Manuel E. Rao
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Manuel E. Rao has a total of 27 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jochen Moll
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Siegen, Paul-Bonatz-Straße 9-11, 57076 Siegen, Germany
5 shared publications - Jonas Simon
Department of Physics, Goethe University Frankfurt, 60438 Frankfurt, Germany
3 shared publications - Peter Kraemer
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Siegen, Paul-Bonatz-Straße 9-11, 57076 Siegen, Germany
2 shared publications - Viktor Krozer
Department of Physics, Goethe University Frankfurt, 60438 Frankfurt, Germany
2 shared publications - Vittorio Memmolo
Department of Industrial Engineering, University of Naples Federico II, 80125 Naples, Italy
2 shared publications Andreas Nuber
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 August 2026
- Published by NDT.net GmbH & Co. KG in e-Journal of Nondestructive Testing
- Vol. 31 (8)
Initial Results for In-situ Structural Health Monitoring of Wind Turbine Blades using an FMCW Radar Network at 60GHz
The continuous increase in the number of wind turbines is one of the major innovations of the 21st century worldwide for generating renewable energy and simul taneously reducing greenhouse gases. Since maintenance by mechanics only takes place at intervals without continuous monitoring and is associated with high profit losses due to shutdowns, intelligent sensors and algorithms are used to monitor the entire structure, in particular wind turbine blades (WTBs). The field study by Maelzer et al. [1] and the fatigue test in the laboratory by Simon et al. [2] have shown that a radar-based approach in the millimeter-wave frequency range for structural health monitoring of WTBs is promising. This work describes the overall system design of a radar-based SHM system and its field deployment in a wind turbine. For this purpose, four sensor boxes are mounted on the main web of two rotor blades of a wind turbine. Each sensor box contains a frequency-modulated continuous wave (FMCW) radar at 60GHz and an acceleration sensor. Furthermore, one control unit per blade is mounted in the hub. Eachsensor box is connected to the corresponding control unit using the Power over Dataline standard for independent communication [3]. One of the three control units is connected to the mobile network for data transfer. A reference damage model developed by Rao et al. [4] and previously implemented on a WTB segment is applied here to simulate an artificial delamination. Initial measurement results are presented taking the changing environmental and operational conditions of the wind turbine into account. References [1] MORITZ MÄLZER, SEBASTIAN BECK, SERCAN ALIPEK, ELIAS REICHART, JOCHEN MOLL, VIKTOR KROZER, CHRISTOS OIKONOMOPOULOS, JÜRGEN KASSNER, MANFREDHÄGELEN,THOMASHEINECKE,etal. Radar-based struc tural monitoring of wind turbines blades: Field results from two operational wind tur bines. STRUCTURAL HEALTH MONITORING 2023, 2023. [2] Jonas Simon, Thomas Kurin, Jochen Moll, Oliver Bagemiel, Raphael Wedel, Stefan Krause, Fabian Lurz, Andreas Nuber, Vadim Issakov, and Viktor Krozer. Embedded radar networks for damage detection in wind turbine blades: Validation in a full-scale fatigue test. Structural Health Monitoring, 22(6):4252–4263, 2023. [3] Tobias Huemmer, Thomas Kurin, Moritz Maelzer, Katharina Fiedler, Sebastian Beck, Jochen Moll, and Fabian Lurz. System architecture of a radar-based structural health monitoring system for wind turbine blades using power over dataline. In IEEE Sensors 2025. IEEE, 2025. [4] Manuel E Rao, Jochen Moll, Peter Kraemer, and Viktor Krozer. Experimental application of a reversible reference damage model for radar-based shm of glass fiber reinforced polymer structures. In 2025 IEEE 12th International Workshop on Metrology for AeroSpace (MetroAeroSpace), pages 780–784. IEEE, 2025.
