Does the Forensic Filler-Control Method Reduce Examiner Overconfidence? An Experimental Investigation Using Mock Fingerprint Examiners
Open Access
- 31 August 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Behavioral Sciences
- Vol. 15 (9) , 1191
Abstract
Examiner overconfidence is a persistent challenge in the field of forensic science, where testimony overstating the validity of forensic techniques has contributed to numerous wrongful convictions. Scholars have proposed a new method for reducing examiner overconfidence (i.e., subjective confidence that exceeds objective accuracy): the forensic filler-control method. The forensic filler-control method, which includes known non-matching “filler” samples alongside the suspect’s sample, is theorized to reduce examiner overconfidence through the provision of immediate error feedback to examiners following match judgments on fillers. We conducted two experiments that failed to yield support for this claim. Among both an undergraduate student sample (Experiment 1) and a forensic science student sample (Experiment 2), the filler-control method was associated with worse calibration (C) and greater overconfidence (O/U) in affirmative match judgments than the standard method. Moreover, the filler-control method produced less accurate non-match judgments, undermining the exonerating value of forensic analysis (i.e., NPV). However, the filler-control method’s ability to draw false positive matches away from innocent-suspect samples and onto fillers produced more reliable incriminating evidence (i.e., PPV) compared to the standard procedure. Our findings suggest that neither the standard procedure nor the filler-control procedure offers a uniformly superior method of conducting forensic analysis. We suggest alternative procedures for enhancing both the inculpatory and exculpatory value of forensic analysis.Keywords
Funding Information
- Barrett Honors College at Arizona State University
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- Absolute-judgment models better predict eyewitness decision-making than do relative-judgment modelsCognition, 2024
- The prevalence effect in fingerprint identification: Match and non‐match base‐rates impact misses and false alarmsApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2021
- Juror appraisals of forensic evidence: Effects of blind proficiency and cross-examinationForensic Science International, 2020
- The impact of evidence lineups on fingerprint expert decisionsApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2020
- Cognitive bias research in forensic science: A systematic reviewForensic Science International, 2019
- A method for increasing empirical discriminability and eliminating top‐row preference in photo arraysApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2019
- Positive versus negative face recognition decisions: confidence, accuracy, and response latencyApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2005
- Procedural bias in forensic science examinations of human hair.Law and Human Behavior, 1987
- Two methods of reducing overconfidenceOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1987
- Do those who know more also know more about how much they know?Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1977