Graphene oxide (GO) produced by Hummers-type methods comprises sheets with varying degrees of oxidation, yet most studies treat GO as being uniform. Here, we fractionate GO via emulsion-based partitioning, with highly oxidized sheets remaining in the aqueous phase (GOw) and less-oxidized sheets stabilizing the oil/water interface (GOe). The resulting fractions exhibit different properties across five tested domains. Contact angles range from 63°(GOw) to 92°(GOee). GOw films transmit 90.2% at 550 nm versus 84.1% for GOee, and microwave reduction decreases GOw transmittance about four times as much as the less-oxidized GOee fraction (4.34% vs 1.07%). PEG-conjugated GOew maintained A549 cell viability above 80% at all dilutions, while GOw and unfractionated GO remained non-cytotoxic at the lower concentrations. GOe-PEG reduced viability at most dilutions. In PVAc composites at 1 wt%, the most-oxidized fraction GOw gave the largest modulus increase (34%), while unfractionated GO and the less-oxidized GOe gave smaller increases that were not statistically separable from each other. In lithium-ion half-cells, GOwww delivers 270 mAh/g at cycle 50, compared with 61 mAh/g for GOeee. Across the fractions generated from a single batch, four of the five property rankings