Does Outcome Utility Bias the Mental Simulations of Risky Events?
Preprint
- 25 February 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Does the utility of an outcome influence people's assessment of risk and uncertainty? Prominent theories propose that people rely on mental simulation to evaluate probabilities and risky events, yet prior empirical findings is mixed as to whether and how utility biases this process. Across four experiments (total N=206, with Experiment 4 pre-registered), we tested this question using a random generation paradigm, in which participants mentally simulated gamble outcomes and said them out loud. Then we compared these responses with probability judgments and predictions. While we identified individual differences, the majority of participants exhibited neutrality, with no systematic impact of utility on their sampling distributions. Nevertheless, an optimism subgroup emerged, with a larger proportion of optimistic participants when the monetary context was more salient. Additionally, outcome utilities have similar effects on probability judgments, predictions, and random generation tasks, consistent with the proposal that these tasks are related to each other and may all rely on mental simulation. These findings indicate that utility does not uniformly distort mental simulation, but can do so for a stable subgroup under particular motivational contexts, and they motivate cognitive models that capture both unbiased and optimistic forms of mental sampling.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- Understanding Individual Subject Differences through Large Behavioral Datasets: Analytical and Statistical ConsiderationsPerspectives on Behavior Science, 2023
- Age, numeracy, and cultural differences in Chinese and American adolescents’ performance on the ratio bias taskJournal of Experimental Child Psychology, 2019
- People’s conditional probability judgments follow probability theory (plus noise)Cognitive Psychology, 2016
- Explaining High Conjunction Fallacy Rates: The Probability Theory Plus Noise AccountJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2016
- Extreme Outcomes Sway Risky Decisions from ExperienceJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 2013
- Cognitive models of risky choice: Parameter stability and predictive accuracy of prospect theoryCognition, 2012
- Recurrence plots for the analysis of complex systemsPhysics Reports, 2007
- The relationship between the illusion of control and the desirability biasJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 1995
- Recent developments in modelling preferences under riskOR Spectrum, 1987
- Anticipatory and post hoc cushioning strategies: Optimism and defensive pessimism in ?risky? situationsCognitive Therapy and Research, 1986