- 1 August 2026
- Published by NDT.net GmbH & Co. KG in e-Journal of Nondestructive Testing
- Vol. 31 (8)
Open AccessInitial Results for In-situ Structural Health Monitoring of Wind Turbine Blades using an FMCW Radar Network at 60GHz
The continuous increase in the number of wind turbines is one of the major innovations of the 21st century worldwide for generating renewable energy and simul taneously reducing greenhouse gases. Since maintenance by mechanics only takes place at intervals without continuous monitoring and is associated with high profit losses due to shutdowns, intelligent sensors and algorithms are used to monitor the entire structure, in particular wind turbine blades (WTBs). The field study by Maelzer et al. [1] and the fatigue test in the laboratory by Simon et al. [2] have shown that a radar-based approach in the millimeter-wave frequency range for structural health monitoring of WTBs is promising. This work describes the overall system design of a radar-based SHM system and its field deployment in a wind turbine. For this purpose, four sensor boxes are mounted on the main web of two rotor blades of a wind turbine. Each sensor box contains a frequency-modulated continuous wave (FMCW) radar at 60GHz and an acceleration sensor. Furthermore, one control unit per blade is mounted in the hub. Eachsensor box is connected to the corresponding control unit using the Power over Dataline standard for independent communication [3]. One of the three control units is connected to the mobile network for data transfer. A reference damage model developed by Rao et al. [4] and previously implemented on a WTB segment is applied here to simulate an artificial delamination. Initial measurement results are presented taking the changing environmental and operational conditions of the wind turbine into account. References [1] MORITZ MÄLZER, SEBASTIAN BECK, SERCAN ALIPEK, ELIAS REICHART, JOCHEN MOLL, VIKTOR KROZER, CHRISTOS OIKONOMOPOULOS, JÜRGEN KASSNER, MANFREDHÄGELEN,THOMASHEINECKE,etal. Radar-based struc tural monitoring of wind turbines blades: Field results from two operational wind tur bines. STRUCTURAL HEALTH MONITORING 2023, 2023. [2] Jonas Simon, Thomas Kurin, Jochen Moll, Oliver Bagemiel, Raphael Wedel, Stefan Krause, Fabian Lurz, Andreas Nuber, Vadim Issakov, and Viktor Krozer. Embedded radar networks for damage detection in wind turbine blades: Validation in a full-scale fatigue test. Structural Health Monitoring, 22(6):4252–4263, 2023. [3] Tobias Huemmer, Thomas Kurin, Moritz Maelzer, Katharina Fiedler, Sebastian Beck, Jochen Moll, and Fabian Lurz. System architecture of a radar-based structural health monitoring system for wind turbine blades using power over dataline. In IEEE Sensors 2025. IEEE, 2025. [4] Manuel E Rao, Jochen Moll, Peter Kraemer, and Viktor Krozer. Experimental application of a reversible reference damage model for radar-based shm of glass fiber reinforced polymer structures. In 2025 IEEE 12th International Workshop on Metrology for AeroSpace (MetroAeroSpace), pages 780–784. IEEE, 2025.
- Open Access
Performance Characterization of Radar-Based Delamination Assessment in Glass Fiber Reinforced Composites
Radar technology in the microwave and millimeter-wave frequency range is the subject of current research for structural health monitoring of composite materials, e.g., damage detection in wind turbine blades. Performance assessment, enabling widespread practical application of this promising and non-contact sensing approach, can be realized via probability of detection (POD) theory, which is a statistical method for determining the detectability of damage through response metrics as a function of flaw size. This paper deals with the experimental investigation of a delamination model represented by two parallel glass fiber reinforced polymer plates separated from each other from to in steps of . Experimental studies with a frequency modulated continuous wave radar are performed under laboratory conditions in the frequency range from to . The signal response is represented by two damage indicators (DIs), according to the root mean square deviation and Mahalanobis distance. Since the reflection of electromagnetic waves exhibits a nonlinear behavior, this also implies a nonlinear response in the DI characteristic. The novelties in this work are the successful implementation of a nonlinear regression model, combined with an optimal threshold decision through receiver operating characteristic curves for a high-resolution POD representation. The POD with confidence bounds indicates the flaw size at which the delamination can be detected reliably. Depending on the radar distance in experimental studies, the binary structural condition (damaged or undamaged) was correctly assessed from to . The minimum detectable size ranges from to .Open AccessPerformance Characterization of Radar-Based Delamination Assessment in Glass Fiber Reinforced Composites
Radar technology in the microwave and millimeter-wave frequency range is the subject of current research for structural health monitoring of composite materials, e.g., damage detection in wind turbine blades. Performance assessment, enabling widespread practical application of this promising and non-contact sensing approach, can be realized via probability of detection (POD) theory, which is a statistical method for determining the detectability of damage through response metrics as a function of flaw size. This paper deals with the experimental investigation of a delamination model represented by two parallel glass fiber reinforced polymer plates separated from each other from to in steps of . Experimental studies with a frequency modulated continuous wave radar are performed under laboratory conditions in the frequency range from to . The signal response is represented by two damage indicators (DIs), according to the root mean square deviation and Mahalanobis distance. Since the reflection of electromagnetic waves exhibits a nonlinear behavior, this also implies a nonlinear response in the DI characteristic. The novelties in this work are the successful implementation of a nonlinear regression model, combined with an optimal threshold decision through receiver operating characteristic curves for a high-resolution POD representation. The POD with confidence bounds indicates the flaw size at which the delamination can be detected reliably. Depending on the radar distance in experimental studies, the binary structural condition (damaged or undamaged) was correctly assessed from to . The minimum detectable size ranges from to . - Open Access
- 9 June 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 15 (12) , 6478
Structural Health Monitoring of Aerial Vehicles Using Guided Electromagnetic Waves in K-Band: Initial Damage Detection Results from Drone Flight Testing
This paper introduces a novel structural health monitoring (SHM) approach based on guided electromagnetic waves propagating in a dielectric waveguide in the frequency range from 23.5 to 26 GHz. This approach enables the detection of structural damage based on the analysis of radar signals. This paper presents the performance of the methodology through an experimental case study considering an autonomous heavy lift drone where the whole SHM system is integrated onboard. The whole data acquisition pipeline is described, and damage detection results based on a damage indicator approach are presented and discussed. Finally, this work proves the ability of guided electromagnetic wave technology to be used in flying aerial vehicles. The methodology can be applied to other aircraft structures and application cases in the future.
