GDGiovanni D'AGostino

Giovanni D'AGostino

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Giovanni D'AGostino has a total of 3 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Varieties of democratic vulnerability: a comparative study of checks and balances and popular acceptance of transgressions

    by Honorata Mazepus, Magnus Feldmann, Giovanni D'AGostino

    The recent wave of democratic backsliding has demonstrated that liberal democracies are vulnerable to subversion by authoritarian leaders. Research showed that democratically elected leaders remove checks and balances that constrain their power. One of the explanations why leaders can violate democratic rules focuses on the response of citizens who trade off democracy for partisan and policy gains. This article investigates cross-country differences in vulnerabilities to democratic backsliding by comparing democratic priority profiles of citizens and the patterns of approval for transgressions of democratic rules. We use observational evidence from online surveys with large quota-based samples of citizens in a two-party presidential system (USA, N > 1700), a multi-party parliamentary system based on proportional representation with some semi-presidential features (Poland, N >1800), and a consociational parliamentary system based on proportional representation (Netherlands, N = > 2100). To complement observational evidence, we test experimentally some of these aggregate-level differences: next to partisanship and policy gains, we also manipulate different democratic transgressions (protest rights and decree powers) and measure their effects on government approval in the three countries. Our results show that citizens of different countries have different democratic priority profiles and differ in their disapproval of specific transgressions. Although overall transgressions are not rewarded, and citizens are mostly vigilant and disapproving of violating democratic rules, we find both observational and experimental evidence indicating that liberal democracies can have different vulnerabilities that relate to the democratic attitudes of citizens.

  • Open Access

    Evaluations of institutional performance among adolescents: Comparing the socializing roles of schools and families

    by Giovanni D’AGostino

    Democratic accountability requires citizens’ political trust to reflect institutional performance, making it crucial to understand what fosters such responsiveness. While existing studies suggest that education shapes evaluative attitudes, direct evidence remains limited because many analyses struggle to separate educational effects from those of parental background. This paper offers a comprehensive test of these explanations by examining adolescents within the same target grade and by assessing school-level civic education characteristics often credited with cultivating critical citizenship norms. It then compares school-level patterns with parental background to evaluate the proxy-versus-cause debate. Using data from three waves of the International Civic and Citizenship Education Study, the analysis shows that structurally low and declining institutional performance depresses political trust among adolescents. However, consistent with the education-as-proxy argument, the positive association between performance and trust is significantly stronger among adolescents with higher parental socio-economic status, while school-level civic education shows no meaningful moderating effect.

  • Open Access

    Trust Judgments Are Not Formed in Isolation: The Importance of Contentious Norms and the Normative Environment in the Evaluative Model of Political Trust

    by Giovanni D'AGostino, Tom van der Meer, Honorata Mazepus

    Citizens express evaluative or critical trust in institutions when their trust results from assessing institutional performance against their own normative benchmarks. Yet empirical evidence on how such benchmarks shape evaluations is inconclusive. Three key limitations account for this ambiguity: prior research has focused on personal rather than injunctive norms, on consensual rather than contentious norms, and on prescriptive rather than descriptive norms. To address these gaps, we introduce and test a comprehensive model with three innovations. First, we conceptualize norms as preferences over normative trade-offs – choices between competing values – rather than as simple endorsements of universally supported principles. This approach better captures realistic moral reasoning while reducing ceiling effects. Second, we extend the focus beyond personal norms to incorporate perceived injunctive norms, thereby accounting for the broader normative environment in which citizens are embedded. Third, we theorize and test the effects of prescriptive norms (what individuals or groups believe politicians should do) and descriptive norms (what individuals perceive political elites actually do). This framework allows us to examine whether citizens benchmark their evaluations not only against the performance they desire but also against the performance they are used to observing. We test this model using a between-subjects vignette experiment embedded in a two-wave panel study with 13,462 respondents across eight European countries. Our results provide novel evidence in favor of the role of norms - especially personal norms – in the evaluative model of political trust.

  • Open Access

    Evaluations of Institutional Performance Among Adolescents: Comparing the Socializing Roles of Schools and Families

    by Giovanni D'Agostino

    Democratic accountability requires citizens' political trust to be reflective of institutional performance. It is therefore crucial to understand what fosters citizens’ responsiveness to such performance. Extant studies suggest that education shapes these evaluative attitudes. Yet, direct evidence remains limited, as many studies struggle to disentangle the effects of education from those of parental background. As a result, the debate over whether education is a genuine cause or merely a proxy for evaluative attitudes remains unresolved. In this paper, I carry out an extensive test of these two competing explanations by, first, focusing on adolescents within the same target grade (before differences in educational attainment arise), and second, testing the effect of school-level civic education characteristics often praised for the instilment of critical citizenship norms. I then compare school-level effects with those from parental background to address the proxy-versus-cause debate. Analysing data from three waves of the International Civic and Citizenship Education Study, I find evidence that structurally low and declining performance depresses political trust among adolescents. Yet, consistent with the education-as-proxy argument, the positive relationship between performance and trust is significantly stronger among adolescents with higher parental socio-economic status, while school-level civic education characteristics do not meaningfully moderate this association.