Executive Approval Dynamics in Presidential and Parliamentary Democratic Regimes
Open Access
- 26 April 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Comparative Political Studies
- Vol. 58 (3) , 526-561
Abstract
Does the type of democratic regime matter for public evaluations of leaders? We argue two characteristics intrinsic to presidential and parliamentary regimes lead to divergent patterns of executive approval. For presidents, direct elections foster more personal leader-voter linkages; for prime ministers, dependence on the legislature for survival contributes to more institutionalized party systems. These two mechanisms should generate higher approval at the outset of a term—larger honeymoons— for presidents than for prime ministers, but also more rapid decline. Analyses of data from 40 countries produce evidence consistent with these constitutionally-based distinctions. Yet we uncover important within-regime differences. Within presidential systems, approval patterns vary along with paths to power—first-election versus re-election, and elected versus unelected. Within parliamentarism, honeymoons are greater for prime ministers overseeing single-party majoritarian governments. Study findings advance long-standing debates about the relative merits of presidential and parliamentary systems—particularly the tradeoff between democratic responsiveness and stability.Keywords
Funding Information
- Center for Human Rights and Democracy at Georgia State University
- Reckford Professorship at UNC-Chapel Hill
This publication has 79 references indexed in Scilit:
- Political Institutions and Democracy2022
- Economic Growth and Political Approval Ratings: Evidence from Latin AmericaPolitical Behavior, 2022
- From election day to presidential approval: Partisanship and the honeymoon period in MexicoElectoral Studies, 2022
- Who does better for the economy? Presidents versus parliamentary democraciesPublic Choice, 2018
- Party System Institutionalization, Predictability, and Democracy2018
- Personalization of campaigns in an SMP system: The Canadian caseElectoral Studies, 2015
- Party Polarization and Mass Partisanship: A Comparative PerspectivePolitical Behavior, 2014
- Democratic Electoral Systems around the world, 1946–2011Electoral Studies, 2013
- Political institutions, voter turnout, and policy outcomesEuropean Journal of Political Economy, 2012
- Incentives to cultivate a personal vote: A rank ordering of electoral formulasElectoral Studies, 1995