- 9 June 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 15 (12) , 6478
Open AccessStructural Health Monitoring of Aerial Vehicles Using Guided Electromagnetic Waves in K-Band: Initial Damage Detection Results from Drone Flight Testing
This paper introduces a novel structural health monitoring (SHM) approach based on guided electromagnetic waves propagating in a dielectric waveguide in the frequency range from 23.5 to 26 GHz. This approach enables the detection of structural damage based on the analysis of radar signals. This paper presents the performance of the methodology through an experimental case study considering an autonomous heavy lift drone where the whole SHM system is integrated onboard. The whole data acquisition pipeline is described, and damage detection results based on a damage indicator approach are presented and discussed. Finally, this work proves the ability of guided electromagnetic wave technology to be used in flying aerial vehicles. The methodology can be applied to other aircraft structures and application cases in the future.
- Open Access
Radar-Based Damage Detection in a Wind Turbine Blade Using Convolutional Neural Networks: A Proof-of-Concept Under Fatigue Loading
This paper reports a convolutional neural network (CNN)-based damage detection approach for radar-based structural health monitoring of wind turbine blades. Subsequent radar measurements are transformed into an image-type representation for use as CNN input. In contrast to conventional approaches that require compensation for temperature and loading effects, the proposed framework inherently learns all required information during the training phase. Its damage detection performance (i.e., detecting intact vs. damaged condition) is demonstrated using measurements from multiple embedded radar sensors during fatigue testing of a wind turbine blade with a length of 31 m. The achieved F1-score for correct damage classification is between 91% and 100% for both the unloaded and the loaded blade.
Open AccessRadar-Based Damage Detection in a Wind Turbine Blade Using Convolutional Neural Networks: A Proof-of-Concept Under Fatigue Loading
This paper reports a convolutional neural network (CNN)-based damage detection approach for radar-based structural health monitoring of wind turbine blades. Subsequent radar measurements are transformed into an image-type representation for use as CNN input. In contrast to conventional approaches that require compensation for temperature and loading effects, the proposed framework inherently learns all required information during the training phase. Its damage detection performance (i.e., detecting intact vs. damaged condition) is demonstrated using measurements from multiple embedded radar sensors during fatigue testing of a wind turbine blade with a length of 31 m. The achieved F1-score for correct damage classification is between 91% and 100% for both the unloaded and the loaded blade.
- Open Access
- 28 March 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Structural Health Monitoring
- Vol. 25 (4) , 2739-2750
Real-time onboard propeller fault diagnosis of autonomous delivery drones through vibration analysis
Delivery drones have become increasingly important in recent years. It is advantageous for commercialization that suppliers are able to deliver orders autonomously and directly to their customers via air transport. However, the safety aspect must be considered. Real-time inspection of delivery drones during operation helps preventing accidents and a threat to civilians. For continuous monitoring, the sensors must be installed on the drone throughout the flight. A promising approach uses the inherent excitation of the servomotors for vibration-based Structural Health Monitoring (SHM). Vibrations can be recorded using triaxial acceleration sensors and analyzed using suitable methods such as stochastic subspace-based fault detection or histogram difference. In comparison to nondestructive testing, reference measurements of the intact structure are necessary in SHM. As soon as laboratory conditions no longer exist and environmental parameters, for example, wind, influence the vibration spectrum, classification methods are necessary for compensation. The recording of comprehensive reference datasets with different environmental conditions is limited by the battery life. This work focuses on diagnosing irreversible rotor blade damages of an 8.5 kg delivery drone. A parametric analysis taking into account systematic fusion of damage indicators and a specific number of considered references were determined for this purpose in order to assess the severity of the existing damage. Onboard SHM to evaluate the airworthiness in real time for linear and hovering flights was achieved.
- 28 March 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Structural Health Monitoring
- Vol. 25 (4) , 2739-2750
Open AccessReal-time onboard propeller fault diagnosis of autonomous delivery drones through vibration analysis
Delivery drones have become increasingly important in recent years. It is advantageous for commercialization that suppliers are able to deliver orders autonomously and directly to their customers via air transport. However, the safety aspect must be considered. Real-time inspection of delivery drones during operation helps preventing accidents and a threat to civilians. For continuous monitoring, the sensors must be installed on the drone throughout the flight. A promising approach uses the inherent excitation of the servomotors for vibration-based Structural Health Monitoring (SHM). Vibrations can be recorded using triaxial acceleration sensors and analyzed using suitable methods such as stochastic subspace-based fault detection or histogram difference. In comparison to nondestructive testing, reference measurements of the intact structure are necessary in SHM. As soon as laboratory conditions no longer exist and environmental parameters, for example, wind, influence the vibration spectrum, classification methods are necessary for compensation. The recording of comprehensive reference datasets with different environmental conditions is limited by the battery life. This work focuses on diagnosing irreversible rotor blade damages of an 8.5 kg delivery drone. A parametric analysis taking into account systematic fusion of damage indicators and a specific number of considered references were determined for this purpose in order to assess the severity of the existing damage. Onboard SHM to evaluate the airworthiness in real time for linear and hovering flights was achieved.