Audrey McManemin
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Audrey McManemin has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Adam R. Brandt
Department of Energy Science & Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA
15 shared publicationsCatherine Juéry
Air Quality Laboratory, TotalEnergies, 69360 Solaize, France
15 shared publicationsVincent Blandin
TotalEnergies Anomaly Detection Initiatives, TotalEnergies, 64170 Lacq, France
15 shared publicationsAndreas Hueni
Department of Geography, University of Zürich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, 8057 Zürich, Switzerland
10 shared publications- Dominik Brunner
Empa, Laboratory for Air Pollution/Environmental Technology, Dübendorf, Switzerland
10 shared publications - Gerrit Kuhlmann
Empa (Dübendorf, Switzerland)
10 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 9 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-32
Reply on RC1
Accurate methane emission quantification is critical for climate mitigation efforts in the oil and gas industry. This study evaluates the performance of five academic methane measurement systems through single-blind controlled release testing at the TotalEnergies Anomaly Detection Initiatives (TADI) facility in France during June and September 2024. Vehicle-based teams from Technical University of Denmark, Heidelberg University, and a collaborative team from Utrecht University/LSCE/Cyprus Institute/Royal Holloway deployed mobile in situ measurement systems, while aircraft-based solutions from Empa/UZH and FAAM BAe-146 utilized hyperspectral imaging and airborne in situ measurements, respectively. Vehicle-based systems demonstrated strong detection capabilities with true positive rates of 93–100 % and minimum detection thresholds below 1 kg CH₄ h⁻¹. Quantification accuracy varied significantly, with slopes ranging from 0.38 to 1.04 when comparing estimated versus true emission rates. Aircraft systems showed more variable performance due to operational constraints and limited data availability. Post-unblinding analysis revealed critical insights into systematic errors, including background concentration calculation issues and wind measurement limitations. Low wind conditions (<2 m s⁻¹) particularly challenged quantification accuracy across all platforms. These findings highlight the importance of robust validation procedures and high-quality meteorological data for reliable methane emission quantification in real-world applications.
- 9 October 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-32
Open AccessReply on RC1
Accurate methane emission quantification is critical for climate mitigation efforts in the oil and gas industry. This study evaluates the performance of five academic methane measurement systems through single-blind controlled release testing at the TotalEnergies Anomaly Detection Initiatives (TADI) facility in France during June and September 2024. Vehicle-based teams from Technical University of Denmark, Heidelberg University, and a collaborative team from Utrecht University/LSCE/Cyprus Institute/Royal Holloway deployed mobile in situ measurement systems, while aircraft-based solutions from Empa/UZH and FAAM BAe-146 utilized hyperspectral imaging and airborne in situ measurements, respectively. Vehicle-based systems demonstrated strong detection capabilities with true positive rates of 93–100 % and minimum detection thresholds below 1 kg CH₄ h⁻¹. Quantification accuracy varied significantly, with slopes ranging from 0.38 to 1.04 when comparing estimated versus true emission rates. Aircraft systems showed more variable performance due to operational constraints and limited data availability. Post-unblinding analysis revealed critical insights into systematic errors, including background concentration calculation issues and wind measurement limitations. Low wind conditions (<2 m s⁻¹) particularly challenged quantification accuracy across all platforms. These findings highlight the importance of robust validation procedures and high-quality meteorological data for reliable methane emission quantification in real-world applications.
- Open Access
- 11 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-32
Comment on egusphere-2026-1744
Accurate methane emission quantification is critical for climate mitigation efforts in the oil and gas industry. This study evaluates the performance of five academic methane measurement systems through single-blind controlled release testing at the TotalEnergies Anomaly Detection Initiatives (TADI) facility in France during June and September 2024. Vehicle-based teams from Technical University of Denmark, Heidelberg University, and a collaborative team from Utrecht University/LSCE/Cyprus Institute/Royal Holloway deployed mobile in situ measurement systems, while aircraft-based solutions from Empa/UZH and FAAM BAe-146 utilized hyperspectral imaging and airborne in situ measurements, respectively. Vehicle-based systems demonstrated strong detection capabilities with true positive rates of 93–100 % and minimum detection thresholds below 1 kg CH₄ h⁻¹. Quantification accuracy varied significantly, with slopes ranging from 0.38 to 1.04 when comparing estimated versus true emission rates. Aircraft systems showed more variable performance due to operational constraints and limited data availability. Post-unblinding analysis revealed critical insights into systematic errors, including background concentration calculation issues and wind measurement limitations. Low wind conditions (<2 m s⁻¹) particularly challenged quantification accuracy across all platforms. These findings highlight the importance of robust validation procedures and high-quality meteorological data for reliable methane emission quantification in real-world applications.
