ZDZhuldyz Davletbayeva

Zhuldyz Davletbayeva

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Zhuldyz Davletbayeva has a total of 29 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Between Induced and Organic Participation: Public Councils in Central Asia

    by Zhuldyz Davletbayeva, Alexandr Zagrebin

    This article examines state-initiated civic participation in Central Asia through the case of Public Councils ( PC s) in Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, and Tajikistan. Drawing on qualitative data from focus groups and expert interviews conducted in 2024–2025, the study explores how PC s operate as induced participatory institutions under centralized and hybrid governance conditions. The findings show that, despite similar legal foundations, PC s across the region remain structurally constrained by low levels of empowerment, limited independence, and co-optation. Additionally, the study identifies instances of issue-specific and conditional effectiveness, where councils achieved tangible outcomes within narrowly defined policy domains, particularly when supported by expert input, public resonance, or state cooperation. These outcomes highlight the contextual value and limitations of induced participation in politically constrained environments. The article contributes to debates on participatory governance by refining the induced participation framework and providing new empirical insights from the underexplored Central Asian context.

  • Open Access

    Analysis of Conceptual Perception and Practical Implementation of Inclusivity Principles in the Civil Service of Kazakhstan

    by Zhuldyz Davletbayeva, Rustamjon Urinboyev, Alexandr Zagrebin, Adilet Kusherbayev

    This article examines the implementation of inclusion principles in the civil service of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Inclusivity has become one of the key priorities of public administration in Kazakhstan within the framework of the “Listening State” concept. This article aims to examine how Kazakhstani civil servants perceive the concept of inclusivity and how it is implemented in civil service practice. The study is based on survey data collected between May and September 2025 from 383 active civil servants across eight regions of Kazakhstan. The findings reveal a lack of a shared understanding of inclusivity and significant deviations from its conceptual foundations. These differences in interpretation suggest the absence of a coherent understanding of inclusivity among civil servants, which is reflected in the practical implementation of inclusive governance principles. In particular, inclusivity is perceived not as a human-centered and individualized approach aimed at addressing the diverse needs of citizens, but rather as a process of reaching the largest possible number of citizens through standardized tools and mechanisms. The findings provide a basis for identifying directions for improving organizational culture and management practices aimed at strengthening inclusivity in Kazakhstan’s civil service. They also contribute to a broader scholarly understanding of the concept and its application in public administration.

  • Open Access

    Коррупционные риски в привлечении частных инвестиций: анализ эмпирических данных

    by Alexandr Zagrebin, Жулдыз Давлетбаева

    Private investment is particularly vulnerable to the risk of corruption due to the specific features of government regulation in this area of economic activity. The purpose of this article is to examine the perception of corruption in private investment attraction in the Republic of Kazakhstan among business representatives and relevant experts, identifying the main types of corruption risks and the factors contributing to them. To achieve this objective, a mixed-method research approach was employed, based on the collection and analysis of empirical data through a sociological survey of business entities (total n=384) and interviews with experts in investment attraction and corruption (total n=10). The results showed that the most characteristic corruption risks in Kazakhstan’s investment sector are associated with resource allocation, the exercise of administrative and regulatory powers, and the provision of non-competitive advantages to individual market participants at the legislative level. The key factors contributing to these risks include legislative deficiencies, high administrative burdens, competition for resources, and insufficient institutional oversight. The main recommendations for further improving anti-corruption policy in this area include improving regulatory procedures and increasing transparency in the allocation of preferential resources to investment entities.

