value) and ground motion models (GMM) become available. We present a sequence of hazard analyses corresponding to different project stages at the BULGG. These reveal the large uncertainty in a priori hazard estimations that only reduce once site-specific GMMs and information on the seismic response of specific stimulation stages are considered. The sources of uncertainty are 1) the large variability in the seismogenic response recorded across all stimulation case studies, as well as 2) uncertain GMMs on the underground laboratory scale. One implication for large-scale hydraulic stimulations is that hazard computation must be updated at different project stages. Additionally, stimulations have to be closely accompanied by a mitigation scheme, ideally in the form of an adaptive traffic light system (ATLS), which reassesses seismic hazard in near-real-time. Our study also shows that the observed seismogenic responses in underground laboratories differ from large-scale stimulations at greater depth in that the seismogenic response is substantially more variable and tends to be weaker. Reasons may be lower stress levels, but also smaller injected volumes accessing a more limited fracture network than large-scale stimulations. Exploring the physical reasons leading to the weaker seismogenic response may reveal ways for safer exploitation of geoenergy resources. Controlled underground laboratory experiments can readily contribute to this, and – as shown in the presented analysis – are likely to be safe in terms of induced seismic hazard.
- 27 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-40
Open AccessUpdating induced seismic hazard assessments during hydraulic stimulation experiments in underground laboratories: workflow and limitations
Advancing technologies to harvest deep geothermal energy has seen backlashes related to unacceptable levels of induced seismic hazard during hydraulic stimulations. A thorough analysis of induced seismic hazard before these operations has recently become standard practice in the last decade. Additionally, more process understanding of the underlying causes of induced seismicity as well as novel approaches to develop geomechanical reservoirs are being explored in controlled underground laboratory experiments world-wide. Here, we present a probabilistic analysis of the seismic hazard induced by the ongoing hectometer scale stimulation experiments at the Bedretto Underground Laboratory for Geoenergies and Geosciences (BULGG). Our workflow allows for fast updates of the hazard computation as soon as new site-specific information on the seismogenic response (expressed primarily by the feedback afb-value and the Gutenberg Richter b-value) and ground motion models (GMM) become available. We present a sequence of hazard analyses corresponding to different project stages at the BULGG. These reveal the large uncertainty in a priori hazard estimations that only reduce once site-specific GMMs and information on the seismic response of specific stimulation stages are considered. The sources of uncertainty are 1) the large variability in the seismogenic response recorded across all stimulation case studies, as well as 2) uncertain GMMs on the underground laboratory scale. One implication for large-scale hydraulic stimulations is that hazard computation must be updated at different project stages. Additionally, stimulations have to be closely accompanied by a mitigation scheme, ideally in the form of an adaptive traffic light system (ATLS), which reassesses seismic hazard in near-real-time. Our study also shows that the observed seismogenic responses in underground laboratories differ from large-scale stimulations at greater depth in that the seismogenic response is substantially more variable and tends to be weaker. Reasons may be lower stress levels, but also smaller injected volumes accessing a more limited fracture network than large-scale stimulations. Exploring the physical reasons leading to the weaker seismogenic response may reveal ways for safer exploitation of geoenergy resources. Controlled underground laboratory experiments can readily contribute to this, and – as shown in the presented analysis – are likely to be safe in terms of induced seismic hazard.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
The Impact of Injection Protocol and Stress Preconditioning on the Hydro-Mechanical Response of the Crystalline Rock
Hydraulic stimulation has been extensively utilized in the geothermal industry as the primary technique to create and develop an efficient heat exchanger in a low-permeable reservoir rock. This technique entails high-pressure fluid injection under various injection schemes to perturb the local stress field at both borehole and reservoir scales, leading to permanent permeability enhancement of the stimulated volume through shear dislocation and dilation. These stress disturbances can also potentially trigger and/or induce seismicity in the reservoir and beyond. Understanding how different injection protocols serve as a preconditioning tool and their impact on the hydro-mechanical response of the stimulated volume would enhance our understanding of geothermal reservoir enhancement and induced seismicity mitigation. In the preparatory phase of the FEAR (Fault Activation and Earthquake Rupture) project in Bedretto Underground Laboratory (Switzerland), various injection protocols were utilized to understand the hydro-mechanical responses of the stimulated volume as well as earthquake rupture processes such as nucleation and premonitory slip. The adopted injection protocols include a) constant pressure injection for a specific time followed by step-rate injection and b) constant pressure withdrawal for a specific time followed by step-rate injection. In both protocols, an approximately equal amount of water (~3000 liters) was injected over the stimulation phase. Each injection protocol was associated with the pre- and post-characterization tests such as HTPF (hydraulic tests on pre-existing fractures) tests. Hydro-mechanical response of the host rock during these tests was monitored using various pressure, strain, and acoustic emission sensors in the injection and monitoring boreholes. At first glance, there appears to be no significant difference in the hydro-mechanical responses as well as the seismicity pattern of these two injection protocols, yet deeper investigation mostly based on the strain data reveals that strategy a) produced more heterogeneity in strain rate on the fiber-optic array whereas b) produced a more homogenized response. Numerical modelling and an experimental campaign in the laboratory are now underway to better understand the underlying mechanisms producing this response with the aim to best select a proper injection protocol for the goal of the FEAR project.
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessThe Impact of Injection Protocol and Stress Preconditioning on the Hydro-Mechanical Response of the Crystalline Rock
Hydraulic stimulation has been extensively utilized in the geothermal industry as the primary technique to create and develop an efficient heat exchanger in a low-permeable reservoir rock. This technique entails high-pressure fluid injection under various injection schemes to perturb the local stress field at both borehole and reservoir scales, leading to permanent permeability enhancement of the stimulated volume through shear dislocation and dilation. These stress disturbances can also potentially trigger and/or induce seismicity in the reservoir and beyond. Understanding how different injection protocols serve as a preconditioning tool and their impact on the hydro-mechanical response of the stimulated volume would enhance our understanding of geothermal reservoir enhancement and induced seismicity mitigation. In the preparatory phase of the FEAR (Fault Activation and Earthquake Rupture) project in Bedretto Underground Laboratory (Switzerland), various injection protocols were utilized to understand the hydro-mechanical responses of the stimulated volume as well as earthquake rupture processes such as nucleation and premonitory slip. The adopted injection protocols include a) constant pressure injection for a specific time followed by step-rate injection and b) constant pressure withdrawal for a specific time followed by step-rate injection. In both protocols, an approximately equal amount of water (~3000 liters) was injected over the stimulation phase. Each injection protocol was associated with the pre- and post-characterization tests such as HTPF (hydraulic tests on pre-existing fractures) tests. Hydro-mechanical response of the host rock during these tests was monitored using various pressure, strain, and acoustic emission sensors in the injection and monitoring boreholes. At first glance, there appears to be no significant difference in the hydro-mechanical responses as well as the seismicity pattern of these two injection protocols, yet deeper investigation mostly based on the strain data reveals that strategy a) produced more heterogeneity in strain rate on the fiber-optic array whereas b) produced a more homogenized response. Numerical modelling and an experimental campaign in the laboratory are now underway to better understand the underlying mechanisms producing this response with the aim to best select a proper injection protocol for the goal of the FEAR project.