- 11 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-32
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-1744
Accurate methane emission quantification is critical for climate mitigation efforts in the oil and gas industry. This study evaluates the performance of five academic methane measurement systems through single-blind controlled release testing at the TotalEnergies Anomaly Detection Initiatives (TADI) facility in France during June and September 2024. Vehicle-based teams from Technical University of Denmark, Heidelberg University, and a collaborative team from Utrecht University/LSCE/Cyprus Institute/Royal Holloway deployed mobile in situ measurement systems, while aircraft-based solutions from Empa/UZH and FAAM BAe-146 utilized hyperspectral imaging and airborne in situ measurements, respectively. Vehicle-based systems demonstrated strong detection capabilities with true positive rates of 93–100 % and minimum detection thresholds below 1 kg CH₄ h⁻¹. Quantification accuracy varied significantly, with slopes ranging from 0.38 to 1.04 when comparing estimated versus true emission rates. Aircraft systems showed more variable performance due to operational constraints and limited data availability. Post-unblinding analysis revealed critical insights into systematic errors, including background concentration calculation issues and wind measurement limitations. Low wind conditions (<2 m s⁻¹) particularly challenged quantification accuracy across all platforms. These findings highlight the importance of robust validation procedures and high-quality meteorological data for reliable methane emission quantification in real-world applications.
- Open Access
- 3 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-32
Comment on egusphere-2026-1744
Accurate methane emission quantification is critical for climate mitigation efforts in the oil and gas industry. This study evaluates the performance of five academic methane measurement systems through single-blind controlled release testing at the TotalEnergies Anomaly Detection Initiatives (TADI) facility in France during June and September 2024. Vehicle-based teams from Technical University of Denmark, Heidelberg University, and a collaborative team from Utrecht University/LSCE/Cyprus Institute/Royal Holloway deployed mobile in situ measurement systems, while aircraft-based solutions from Empa/UZH and FAAM BAe-146 utilized hyperspectral imaging and airborne in situ measurements, respectively. Vehicle-based systems demonstrated strong detection capabilities with true positive rates of 93–100 % and minimum detection thresholds below 1 kg CH₄ h⁻¹. Quantification accuracy varied significantly, with slopes ranging from 0.38 to 1.04 when comparing estimated versus true emission rates. Aircraft systems showed more variable performance due to operational constraints and limited data availability. Post-unblinding analysis revealed critical insights into systematic errors, including background concentration calculation issues and wind measurement limitations. Low wind conditions (<2 m s⁻¹) particularly challenged quantification accuracy across all platforms. These findings highlight the importance of robust validation procedures and high-quality meteorological data for reliable methane emission quantification in real-world applications.
- 3 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-32
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-1744
Accurate methane emission quantification is critical for climate mitigation efforts in the oil and gas industry. This study evaluates the performance of five academic methane measurement systems through single-blind controlled release testing at the TotalEnergies Anomaly Detection Initiatives (TADI) facility in France during June and September 2024. Vehicle-based teams from Technical University of Denmark, Heidelberg University, and a collaborative team from Utrecht University/LSCE/Cyprus Institute/Royal Holloway deployed mobile in situ measurement systems, while aircraft-based solutions from Empa/UZH and FAAM BAe-146 utilized hyperspectral imaging and airborne in situ measurements, respectively. Vehicle-based systems demonstrated strong detection capabilities with true positive rates of 93–100 % and minimum detection thresholds below 1 kg CH₄ h⁻¹. Quantification accuracy varied significantly, with slopes ranging from 0.38 to 1.04 when comparing estimated versus true emission rates. Aircraft systems showed more variable performance due to operational constraints and limited data availability. Post-unblinding analysis revealed critical insights into systematic errors, including background concentration calculation issues and wind measurement limitations. Low wind conditions (<2 m s⁻¹) particularly challenged quantification accuracy across all platforms. These findings highlight the importance of robust validation procedures and high-quality meteorological data for reliable methane emission quantification in real-world applications.
