Philosophers’ linguistic expertise: a psycholinguistic approach to the expertise objection against experimental philosophy
Open Access
- 23 February 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Synthese
- Vol. 200 (1) , 1-33
Abstract
Philosophers are often credited with particularly well-developed conceptual skills. The ‘expertise objection’ to experimental philosophy builds on this assumption to challenge inferences from findings about laypeople to conclusions about philosophers. We draw on psycholinguistics to develop and assess this objection. We examine whether philosophers are less or differently susceptible than laypersons to cognitive biases that affect how people understand verbal case descriptions and judge the cases described. We examine two possible sources of difference: Philosophers could be better at deploying concepts, and this could make them less susceptible to comprehension biases (‘linguistic expertise objection’). Alternatively, exposure to different patterns of linguistic usage could render philosophers vulnerable to a fundamental comprehension bias, the linguistic salience bias, at different points (‘linguistic usage objection’). Together, these objections mount a novel ‘master argument’ against experimental philosophy. To develop and empirically assess this argument, we employ corpus analysis and distributional semantic analysis and elicit plausibility ratings from academic philosophers and psychology undergraduates. Our findings suggest philosophers are better at deploying concepts than laypeople but are susceptible to the linguistic salience bias to a similar extent and at similar points. We identify methodological consequences for experimental philosophy and for philosophical thought experiments.Keywords
This publication has 81 references indexed in Scilit:
- Moral intuitions: Are philosophers experts?Philosophical Psychology, 2013
- Polysemy in sentence comprehension: Effects of meaning dominanceJournal of Memory and Language, 2012
- Generalized event knowledge activation during online sentence comprehensionJournal of Memory and Language, 2012
- The Nature and Organization of Individual Differences in Executive FunctionsCurrent Directions in Psychological Science, 2012
- Persistent bias in expert judgments about free will and moral responsibility: A test of the expertise defenseConsciousness and Cognition, 2011
- Effects of event knowledge in processing verbal argumentsJournal of Memory and Language, 2010
- Activating event knowledgeCognition, 2009
- On the Meaning of Words and Dinosaur Bones: Lexical Knowledge Without a LexiconCognitive Science, 2009
- Time in the mind: Using space to think about timeCognition, 2008
- Feature Centrality and Conceptual CoherenceCognitive Science, 1998