Spacetime Emergence and the Fear of Intimacy
Preprint
Abstract
We provide a reply to the Argument from Intimacy on behalf of defenders of emergent spacetime in theories of quantum gravity. We argue that if one accepts that spacetime regions are nowhere in the sense that they are locations but do not have locations, then the Argument from Intimacy can be resolved. We go on to consider a problem with this response, namely that it is unavailable to super-substantivalists. We argue that this is right for identity but not priority super-substantivalists. We then suggest that there is no cost for our solution here, since identity versions of super-substantivalism face severe challenges in the context of spacetime emergence and so should be rejected anyway.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Atoms, combs, syllables and organismsPhilosophical Studies, 2023
- The harmony of groundingPhilosophical Studies, 2022
- A General Theory of Location Based on the Notion of Entire LocationJournal of Philosophical Logic, 2022
- Somewhere Together: Location, Parsimony and MultilocationErkenntnis, 2021
- Supersubstantivalism and the argument from harmonyThought: A Journal of Philosophy, 2021
- The curious case of spacetime emergencePhilosophical Studies, 2019
- Inter-theory relations in quantum gravity: Correspondence, reduction, and emergenceStudies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics, 2018
- Emergent spacetime and empirical (in)coherenceStudies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics, 2013
- Sider, the inheritance of intrinsicality, and theories of compositionPhilosophical Studies, 2009
- Spatial Reasoning and Ontology: Parts, Wholes, and Locations2007