- Open Access
- 14 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Supplementary material to "From research to reality: Academic methane measurement systems tested at the TADI controlled release facility"
- 14 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessSupplementary material to "From research to reality: Academic methane measurement systems tested at the TADI controlled release facility"
- Open Access
- 14 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-32
From research to reality: Academic methane measurement systems tested at the TADI controlled release facility
Accurate methane emission quantification is critical for climate mitigation efforts in the oil and gas industry. This study evaluates the performance of five academic methane measurement systems through single-blind controlled release testing at the TotalEnergies Anomaly Detection Initiatives (TADI) facility in France during June and September 2024. Vehicle-based teams from Technical University of Denmark, Heidelberg University, and a collaborative team from Utrecht University/LSCE/Cyprus Institute/Royal Holloway deployed mobile in situ measurement systems, while aircraft-based solutions from Empa/UZH and FAAM BAe-146 utilized hyperspectral imaging and airborne in situ measurements, respectively. Vehicle-based systems demonstrated strong detection capabilities with true positive rates of 93–100 % and minimum detection thresholds below 1 kg CH₄ h⁻¹. Quantification accuracy varied significantly, with slopes ranging from 0.38 to 1.04 when comparing estimated versus true emission rates. Aircraft systems showed more variable performance due to operational constraints and limited data availability. Post-unblinding analysis revealed critical insights into systematic errors, including background concentration calculation issues and wind measurement limitations. Low wind conditions (<2 m s⁻¹) particularly challenged quantification accuracy across all platforms. These findings highlight the importance of robust validation procedures and high-quality meteorological data for reliable methane emission quantification in real-world applications.
- 14 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-32
Open AccessFrom research to reality: Academic methane measurement systems tested at the TADI controlled release facility
Accurate methane emission quantification is critical for climate mitigation efforts in the oil and gas industry. This study evaluates the performance of five academic methane measurement systems through single-blind controlled release testing at the TotalEnergies Anomaly Detection Initiatives (TADI) facility in France during June and September 2024. Vehicle-based teams from Technical University of Denmark, Heidelberg University, and a collaborative team from Utrecht University/LSCE/Cyprus Institute/Royal Holloway deployed mobile in situ measurement systems, while aircraft-based solutions from Empa/UZH and FAAM BAe-146 utilized hyperspectral imaging and airborne in situ measurements, respectively. Vehicle-based systems demonstrated strong detection capabilities with true positive rates of 93–100 % and minimum detection thresholds below 1 kg CH₄ h⁻¹. Quantification accuracy varied significantly, with slopes ranging from 0.38 to 1.04 when comparing estimated versus true emission rates. Aircraft systems showed more variable performance due to operational constraints and limited data availability. Post-unblinding analysis revealed critical insights into systematic errors, including background concentration calculation issues and wind measurement limitations. Low wind conditions (<2 m s⁻¹) particularly challenged quantification accuracy across all platforms. These findings highlight the importance of robust validation procedures and high-quality meteorological data for reliable methane emission quantification in real-world applications.