  • Open Access

    From Accumulation to Conversion: Intellectual Capital and Economic Response

    by Gulimzhan Suleimenova, Almakul Abdimomynova, Nurziya Mazhitova, Zhuldyz Davletbayeva

    The transition to a knowledge-based economy increasingly depends on the accumulation and effective use of regional intellectual capital (RIC). This challenge is particularly acute for resource-oriented countries seeking to reduce their dependence on natural resources and achieve sustainable long-term development. However, its immediate economic effects of RIC remain unclear. The paper examines whether regions that accumulate RIC are able to convert it into short-term economic dynamics and whether such accumulation creates the foundations for long-term regional transformation. Using panel data for regions of Kazakhstan, the empirical strategy distinguishes between two complementary dimensions of RIC impact. The structural effect of RIC is estimated using a two-way fixed-effects panel model, while the short-term conversion effect is operationalized through a novel indicator - the Regional Intellectual Capital Conversion Elasticity (RICCE_Elasticity). The results show that RIC functions primarily as an accumulated institutional resource whose development impact depends not only on its stock, but also on regional mechanisms that enable its economic conversion. By distinguishing between accumulation and conversion effects, the paper contributes to the literature on intellectual capital and regional development.

  • Open Access

    Inclusive governance and related concepts: A review and policy insights

    by Zhuldyz Davletbayeva, Ulan Bekish, Gulimzhan Suleimenova, Alexandr Zagrebin, Arman Abdanbekov

    Type of the article: Research ArticleAbstractInclusive governance has attracted growing scholarly attention as both a normative principle and a practical approach. This paper aims to conduct a bibliometric and science-mapping analysis of the academic literature on inclusive governance and related concepts. The analysis is based on 1,990 documents indexed in the Scopus database, covering the available period from 1976 to 2025. Data processing and analysis were conducted using the Bibliometrix package in R. The results reveal a pronounced growth trajectory of inclusive governance research, with a sharp acceleration after 2013 and particularly strong expansion in the post-2020 period. Citation dynamics highlight the enduring influence of foundational works on participatory and democratic governance, alongside the rising prominence of sustainability-oriented and decision-making frameworks. Keyword co-occurrence and thematic mapping identify a strong conceptual core centered on participatory governance and governance approaches, complemented by more specialized human- and community-centered themes. A domain-based thematic analysis further demonstrates that inclusive governance is conceptualized differently across research areas. Public governance emphasizes participation and normative sustainability principles, environmental governance focuses on resource management and issue-specific challenges, while economic and organizational governance integrates institutional, innovation-driven, and stakeholder-oriented perspectives. The findings confirm inclusive governance as a conceptually plural yet increasingly coherent research field, while also pointing to persistent gaps in geographical representation and contextual diversity, and offering directions for future research and policy-oriented inquiry.AcknowledgmentsThis research has been funded by the Committee of Science of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan (Grant No. BR27100377).

  • Open Access

    ANALYSIS OF CURRENT PROJECT MANAGEMENT PRACTICES IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN

    by R. Ismailova, A. Aitbayeva, Zh. Davletbayeva, R. Doszhan

    The article examines current project management practices as a tool for improving the efficiency of public administration in implementing projects to address socio-economic problems. The purpose of the article is to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the current project management system in the public sector of the Republic of Kazakhstan. The research used comparative analysis and case analysis to assess international experience, content analysis to study legislation regulating project activities in domestic practice, and SWOT analysis to identify the strengths and weaknesses of project management within government structures. The article focuses on the analysis of regulatory legal acts and the institutional and organizational aspects of implementing the project approach in the activities of government agencies. Based on the analysis, the key problems of project management implementation have been identified, including insufficient staff training, limited digital tools, and poor coordination between departments. Taking into account international experience, recommendations are proposed to improve the current system: the development of project offices, the introduction of uniform standards, and the increased transparency and digitalization of processes. The results of the study will enable the development of recommendations to improve the functioning of the project management model in the public sector of Kazakhstan and to ensure compliance with international project management standards. The results obtained can be used to develop state policy in project management.

  • Open Access

    Corruption and investment research trends: A bibliometric analysis and future directions

    by Zhuldyz Davletbayeva, Alexandr Zagrebin

    Type of the article: Research ArticleAbstractThe relationship between corruption and investment has attracted growing scholarly attention amid global concerns over governance quality, institutional efficiency, and capital mobility. This paper aims to systematize and critically assess how the relationship between corruption and investment has been explored in academic literature from 2015 to 2024, without limiting either concept to specific forms or levels. A bibliometric analysis was conducted based on 1,535 journal articles indexed in the Scopus database. The study identifies publication trends, dominant keywords, and seven thematic clusters, which reflect major research areas such as institutional quality, foreign direct investment, sustainable development, public policy, and social outcomes. A focused subset of 184 articles, containing both corruption- and investment-related terms in their titles, served as the basis for thematic classification. Three main research approaches are identified: (1) investment-type studies, which overwhelmingly focus on foreign direct investment (FDI), while domestic and informal investments are rarely addressed; (2) causal-explanatory models, which emphasize economic and institutional determinants but largely omit cultural and behavioral variables; and (3) case-based empirical analyses, which are often concentrated on single-country contexts. China is the most frequently studied country, whereas Central Asia, the Middle East, the CIS region, Western Europe, and the Commonwealth are all significantly underrepresented. The findings reveal thematic fragmentation, conceptual bias toward FDI, and persistent geographical imbalance. The study provides a foundation for future research and supports the development of more diversified, context-sensitive approaches to understanding the corruption-investment nexus.


  • Open Access

    Transformation of public administration in Kazakhstan: an analysis of inclusivity and human-centeredness

    by A. M. Kusherbayev, R. T. Dulambayeva, Zh. Zh. Davletbayeva

    Contemporary public administration reforms in Kazakhstan are oriented toward the principles of inclusiveness and human-centeredness; however, their theoretical conceptualization and practical implementation remain insufficiently studied and systematized. The research problem consists in the insufficient theoretical elaboration and systematization of the relationship between inclusiveness and human-centeredness in Kazakhstan's public administration and in the gap between the declared principles and their practical implementation. This article fills this gap by comparing the essential characteristics of the two approaches and clarifying their interaction based on the experience of Kazakhstan. The aim of this study is to identify the interrelation between inclusive and human-centered approaches, assess their implementation in the context of Kazakhstan, and develop recommendations for their integration. The methodological basis of the study includes qualitative analysis of secondary sources, comparative analysis of governance models, examination of Kazakhstan’s experience, and the development of the author's conceptual model. The originality and scholarly value of the research lie in the exploration of the relationship between inclusive and human-centered approaches, their application to Kazakhstan’s governance practices, and the formulation of an original model of inclusive public administration. The findings demonstrate that inclusive governance involves broad participation of all societal groups, while the human-centered approach focuses on prioritizing the needs of each individual citizen. These approaches are shown to be complementary. Practical examples, such as the «e-Otinish» and electronic petitions system, illustrate the potential of digitalization in implementing the principles of openness, accountability, and citizenoriented service delivery.

  • Open Access

    A Competency Model of Inclusive Governance: A Human-Centered Approach to Civil Service in Kazakhstan

    by Zhuldyz Davletbayeva, Ulan Bekish, Alexandr Zagrebin, Adilet Kusherbayev

    In the context of the transformation of public administration systems, inclusive and human-centered approaches that focus on addressing the needs of citizens and increasing the participation of various social groups in decision-making are becoming increasingly important. The purpose of this article is to develop a conceptual model of civil service competencies that support the implementation of inclusive and human-centered governance within the framework of the “Listening State” concept. The methodology of the study includes an analysis of strategic and regulatory documents of the Republic of Kazakhstan, as well as a comparative review of international practices from the United Kingdom, Canada, and New Zealand. The practical implementation of the model involves the development of behavioral indicators that take into account regional and cultural specificities, the introduction of mandatory training programs on inclusive leadership, intercultural communication, and digital literacy, as well as the establishment of regular competency assessments using adapted 360-degree feedback methods. Additional important steps include strengthening interagency coordination and developing digital citizen feedback tools to enhance openness and engagement. At the same time, potential risks such as resistance to change, limited funding, and institutional inertia may arise, requiring strong leadership support and a phased implementation plan with continuous monitoring. The results can be used to revise approaches to the selection, training, and evaluation of civil servants and to guide the development of a new civil service model that is focused on citizens’ needs and the promotion of human-centered governance.