Leveling and Spotlighting: How the European Court of Justice Favors the Weak to Promote its Legitimacy
Preprint
- 9 April 2024
- preprint
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in APSA Preprints
Abstract
As private actors turn to international courts (ICs), we argue that judges can seize individual rights litigation to promote themselves as protectors of the weak. By leveling the odds for less resourceful individuals and spotlighting their rights claims, ICs can cultivate support networks in civil society. We verify this legitimation strategy by scrutinizing the first IC with private access: the European Court of Justice (ECJ). Often cast as a stealthy pro-business court, we show that ECJ judges instead publicized themselves as individual rights promoters: do they match words with deeds? Leveraging an original dataset, we find that the ECJ “levels,” favoring individuals’ rights claims compared to claims by businesses boasting larger, more experienced legal teams. The ECJ also “spotlights” support for individuals through press releases that lawyers amplify in law journals. Our findings challenge the view that ICs build legitimacy by stealth and the “haves” come out ahead in litigation.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 64 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Effect of Judicial Decisions on Issue Salience and Legal Consciousness in Media Serving the LGBTQ+ CommunityAmerican Political Science Review, 2024
- Judicial resistance during electoral disputes: Evidence from KenyaElectoral Studies, 2023
- The CJEU Database Platform: Decisions and Decision-MakersJournal of Law and Courts, 2023
- The Sources of Resilience of International Human Rights Courts: The Case of the Inter-American SystemLaw & Social Inquiry, 2021
- Multi-Method Social Science2016
- Brokering Europe2015
- Judicial Behavior under Political Constraints: Evidence from the European Court of JusticeAmerican Political Science Review, 2008
- The Influence of Oral Arguments on the U.S. Supreme CourtAmerican Political Science Review, 2006
- The Politics of Constitutional Review in Germany2004
- Political Opportunity Structures and Political Protest: Anti-Nuclear Movements in Four DemocraciesBritish Journal of Political Science, 1986