- Open Access
- 10 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
- Vol. 19 (3) , 923-934
Controlled release testing of commercially available methane emission measurement technologies at the TADI facility
This study presents an independent and blinded controlled release evaluation of methane detection and quantification technologies in Europe. Conducted at the TotalEnergies Anomalies Detection Initiatives (TADI) site in France, the campaign tested eight commercial systems – including satellite, drone, and continuous monitoring platforms – under controlled single-blind conditions. Participants submitted methane emission rate estimates without prior knowledge of true release values. Performance was assessed through detection limit curves, parity plots, and statistical metrics including slope and R2. False positive detection rates ranged from 0 % to 11 %. Quantification slopes ranged from 0.09 to 1.13, with a trend toward underestimation, and R2 values ranged from 0.08 to 0.97. Wind conditions – particularly low speeds and high variability – were a key factor affecting quantification accuracy, emphasizing the need for high-quality wind data integration. This study underscores the importance of rigorous, standardized testing to benchmark technology performance and inform regulatory efforts. Results highlight platform-specific strengths and challenges, providing actionable insights for participants, policymakers, and regulators. These findings support the development of robust, validated methane measurement tools critical to achieving effective emissions monitoring and reduction strategies under evolving regulatory frameworks, such as those in the European Union.
- 10 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
- Vol. 19 (3) , 923-934
Open AccessControlled release testing of commercially available methane emission measurement technologies at the TADI facility
This study presents an independent and blinded controlled release evaluation of methane detection and quantification technologies in Europe. Conducted at the TotalEnergies Anomalies Detection Initiatives (TADI) site in France, the campaign tested eight commercial systems – including satellite, drone, and continuous monitoring platforms – under controlled single-blind conditions. Participants submitted methane emission rate estimates without prior knowledge of true release values. Performance was assessed through detection limit curves, parity plots, and statistical metrics including slope and R2. False positive detection rates ranged from 0 % to 11 %. Quantification slopes ranged from 0.09 to 1.13, with a trend toward underestimation, and R2 values ranged from 0.08 to 0.97. Wind conditions – particularly low speeds and high variability – were a key factor affecting quantification accuracy, emphasizing the need for high-quality wind data integration. This study underscores the importance of rigorous, standardized testing to benchmark technology performance and inform regulatory efforts. Results highlight platform-specific strengths and challenges, providing actionable insights for participants, policymakers, and regulators. These findings support the development of robust, validated methane measurement tools critical to achieving effective emissions monitoring and reduction strategies under evolving regulatory frameworks, such as those in the European Union.
- Open Access
- 16 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
- Vol. 19 (1) , 333-358
Quantifying CH 4 point source emissions with airborne remote sensing: first results from AVIRIS-4
Atmospheric concentration of methane (CH4), a potent greenhouse gas, increased significantly since pre-industrial times, with anthropogenic emissions originating primarily from agriculture, fossil fuel sector and waste management. However, considerable uncertainties persist in the detection and quantification of anthropogenic CH4 emissions. In this study, we present first CH4 observations, plume detections and emission estimates from the new state-of-the-art Airborne Visible InfraRed Imaging Spectrometer 4 (AVIRIS-4), which participated in a blind controlled release experiment in September 2024 in southern France. We used an albedo-corrected matched filter to retrieve CH4 maps from the spectral images and estimated CH4 emission with the Integrated Mass Enhancement (IME) and Cross-Sectional Flux (CSF) methods. Our results demonstrate that AVIRIS-4 can reliably detect emissions as low as 5.5 kg CH4 h−1 under good weather conditions at low flight altitudes (< 1500 m) and 1.45 kg CH4 h−1 under ideal conditions. These low-altitude detection limits are substantially lower than published detection limits for the predecessor instrument AVIRIS-NG, which were in the order of 10–16 kg CH4 h−1 under comparable conditions. While AVIRIS-4 provides highly accurate CH4 maps at < 0.5 m resolution, emission estimation is limited by the accuracy of the effective wind speed, whose uncertainty and natural variability contribute substantially to the overall uncertainty. Using wind speed at source height performs well for small releases (below 20 kg CH4 h−1) (rRMSE =1.065; rMBE =0.361) and overall (rRMSE =0.702; rMBE =−0.204). Using literature-derived effective wind speeds improves the apparent fit between estimated and reported CH4 emissions, but degrades performance both in overall agreement (rRMSE =2.098; rMBE =0.964) and for low-emission events (rRMSE =2.367; rMBE =1.711). Interestingly, the high spatial resolution makes it possible to retrieve the cast shadow of the CH4 plume, which can be used to estimate source and plume height, and could provide an approach for better constraining the height-dependency of the effective wind speed. On the bottom line, the controlled release experiment provides critical insights into the sensor's capabilities and guides further improvements to detect and quantify low intensity sources in the fossil fuel and waste management sectors, with implications for more accurate global greenhouse gas monitoring.
