Abstract
Background Some studies have reported that the electromagnetic navigation (EN) technique is better than the free-hand (FH) method. Nevertheless, there are few clinical trials. In recent years, several clinical trials have been conducted, providing sufficient information to compare the two methods. Methods We compared the FH and EN techniques (SURESHOT, Smith and Nephew, Inc., Memphis, TN) in terms of the distal locking time, exposure time, first success rate, healing time and operative time. We comprehensively searched the Medline, Embase, and Cochrane library databases according to predetermined inclusion and exclusion criteria, and then we extracted data for specific variables from these reports. The risk of bias was assessed. Stata 13.0 was used for analysis. Results Nine studies involving 579 patients were pooled in this study. The meta-analysis showed that EN was associated with a shorter distal locking time (P = 0.001) and exposure time (P = 0.001) than FH performed by surgeons who are not proficient in using the FH technique. No significant differences were found in the first success rate (P = 0.231), healing time (P = 0.09) or operative time (P = 0.510). Conclusion The EN technique has the advantages of a shorter distal locking time and smaller amount of ionizing radiation exposure compared with the FH technique.

This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit: