This study aims to compare the structural responses of tall buildings (TBs) with different twisting rates and core wall configurations to investigate their effect under various loading conditions. The study examines three groups of TBs with varying core wall layouts: hexagonal shape for group A, circular shape for group B, and square shape for group C. Three models were constructed for each group, with twisting angles of 0°, 90°, and 180°. The study initially compares the nine different models’ natural periods of vibration and modal mass participation ratios. The towers’ wind and seismic responses for each model under wind, response spectrum (RS), and nonlinear time history (NTH) analysis are also presented. The wind, RS, and NTH analysis outcomes regarding the structural system (natural periods, drift ratios, story shear forces, and overturning moments) and members (shear forces and bending moments on columns and walls) have been compared. Finally, a multiple-criteria decision-making algorithm was used to determine the optimum model based on the investigated responses. The findings indicate that the core wall layout has a more significant influence on the response of TBs than the twisting rate. Specifically, a building with a hexagonal core wall system and 0-degree twist is identified as the optimal configuration. Although its effects are less significant than seismic forces, wind analysis reveals that twisting in buildings slightly reduces the natural period and drift ratios. This study emphasizes the impact of TBs configurations and twisting rates on both wind and seismic responses.