- 16 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
- Vol. 19 (1) , 333-358
Open AccessQuantifying CH 4 point source emissions with airborne remote sensing: first results from AVIRIS-4
Atmospheric concentration of methane (CH4), a potent greenhouse gas, increased significantly since pre-industrial times, with anthropogenic emissions originating primarily from agriculture, fossil fuel sector and waste management. However, considerable uncertainties persist in the detection and quantification of anthropogenic CH4 emissions. In this study, we present first CH4 observations, plume detections and emission estimates from the new state-of-the-art Airborne Visible InfraRed Imaging Spectrometer 4 (AVIRIS-4), which participated in a blind controlled release experiment in September 2024 in southern France. We used an albedo-corrected matched filter to retrieve CH4 maps from the spectral images and estimated CH4 emission with the Integrated Mass Enhancement (IME) and Cross-Sectional Flux (CSF) methods. Our results demonstrate that AVIRIS-4 can reliably detect emissions as low as 5.5 kg CH4 h−1 under good weather conditions at low flight altitudes (< 1500 m) and 1.45 kg CH4 h−1 under ideal conditions. These low-altitude detection limits are substantially lower than published detection limits for the predecessor instrument AVIRIS-NG, which were in the order of 10–16 kg CH4 h−1 under comparable conditions. While AVIRIS-4 provides highly accurate CH4 maps at < 0.5 m resolution, emission estimation is limited by the accuracy of the effective wind speed, whose uncertainty and natural variability contribute substantially to the overall uncertainty. Using wind speed at source height performs well for small releases (below 20 kg CH4 h−1) (rRMSE =1.065; rMBE =0.361) and overall (rRMSE =0.702; rMBE =−0.204). Using literature-derived effective wind speeds improves the apparent fit between estimated and reported CH4 emissions, but degrades performance both in overall agreement (rRMSE =2.098; rMBE =0.964) and for low-emission events (rRMSE =2.367; rMBE =1.711). Interestingly, the high spatial resolution makes it possible to retrieve the cast shadow of the CH4 plume, which can be used to estimate source and plume height, and could provide an approach for better constraining the height-dependency of the effective wind speed. On the bottom line, the controlled release experiment provides critical insights into the sensor's capabilities and guides further improvements to detect and quantify low intensity sources in the fossil fuel and waste management sectors, with implications for more accurate global greenhouse gas monitoring.
- Open Access
- 24 December 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-38
Reply on RC1
Atmospheric concentration of methane (CH4), a critical greenhouse gas, increased significantly since pre-industrial times, with anthropogenic emissions originating primarily from agriculture, fossil fuel use and waste management. However, considerable uncertainties persist in the detection and quantification of anthropogenic CH4 emissions. In this study, we present first CH4 observations, plume detections and emission estimates from the new state-of-the-art Airborne Visible InfraRed Imaging Spectrometer 4 (AVIRIS-4), which participated in a blind controlled release experiment in September 2024 in southern France. We used an albedo-corrected matched filter to retrieve CH4 maps from the spectral images and estimated CH4 emission with the Integrated Mass Enhancement (IME) and Cross-Sectional Flux (CSF) methods. Our results demonstrate that AVIRIS-4 can reliably detect emissions as low as 5.5 kg CH4 h−1 under good weather conditions at low flight altitudes (4 h−1 under ideal conditions. While AVIRIS-4 provides highly accurate CH4 maps at 4 h−1) (rRMSE = 1.065; rMBE = 0.361) and overall (rRMSE = 0.702; rMBE = -0.204). Using literature-derived effective wind speeds improves the apparent fit between estimated and reported CH4 emissions, but degrades performance both in overall agreement (rRMSE = 2.098; rMBE = 0.964) and for low-emission events (rRMSE = 2.367; rMBE = 1.711). Interestingly, the high spatial resolution makes it possible to retrieve the cast shadow of the CH4 plume, which can be used to estimate source and plume height, and could provide an approach for better constraining the height-dependency of the effective wind speed. On the bottom line, the controlled release experiment provides critical insights into the sensor’s capabilities and guides further improvements to detect and quantify low intensity sources in the fossil fuel and waste management sectors, with implications for more accurate global greenhouse gas monitoring.
- 24 December 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-38
Open AccessReply on RC1
Atmospheric concentration of methane (CH4), a critical greenhouse gas, increased significantly since pre-industrial times, with anthropogenic emissions originating primarily from agriculture, fossil fuel use and waste management. However, considerable uncertainties persist in the detection and quantification of anthropogenic CH4 emissions. In this study, we present first CH4 observations, plume detections and emission estimates from the new state-of-the-art Airborne Visible InfraRed Imaging Spectrometer 4 (AVIRIS-4), which participated in a blind controlled release experiment in September 2024 in southern France. We used an albedo-corrected matched filter to retrieve CH4 maps from the spectral images and estimated CH4 emission with the Integrated Mass Enhancement (IME) and Cross-Sectional Flux (CSF) methods. Our results demonstrate that AVIRIS-4 can reliably detect emissions as low as 5.5 kg CH4 h−1 under good weather conditions at low flight altitudes (4 h−1 under ideal conditions. While AVIRIS-4 provides highly accurate CH4 maps at 4 h−1) (rRMSE = 1.065; rMBE = 0.361) and overall (rRMSE = 0.702; rMBE = -0.204). Using literature-derived effective wind speeds improves the apparent fit between estimated and reported CH4 emissions, but degrades performance both in overall agreement (rRMSE = 2.098; rMBE = 0.964) and for low-emission events (rRMSE = 2.367; rMBE = 1.711). Interestingly, the high spatial resolution makes it possible to retrieve the cast shadow of the CH4 plume, which can be used to estimate source and plume height, and could provide an approach for better constraining the height-dependency of the effective wind speed. On the bottom line, the controlled release experiment provides critical insights into the sensor’s capabilities and guides further improvements to detect and quantify low intensity sources in the fossil fuel and waste management sectors, with implications for more accurate global greenhouse gas monitoring.
- Open Access
- 24 December 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-38
Reply on RC2
Atmospheric concentration of methane (CH4), a critical greenhouse gas, increased significantly since pre-industrial times, with anthropogenic emissions originating primarily from agriculture, fossil fuel use and waste management. However, considerable uncertainties persist in the detection and quantification of anthropogenic CH4 emissions. In this study, we present first CH4 observations, plume detections and emission estimates from the new state-of-the-art Airborne Visible InfraRed Imaging Spectrometer 4 (AVIRIS-4), which participated in a blind controlled release experiment in September 2024 in southern France. We used an albedo-corrected matched filter to retrieve CH4 maps from the spectral images and estimated CH4 emission with the Integrated Mass Enhancement (IME) and Cross-Sectional Flux (CSF) methods. Our results demonstrate that AVIRIS-4 can reliably detect emissions as low as 5.5 kg CH4 h−1 under good weather conditions at low flight altitudes (4 h−1 under ideal conditions. While AVIRIS-4 provides highly accurate CH4 maps at 4 h−1) (rRMSE = 1.065; rMBE = 0.361) and overall (rRMSE = 0.702; rMBE = -0.204). Using literature-derived effective wind speeds improves the apparent fit between estimated and reported CH4 emissions, but degrades performance both in overall agreement (rRMSE = 2.098; rMBE = 0.964) and for low-emission events (rRMSE = 2.367; rMBE = 1.711). Interestingly, the high spatial resolution makes it possible to retrieve the cast shadow of the CH4 plume, which can be used to estimate source and plume height, and could provide an approach for better constraining the height-dependency of the effective wind speed. On the bottom line, the controlled release experiment provides critical insights into the sensor’s capabilities and guides further improvements to detect and quantify low intensity sources in the fossil fuel and waste management sectors, with implications for more accurate global greenhouse gas monitoring.
- 24 December 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-38
Open AccessReply on RC2
Atmospheric concentration of methane (CH4), a critical greenhouse gas, increased significantly since pre-industrial times, with anthropogenic emissions originating primarily from agriculture, fossil fuel use and waste management. However, considerable uncertainties persist in the detection and quantification of anthropogenic CH4 emissions. In this study, we present first CH4 observations, plume detections and emission estimates from the new state-of-the-art Airborne Visible InfraRed Imaging Spectrometer 4 (AVIRIS-4), which participated in a blind controlled release experiment in September 2024 in southern France. We used an albedo-corrected matched filter to retrieve CH4 maps from the spectral images and estimated CH4 emission with the Integrated Mass Enhancement (IME) and Cross-Sectional Flux (CSF) methods. Our results demonstrate that AVIRIS-4 can reliably detect emissions as low as 5.5 kg CH4 h−1 under good weather conditions at low flight altitudes (4 h−1 under ideal conditions. While AVIRIS-4 provides highly accurate CH4 maps at 4 h−1) (rRMSE = 1.065; rMBE = 0.361) and overall (rRMSE = 0.702; rMBE = -0.204). Using literature-derived effective wind speeds improves the apparent fit between estimated and reported CH4 emissions, but degrades performance both in overall agreement (rRMSE = 2.098; rMBE = 0.964) and for low-emission events (rRMSE = 2.367; rMBE = 1.711). Interestingly, the high spatial resolution makes it possible to retrieve the cast shadow of the CH4 plume, which can be used to estimate source and plume height, and could provide an approach for better constraining the height-dependency of the effective wind speed. On the bottom line, the controlled release experiment provides critical insights into the sensor’s capabilities and guides further improvements to detect and quantify low intensity sources in the fossil fuel and waste management sectors, with implications for more accurate global greenhouse gas monitoring.
- Open Access
- 19 December 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-21
Reply on RC1 and RC2
This study presents the first public, academic, blinded controlled release evaluation of methane detection and quantification technologies in Europe. Conducted at the TotalEnergies Anomalies Detection Initiatives (TADI) site in France, the campaign tested eight commercial systems – including satellite, drone, and continuous monitoring platforms – under controlled single-blind conditions. Participants submitted methane emission rate estimates without prior knowledge of true release values. Performance was assessed through detection limit curves, parity plots, and statistical metrics including slope and R². False positive detection rates ranged from 0 to 11 %. Quantification slopes ranged from 0.09 to 1.13, with a trend toward underestimation, and R2 values ranged from 0.08 to 0.97. Wind conditions – particularly low speeds and high variability – were a key factor affecting quantification accuracy, emphasizing the need for high-quality wind data integration. This study underscores the importance of rigorous, standardized testing to benchmark technology performance and inform regulatory efforts. Results highlight platform-specific strengths and challenges, providing actionable insights for participants, policymakers, and regulators. These findings support the development of robust, validated methane measurement tools critical to achieving effective emissions monitoring and reduction strategies under evolving regulatory frameworks, such as those in the European Union.
- 19 December 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2025, 1-21
Open AccessReply on RC1 and RC2
This study presents the first public, academic, blinded controlled release evaluation of methane detection and quantification technologies in Europe. Conducted at the TotalEnergies Anomalies Detection Initiatives (TADI) site in France, the campaign tested eight commercial systems – including satellite, drone, and continuous monitoring platforms – under controlled single-blind conditions. Participants submitted methane emission rate estimates without prior knowledge of true release values. Performance was assessed through detection limit curves, parity plots, and statistical metrics including slope and R². False positive detection rates ranged from 0 to 11 %. Quantification slopes ranged from 0.09 to 1.13, with a trend toward underestimation, and R2 values ranged from 0.08 to 0.97. Wind conditions – particularly low speeds and high variability – were a key factor affecting quantification accuracy, emphasizing the need for high-quality wind data integration. This study underscores the importance of rigorous, standardized testing to benchmark technology performance and inform regulatory efforts. Results highlight platform-specific strengths and challenges, providing actionable insights for participants, policymakers, and regulators. These findings support the development of robust, validated methane measurement tools critical to achieving effective emissions monitoring and reduction strategies under evolving regulatory frameworks, such as those in the European Union.