L1/L2 Spanish grammars and the pragmatic deficit hypothesis
- 1 April 1999
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Second Language Research
- Vol. 15 (2) , 161-190
Abstract
In recent research on primary (L1) and non-primary (L2) acquisition,special attention has been given to whether syntactic development is subject to a continuity condition. While it has been proposed that the continuity condition applies to both L1 and L2 syntactic growth,the changes that take place in developing grammars have sometimes been attributed to other cognitive systems. Specifically, it has been proposed that child grammars are ‘underspecified’ because they lack a pragmatic principle which determines the range of indices available for establishing verbal and nominal coreference. According to this proposal, a grammar which is underspecified for Number has null subjects and bare NPs only with non-inflected verb forms. Assuming that adults will not have a pragmatic deficit of the kind proposed for children, we have analysed data from child L1 Spanish and adult L2 Spanish. The results of our analysis show that: (1) in child L1 Spanish, the feature Person may encode Number so that when Person is distinctively implemented, root infinitives and bare NP subjects will cease to occur. However, the pervasive morphology of Spanish verbs conspires against the possibility of providing clear-cut evidence for underspecification in the case of child Spanish; (2) the different nature of L1 and L2 root infinitives may provide partial evidence for underspecification in the case of L1 Spanish; and (3) in the case of L2 learners, the distribution of null and overt subjects seems to be partially determined by their L1 rather than by underspecification.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- L2 ACQUISITION AND OBLIGATORY HEAD MOVEMENTStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 1998
- Regular verbs, past tense and frequency: tracking down a potential source of NS/NNS competence differencesSecond Language Research, 1997
- Second language acquisition: Theoretical and experimental issues in contemporary researchBehavioral and Brain Sciences, 1996
- How, Hang on a Minute1996
- Null Arguments in German Child LanguageLanguage Acquisition, 1996
- Negation in early German-English Interlanguage: more Valueless Features in the L2 initial stateSecond Language Research, 1996
- VP, Null Arguments and COMP Projections1994
- Functional Categories in Early Child GermanLanguage Acquisition, 1993
- On the Transfer of Parametric Values in L2 DevelopmentLanguage Acquisition, 1993
- Functional Categories and Language AcquisitionCanadian Journal of Linguistics/Revue canadienne de linguistique, 1992