Experimental Comparison of Acoustic Characteristics for a High-Efficiency Magnetic Gearbox and a Mechanical Planetary Gearbox for Industrial HVAC Applications
- 18 September 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion
- Vol. 39 (1) , 182-190
Abstract
In industrial fan applications, gearboxes or belt drives are often utilized to reduce the motor footprint to an acceptable level to maximize airflow. Customers demand fans with minimal noise and maintenance requirements, as well as a large mean time to failure (MTTF); however, mechanical gearboxes and belt drives are associated with high noise levels, significant maintenance requirements, and low MTTF rates, especially in harsh environments. This paper presents the development of a radial flux coaxial magnetic gear optimized for cost and modulator retention. The results reveal that sizable retaining features on the modulators' tangential sides may be employed while still maintaining high electromagnetic performance. A magnetic gear prototype was constructed and evaluated to determine its A-weighted acoustic noise characteristics. A similar commercial-off-the-shelf mechanical planetary gearbox was also evaluated to provide a benchmark for comparison with the magnetic gearbox. The results reveal the novel finding that the magnetic gearbox became quieter as the load increased, and the mechanical gearbox was louder than the magnetic gearbox at rated speed, except at very light loads. A second magnetic gearbox was also tested and proved to be louder than the mechanical gearbox; however, this second magnetic gearbox also became quieter as its load increased.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Security Innovation
- Capstone Project Program
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Design of an Extremely Efficient, Rare-Earth Free, 5 kW Motor in a NEMA 210 Frame2022
- Design and Analysis of an Axial Flux Coaxial Magnetic Gear with Balanced Axial Forces for Precision Aerospace Actuation Application2022
- Magnetically geared conveyor drive unit - an updated version2020
- Performance Impacts of Practical Fabrication Tradeoffs for a Radial Flux Coaxial Magnetic Gear with Halbach Arrays and Air Cores2019
- Acoustic Noise Analysis of a Magnetically Geared Permanent Magnet Generator2019
- Evaluation of a magnetic gear for air‐cooled condenser applicationsIET Electric Power Applications, 2018
- The effect of modulating ring design on induction machine with integrated magnetic gear torque2017
- Vibration and noise characteristics of coaxial magnetic gear according to low-speed rotor structureJournal of Mechanical Science and Technology, 2017
- Analysis of the end-effects in magnetic gears and magnetically geared machines2014
- Start-up problem with an induction machine and a permanent magnet gear2014